24 ms·
System76 News: Coreboot and Linux Advances
- nwah1 8y agoI admire the efforts to get coreboot support, and love their open hardware initiatives, but I don't understand why everyone has NIH syndrome. There was no need for them to create their own distro. That is a huge expense just to reinvent a wheel that has already been reinvented ten thousand times. And in the end most of their users will probably just load up the one they use already.
- lallysingh 8y agoReinvent? https://pop.system76.com/docs/difference-between-pop-ubuntu/ https://pop.system76.com/docs/difference-between-pop-ubuntu/ It's a few add-ons to Ubuntu.
- Q6T46nT668w6i3m 8y agoThe page you linked says it’s more than a “few add-ons:” > To call it a re-skinned Ubuntu brushes over all of the features and quality-of-life improvements that Pop! developers work diligently to create.
- prophesi 8y agoTo be fair, developing "a few add-ons" requires considerably more time & effort than a simple reskin.
- cs702 8y ago> but I don't understand why everyone has NIH syndrome. Many free/open-source advocates have been complaining about NIH syndrome for years and years and years... to no avail. Consider, for example, the situation with window managers and desktop environments. Off the top of my head, we have Gnome, KDE, Unity, XFCE, Openbox, dwm, Gala, KWin, Fluxbox, Enlightenment, JWM, and Ratpoison -- to name only 12 of the remarkably large number available for Linux. I suspect there are well over 100 window managers/desktop environments for Linux actively used in the wild today. And that's just window managers/desktop environments. The number of people who have complained over the decades about this proliferation is... quite large. The number of words that have been written and spoken in waste, and the number of flame wars that have raged on, over which particular choice is best is also... remarkably large. Search for "Gnome versus KDE" or "Unity versus Gnome" if you want to see some examples. I've come to accept this is The Way of free/open-source software. On the flip side, some people love all this variety and choice.
- Lowkeyloki 8y agoI actually enjoy having choices. That's part of why systemd's feature creep to swallow everything bothers me. It represents choice being taken away from the administrator of the system.
- cs702 8y agoThanks. I made a note about the fact that many people -- including me, in fact -- like having variety and choices.
- asveikau 8y agoI am often reminded that there are multiple personality types showing up in many things, such as software. To my personality type, I would wonder why you wouldn't want a replaceable window manager, and I consider a reaction like yours to be the product of some kind of odd software design authoritarianism. But we're not both right or both wrong, this is just a point where we differ. PS: a bunch of those desktop environments you cite are not actually window managers.
- cs702 8y agoThanks. Corrected!
- ajnin 8y agoI was thinking the same thing. I wish they focused their efforts on making good hardware. The risk is that some features like power management will only work well with their OS and not other distros.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rocky1138 8y agoIt's marketing speak. They hardly have their own distribution on a technical level. System76 can use this to prevent any non-developer UI mistakes like material design getting into the mix from upstream.
- AdmiralAsshat 8y agoI don't think it's unusual that a hardware vendor would want to provide an OS that is absolutely guaranteed to work on the hardware they're selling--that's just protecting your customers. Ideally it shouldn't even be necessary if all of your components have well-supported drivers, but this is Linux we're talking about--only three years ago I had to replace the default wireless card in my Dell XPS 13 because the broadcom one was flaky as hell in Linux. As good FOSS citizens, they would be encouraged to try to upstream all of their tweaks to GNOME or Ubuntu instead, but that's no guarantee that the changes would actually be accepted. Isn't that how Unity started in the first place?
- wmf 8y agoThey could have gotten Ubuntu certified on their computers like Dell does, although they'd probably have to pay Canonical.
- behringer 8y agoWelcome to linux
- effie 8y agoIt is to make the best product they can and avoid pitfalls of supporting millions of existing distros. If you had put in a lot of effort in making the hardware, would you just say to your buyer: "just download and install any linux os" and deal with the endless user problems that will, as a rule, appear? No, you provide the best system you can so everything works as smoothly as possible so the users are happy and do not call support or (god forbid) return the goods.
- currymj 8y agoI ended up having the opposite experience; I went and installed Pop on my non-System76 workstation. It is basically just Ubuntu, with a custom desktop environment (that is actually perfectly fine although optional), but more importantly, ppas for up-to-date NVIDIA drivers and CUDA. It's sort of like if a machine learning person installed Ubuntu on their workstation, did all the configuration work to get it working with their GPUs, and then turned that into a distro.
- 4thaccount 8y agoAlso it has a bunch of common desktop shortcuts installed and canonical metrics all disabled...and disk encryption.
- lamby 8y agoHave you used it, out of interest? It's very slick, at the very least..
