6 ms·
Voice Pitch Predicts Labor Market Success Among Male CEOs (2012) [pdf]
- hartator 8y agoI remember reading another article that CEO who looks stressed and anxious on their video call with shareholders perform better than ones who look regular. Definitely an interesting subject.
- crsv 8y agoI enjoyed imaging the abstract being read aloud by Elizabeth Holmes with her clownish deep voice she worked to portray in the later stages of her fraudulent career. It's funny how these perceptions and findings sometimes line up.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoYes, Elizabeth Holmes was a fraud. But choosing to lower your voice to have a more commanding presence does not seem fraudulent not particularly "cartoonish" to me. Regardless of ones feelings towards Margaret Thatcher's policies, Thatcher was most definitely not fraudulent, and her lowering her voice was almost a virtual necessity in her political era.
- EnderViaAnsible 8y agoI think part of the problem is that Holmes's voice sounded artificial. To be effective, generally speaking, you would imagine the voice couldn't sound like you were trying to speak with a deep voice. (But surely studies have been done on this. Does it matter?) But I agree with you. I've always "dressed up" in work situations, for example, because people respond more positively to me when I look sharp. I think it witheringly stupid that people would assess my competence based on something so tangential, but if they are going to have a prejudice, why shouldn't I make it a prejudice in my favor (by dressing well instead of whatever I want to wear)? Short men should be wearing hidden heel shoes, too. Those inches are worth a lot more money than the shoes are. Etc.
- lenticular 8y agoSubconscious gender/racial biases, which absolutely everyone has, are so devilish because they take conscious effort to overcome.
- microcolonel 8y agoSurely the effect is just as likely to flow in the complete opposite direction: male CEOs who perform better gain deeper voices, or there is a common factor affecting both; and of course, the effect is measured specifically among male CEOs.
- lenticular 8y agoI doubt it is anywhere near just as likely to flow in the opposite direction. It's not like masculine white males are favored just because of their voice pitch. That ideal as the ideal of power is deeply ingrained in our society. More generally, humans will basically always show bias towards those in more dominant groups, because currying favor with such people is a far better winning strategy than being nice to low-status individuals. Whether the Hutus and Tutsis, white and black, masculine male vs effeminate, etc, it always is the same. This is just an unfortunate thing about the human brain, but we can use our reasoning ability to correct it. But first, we have to accept hat it exists.
- microcolonel 8y agoWhy would it be unfortunate that masculine men are preferred in some roles to effeminate men? I don't see the moral issue of such a preference.
- lenticular 8y agoWe're talking about employment here. Masculine vs. feminine has nothing to do with job performance except in maybe porn or something. If masculine men are preferred, then that means everyone else isn't. It's an obvious avenue for discrimination against women and LGBT people. I'm a very masculine gay man (I'm just stating that as a fact, I'm not better than anyone else for it). I do know many more effeminate gay men. Things really are more difficult in the workplace for them especially, not jut in my experience, but empirically. I'm glad I don't have that affect because it makes my life easier, but biases like this can creep in and will always be damaging.
- adamwong246 8y agoA quick google search shows thyroplasty to be a great investment!
- rangersanger 8y agoseems like gore-tex is all over hacker news this week. From corneas to voiceboxes.
- darkpuma 8y agoI mean, gore-tex (ePTFE) has been used for medical implants for decades.
- alexandercrohde 8y agoI didn't read the whole article, but my first question is if they controlled for direction of effect. The "winner effect" is a known phenomenon when people succeed in competition their body starts to produce more testosterone (for men). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winner_and_loser_effects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winner_and_loser_effects
- JimboOmega 8y agoShort term testosterone would have little effect. However voice pitch is highly social and situational... it could still all be correlated. Someone who feels confident and feels like they "won" might subconsciously lower their voice in other interactions. To give another example, men tend to subconsciously lower their voices when talking to a woman they find attractive. There's a lot of other things going on than just the physiology.
