12 ms·
London girl could be first to have “air pollution” listed as cause of death
- tsomctl 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Smog_of_London https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Smog_of_London
- paulddraper 8y agoI don't know how this normally works. But isn't "air pollution" an overly ambiguous cause of death? Could be lung cancer, injury, asphyxiation, etc. It seems a bit like listing "sugar" as the cause of death.
- Funes- 8y agoWell, if it is confirmed that it had a decisive role in this unfortunate event, I guess it would be fair to say that air pollution is one of the primary causes of the development of the subsequent ailments she went through, which ultimately lead her to her death. If removing air pollution from the equation would have saved her life, I think it's reasonable to say that it was, if not the sole cause of her death, one of the causes.
- maxk42 8y agoAsthma was her cause of death. It may be due to a genetic disorder, a disease, or some other cause. But air pollution was not definitively shown to be the cause of her death. This is a political move committed by Stephen Holgate, the former chair of the U.K. government's advisory committee on air pollution. The article pretty much spells that out.
- chabes 8y agoSounds like politicians are trying to cover their asses after an entirely preventable (under their own legislation) death
- briandear 8y agoSo are Pepsi or hamburgers listed as a cause of death when someone dies of a heart attack due to obesity? Calling air pollution a cause of death is a stretch.
- jefflombardjr 8y agoPepsi and hamburgers are not shared resources. Air is. Asthma is induced by both genetic and environmental factors. [0] So air pollution causing asthma is hardly a stretch. Especially if you've been exposed 1/3 of your life at such a young age. She was 9 years old. Having developed lungs and going into that area is majorly different than developing lungs in that area. [0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21799018 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21799018
- eeZah7Ux 8y agoNo. Example: If a person made to ingest something that leads to immediate cardiac or respiratory failure we call it "poisoned to death". Same for "being stabbed" rather than "cardiac failure due to blood loss"
- paulddraper 8y agoThose are causes of death. ICD-10 has X85 "Assault by drugs, medicaments and biological substances" and X99 "Assault by sharp object". [1] But it is unprecedented (AFAIK) to specify an external cause that is so far removed from the point of death. E.g. assuredly people have died from the long-term effects of tanning, but "sun tan" is not considered to be a cause of a death. [1] http://apps.who.int/classifications/apps/icd/icd10online2005/fr-icd.htm?gx85.htm+ http://apps.who.int/classifications/apps/icd/icd10online2005...
- wbl 8y agoBritish law is not medical coding. Misadventure isn't a medical code and could cover many of the bizarre ones like whale ingestion.
- ppseafield 8y agoOK, what about lead poisoning? An environmental hazard, especially effects children, preventable, mostly affects poor folks and developing nations. This seems like it's pretty analogous.
- briandear 8y agoBut she lived in that street for years. Just like someone might have eaten cheeseburgers for years and died of a heart attack. You don’t say that someone died from chronic cheeseburger ingestion.
- libraryatnight 8y agoNot being snarky, but perhaps we should. It wouldn't be untrue. When people drink their livers to death we often say they died of alcohol abuse even if we note they died of liver failure - seems reasonable if someone ate tons of cheeseburgers we could say they died of cheeseburger abuse etc. It's a bit dramatic, but could also be useful?
- chabes 8y agoFrom the article: “Ella lived near a busy street where pollution levels were consistently recorded at above the legal limit between 2010 and her death in 2013.” It seems there was legislation, enacted to protect people, that was ignored for years. The child’s death was not of their own doing, so I’m not sure why folks are even mentioning sugar or cheeseburgers.
- paulddraper 8y agoThat has nothing to do with it. Irrelevant to cause of death if child was to force-fed or self-fed cheeseburgers.
- just_a_dev 8y agoShe died of respiratory failure as a result of an asthma attack. This is asinine, we don't claim people who die from a heart attack to have died because of cheeseburger overdose... This world gets more and more absurd daily.
