9 ms·
Apple tells lawmakers people will hurt themselves if they try to fix iPhones
- nsxwolf 8y agoI've only hurt my ego. I've tried to fix an iPhone and an iPad. Destroyed both.
- brian_herman__ 8y agoSame here tried to fix an iPad, ended up selling it online.
- rootusrootus 8y agoSame. Tried it myself, broke it, told my wife to take to the Apple Store before I rendered it completely trash.
- progval 8y agoI know someone who got his macbook on fire by trying to remove the battery. It wouldn't have happened if it wasn't glued to the computer.
- imgabe 8y agoPeople can hurt themselves trying to fix their cars too, or any other object. That's not a good reason to make your product unrepairable.
- threatofrain 8y agoPlus a lot of people repair things by taking it to a repair person.
- rad_gruchalski 8y agoSo where‘s the problem? People who fix them are out there and spare parts are available.
- EpicEng 8y agoI don't think the GP meant that to be a problem. What I got from it was "even if safety concerns are legitimate, trained professionals often do the work." So the safety angle becomes even more silly.
- rad_gruchalski 8y agoFor general public, I am not do sure. There‘s a reason why I‘m not attempting replacing the battery in my 2015 mbp or in an iphone. I just don‘t want to cause the damage but I can imagine random people not even waiting until the battery is fully discharged before going in.
- EpicEng 8y agoYet there are any number of equally dangerous activities the average citizen can participate in if they like. There are 100 things in your home that can kill you if you decide to start fiddling. Why are Apple products any different? Why should Apple own the repair aspect? Does Maytag tell me that only a Maytag authorized repair shop is allowed to service my water heater?
- rad_gruchalski 8y agoBut they are not. Go on ifixit, order parts and fix, if you wish. Why the downvoting. Heh.
- EpicEng 8y agoThis article is literally about Apple lobbying to make it harder for independent operations to repair their devices. They won't sell people parts. What does that say to you?
- rad_gruchalski 8y agoSource them from places where such laws do not exist?
- jVinc 8y agoIt seems to me that an iPhone is a lot easier to repair than a car. Sure you need to be careful about the gluing if you want to retain the aesthetics, but replacing the motor in your car is also a pretty extensive operation requiring extremely expensive tooling and if you aren't careful you'll end up hurting the aesthetics just the same. Of cause you could then redo the paint job, but at that point, aren't we really in the realm of cost/tools/effort where doing a decent repair job on an iPhone is still much easier?
- silversconfused 8y agoReplacing a motor requires hand tools and a motor lift. That's it. Upgrading or modifying might take special tools like an ECU programmer, but a straight mechanical replacement is just a bunch of screws and bolts.
- nsx147 8y agodon't forget the vacuum lines and electrical...
- saagarjha 8y agoIs it? There are a lot of very small, fiddly components.
- mtreis86 8y agoDepending on the car, there are quite a few more small fiddly components. Magnitudes more.
- protomyth 8y agoI'm not exactly dexterous, and I replaced the screen and battery on my iPhone and it went really well. You need to be a bit slower than you would repairing a car, but I really don't see it as harder.
- saagarjha 8y ago
- nerdponx 8y agoIt's not even about making it repairable. It's about just making the repair tools and manuals available for sale to the public.
- r00fus 8y agoApple really should double down on the concept iPhone-as-a-service bundled with AppleCare.
- rblatz 8y agoMy wife and I signed up for their iPhone as a service plan. It’s really the best way if you want to do a new iPhone every year. But if they start dropping crappy iPhones I may change my mind.
- nategri 8y agoReminds me of the difference between the Apple II and the very Jobs-ian Macintosh. One you could get into and upgrade without even a screwdriver. The other took two special tools and would happily zap you to death if you touched the wrong part, even unplugged.
- organsnyder 8y agoSome of that had to be unavoidable due to the integrated display, though. CRTs inherently deal with dangerous voltages. I don't think of Jobs as having been against repairability directly; rather, his singular pursuit of elegant designs resulted in a lot of other desirable features—repairability being a big one—getting steamrolled.
- jacobush 8y agoIt was not unheard of for CRTs to have an internal metal shield of some sort.
- everyone 8y agoIgnoring many of the more pragmatic requirements of a design in favour of superficial aesthetics is not elegance. Elegant design is solving as many requirements as possible with as few elements as possible. A claw hammer is elegant, macs are not.
- tomjakubowski 8y agoWeight + slimness (the primary drivers of unrepairable Mac designs) yield pragmatic benefits in laptops and especially in phones. There are superficial aesthetic qualities to slimness also, to be sure, but you cannot just brush away the benefits in ease of use and portability.
- everyone 8y agoWell the parent comment was referring to the apple macintosh, which is what I was also referring to. Though that does seem to be Apples general design policy 'make it look nice' to the exclusion of all else. Hey it sells though! I've literally seen a regular non technical person, when asked what kind of computer they want to buy, answer "I want a red one!"
