11 ms·
> Why have users chosen those environments? Because they don't give a rat's ass about the freedom aspect of free software. If software A requires four clicks t
by kazinator 8y ago
> Why have users chosen those environments?
Because they don't give a rat's ass about the freedom aspect of free software. If software A requires four clicks to do something, but B has a way to do it in 3, they are on B without a second thought.
But in this case, those users are not just any old end users; the are actually supposed to be FOSS developers, so there is a heavy irony there.
I think what is doing on is that large numbers of people are now "reluctant" FOSS developers. They do FOSS because someone told them to. They got a job somewhere and the job involves writing code that gets upstreamed somewhere and is redistributable. Well, they don't give a damn about that, it's just a job, no different from working on proprietary software. Or they work on some proprietary stuff, but it interacts with and depends on some FOSS pieces so they get in there and make changes out of necessity, and those changes are freely licensed only because they are derived from a work which requires that due to copyright doctrines about derived works.
It's partly a generational thing. Notice how Doc Searls looks about fifty-something. He remembers a grassroots free software movement which was about actually about displacing proprietary software and liberating the user, and not about about providing reliable commodity middleware for locked-down devices and cloud services.
If you were born after 1990, you don't know a world in which Linux and other FOSS wasn't used for making locked-down tech, and proprietary web sites that lock in millions of people and step on their privacy. So of course it's hard to understand someone like Doc Searls.
The free software ideology originated in a world in which you still installed applications locally and ran them on local data, on a machine where you were allowed to stick in a floppy disc with any piece of machine language in its boot sector that could easily take over the machine. The machine that was understood to be owned by you once you paid for it.
- michaelmrose 8y agoIts more like if it takes 12 clicks to do it but I was shown how to do so at school/work, or it was preinstalled I will keep on clicking.
- Drdrdrq 8y ago>> Why have users chosen those environments? > Because they don't give a rat's ass about the freedom aspect of free software. If software A requires four clicks to do something, but B has a way to do it in 3, they are on B without a second thought. Convenience always wins. Always. Users do care about free (as in beer) and they care if the product or service will disappear without warning (hello Google!). But the definitions of FOSS are so strict that they harm developers, and thus products, and thus convenience for users. OP is describing the symptoms of this phenomena.
- the_af 8y ago> Convenience always wins Yes, but convenience also leads to greedy "algorithms" prone to getting stuck in local maxima. Convenience can make us lazy and choose the wrong long-term solutions. This applies to more things than just tech ("convenience" may make us choose foods that are wrong for our health, for example).
- kazinator 8y agoTraditional free software developers do not use the most convenient program without caring about freedom. Otherwise, for instance, nobody would be debugging with gdb, rather than Visual Studio or what have you.Nobody would be LaTeXing instead of using MS Word or Adobe Illustrator. GIMP isn't as good as Photoshop (if I believe what people say), yet people still use it. (I've only ever used GIMP since 1996; I have no idea about Photoshop and don't care; it's not free, won't use it.) People went through all sorts of inconveniences to use free software, like manually figuring out monitor clock timings to stick into their X configuration, building their own custom kernels and whatnot. You can't say "convenience wins" with a straight face; that's like saying free software doesn't exist.
- magduf 8y ago>Otherwise, for instance, nobody would be debugging with gdb, rather than Visual Studio or what have you. If you're working with embedded Linux, Visual Studio isn't going to be much help for debugging on a target. >Nobody would be LaTeXing instead of using MS Word or Adobe Illustrator. LaTeX does some things much better than Word, and Illustrator is very expensive. >GIMP isn't as good as Photoshop (if I believe what people say), yet people still use it. GIMP is free. Photoshop is not. You seem to be assuming the people have unlimited money to purchase software licenses. Many free software programs are used not because they're better, but just because they're free and good enough. If I just want to crop and rescale some photos or something, why on earth would I buy a Photoshop license when I can just download and use GIMP for free?
- kazinator 8y agoMany proprietary programs also get used because they are good enough. Not everyone wants to do a simple thing using some UI that has grown into a Boeing 747 cockpit. Some Windows users use neither GIMP nor Photoshop to crop an image, but rather MS Paint, which is comes with the OS, so it is "no additional cost", and requires next to no training to use. MS Paint has vastly diminished functionality compared to either GIMP or Photoshop.