- jeanmichelx 8y agoIt's easy to not eat cheeseburger, it's hard not to breathe
- just_a_dev 8y agoIt's easy to live outside of a heavily polluted area if you have severe asthma.
- eropple 8y agoShe was nine fucking years old. I am straining to maintain the notion of civility that HN demands, so I will only ask you this: what bent you to make you think this sort of thing is reasonable or okay or decent?
- just_a_dev 8y agoSo blame her parents? Blame poverty if they couldn't move?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sctb 8y agoPlease stop posting unsubstantively. You've been doing it a lot, and eventually we ban accounts that won't follow the guidelines by posting thoughtfully and informatively. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- lnsru 8y agoI am just thinking about fireworks during New Year’s celebration. We pollute all major cities all over the world for 2 days just like that and then complain about pollution. Insane! Edit: I see many people here like fireworks. But if we as humanity can’t handle this crazy stupid pollution source, we also cannot do anything else. Forget handling diesel car pollution or improving public transport.
- Al-Khwarizmi 8y agoNot to defend the fireworks, but between pollution one night a year and pollution 24 hours a day, 356 days a year from the diesel cars going through my street and neighboring streets all the time... I know what I should be most worried about, and it's not the fireworks.
- ghobs91 8y agoThe cause of death is respiratory failure, not "air pollution". I'm getting real tired of even big names like CBS getting in on this clickbait game.
- habnds 8y agoThat's like saying someone who bleeds out after being shot died of "circulatory failure". Words have meanings and you don't get to redefine things to make yourself feel better. The court ruled that the girl wouldn't be dead if not for years of illegal air pollution. It's a fact.
- matz1 8y agoBoth are correct, both are fact, it's up to you to decide which are more important to you.
- habnds 8y agono reasonable person would agree that it's correct to call a gunshot wound "circulatory failure" because that's not what society has agreed that those words mean. You can decide personally that they mean something different, but you would be wrong. Language is determined socially not personally.
- matz1 8y agoAnd how does it become the "society" ? It starts from the individual.
- habnds 8y agoyes sure, you could individually start a movement to redefine the meaning of a word, Frindle-style, but here, today, in our society, the words "respiratory failure" do not mean the same thing as "poisoned by air pollution".
- 8y ago
- sjg007 8y agoMaybe now the U.K. will do something about truck, bus and automobile particulates.
- reaperducer 8y agoConsidering the number of people in this thread defending pollution and blaming the dead girl or her parents, I wouldn't count on it. Some days HN goes from its usual baseline mechanical callousness to outright horror film.
- llamathrowaway 8y agoI don’t think anyone is actually defending pollution. Those who say ‘meh it’s asthma not pollution’ just enjoy being a contrarian, who would point out any perceived ‘error’ in others’ words. They don’t really have any agenda to push nor any opinions of their own that worth posting. Just nitpicking here and there to show how others are ‘wrong’. Back to the topic, I wish we could ban diesel ASAP. I passed through Oxford Street a few times when it was virtually shut off by the protesters last month, so none of the diesel-burning black cabs not busses were there. It was much, much more pleasant than any other busy London street, almost serene, if there were not that many shoppers...
- adventured 8y agoHas the UK begun adopting electric buses? They seem to be getting tested or rolled out gradually everywhere these days.
- cardinalfang 8y agoLondon had the largest trolley bus network in the world until about 1960 when about 2000 electric buses were replaced with diesels.
- DanBC 8y agoYes, but it's a slow process. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low_emission_buses_in_London https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low_emission_buses_in_London
- ptaipale 8y agoThis tells perhaps more about the politics of naming causes of death than actual historical causes of death, considering the history of air pollution and smogs in London.
