8 ms·
Because it's much easier to deny something that big than to take care of it. We'd need a economic/cultural revolution at a global scale. Everything has to scale
by lm28469 8y ago
Because it's much easier to deny something that big than to take care of it. We'd need a economic/cultural revolution at a global scale. Everything has to scale down, no more ICE, not more plastic, no more food imported from the other side of the world, reduce meat consumption, reduce traveling &c.
The current system is based on unlimited and exponential growth, everything else is considered a failure. An unlimited growth in a finite environment isn't possible, it's called instability.
The second problem is that many people convince themselves that "Science" will save us, that we'll terraform Mars or that shifting to electric cars will be enough, but that's too little, too late. Even if we'd hit our ecological goals, and we're not, we'd be far from fixing the problem. We don't need to slow down, we need a complete paradigm shift. It's like when you move form a basic 40sq meter flat to a fancy 250sq meter house, going back is very hard.
- kmlx 8y ago> An unlimited growth in a finite environment isn't possible, it's called instability. but our environment is the universe, and the universe is infinite in resources...
- swarnie_ 8y ago> but our environment is the universe, and the universe is infinite in resources... Get a human permanently and self-sufficiently out of LEO and i'll agree a limited part of the solar system is our environment. For the foreseeable future our environment is earth and not a lot else.
- kmlx 8y agofor the foreseeable future we're planning on mining asteroids and the having a base on the moon... so i don't understand your point.
- lm28469 8y agoSee that's exactly what I'm talking about. We have a very real thing happening right now on earth with extreme consequences: major species extinction, air pollution, water pollution, soon to be ecological refugees, &c. But the answer is mining asteroid and having a moon base. Why would we care about asteroid gold and the few (<100) people that might go to the moon and live an extremely strenuous life. It's not like we'll all go to the moon, crack open a cold one and watch the moon superbowl.
- oceanplexian 8y agoTry telling someone from a few hundred years ago they’d catch a jet airplane to an undiscovered continent thousands of miles away for a quick vacation. And on the way they could crack a cold one traversing oceans that explorers would spend months trying to traverse in a wooden boat. They could even buy tickets on a magic handheld machine which can teleport information through thin air to anywhere on the planet in fractions of a second. If you change your sense of scale from a few years to a few hundred, yeah, I think it’s likely humanity will be watching the moon superbowl, in fact it’s probably the most dull and conservative view of the future someone could have.
- adrianN 8y agoWe don't have time to wait a few hundred years for technology to improve though. The fate of the climate is decided in the next ten to twenty years. If we don't stop catastrophic climate change now, it's quite likely that technological society will be busy fighting for scarce resources here instead of building space colonies.
- coldtea 8y agoFor the foreseeable future those involve a handful of people getting there as a novelty (in the same way people having been on the ISS for decades), not 8 billion needing to survive. Not to mention they're still vaporware... Brochures are easy. In 30 years Miami might be under the waters, and we'd still be extremely lucky if we have a 200 sq ft base on the moon. (On which a man haven't even set foot for the last 48 years).
- kmlx 8y ago> Why would we care about asteroid gold and the few (<100) people that might go to the moon and live an extremely strenuous life. scientific progress.
- adrianN 8y agoIt will take at least a century of focused effort until an off world colony can be self sufficient. Think of how complex even the simplest things are that you interact with on a daily basis and how difficult it would be to replicate the industries that manufacture them on the Moon or Mars.
- 8draco8 8y agoYou are correct but infinite resources of universe are out of our reach at the moment and if we will not work smart with Earth local resources we may never reach a level at which we will be able to benefit from resources outside of our planet.
- lm28469 8y agoYeah right, how much does it cost to ship 1kg in space again ? Do we even have the raw resources on earth / the tech to move everyone to a new planet and terraform it before we're all toast ? Even if we do what's your moral standpoint on the fact that humanity destroyed 3+ billion years of evolution on earth in a few hundred years ? Who in their right mind think that terraforming a planet is easier than just stopping destroying our home planet ? Even if we do move to a new planet, in what kind of conditions will we live, I doubt we'd have even 10% f the comfort we have today. So why not scale down here, on earth, in the first place ?