- jakelazaroff 8y ago> Because they don't give a rat's ass about the freedom aspect of free software. If software A requires four clicks to do something, but B has a way to do it in 3, they are on B without a second thought. Isn't this kind of the point, though? To compete with proprietary software, free software needs to actually be competitive. "It's not as good as this other (proprietary) software, but it's free" won't cut it.
- crankylinuxuser 8y agoUntil you want your data. Turns out data roach motelling is a big thing. And it's even better for the corp interests if they can tie hardware and software to irreplaceable APIs that lock the user down to the whims of the owner. It's time to take the fight back to "Owner"... If you purchased it, why can't you do what you want? Why are you prevented from doing arbitrary actions?
- Naac 8y agoCase in point, it's surprisingly frustrating to get your photos off of Instagram on mobile.
- kibwen 8y ago> "It's not as good as this other (proprietary) software, but it's free" won't cut it. Except that it has to cut it in order for a free software movement to exist, because otherwise free software is starved by a chicken-and-egg problem where developers don't use free software because it's inferior, and free software never improves because developers don't use it. In other words, being willing to use technically inferior software solely because of the superior freedoms it grants is the way to make the engine of free software run. GCC was not the best C compiler in the world when Linux started using it.
- zapzupnz 8y agoI don't believe this to be the case. Sure, software can have growing pains, but there's nothing to stop free software projects from moving to embrace what people love about proprietary packages, delivered in a user-friendly way. Software doesn't need to be better to win. Look at Google Docs, a shallow imitation of what document editors were doing even in the early 90s. It became popular in spite of it. (And don't say it was just because of Google's huge influence; they've had plenty of reimplementations-of-what-we-already-have-except-on-their-servers that have failed miserably). I look at Google Docs as an example of someone saying "right, we mightn't have all the answers, but we have the answers to what people want right now", which turned out to be easier collaboration rather than nitty-gritty, barely-used features. Nobody except company IT admins gave a flying toss about whether moving to Google Docs had any licence or implications on software freedoms; it was inferior to Word (and others) in so many ways, remains so, but does what users want. I am unconvinced that the argument that users should ever settle for inferior software just because it comes with superior freedoms is anything other than masturbatory. It has the pretence of being user-focused (freedoms) without actually being user-focused (what users care about). I think it would be a better strategy to focus on the latter whilst also promising and delivering the former.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y ago>about about providing reliable commodity middleware for locked-down devices and cloud services. Free software made cheap, network centric computing feasible. This led from a model where the user ran their applications (open or closed) on their machines to one which turned the user's machine into a dumb terminal to access the network. This resulted in defacto loss of user privacy and control. In a world where Windows was dominant and you had to pay a per cpu licensing fee, would companies be trying to put everything on the web, or would they create more apps that ran locally with some network based syncing? It would have been a smart computer, dumb network world instead of the dumb computer, smart network world we have now. One of the great ironies of computing is how free software in its quest to enable user freedom actually enabled a world with less defacto user freedom than before.
- ThrowawayR2 8y ago> Free software made cheap, network centric computing feasible. Anybody remember the dot-com boom? Sun Microsystem's silly "The Network Is The Computer." ads? No? Linux wasn't even a blip on the radar back then at the enterprise level. > In a world where Windows was dominant and you had to pay a per cpu licensing fee, would companies be trying to put everything on the web, or would they create more apps that ran locally with some network based syncing? Um, obviously yes? The fact that Sun and the other UNIX server vendors and Oracle other server software vendors were charging various fees for their OS and software, on a per server or per CPU basis, did nothing to put the brakes on the dotcom boom. Network-centric computing took off well before free software became the buzzword of the mid to late '00s.
- regularfry 8y agoLinux itself might not have been (although I'd challenge that if I could remember dates a bit better); Apache and Perl certainly was.
- pjmlp 8y agoIn 2000 we were delivering UNIX software into production on Aix, Solaris and HP-UX boxes, my employer at the time did not consider either GNU/Linux or BSD fit for the quality standards we expected from a standard UNIX, although we did use them on some internal servers, including our builds.
- jcastro 8y ago> Because they don't give a rat's ass about the freedom aspect of free software. It's attitudes like this that make people really not care about FOSS. Yelling at people because they're not using IRC instead of slack isn't a good way to convince anyone.