- pinewurst 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Smog_of_London https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Smog_of_London
- esotericn 8y agoI'm very familiar with this part of London. I haven't quite lived on the road in question but I know people who have. It's not clear the exact location but I imagine it to be near a busy junction with lots of vehicles idling. Ultimately in a system where people bid for housing this sort of thing is bound to happen. It's notably cheaper to live on a main road, near a pollution hotspot, etc; there's also commonly social housing in those sorts of locations, which makes moving less about marginal income and more about navigating a bureaucracy (if you're paying below market rent you may need double or triple the amount to move to a nearby privately rented place). In my view we should heavily tax diesel cars out of existence, at least in busy cities. The alternatives are to either demolish large amounts of housing (the South Circular Road and A2 in London are lined with residential; so too are most major roads in the capital), to basically delete the road network, or to accept these deaths as a way of life.
- osrec 8y agoI believe they've started the taxation in some sense. I can no longer drive my old diesel car in London without paying £18 per day for the privilege. That's enough to make me never want to drive it in central London.
- esotericn 8y agoThe South Circular Road (where this girl lived) is due to be the boundary of the ULEZ[1] in 2021 when it is expanded. At the moment it only covers a very small area of the central congestion zone (smaller than Zone 1). If anything the pollution there is likely to become worse as it forms the official diversion. We already see this; Marylebone Road, the current northern boundary of the ULEZ and Congestion Charge zone, is one of the most polluted roads in the capital. I work around there. Me and my team actively avoid walking along the main road for that reason. [1] Ultra Low Emission Zone https://tfl.gov.uk/modes/driving/ultra-low-emission-zone https://tfl.gov.uk/modes/driving/ultra-low-emission-zone
- 7952 8y agoI wish they would just ban these dirty cars completely from the zones. Being able to poison the air is not a privilege that you should be able to buy. It turns a moral issues into a financial one.
- alexandercrohde 8y agoFor anybody who thinks this type of thing is "just asthma," it may help to remember that there's strong and growing evidence that air pollution has all kinds of health effects on everybody. For example: "Our findings add to the growing body of evidence that air pollution may play a role in autism, as well as in other neurodevelopmental disorders." [1] 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_pollution#Health_effects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_pollution#Health_effects
- village-idiot 8y agoNOx is really nasty stuff. It won’t kill you straight up like CO or CO2 can, but it can mess up a lot of various systems to the point where your lifespan is limited.
- imtringued 8y agoIf this is related to local air pollution then what is the biggest producer of that pollution? I mean are there any coal plants or blast furnaces near her home? Was there a construction site pouring concrete or demolishing a building and creating toxic dust? Is the traffic especially bad? It is far simpler to move pollution away from locations than it is to reduce them in the first place. Therefore knowing what the source of the pollution is far more important than the pollution itself. If this death really was caused by global air pollution then good luck, nobody can help you when China and India are ramping up their pollution, certain industries might never stop emitting CO2 and capturing CO2 in the air will never be economical without a huge carbon tax.
- alexandercrohde 8y agoActually, to clarify, I believe this type of pollution is very easily stoppable at the source. There are basic "particulate filters" that could catch almost all of this pollution, and I don't believe there is any reason that they couldn't be standardized on all busses, cars, coal-power plants. CO2 is something entirely different.
- Brakenshire 8y agoI think lung problems are actually more strongly linked to Nitrogen Dioxide pollution, although particulate pollution is still an issue. Particulate filters I think are required to be fitted for the last 10 years or so, the problem is they require frequent high speed travel to function properly, and people have routinely removed them.
- esotericn 8y agoThe South Circular Road is a major arterial road across Inner London which was not really "designed" as such (for a lot of its' length it is made up of a bunch of minor roads lined by terraced houses glued together).
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoThere's very little coal in the UK now. There are fewer than 10 coal power stations left, and the nearest is over 100 miles from London. The specific London problem is traffic, and maybe added to by the current fashion for log stoves. You get the constant thick taste of the fumes about 10 miles outside the centre, and it's there permanently. Just about everywhere inside the north and south circular, which is more like 4 or 5 miles outside the centre, is badly polluted, but the south circular exceptionally so - it's almost constantly gridlocked and wasn't built for the volume of traffic it has. South Circular makes it sound like a major road or city motorway - it's used as one, and was probably intended to one day be rebuilt as one. Except it's just a regular one lane each way street for most of it, with lights and junctions, and lined with houses and shops. So dirt and grit if you leave windows open, or washing out, black gunk in the nostrils and the constant taste. Locals get used to it to some extent. It strikes us every single time we visit the relatives down there.
