8 ms·
I still don't understand this trend of replacing the sodium lamps with LED. The sodium lamps use roughly the same amount of energy, cast a light quality that i
by jedberg 8y ago
I still don't understand this trend of replacing the sodium lamps with LED. The sodium lamps use roughly the same amount of energy, cast a light quality that is better for both humans and animals, and are already there, saving a bunch of money in doing replacements.
Why are all these cities undertaking huge renovations to go to LEDs?
- melling 8y agoMy guess is LED lights are supposed to last a lot longer. The human cost of replacing lights is probably a lot more than the cost of the bulb. Labor is expensive.
- jedberg 8y agoNot really. The rated life of sodium is 24,000 hours, and LED is 25,000. With a lot of money you can get LEDs with rated life up to 200,000 hours, but that's not typically what cities are buying.
- TylerE 8y agoAs the article states the LEDs are failing well under rated lifespan. If I use conservative estimates (10 hrs per day, "few years" = 4), then these LEDs are failing at under 15,000 hrs.
- jedberg 8y agoWhich of course only makes a stronger argument for keeping the longer lasting sodium lamps. :)
- melling 8y agowhere did you come up with 25,000? The article says the LEDs were supposed to last at least a decade, which is the length of the warranty.
- jedberg 8y agoThat's just the average rated life of an LED street lamp. But if you do that math, that's about 5.7 years at an average of 12 hours a day. So these lamps were probably rated closer to 50,000 hours. You can also get sodium lamps that last that long. It's just an average.
- melling 8y agoDo you give a warranty on the average? I doubt it. A 10 year warranty probably means the average is longer than 10 years.
- Itsdijital 8y agoMind you LED life span is usually rated to ~75% brightness instead of complete failure like other bulbs.
- the8472 8y agoOr alternatively, why not red-orange LEDs to achieve similar effects?
- colek42 8y agoOr RGBW LEDs so the color can be changed depending on conditions.
- ShinTakuya 8y agoThat would add to the cost.
- Dylan16807 8y agoWhat conditions? When would you ever want white? And the point of specific warm LEDs is avoiding higher frequencies. It's not the same as mixing light from red and green LEDs.
- ollie87 8y agoI can see one use case, on a busy road if there is a major collision the emergency services being able to switch them to bright white would be great.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoThe City of Chicago is funding a replacement of all it's sodium bulbs with LEDs solely off the energy cost savings [1]. I'm unsure what sodium lamps you're referring to that use a similar amount of energy as LEDs. > The sodium lamps use roughly the same amount of energy "The new LED lights will consume 50% less electricity than the existing High Pressure Sodium (HPS) lights. When fully implemented the new fixtures are estimated to save the City $10 million a year in utility costs. By consuming less electricity, the City is helping reduce its carbon footprint. LED fixtures last up to two-three times longer than HPS fixtures." > cast a light quality that is better for both humans and animals "Compared to HPS lights, LED lights make it easier to see the contrast between an object and its surroundings; so one can quickly and more accurately identify people, vehicles, road debris or other things on the street or sidewalk. The whiter light also enhances peripheral vision and improves the quality of video resolution" [1] http://chicagosmartlighting-chicago.opendata.arcgis.com/pages/program-background-and-benefits http://chicagosmartlighting-chicago.opendata.arcgis.com/page...
- jedberg 8y ago> The new LED lights will consume 50% less electricity than the existing High Pressure Sodium (HPS) lights. Not sure how they're going to achieve that. LEDs produce 37 to 120 lumens/watt, HPS and LPS produce 50 to 160 lumens/watt. The sodium lamps lose out only because they are omnidirectional and a mirror is required to aim their light down, so some of the light is blocked by the lamp itself. But overall LEDs don't save 50%. > Compared to HPS lights, LED lights make it easier to see the contrast between an object and its surroundings; This is true, but it's a red herring. While that might increase safety in one regard, the light cast by an LED is very blue, which affects both humans and animals, making their bodies think it is still daytime. This disturbs the natural hunting and migration patterns of the animals, and more importantly, disturbs the sleep of the humans. Sleep deprived humans are for more dangerous than ones that have a harder time detecting object edges. Also, shouldn't we consider quality of life issues when making these changes, and not just efficiency?