- cfitz 8y agoPeople will hurt themselves because of the difficulty in repairing the device, not because everyone trying to repair an iPhone (or other Apple device) is incompetent. Of course you are more exposed to injury when you need to simultaneously use a heat gun and 1-2 other tools just to get started fixing a cracked display on an iDevice... Edit: Speaking from experience here. Used to purchase broken iPhones in college, fix them, and sell them for a profit. The latest generations are miles away from the repairability of the first several generations.
- PaulHoule 8y agoIf they are that dangerous then they shouldn't let you take an iPhone on a plane.
- saagarjha 8y agoThe list of things that are allowed on planes is not necessarily grounded in reason: https://www.xkcd.com/651/ https://www.xkcd.com/651/
- equalunique 8y agoFollowing media coverage of Apple lobbying in those two states, the company has been much quieter. Rather than lobbying on its own behalf, the company has relied on CompTIA, an organization funded by tech companies like Apple, Microsoft, and Samsung, to testify against the legislation at hearings and meet with lawmakers. The in-person meetings in California came a few weeks after CompTIA and 18 other trade organizations associated with big tech companies—including CTIA and the Entertainment Software Association—sent letters in opposition of the legislation to members of the Assembly’s Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee. One copy of the letter, addressed to committee chairperson Ed Chau and obtained by Motherboard, urges the chairperson “against moving forward with this legislation. I am shocked and ashamed that CompTIA would lobby against right to repair. To think that they are viewed as a high and mighty standards organization in the IT world - it's sickening to think that people worshiping them are essentially boot-licking - a term that I try to avoid using, but in this instance, unfortunately seems accurate.
- barbecue_sauce 8y agoDoes anybody really take CompTIA seriously anymore?
- timClicks 8y agoLegislators, apparently.
- nvr219 8y agoHR people do unfortunately
- equalunique 8y agoCompTIA Security+ is basically a minimum requirement for any DOD-related IT contract at Leidos Inc., and probably for most other large IT contractors along the Washington DC-area "beltway" too. So yes-ish depending on whether or not US government IT is a "serious" thing in your opinion. On the other hand, you have nuclear missile systems using floppy disks as recent as 2017, so I guess it's a bit of a toss-up.
- holy_city 8y agoThis is an absurd argument, and I'm 50/50 on right to repair. "This is dangerous to disassemble so we shouldn't have to provide instructions, tools, and documentation on to how to safely disassemble it." Or "Normal people can't repair these things, so we shouldn't be required to help normal people repair these things." Those are exactly the arguments why Apple should provide documentation, parts, and tools! So people don't get hurt!
- SpicyLemonZest 8y agoApple's arguing that some people will hurt themselves no matter what they put in the documentation. If that's true, this legislation really would put them between a rock and a hard place, because you bet I'm suing Apple if a battery blows up while I'm trying my best to follow their official directions.
- holy_city 8y agoThat's why there's such a thing as limited liability. Guitar amps are a good example - they're extremely dangerous if you're not careful. But manufacturers have provided repair manuals for decades, and I highly doubt any of the people who have hurt themselves because they forgot to discharge the rectifier caps successfully sued the manufacturer because they were being stupid.
- kakwa_ 8y agoI really like how Fender is shipping the schematic with their amp (I hope they still do it). That being said, guitar amps, specially tube amps are indeed extremely dangerous, not only the caps, but also the 300, 400 and sometimes 500 volts DC around the tubes. You need to be extremely cautious when handling these, specially if they are powered and opened (to check voltages in various points of the circuit for example). That being said, I've not seen a lot of guitarists actually opening and servicing their amp themselves, even if the circuits tend to be quite simple and easy to maintain/repair (few components, no SMD).
- bsmith 8y ago
- Shivetya 8y agoWell then, if the battery is such a risk I can only recommend two outcomes. packaging improve for the battery component so that it is not a risk or that such items not allowed to be taken into areas where they may be a risk. heck they could even be regulated as such they be replaceable without disassembling the phone if Apple cannot render them safe otherwise.
- protomyth 8y agoYep, if the battery is such a danger then the government needs to step in and mandate some safety packaging on mandate no glue may be used to secure a battery and it must have a safe way to replace it. People are putting these things up to their heads and if its a repair danger then it is obviously a danger in other situations.
- jbverschoor 8y agoThis is the only correct response.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- return1 8y ago... or any phones
- msla 8y ago> Apple tells lawmakers people will hurt themselves if they try to fix iPhones "Are you threatening me?" -- The Great Cornholio Seriously: That sounds like a... well, like a threat. Like they're willing to employ active measures to enforce Do Not Repair, and then say "I told you so!" when one of their designs just happens to draw blood if you attempt to open the case without specific foreknowledge and specialized tools.
- Pmop 8y agoThat would be a sad but funny epilogue to this history: trap laden phones, designed to keep their owners away from any diy repair dreams.
- js2 8y agoI'm handy but not a trained technician. For example, I've replaced a starter in a 2003 Honda Odyssey, repair appliances around my house, etc. I used an iFixit kit to replace the battery and screen in an iPhone SE. It took me about an hour following their guide. The hardest part was getting the old battery unglued from the case. I was careful to follow their warnings about fully discharging the old battery. Nothing burst into flames. Was it potentially dangerous? I suppose... but so is using power tools. Frankly I'm more worried about fire every time I charge one of my 18650 flashlight batteries. This is BS from Apple, and further it's paternalistic.