- Brakenshire 8y agoCategorization of cause of death is an interesting issue, there are a lot of cases like this where there are multiple contributory factors, and how you decide which to list is not clear. For instance, people don’t really die of dementia, they die of medical problems secondary to dementia, malnutrition, lack of exercise, and so on. Lung-related deaths amongst miners are related to exposure to pollution, but also to genetic predispositions which massively increase risk. If you drink enough alcohol to raise your risk of liver failure a hundred times, and die of liver failure, that’s a fairly clear causal link, but what about if you drink a smaller amount, and only increase your risk five-fold, but still die of liver failure? Or if you drink a small amount, raise your risk 20%, but still die of liver failure? There is no hard line between someone who has rolled the dice on bad odds and come off badly, and someone who has rolled the dice on moderate or good odds but still come out badly. For this girl, there likely would have been genetic factors or simply bad luck which compounded air pollution, but it’s difficult to say that air pollution didn’t contribute significantly as one of the causes of her death. And that is important to know, to be able to reduce deaths and ongoing poor health in the future. As electronic medical records become more prevalent, this is going to become more important. For instance, you could look back through patients with a cause of death like this, and pick out the frequency and timing of hospitalization as linked with local episodes of air pollution, that could then be used to inform advice to patients currently suffering from the same symptoms in the same pattern. You could essentially join together medical care, epidemiology and public health in a symbiosis which could be hugely beneficial.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoIn the US, this is a racial injustice issue.* I can't help but wonder if it is in the UK as well. * https://ggwash.org/view/71256/why-are-city-planners-so-afraid-to-talk-about-race https://ggwash.org/view/71256/why-are-city-planners-so-afrai...
- esotericn 8y agoIf we exclude Central London and talk about Zone 2 outwards, anecdotally I'd say it is purely based on knowing the makeup of certain neighbourhoods. Removed from that though, you only need to make a few assumptions to come to the conclusion it would be anyway. If we assume, say, that people would prefer to live on a side street over a main road, and then away from a junction rather than on a junction, from that it stems that it's going to be cheaper to own/rent a place in the most polluted areas. There are differences in income and wealth by race.
- crimsonalucard 8y agoIf everyone is responsible than no one is.
- BurningFrog 8y agoA quick googling gave this historical graph of London's air pollution index: https://ourworldindata.org/london-air-pollution https://ourworldindata.org/london-air-pollution The peak is at 623¹ in 1891. After another minipeak at 409 in 1935, it went down fast to 26 in 1994 and is now 16. That's not to say this isn't a problem today. But it was much worse in the past, and this girl is far from the first to die from it. ¹ suspended particulate matter (SPM), measured in micrograms per cubic metres
- inamberclad 8y agoYep, but the headline says listed as a cause of death. I don't know anyone who doesn't know about the London Fog from the industrial revolution.
- BurningFrog 8y agoI think today people mostly know it from watching The Crown :)
- rorykoehler 8y agoDepends on the day that's in it. There have been days you could see the particles, not as a haze but as actual individual particles. I don't have asthma and London air triggered exercise induced asthma on hot calm summer days (this was 10 years ago).
- thatoneuser 8y agoWhat about people who committed suicide by running a car in the garage? What about smoking? Sensationalism is the biggest threat to people accepting climate change in a wholesome way. Take a stand. End Sensationalism.
- tomjakubowski 8y agoAir pollution is, unfortunately, an issue with broader scope than just climate change, and the particular effects of the pollution that slowly killed this girl aren't related to it.