- kmlx 8y ago> Even if we do what's your moral standpoint on the fact that humanity destroyed 3+ billion years of evolution on earth in a few hundred years ? didn't the earth go thru numerous planet-wide extinction events? and those were much much faster than a few hundred years.
- coldtea 8y agoYes, but we weren't there as a civilization then. And the next one could wipe us all out. In which case it will be little consolation that amoebas or even cockroaches and squirrels might survive...
- lm28469 8y agoThe very big difference is that we are, at least partially, causing it, aware of it, aware it's going to be bad, and we know how to improve it. So we're making the decision, as a specie, not to care. But sure in the big scheme of things it's not changing much, it's more of a personal / moral position.
- oceanplexian 8y agoBut plenty of things cause extinction events, hell humans were causing the Wolly Mammoth to go extinct long before we had anything resembling a civilization. Plenty of other plants and animals will drive other animals to extinction. It’s the circle of life, one which we, being animals, are a part of.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoUnless we make a breakthrough in physics (which is pretty unlikely to be possible in our current understanding), the universe will be limited to us. The best we can do is a sphere of human economy expanding its radius at near the speed of light. That still leaves out a good chunk of universe forever inaccessible to us. Physics does seem to put a limit on growth.
- coldtea 8y agoNo, our environment is Earth, and only because we evolved to its conditions, and only by a very much luck that had them be in a very narrow zone that was good for life (and even Earth could not care less about us). Our immediate environment aside from Earth is the vastness of the solar system, in planets totally unsuitable to support us, and with extreme costs to even get us to the nearest one, and with vast expanses of space and radiation to go through to get to the next. We got humans to the closest rock for a few years, on a huge cost and effort, and with big risks (and some casualties), based on the competition of 2 superpowers. Since then, not only we haven't established any "base", but we haven't even been there for 48+ years (almost half a century)... And even if by a very slim chance (which people who view technological progress as some kind of boundless Paolo Coelio fairy tale take for granted) we manage to do something in those planets, the next step (some earth like habitable planet elsewhere) is extremely more challenging, and speed of light limits would apply (of course people who view technological progress as some kind of boundless Paolo Coelio fairy tale bypass them with exotic contraptions that have us riding wormholes and what have you...). And that's if war and climate mayhem doesn't have us concentrate all our efforts here... Some food for though: don't concentrate on the pedantic details, but the high level arguments: http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2009/11/the_myth_of_the_starship.html http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2009/11/the_myth... http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2007/06/the_high_frontier_redux.html http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2007/06/the_high...
- oceanplexian 8y agoI think the idea that science is some kind of fairy tail or magical solution to all our problems is a bit off. But, ask someone in the 1800s how they feel about the future and you’d get some pretty ignorant and wildly inaccurate responses. The thing is, you and I are no more qualified to speculate on the future than someone from 100 years ago would be qualified to speculate on the Internet. However I can say one thing: if we even make a fraction of the progress in the next 100 years compared to the progress in the last, I don’t think we have anything to worry about when it comes to energy or transportation.
- coldtea 8y ago
- roscorollo 8y agoOur current environment and resource reach only extends to low earth orbit. Even the moon which is the closest stable near earth resource is at least a couple of decades away from any practical use. Chances are that the climate of earth will become more unstable before any kind of space based economy can really be taken seriously.
- 0xffff2 8y agoThe moon is "a couple decades away from any practical use" in the same way that fusion power is. Likewise, there have been models of orbital economies for decades, and no one has even tried to actually do it. For all practical purposes our current reach extends to the surface of the Earth and no further.
- akvadrako 8y agoThe universe might be infinite, but growth will eventually be limited by the speed of light. Per capita energy usage is about 6 MWh / year and our population has been doubling every 53 years. Assuming that continues, in 10000 years we'll be using 4e69 Wh / year. If we figure out 100% conversion of mass to energy, that's 1e56 kg of fuel, which is a lot more than all the matter in the visible universe. You can play with these numbers a little, but even reducing the energy usage per person by a million only gives us another 1000 years. Soon we'll be growing so fast that every year we'll use all the resources within one light-year.