- naikrovek 8y ago> the light cast by an LED is very blue For blue LEDs, sure. LEDs today can be made to emit any color all the way up to pure white.
- babypuncher 8y agoThe color rendering index of low pressure sodium bulbs is vastly inferior to that of a typical white LED. High pressure sodium bulbs are even worse in that regard.
- function_seven 8y agoFor backlighting LCD screens, sure. But for street lighting, I don't want a good CRI. I want to minimize blue light, harsh shadows, and glare. The old yellow sodium lights were nice. The new LED streetlights around me are terrible.
- stfp 8y agoThey really really suck! Walking at night is a pain in the eyes for me now.
- Itsdijital 8y agoI call them retina burners. A new supermarket by me installed all LEDs for the parking lot, and used warm white ones. You wouldn't even be able to tell they aren't incandescent without looking. I really hope more word gets out to not use "bright white" LEDs for outdoor lighting.
- mixmastamyk 8y agoThought they were more of a peach color.
- babypuncher 8y agoIt depends on the type of sodium lamp. High pressure sodium bulbs emit light in an extremely narrow bandwidth around 589.3 nm, earning them a color rendering index of -44 (out of 100). Low pressure sodium bulbs broaden this range enough to earn a CRI of 24. These are the peach colored ones you are familiar with.
- jedberg 8y agoThat's exactly why the light quality of sodium is better. Because at night you want yellow lights so you don't screw up the sleep patterns of both humans and animals.
- wnevets 8y ago>The sodium lamps use roughly the same amount of energy That doesn't sound right, source? edit: https://www.stouchlighting.com/blog/led-vs-hps-lps-high-and-low-pressure-sodium https://www.stouchlighting.com/blog/led-vs-hps-lps-high-and-... Why would LEDs put Sodium vapor lights out of business? Sodium lamps have the worst color rendering of any bulb. They produce a dark yellow glow which is generally a very low quality light. Additionally, there are serious waste disposal issues with sodium lamps. In particular, they have been known to start fires in the event that the lamp is broken and the sodium metal is exposed. The sodium can catch fire even in the event that the lamp is broken on the ground. For this reason it is safest to break sodium lights under water and then to subsequently dispose of the destroyed bulb. Lastly, HPS and LPS lights are monochromatic, so they can mess with your color vision if you look at them for an extended period of time. Perhaps more importantly, in the last few years LED efficiency has surpassed that of even LPS and HPS lights and its efficiency improvements are progressing at a much more rapid rate. The largest selling point of LPS and HPS lights is the cheap selling price, the high energy efficiency (low operating costs), and the relatively long lifespan. LPS and HPS still retain these advantages over most conventional bulbs but they lose on all three counts to LEDs. In some areas (e.g. lifespan) they are drastically inferior to LEDs. The extremely low maintenance and replacement costs with LEDs is actually a major cost benefit over the long term. LED lifespan can be greater than 100,000 hours (more than four times that of LPS or HPS). Having to purchase one bulb versus 3 or 4 bulbs over the course of time is a significant selling point for LEDs. The bottom line is that having lost their traditional advantage of being the most energy efficient bulb on the market, there’s very little reason to use a sodium vapor light when LED lighting is available.
- sp332 8y agoThe low color quality, specifically the very warm hue, is a feature for nighttime lighting. Blue light messes with sleep cycles of humans and animals. The very narrow spectrum benefits astronomers because it's easy to filter out light pollution from low-pressure sodium lamps.
- notatoad 8y agoI thought the wider spectrum of light coming from LED streetlamps means they can be run at a lower brightness to provide the same visibility, which means less overall light pollution (less reflection back upwards) and less power usage.
- dlivingston 8y agoI watched a YouTube video [0] this morning which actually does a fantastic job of explaining the pros and cons of LED-based traffic lights. Short answer: it's complicated. [0]: https://youtu.be/GiYO1TObNz8 https://youtu.be/GiYO1TObNz8
- jacobolus 8y ago> Why are all these cities undertaking huge renovations to go to LEDs? From what I understand one big driver is federal subsidy money. I’m not an expert on the financing though. Also a ton of industry marketing / propaganda. And poorly designed recommendations / regulations for road engineering.
- compuguy 8y agoNot all are. In the county I live in, they are still using sodium lamps. The one exception I'm aware of is a pilot program at a commuter parking lot, where they use LED lamps.