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoConfiguring Linux userland's components to work together in a way that isn't garbage for what you're trying to do is an absurdly complicated task, that's why there are so many Linux distros: maintaining a distro is pretty much the only way to avoid doing all that work over and over again. It's a significant flaw in the Linux ecosystem.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- shmerl 8y agoWhat's the story with AMD and coreboot? Why can't AMD support it? Their whole AGESA is a glaring blob.
- benchaney 8y agoNeither intel nor AMD supports core boot. Community efforts to add core boot focus entirely on intel because of market share (although intel is also plenty hostile to floss in this regard).
- bravo22 8y agoNot sure about the support. Intel employees regularly submit to coreboot repo. I know at least for the Atom based designs that I've been involved in Intel provides reference designs using coreboot and supports it.
- wahern 8y agoAMD is a sponsor of coreboot according to https://www.coreboot.org/Sponsors https://www.coreboot.org/Sponsors Personally, I think the fundamental issue relates to IP. If the hardware design is made transparent by amazing and freely available documentation you invite infringement claims, particularly from IP trolls. (Threats from competitors are probably more existential, though, at least for large companies.) Often time companies will say that their products contain third-party IP that they cannot disclose, but that's just a roundabout way of saying neither the company nor its suppliers want the hassle. There are other reasons, too. For example, if you can't consistently provide such documentation it can make you look worse than if you had never bothered as it makes you appear unreliable. But I think the IP issue is what makes it a simple decision, notwithstanding whether the threats are actually substantial.
- monocasa 8y agoI think it's that DRM doesn't work if they don't have a place that the user doesn't own, combined with that core is also used for system init because it's in the right place and you already want similar crypto you'd need for DRM for secure boot. There's not really any interesting IP in those cores from what we've seen.
- bgorman 8y agoIf System76 had all their laptops come with Coreboot I would strongly consider buying from them next time I refresh my laptop.
- akvadrako 8y agoCoreboot is just not that relevant anymore. There is no clear line between hardware and software, so CPUs contain lots of totally closed software and of course totally closed hardware. That means you aren't really gaining much by moving that line 1% closer to total freedom, but it takes lots of effort.
- ladzoppelin 8y agoDo these have 4k screens and work with 4k monitors?
- xur17 8y agoThe highest res I see is 1080p, which seems fairly low, especially for their 15 and 17" screens.
- hughes 8y agoThe exclamation point in "Pop!_OS" is making me uncomfortable.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mises 8y agoI've heard good things about it, but oh, that name... it makes it sound like an early-2000s kids' toy. Just name it Pop OS. And get rid of the underscore if you want to be user-friendly to the average person.
- droidist2 8y agoYou're talking about the toy "Bop It" aren't you? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oF91cJQQONs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oF91cJQQONs
- dotnetcorenoob 8y agoDo people actually buy laptop/desktop from system76? I tried to price a laptop from them before and it was quite expensive compare to main stream vendors like Dell. Its cheaper just buy a OEM laptop and slap ubuntu on it.
- 4thaccount 8y agoYes. System76 is definitely expensive, but their customer service is the best I've seen for any product period. They have a super snappy site with real people you can talk to in Denver and ask off the wall questions about the hardware and OS. To some, having that kind of support is worth a markup rather than trolling through Ubuntu forums and asking StackExchange answers. My last few Linux machines were all repurposed Windows computers though. It's also nice to help support Linux on desktop this way.
- qaq 8y agoI'd buy one but the design is too ugly :(
- mark_l_watson 8y agoI bought one last fall, a laptop with a 1070 GPU - I love it. It is large and heavy so I still use my MacBook when traveling.
- xeRTRex 8y agoI purchased one about 2 years ago. I am generally happy with purchase, but certainly don't feel like I saved any money. I did need to reinstall the operating system (and have since switched to Manjaro). The fan is loud and battery is lousy, but the hardware has not deteriorated other than the connection to the monitor needed tightening. They also don't void the warranty if you open up the machine and tinker, which was a bonus because I wanted to install my own second SSD. I also really like the look and the keyboard is excellent. Plus a good number of ports including usb-c and Ethernet which wasn't as common two years ago.
- faissaloo 8y agoYou say you installed Manjaro, that probably explains your battery woes. Pop!_OS does alot good battery optimisation, I generally wouldn't recommend getting a System76 laptop if you don't like it out of the box.
- Lowkeyloki 8y agoThis is cool and all, but I can't help but cringe when I see a corporate entity using Tumblr for official communication.
- barberousse 8y agoThey probably never migrated when the Tumblr company blog trend ended
- Lowkeyloki 8y agoI didn't realize this was ever a trend. I'm glad it died.
- ProAm 8y agoWhat would be better? Twitter?
- jplayer01 8y agoSnapchat, obviously
- akskos 8y agoTiktok
- thekyle 8y agoMaybe Medium or running their own WordPress install?