- kuschku 8y agoWhen IRC looks like this https://quasseldroid.info/assets/images/phone.png https://quasseldroid.info/assets/images/phone.png or this https://blog.irccloud.com/static/2018-05-14-slack-integration/sidebyside-irccloud.png https://blog.irccloud.com/static/2018-05-14-slack-integratio... and people still complain about IRC’s UI or usability, then what more can we IRC devs do?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jamesgeck0 8y agoIRCCloud is okay, but the UX/UI isn't anywhere near as nice as Slack.
- kuschku 8y agoThat may be true, but it's good enough that it should be easily usable by developers. And I'm personally working on Quasseldroid, improving its UI to make it much more usable. If you have suggestions on how to make Quasseldroid usable for the people that refuse to use IRC, I'd love to hear them :)
- jamesgeck0 8y ago> it's good enough that it should be easily usable by developers. Sure, but the reason all the developers at my workplace use Slack is because we have to communicate with a lot of people who aren't developers. Slack's good UX extends beyond the basic chat interface to configuration, administration, and initial signup. It's significantly easier for someone nontechnical to toss money at Slack to get a new private space than it is with IRC. The first page of "IRC hosting" search results on Google for me are mostly shell accounts; nothing turnkey and professional looking that a business person could/would use.
- api 8y ago> If software A requires four clicks to do something, but B has a way to do it in 3 The difference is usually more like "software A requires an hour of setup and constant maintenance on a dedicated VM or container due to dozens of dependencies, and software B requires 3 clicks"
- kccqzy 8y agoAnd also the difference between "the code is inelegant and sucks and I'll remove it, damn the users" and "the code may be ugly but the feature users want is ugly so let's do it". Case in point, I recently upgraded the computer of a non-technical person from Ubuntu 18.10 to 19.04. And now desktop icons are completely broken. It's been reimplemented in JS, with horrible performance, and doesn't even support features like dragging an icon to a folder. Their reason for removal? A bunch of technobabble no user would understand. https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/nautilus/issues/158 https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/nautilus/issues/158
- price 8y agoStuff gets removed from proprietary software all the damn time. To pick a notorious example: have you tried to use Google Reader lately? :-P Others I've personally noticed in the last couple of years include features of Dropbox; of Gmail; of Facebook; of Google Search; and various startups acquired and shut down -- including a mobile app with no backend of its own. When stuff gets removed or shut down, the basic reason is that it takes work to keep it going, and someone decides to stop allocating any work to that. Even with client-side software with no service to run (like that mobile app), the platforms they run on change, and it takes work to keep up. And that's exactly what I see in that GNOME issue you link to. There's a bunch of technical detail about why it's so much work -- but the point they're making is it's been a lot of work to keep that feature going the way it was, and it'd be even more work to continue doing so as the rest of the software on the desktop changes around it in the ways that are planned. And so they decide to drop the existing thing and build a new one in a much easier way. The only difference from proprietary software is that everyone has the option to step in and say, no, I'm going to go pick up that work, and everyone's welcome to use my version instead. In fact, GNOME makes a great example, because there have been a bunch of popular projects precisely about doing that with previous decisions they've made: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cinnamon_(software) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cinnamon_(software) is one of the bigger ones. If people had that option with Google Reader, it'd be alive today. (I'm told it was a very small amount of work to keep running, and when the ax fell on it many Googlers pleaded to be allowed to just keep it running on their own time.) Ditto for many of the other proprietary things I've missed after they went away.
- em-bee 8y agogood point on the "reluctant" FOSS developers. i see this a lot. big companies have teams that work on FOSS projects, but most of the people in those teams don't understand what the fuss is about. they come to FOSS events to promote their products and treat them no different than their proprietary ones. the thing is, their leaders may actually understand FOSS and believe in it because they can see the benefits, but they don't understand that for the developers below them it is just another job. i have argued that exact point in a company where i worked, telling the leaders that if they want to get the developers to make actual voluntary contributions and participate in the FOSS community the leaders need to set an example and actively motivate the developers to do so. just assigning someone to work on a FOSS project is not enough to help that person to join the FOSS community. there are exceptions of course, where someone interacting with the community realizes that there is more to it and becomes drawn into it, but that's not the norm.
- raverbashing 8y agoAnd that's why everything is continue to go downhill in the Free Software world Because of the mentality that UX problems are just "the user being lazy" IRC stopped in time. Linux desktop is a mess and have very weird ideas about UX (especially Gnome, they love making things "simple" by shipping a car with no gearbox but only one speed) "Freedom" is a "cost/quality" like any other, some people might value it the most, some people might value it the least, but it is less important than other factors.