4 ms·
This is the “city as a closed universe” fallacy. What you actually have to do is line up every potential purchase of a home (which may be more than one per buye
by jseliger 8y ago
This is the “city as a closed universe” fallacy. What you actually have to do is line up every potential purchase of a home (which may be more than one per buyer) in the city by any person in the world in that order.
If only we had some example of a city that built as much as the market demands. https://jamesjgleeson.wordpress.com/2018/02/19/how-tokyo-built-its-way-to-abundant-housing/ https://jamesjgleeson.wordpress.com/2018/02/19/how-tokyo-bui...
- eecsninja 8y agoIf only the naysayers of development as a solution bothered to do research on how Asian cities (esp Tokyo) develop to get ideas to apply to cities in the west.
- dragonwriter 8y agoThe US has about 10× as many immigrants as a share of population as Japan does, and the Bay Area is significantly higher than the US average share. Globalized demand is not an issue Tokyo (or most Asian cities) face. Globalized demand is what makes it impractical for SF to lower market clearing costs significantly by increasing supply. Also, Japan has a shrinking population, which means that not only isn't globalized demand a thing, the localized potential demand is shrinking, too. So, yeah, boosting supply works well on prices there, for reasons where it wouldn't in SF or the Bay Area more generally. (And the US shutting down immigration to control the SF housing market, aside from being a radical national solution to an isolated local issue, would also undercut the economic engine driving progress in SF--and lots of other places in the country. While that also would contribute to lower housing prices, we've done "tank the economy to drop housing prices" back around 2008, and I don't think it was all that popular; the cure is worse than the disease.) I wish the people pointing to Asian cities as a role model for SF bothered to do research on the differences between the situation facing SF and those facing the Asian cities at issue.
- megaremote 8y agoTokyo is a weird case, since apparently people don't like living in used homes.
- kurthr 8y agoIf only a single self fulfilling data point of the largest city of an insular society (requiring citizenship to buy) with falling population near the edge of recession for 30 years was representative of the world's real estate market. Also, I'd recommend talking to people in Tokyo about the cost of living/working there (you'll find most people commute in over an hour by train) and about rising homelessness. This is with a population growth rate over the last 30 years of less than 0.5% and is EXPECTED TO RELENTLESSLY DECLINE AFTER 2020 to 2100 by 6million people. http://worldpopulationreview.com/world-cities/tokyo-population/ http://worldpopulationreview.com/world-cities/tokyo-populati... If you want some other data points on massive building increases, I offer you Beijing, Shanghai, and Shenzhen, where prices have doubled many times while the available housing has also more than doubled over less than 30 years at a more than 2.5% population growth rate.
- eecsninja 8y agoThe data you linked is for the entire Tokyo metropolitan area. The trend is that people are moving out of rural areas and into the urban core. It would be more appropriate to look at the central part of Tokyo, the 23 wards (former city of Tokyo): http://www.newgeography.com/content/002923-the-evolving-urban-form-tokyo http://www.newgeography.com/content/002923-the-evolving-urba... From 1990 to 2010 (latest year in data), the population grew 9.6%. In the same time period, SF's population grew 11.3%: http://worldpopulationreview.com/us-counties/ca/san-francisco-county-population/ http://worldpopulationreview.com/us-counties/ca/san-francisc... Not a big difference if you ask me. Yet SF prices have skyrocketed. Tokyo may require citizenship to buy, but that doesn't mean foreigners can't rent. Rent prices in central Tokyo often start at around $1500/month, which is a lot less than that of SF bay area suburbs.
- pixelcort 8y agoIt is possible to buy housing in Tokyo without citizenship. You don’t even need permanent residency. Source: I am a homeowner in Tokyo.
- Spooky23 8y agoThat’s a bad example. I live in a median market, where the price per square foot is about $150 for a detached house in an urban area with tight supply. The difference why places like California and NYC are so out of control has less to do with supply than demand. As fiscal policy and philosophy demand consolidation and concentration, more and more people in the same circumstances go to the same place. Since the mid 70s, smart jobs go to the top 10 cities, dumb jobs go the the South or offshore, and everything else is mined for value. It doesn’t have to be that way. When IBM was at its prime, their big engineering centers were in places like Upstate NY, Minneapolis, Tampa, RTP, Toronto, etc. GE did similar things. Modern tech companies would rather pay 3-7x more for folks in the Bay Area or NYC. That’s all about control and where the money is.
- marcosdumay 8y agoThe pressing question is: where are the companies that pay 1/7 if the salaries elsewhere and use the low prices to drive their SV competitors out of the market? I imagine the answer runs around government intervention and wealth concentration.
- dkasper 8y agoMany of the most popular products made in SV are free so there’s not much room to compete on price.
- less_penguiny 8y agoPerhaps because the value of being in the valley, near customers, know-how, and investment, is worth the multiple (though I'd put the salary difference closer to 2.5x than 7x).
- imtringued 8y agoBecause SV has more financial capital and can pay 7 times higher salaries or even afford to make losses.
- Spooky23 8y agoIt doesn’t matter because most of the players are losing money — the social connections allows you to burn billions and make no money at all. The consolidation / concentration issue applies more to normal businesses. Regional banking, for example is dead, and that has all sorts of negative impacts on places that aren’t the biggest cities. Not only are the workers gone, but there’s no commercial banking available anymore.