- alexandercrohde 8y ago>> Short term testosterone would have little effect. Calling BS on that. Doubt you looked that up. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c4LbafuDmI4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c4LbafuDmI4
- 55555 8y agoThe effect the article refers to probably lasts hours to a day. The doses that FtM transgender are taking are higher than the normal male range, I'd estimate.
- JimboOmega 8y agoYeah, that's what I was referring to as short term - hours to a day. The linked YouTube video is a year. If a cis-man was to take a similar dose (and thus say, have double physiological T levels) they would certainly not notice their voice changing the next days. Most transgender medicine protocols target physiological levels of the hormones for the desired gender. It gets a bit more complicated with transwomen, because women have a tremendous range of variation during each cycle (never mind pregnancy), and because high estrogen levels can suppress testosterone on their own (so you don't need a separate medication to do that)... so there are different schools of thought as to the best way to do it. Targeting physiological levels is done mostly because that seems like a good idea a priori. One of the joys of being transgender is being part of an ongoing science experiment.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rdlecler1 8y agoWe see similar outcomes with height. I’ve always wondered how much the gender gap in income—if any—was driven by differences in height. Are people negatively biasing women because they are women or are they biasing against shorter people in general? Meg Whitman was 6’1”. Marissa Meyer is 5’8”. Sheryl Sandberg is 5’8”, Elizabeth Holmes is 5’7” Indra Nooyi is 5’9”.
- Animats 8y agoMale income peaks around 6' to 6'1".[1] [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/05/the-financial-perks-of-being-tall/393518/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/05/the-fin...
- bayareanative 8y agoI wonder why there is a penalty for being taller than 6'1"? Are others intimidated and therefore punishing advantages?
- door5 8y agoIt isn't, there is an enormous body of evidence demonstrating that the gender pay gap is driven by overt sexism and institutional barriers. This evidence is far more compelling than speculation about height.
- cal5k 8y agoI’m very sceptical of this explanation. Sexism probably still plays a role, but not nearly as big a role as population-level average differences in personality/interests. Some interesting papers: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0956797617741719?journalCode=pssa& https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/095679761774171... https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0191886917305962?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S019188691... https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/ijop.12529 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/ijop.12529
- 8y ago
- Animats 8y agoCan you run voice filters with Skype for interviews?
- peteretep 8y agoI would buy a voice-training app for this
- door5 8y agoAnother way in which rigid, patriarchal gender roles hurt men as well as women. Straight men should be far more critical of sexism and misogyny than they are. This attitude is directly tied to oppression against women in the workforce.
- LanceH 8y agoThat's a rather sexist statement telling men what they should be thinking.
- door5 8y agoIt's not sexist to point out that men historically have held disproportionate cultural, social, economic, and political power and continue to do so to this day.
- epicureanideal 8y agoAnd historically men have fought wars, guarded borders, done very dangerous jobs, and so on. Most men have not held power. A top 1% of men held power, and 99% of men did dirty and dangerous jobs at the bottom of the hierarchy, and worked worse than animals to try to provide for and protect their families. Men give up seats on lifeboats for women, yada yada yada. Trying to frame this whole thing as "men vs women" is ridiculous, because men are so incredibly in favor of sacrificing themselves for women. Clearly other issues are involved than some "pure evil sexism".
- door5 8y agoI didn't frame it as men vs. women. I framed it as challenging patriarchy, which is a system and ideology of male dominance and control.
- ummonk 8y agoShould we? Judging from its actions, feminism seems to be focused on trying to get men at the top to share their power with women. While I can support this out of a sense of fairness, I see no reason to support it purely out of self-interest. It's not like having a mix of men and women at the top will benefit me.