- Carlee 8y agoYou should check out Hans Rosling's lectures [1]. Statistics points towards the fact that as people become more wealthy, they have less children. It should stagnate around 11 million people by most models. [1] https://youtu.be/FACK2knC08E https://youtu.be/FACK2knC08E
- TeMPOraL 8y agoGrowth is fine, really. I'd start worrying when our economy starts to expand at a noticeable fraction of the speed of light. The problem is sustainable growth. The path we're on isn't sustainable, unless we hit some scientific and political miracles in the next years. Sustainable growth is unfortunately slower than unsustainable one, so it loses out in competitive environment. Still, I don't think we should focus on attacking growth in general - just the type we have now. Done right, economic growth may yet save us.
- rbag 8y agoI don't understand how growth is not a problem. The earth is a finite world, sustainable or not you won't be able to grow indefinitely. Also we already consume more than we should, if we go back that would impact the GDP.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> The earth is a finite world, sustainable or not you won't be able to grow indefinitely. It's not "indefinitely". It's just "long enough that we can bootstrap a space economy and expand into the Solar System", or alternatively "long enough so that we can fix the environmental damage, get rid of poverty and most diseases, and slowly S-curve the economy into some acceptable state". Or some combination of that. Moreover, not all growth is tied to physical space and resource use. We're also not using the space and resources we have efficiently. There's plenty of room on Earth for us to grow, but it might start looking more like improving things than expanding them. > if we go back that would impact the GDP. Switching to a sustainable level of growth will require that - slowing down the growth itself, and even a temporary shrinking of the economy.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoIn theory Growth could be detached from energy consumption, if I cook my neighbours a meal tonight and charge them £20 and tomorrow they do the same for me then GDP has grown by £40 but energy consumption has staid the same. In reality it seems most of the things we find valuable do involve energy consumption. We are so far from completely decoupling it that you might as well consider money and energy to be the same thing. The more you spend and the richer you are the more damage you are causing the environment. It seems politicians (of the environmental kind) who tell you we can grow and save the planet are almost certainly lying.
- grenoire 8y agoWhat's ICE?
- MrBuddyCasino 8y ago> many people convince themselves that "Science" will save us Why won't it? The main issue is where we get our energy from. There are working methods that are CO2 neutral. I'm firmly in the "only science will save us" camp. > It's like when you move form a basic 40sq meter flat to a fancy 250sq meter house, going back is very hard. I believe this is view harmful to the cause because it will only result in pushback, and rightfully so. Only excess wealth creates the spare capacity to care for the environment.
- js8 8y ago> Why won't it? The problem is that many people (who express that conviction) treat "Science" just like the God in the famous anecdote: http://epistle.us/inspiration/godwillsaveme.html http://epistle.us/inspiration/godwillsaveme.html It is important to understand the limits of science. It won't save you universally from everything, no matter what you do. Your own action (or inaction, in case of waste) determines what can be done.
- selimthegrim 8y agoWhen Hillary said that she believed in science on stage during the 2016 DNC I remember audibly groaning
- js8 8y agoFWIW, I heard Joe Biden considers climate change to be a crisis and wants to tackle it in a moderate way. Go figure.
- crispinb 8y agoThe main issue is where we get our energy from. No, that's just the most currently newsworthy of literally hundreds of causes of the global ecological collapse. Ecologists have been mapping many of these causes for decades. The overarching cause of all the component causelets (eg. emissions, habitat destruction, soil & water degradation, etc) has been the expansion of a crude global civilisation based on selective ignorance of science. We pretend to respect science when it produces stuff we like ("technology"), but ignore the inconvenient understandings revealed by science as it relates to the complex living systems that sustain us.
- crispinb 8y agoAn unlimited growth in a finite environment isn't possible Even limited 'growth' has not actually happened. It's a fiction. The physical reality is that complex sustainable evolved systems have been broken down to feed simpler crude unsustainable techological ones. There's no 'growth' to be seen - just an increase in planetary entropy. This is somewhat masked on a short-term & local scale because of the remarkable resilience of the evolved systems. But as those systems collapse, which now seems inevitable, the fictional nature of 'economic growth' will become very evident indeed.
- ebalit 8y agoI don't like this argument as it misses the fact that the Earth is not a closed system. Life on earth is only possible because we're receiving a constant flow of energy from the sun. Surely, we should not expect exponential growth, but it doesn't mean we could not have unlimited growth.
