10 ms·
What scares me about modern "casual" games like this one is their ability to extract money from people in a methodical, merciless way. There's no proper defense
by simonebrunozzi 8y ago
What scares me about modern "casual" games like this one is their ability to extract money from people in a methodical, merciless way. There's no proper defense for most people.
I fear our society will end up in a worse place because of businesses like this one.
- X6S1x6Okd1st 8y agoCould you elaborate?
- toomuchtodo 8y agohttps://levelskip.com/misc/Skinners-Box-and-Video-Games https://levelskip.com/misc/Skinners-Box-and-Video-Games
- chaostheory 8y agoThese games are a modern version of slot machines. It's habit forming, and it burns time and money. tbf it's still slightly better than things that you see in a casino
- yoz-y 8y agoCoin ups existed a long time ago too. Arguably you got even less value from those per dollar spent.
- the_af 8y agoI suppose they have all the downsides of coin ups plus they are also more readily accessible. You don't have to go anywhere to get your fix, it's there in your phone.
- ken 8y agoBut with those, it only operated when it was fed coins. It's been shown that people spend less when they pay with cash than credit cards. Casual mobile games go beyond even credit cards and have users spend nebulous tokens. They go as far as they can to disconnect the play from the loss of money, and that's bad. I see a significant difference between "have people pay for a fun service" and "engineer an experience specifically to be addictive".
- j-c-hewitt 8y agoEver carried around $20 in quarters in a fanny pack as a five year old? It's pretty heavy. There's a pretty low ceiling on how much you could spend back in the day and it was impossible to silently, digitally spend an unlimited quantity of your parents' money.
- the_af 8y agoAlso, in the early/mid days of coin-up games, a skilled player could win a game with a single coin while having fun in the process and using their skills instead of simply waiting for stuff to happen.
- j-c-hewitt 8y agoFighting games and head-to-head puzzle games like Bubble Bobble in a popular arcade were pretty cool like this in that people would line up to go up against the reigning champion who could go hours on a single quarter. Sort of weird how most "social" games are both a( trash and b( almost entirely single player with a tacked on multiplayer 'tournament' mode in which you play single player against some other player's template. Even in turn based games that would not suffer from a mobile connection's latency, they still have you go up against the AI with another player's template. Regression from the 1990s: absolutely pathetic. I wonder if legalization of internet slot machines would wipe out mobile gaming revenue and just expose it for what it is which is a workaround for laws against gambling.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Sort of weird how most "social" games are both a( trash and b( almost entirely single player with a tacked on multiplayer 'tournament' mode in which you play single player against some other player's template. Most “social games” are like that because if a game isn't like that, even if it has social elements, it's not considered a “social game”, even if on top of the social elements it has either gameplay-affecting (e.g., any of the wargaming.net games) or cosmetic (e.g., PUBG Mobile) lootboxes.
- ordinaryradical 8y agoI think if we could wrap our minds around what is happening psychologically in these games, most of them would be off-limits to children. What's interesting is that we've decided to define gambling according the rules of the game—in reality, "gambling" is probably more akin to a psychological state that can be induced by many different rulesets and experiences. Mobile games today are largely thinly-veiled attempts to induce this state in children through various Skinner Box mechanics in order to get at their parents' wallets. Fine. But the real question is: what happens to the mind of an eight-year-old if they have a gambling simulator in their pocket every day? What happens to their neurological development after five years of exposure to this "gambling" state?
- dna_polymerase 8y agoUnderrated comment IMHO. Those "casual"-games look like a gateway drug to gambling addiction to me. They borrow mechanics from games usually found in casinos and it is frightening to see how we let our kids play these games without much thought.
- icebraining 8y agoCountries have already started banning some games with such mechanics, like loot boxes; e.g. https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-43906306 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-43906306
- aeternus 8y agoMany of those games are actually implementing gambling with their virtual currency. They have events where you buy an entry ticket using the in-game currency then either double/triple-up or lose-it-all as the result of some random event. I'm surprised this is even legal in the US, and not caught for app store TOS violations. It seems they've simply replaced the concept of casino chips with virtual currency. They do have some 'gameplay' outside of this but it is not much different from the various frills on video slot machines.