- lone_haxx0r 8y agoMedium is much, much worse than Tumblr. It's always full of annoying banners, a useless popup appears whenever you select text, and visually it's nothing to write home about. Just look at this [1] atrocity and determine how much of the screen area is devoted to absolutely useless crap. [1] https://u.teknik.io/SJxU2.png https://u.teknik.io/SJxU2.png
- tracker1 8y agoAside: page doesn't load with uBlock enabled...
- thekyle 8y agoI have uBlock Origin installed and it works fine with the default lists.
- O_H_E 8y agoSame here
- tracker1 8y agoTo my recollection, I never changed the install... unless a new google profile login to chrome carries settings from another, previous chrome install for the plugin. Because if I did change the lists, it was literally years ago, and I wouldn't have added an esoteric option. I only know it didn't render when I came in... disabled uBlock Origin, and it did render.
- bizkeep478 8y agoI wish System76 had better build quality. I've been looking for a Linux vendor to support. They seem to be an EVGA reseller with terrible customized cases. Even the new woodgrain case feels janky and cheap.
- tonysickpony 8y agoI love Pop!_OS. I have used Gentoo, Ubuntu and Arch in the past 10 years. I ended up with Antergos packaged version of Arch with a bunch of personal tweaks. I tried different distro every now and then but always ended disappointed. My only needs for distros are to install softwares I use and run them. It turns out to be significantly hard, none of the distros do that without glitches, screen tearing and inconsistency across GUI frameworks. Surely I can tweak them to my liking, but the rabbit hole goes very deep until it comes to a satisfying result. Pop!_OS is the first OS that stay out of the way, I barely notice the existence of OS, and neither do I want to tweak it, and that is the way I want from a distro. The workspace arranging and switching is a nice touch, making it feel like home for tiling window manager users, coming from i3wm, xmonad or whatsnot. I don't have any obsession with distros. I want one that works. Pop!_OS provides by far the closest experience I get.
- dxxvi 8y agoLucky you because there's an OS that tweaks everything to your liking. The fact that Pop!_OS is not a rolling distro might be a big - for many people.
- tonysickpony 8y agoFair point. I enjoy rolling release model too. Some times I hope Pop!_OS and Elementary were not based on Ubuntu at the first place.
- Fnoord 8y agoRolling distributions simply do not provide the stability for serious production environments.
- scandox 8y agoIs a desktop a production environment?
- Intermernet 8y ago
- droptablemain 8y agoI bought a Galago Pro (since discontinued) in 2015. It's still my daily driver and it's held up very well. I even once dropped it from a second-floor balcony.
- dragosmocrii 8y agoIt will serve you well for many years to come. My gazp6 from 2011 still runs solid
- darrmit 8y agoI love the idea of System76 and Coreboot and keep checking in on them every few months but the story seems to remain the same - horrible battery life. I can’t see dropping over 1k on a laptop that barely lasts 4 hours out of the box.
- cbsmith 8y agoThe Galago Pro has the rough battery life. The Darter addresses that issue.
- bwat49 8y agoThe new darter pro gets decent battery life, I get around 7 hours on mine. It has similar hardware to the galago pro, but with a 54 whr battery instead of 35 whr. Their other models do have poor battery life though. The galago pro is especially egregious, I don't know why anyone would buy a 13 inch laptop that only gets 3 hours of battery.
- cbsmith 8y agoI actually had considered it at one point. Sometimes the reason you want something small & compact is you don't need to run it for that long.
- sara1732 8y agoThey found world's biggest fish Even you can't believe how big fish is this That's unbelievable http://bit.ly/2FHl4pM http://bit.ly/2FHl4pM A cute dog is dancing in video Just watch this video and try to control your laugh http://bit.ly/2ZK1XVs http://bit.ly/2ZK1XVs See how a Turkey saved the life of his friends Even those birds also have love in their hearts http://bit.ly/2WhAiZS http://bit.ly/2WhAiZS
- sara1732 8y agoThey found world's biggest fish Even you can't believe how big fish is this That's unbelievable http://bit.ly/2FHl4pM http://bit.ly/2FHl4pM A cute dog is dancing in video Just watch this video and try to control your laugh http://bit.ly/2ZK1XVs http://bit.ly/2ZK1XVs See how a Turkey saved the life of his friends Even those birds also have love in their hearts http://bit.ly/2WhAiZS http://bit.ly/2WhAiZS Guy made world record He drive car on two wheels See his video how he is driving http://bit.ly/2ZOYaWX http://bit.ly/2ZOYaWX See the video of this man he is catching balls and he is wearing blindfold http://bit.ly/2Vx4Mdl http://bit.ly/2Vx4Mdl
- mkesper 8y agoModerators, this is SPAM!