- crispinb 8y ago> it misses the fact that the Earth is not a closed system How so? It's not an argument per se - it's just a description of the physical reality that what economists falsely describe as 'growth' is actually a transfer of matter and energy from complex evolved sustainable systems (ie. what some people call 'nature', which I find to be misleading) to simple cultural-technological unsustainable systems. This transfer process damages the former to build the latter, increasing entropy (because our early-stage human tech is less ordered than evolved systems are). It is not 'growth' in any meaningful sense of the term at all, whether limited or unlimited.
- lioeters 8y agoInteresting point, that economic growth is a fiction - when the cost of growth is the deterioration of our own living environment, which is the true source of value. In fact, I'd posit that we do not even have the ability to produce "true value", we only know how to transform and consume it - perhaps in the same way that we're unable to "create energy" out of nothing. But then again.. Growth in general is all about consuming our surroundings, transforming the elements into new organizations, leaving waste behind. Apparently, the main measure of economic growth is the gross domestic product - "the monetary value of all the finished goods and services produced", which is based on spending and consumption. Planetary entropy, as you say. As someone else commented in this thread, what we need is a significant global shift in mentality and culture, our value systems and vision of what it means to be a grown-up civilization, not as an ever-hungry consumer, but an intelligent layer of nature.
- filleokus 8y ago> We'd need a economic/cultural revolution at a global scale. Everything has to scale down, no more ICE, not more plastic, no more food imported from the other side of the world, reduce meat consumption, reduce traveling &c. This is a sentiment that rubs me the wrong way. I totally agree that we, at a global scale, need to drastically reduce our carbon footprint. And these reductions will have changes to our society. But many of the suggestions of those currently engaged in the cultural revolution are either focusing on small problems (like not buying food in plastic containers) or have complicated unintended consequences (like buying locally grown foods). Shipping stuff on large boats is incredibly efficient per kg/km. It's not unlikely that I emit more Co2 driving my car to/from the grocery store than the emissions from shipping all the things I purchase to the store itself. We should focus on things like stopping the burning of fossil fule for electricity generation and carbon natural land based transportation long before we almost religiously ban plastic straws. I don't think the best way forward to actually solving this problem is engaging in some almost Protestant self hatred and punishment, trying to make the transition as impactful on our lives as possible.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoThat's another thing where I believe "those currently engaged in the cultural revolution" often get confused. Not all stuff bundled together under "problems with environment" is created equal. Container ships are a problem because they usually run on ridiculously dirty fuel, which ends up polluting the ocean. But they're also extremely energy-efficient on a mass/distance basis. A saner world would have them use cleaner fuel[0]. Cars are a problem because at the scale they're used, they're both significant contributor to global warming and inefficient, energy-wise. Electrifying land transportation would fix the inefficiency and significantly reduce the carbon footprint. Powering the new electric fleet with green energy[1] would finally kill the emission issues. Plastic straws, plastic packaging and other consumer disposables are a problem[2] because the plastic ends up in oceans, where it gets broken by UV into microplastics which then end up back in the food chain. Beyond that, it's mostly a sad thing to see. Energy and emissions-wise, plastic disposables are much smaller problem than other uses of fossil fuels, and sometimes they're likely better than the reusable alternatives proposed. But it's still so fucking sad to see so much garbage existing only as vehicle for marketing. IMO people need to stop bundling these problems together. Even though they're all related, energy security != global warming != poisons in food chain != ethical considerations about animals. Those are all separate problems, with separate sets of solutions, and quite honestly, different prioritization. -- [0] - My utopia would have nuclear-powered cargo ships as permanent global infrastructure, essentially treated as virtual conveyor belts. [1] - Renewables or nuclear. [2] - And we aren't even sure yet how big a problem this is. AFAIK this topic is covered mostly out of quite reasonable abundance of caution - we've noticed plastics showing up where they aren't supposed to. Even though there isn't any clear danger identified yet, history teaches us that human-released chemicals showing up in unexpected places generally don't lead to happy outcomes.
- mirimir 8y agoYeah, at some point denial is the most acceptable option. It's arguably not so much "science will save us" as "economics will save us". That's almost a religion in the US. Also, some distrust science on religious basis. And some even believe that it's all part of the coming apocalypse. Which is God's will.