- ApolloFortyNine 8y ago
- ragona 8y agoI wonder about this often. I contend that we are getting better at extracting money from people. Is there some sort of line we will cross at which point the majority of people are psychologically unprepared to resist spending their money in a way that causes them financial harm? We understand that friction causes consumers to consider their purchase more carefully, so we've worked hard to lower friction, and this has a statistically noticeable increase in users who complete their purchase. I'm genuinely curious whether we'll eventually reach some sort of threshold where the bulk of the economy is simply driven by overriding our better instincts.
- fwip 8y ago> the bulk of the economy is simply driven by overriding our better instincts Not to take away from your point, but you could probably argue that advertising pushed us past that point decades ago.
- ragona 8y agoI completely agree! I’m not sure how to define the horizon, so I’m not sure whether we’ve passed it. It’s not clear to me exactly how effective advertising is, and its effectiveness also clearly oscillates over time and between demographics!
- njarboe 8y agoAnd easy credit makes it much worse when you can go into debt to buy something you don't need or really want.
- mdorazio 8y agoI'm with you on this and I think the problem really got started when Zynga began actively optimizing to monetize underlying addiction in its core users years ago. The real solution here is that we need legislation for "casual" games that puts addictive games into the same bucket as gambling, but doing that is going to be really difficult (how do you even legally define bad addicting gameplay?).
- chipperyman573 8y agoA really simple solution would be to cap the amount of money a user can spend on a single game in a certain time period after the initial buy-in (so games could still charge hundreds of dollars for Premium/GOTY/etc editions). Even something like $50/mo would stop whales
- SkyBelow 8y agoIf it is a simple solution, then there likely is a simple work around. In this case, large companies with multiple games can have cross game promotions. Also, $50/game/month is still a very larger amount of money for many people and doesn't resolve the issue of kids being allowed to gamble.
- chipperyman573 8y agoSure, Blizzard does this a lot with their games. The idea behind it is more that it prevents whales, destroying the business model... the kids spending $100/mo are nothing compared to the people who spend literally tens of thousands of dollars on these games every month. That's who they're targeting.
- PhasmaFelis 8y ago> Also, $50/game/month is still a very larger amount of money for many people and doesn't resolve the issue of kids being allowed to gamble. The business model for these games is that 99% of players spend negligible amounts, and 1% spend hundreds or thousands; the minnows are a loss leader to get to the whales. Restricting spending to $50 or $100/month would destroy games like this entirely. (Which I'm fine with, personally.)
- tarr11 8y agoI think comments like this are too dismissive of how important and valuable games are in many people's lives. Personally, I fear the opposite, that over-regulation of rapidly changing industries based on fear and anecdata will make people's lives worse.
- the_af 8y agoIf you ever talked to anyone in the industry of Zynga-like games about how they think about their customers (i.e. the players), you'd be dismissive too. It's scary.
- ahoy 8y ago"games" is a broad category. Chess or Doom or Undertale never nickle-and-dimed anyone for $500. I can't help but think you're purposefully trying to obscure that point.
- tetha 8y agoNo, I think that's exactly the point. I have spent some money on doom, counterstrike, quake, unreal or even chess. Or none on games like tremulous. I've spent a lot of time in these games, I've found friends in this games that I by now know for more than a decade. A lot of that is gone with modern match making, and modern match making is made worse with transactions. Because you need to funnel more people into the matchmaking grinder.
- mattnewport 8y agoI think it's reasonable to draw distinctions among different types of games. Having spent much of my near 20 year career in the games industry, I'm saddened and disgusted by much of what has happened with the monetization strategies pioneered by mobile and free to play games. Maybe there's some grumpy old man syndrome at work but I also have a degree in psychology and the way these games are transparently optimized to exploit human psychology worries me quite a bit. I left the industry in part because of these trends and I won't be letting my own kids play these types of games. I don't know that regulation is the answer (and I'm generally anti regulation) but I do think there's a real problem here.