- spyckie2 8y ago> To identify a set of executives for analysis, we start with a list of male CEOs from the Standard & Poor’s 1500 stock index analyzed by Engelberg, Gao & Parsons (in press). We restrict attention to only male CEOs because of the sexually dimorphic nature of voice pitch (Titze, 1994) and the poor representation of female CEOs among S&P 1500 firms (Bertrand & Hallock, 2001). > We intersect the Engelberg et al. (in press) observations with the Mayew & Venkatachalam (2012) CEO speech corpus, which is derived from publicly broadcast telephonic earnings conference calls archived in the Thomson Reuters StreetEvents database (www.streetevents.com). > The median sample CEO is 56 years old, operates a firm with $2.427 billion in assets, and is paid $3.692 million annually. > A test of mediation using the product of coefficients method for large samples following Preacher & Hayes (2008) confirms firm size mediates the effects of voice pitch (Z=3.15, p=0.002). The paper states that a lower voice is perceived (by everyone else) to be a better leader. Sounds reasonable enough, I guess. The statistics then show that the lower the voice, the better the compensation of the CEO and the larger the firm the CEO runs, with a strong correlation. This is where I scratch my head a bit. A couple of thoughts for why this may be, all guesses, really: 1) Listed companies on the S&P 1500 are mostly very mature and the CEOs may not do much of the value creation. Other people (CTO, COO, CFO, etc) might be doing most of the value creation with the CEO holding the company together. (This is in contrast to many tech companies - Jeff Bezos, Bill Gates, Steve Jobs, Elon Musk, etc - who are strategically involved in the company. It is their strategic directional leadership that they bring in that people trust, rather than how they make you feel when they talk) 2) In mature markets that aren't tech related, innovation is not a strong factor of growth, it's usually intangibles like connections, communication, convincing people, alignment, deals, etc. Having a "leader voice" can have a strong impact to get buy in from everyone, internal and external. 3) There may very well be a physiological link between a lower voice and strong leadership qualities, rather than just the perception of it, who knows? Or people who have a lower voice get innate advantages in leadership due to people trusting them more and them having an easier time because of that, kind of like a flywheel effect. 4) The statistics may be wrong. This doesn't seem to be the case with how they designed it.
- stanfordkid 8y agoThis is intriguing -- I would guess that a successful strategy would be to short stocks with high growth that have a CEO with "evolutionarily advantageous" traits (height, attractiveness, depth of voice) ... and go long stocks with high growth that have CEO's lacking these characteristics: The company with the "suave" CEO is likely building revenue as a result of sales and people charisma rather than core innovation.
- Zenbit_UX 8y ago>The company with the "suave" CEO is likely building revenue as a result of sales and people charisma rather than core innovation. Yes, because tall people can't have good products too...?
- balfirevic 8y agoNo, that is not implied in the parent comment.
- 1k 8y agoDoes pitch get lower with age? That would correlate with larger companies tending to choose more experienced CEOs. That aside, there are other forms of biases, like people preferring better _looking_ leaders (based on socially perceived ideals on height, color, religion, hereditary status) and so too will they prefer better sounding CEOs.
- smudgymcscmudge 8y agoHere’s to hoping 58 is the age where my voice changes and I get a high power executive position.
- candybar 8y agoThis isn't particularly convincing, given that it's such a small and skewed sample and the effect is so small. The average CEO in this sample operates a firm of 8B and makes 8M - the effect they found was 30M for firm size and 19K for annual comp for each percentage decrease in pitch. It's quite likely that merely adding, say, Steve Jobs or Michael Bloomberg into the sample would've been enough to reverse the effect. Also, what would be much more interesting is if CEOs as a group were substantially different from the general population in this regard - but they are saying the median CEO wasn't at all extraordinary. To the extent that there is an effect, I think the causality may be the other way - voice pitch isn't an immutable characteristic of each speaker but situational. One well-known effect is that people tend to speak with a higher pitch when talking to relatively high status people and a lower pitch when talking to relatively low status people. It seems quite possible that CEOs of larger companies perceive wall street analysts and investors as lower status than CEOs of smaller companies do, causing this discrepancy. It seems far more plausible than lower-pitched men being CEOs of disproportionately larger firms, without the same effect holding up across the entire professional spectrum.