- shados 8y agoTaking away people with gambling addictions, children, etc (all good reasons for these games not to exist at all), I've felt for a while that their success is a great example of disparity in disposable income. I'll be forward and be completely honest: I've spent several thousands of dollars on a single of these games. And I've played many of them. Some with just straight micro-transactions (eg: League of Legends skins), some straight up "gacha" or "lootboxes" (eg: Fire Emblem Heroes, FF Brave Exvius, and so on). When you look at a videogame compared to other form of entertainment, is just how efficient they are in a "fun per dollar" point of view. MMORPGs that cost $10-15/month and people play obsessively several hours a day are way better than going to a bar to drink, money wise. But what if efficiency is tossed out of the window, how much is "fun" worth to someone? It's likely a factor of their disposable income. But we're now at a point where adult professionals are very much part of the player base. So if a game is free to play, but has a loot box mechanic that can make it "more fun", what happens? Well, for people without money to burn in a fire pit, it might not be worth it at all, so they won't spend a dime. For the senior executive who makes 500k or 1million a year? They could blow through 5 grands in an afternoon without really caring. So if you have a gaming population where 90% (I'm making numbers up) don't spend a dime, 9% is spending a moderate amount because of predatory practices (kids, addicts, etc) or because they like it, and then 1% spend an INSANE amount of money because they have no real "limit", you may come up WAY ahead than if you charged a flat fee and the same amount to everyone. Because the rich people are just THAT much richer to make up for everyone else. I know I've read some articles (none that I can find to confirm my memory) where some of the smaller gacha games with a few tens of thousands of players run fully on the pockets of a few hundred people, if that.
- mattnewport 8y agoDo you feel happy with your purchases still? Is there any buyer's remorse? I'm interested to know how many people who weren't obviously exploited and could afford to spend hundreds or thousands on these games feel honestly satisfied with their purchases and wouldn't in retrospect have preferred to use that money for something else.
- shados 8y ago
- kevin_b_er 8y agoI believe a time will come where these game types are recognized in many places as fundamentally evil for their psychological manipulation of children.
- SkyMarshal 8y ago>There's no proper defense for most people. Education is a defense. Once a person is aware of the psychological dark patterns being used against them, they start becoming less susceptible. Whether it's by video games, salesmen, politicians, etc. education is the best defense.
- moate 8y agoAgreed, but that doesn't mean it's easy. For one, there's so many dark patterns and bad actors in so many sectors of your life. I might be aware of the 80% of stuff that's happening (and hopefully it's the most likely 80%) but I'm not aware of that other 20% and there's always new bad things that come up. It's a constant battle, and many people just don't have the bandwidth to keep up.
- askafriend 8y agoI'm guessing this is why Apple decided to release their Apple Arcade subscription product [0]. Parents could buy the subscription and know that their kids would have access to quality games that don't employ these dirty mechanics and work off-line, with no ads. I think the subscription will do well for this one reason alone. [0] https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2019/03/apple-introduces-apple-arcade-the-worlds-first-game-subscription-service-for-mobile-desktop-and-the-living-room/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2019/03/apple-introduces-appl...
- sjg007 8y agoThank god.. also gets rid of the ads. Those are merciless.
- kexx 8y agowhat's wrong with apple and their understanding of reality? every single time they trying to do something, they claim they are the first who are doing it, when they literally did not do anything ever the first time. or maybe they don't understand the word 'first'?
- askafriend 8y agoIs there another subscription out there like this one? It seems pretty novel to me.
- Nuzzerino 8y agoI stopped playing not long after they raised the star cap to 13. I had nearly a full 13 star team, and had spent $11000 on the game, half of which was after I was laid off from my job. At one point I was the strongest player on my server (S6), already a competitive server (See video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9l3y6zOJtUM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9l3y6zOJtUM). There were people who had spent 3-5x as much as me and were still weaker because of suboptimal gameplay, but they could always spend more to catch up. This is not a brag, but rather an illustration of how rivalry between players at the top can be one of the strongest ways to motivate them to fork over more money. The amount of peer pressure from my clan leader to keep buying was insane. Eventually I told him I couldn't do it anymore. It was fun for awhile but I am still shocked that I still spent thousands of dollars that I really needed at a later time. I fault myself more than the game's system for those decisions. Sometimes one can forget the value of money until once again experiencing the effects of not having it. A lot of young professionals are making more money than they really need, and with the perception that they won't need it in the future. Therefore, there's a lot of people out there taking it for granted, and therefore not making it a second thought to spend on these pay to win mobile games. If you were to take away these mobile games, then this class of people would find some other equally stupid way to waste their money. In western society, there will never be a shortage of those possibilities.