- tty2300 8y agoThanks to the work by ifixit its possible for anyone to replace an iPhone battery but without the hard work from a 3rd party there is no way you would be able to replace a battery. You have to know exactly which screws to remove, the direction to lift things, the connectors to discounted and when to apply force because lifting the battery requires a huge amount of heat and force.
- snotrockets 8y agoBut that’s exactly what the right to repair is all about: requiring apple to sell the manuals and tools needed to safely fix your devices. If anyone should be lobbying against it, it should be ifixit...
- simonsays2 8y agoApple is doomed. Huawei will replace them.
- Someone1234 8y agoIf Apple provided the same jigs, repair tools, and documentation that the Apple stores use wouldn't that reduce the likelihood of injury? Nobody is suggesting Apple provide these for free, but right now Apple will even block third parties from trying to provide equivalent jigs, tools, and documentation.
- eridius 8y agoEnd users wouldn’t be using them. I’m all for Apple providing support for third-party repair shops. I’m against Apple being forced to allow actual end-users to open up and “repair” their phones, because the latter is not going to end well. I shouldn’t be allowed to open up my own phone, but I should be able to take it to a third-party repair shop with access to Apple tools and training materials.
- Notorious_BLT 8y agoIn what universe should it not be okay for you to open up your own phone? You own it, you should be allowed to do whatever you want to it.
- eridius 8y agoYou’re allowed to open up your phone today. Nobody is saying the police should knock down your door because you opened your phone. What’s at stake right now is if you open your phone, you void your warranty and Apple will not provide any more support for you. Which seems perfectly justified to me; iPhones are sufficiently complicated that end users will absolutely damage or destroy their phones by opening them up. The distinction I’m drawing is between end users and third-party repair shops. Users need to have a way to get support, and Apple Stores aren’t available everywhere, or aren’t necessarily offering repairs as cheaply as a third-party shop could. Third-party repair shops should be able to repair iPhones without voiding warranty, as long as they use Apple-supplied parts and with access to Apple-supplied training materials. But end users shouldn’t.
- 8y ago
- mmastrac 8y agoInjured myself a few times trying to separate some of the new devices that are glued together (looking at you, Google Pixel). My Amazon Kindle's screen died trying to get the plastic bezel off it too. :( Right to repair + repairability legislation is the double-punch we need. Apple is probably concerned that the latter will be the next step after we get the right to repair things, but we really need it.
- js2 8y agoDid you follow a guide? I didn't have any trouble with an iPhone SE, but I had an excellent ifixit guide and their toolset.
- mmastrac 8y agoFor both I did. The Google Pixel screen cracked because the safe space for prying it apart is so tiny. Kindle guides aren't as good as phone guides and didn't explain the risk of pulling apart the display layers when wedging apart the bezel. :(
- henryfjordan 8y agoI'm torn on repairability. The iphone would be worse by some metrics if it had to be designed in such a way that it would be repairable (size, for instance). So long as I can determine repairability (by looking at the service manual or similar) then I'm fine letting people decide for themselves what they want to buy. The only other argument I could see for a "repairability" law would be from an environmentalist standpoint, but I would want that law to allow a less-repairable item that was sufficiently recyclable.
- xoa 8y agoIn America at least I think the repair debates as a matter of law are off the mark overall. What I think is at the actual root of the problem for most people (and for the market), and what I'd really like to see legally, would be adaptive mandated warranty periods that better match the common sense expectation of how long a device should reasonably last. Say 1 year per $200 up to a max of 5 years for a napkin example, though it may be that a non-linear curve with monthly resolution would work better. But the core market issue really is the same old story about externalities and information asymmetry: manufacturers know failure rates far better then consumers, are in far more of a position to make money on the tradeoffs, and the total cost isn't reflected in the sticker price. While for something super bargain basement there is an understanding that durability may be less, I think most people feel like a premium, ~$1k+ computer should be expected to last a good 4-6 years, and if not then the manufacturer should repair or replace it at no additional charge, including a reasonable amount for shipping (COTUS at least). How exactly a manufacturer chooses to hit that should be up to them, but that's what the standard result should be. So in the case of Apple, if they still wanted to make expensive to repair 1st/certified-3rd party only devices they could, but they'd have to eat all the expenses of that. No foisting it off onto an unlucky 0.1% or 1% or 2% or 7% or whatever of customers, it should be their job to get it right. If it makes the retail price too expensive, then they'll naturally have to figure out how to lower the failure rate or decrease the repair cost. Extended warranties should never be a thing except for special extra commercial services (onsite repairs, specific SLAs, advance replacement and so forth).
- umanwizard 8y agoI've never actually owned a phone that stopped working for any reason other than negligence on my part. Maybe I'm just particularly negligent, but I always either lose them, drop them, or get them wet long before their natural life expires. Part of the reason is that the repair or replacement cost doesn't bother me enough for it to be worth putting it in a case (which is a privilege of being a well-paid software engineer; I understand not everyone can afford to have the same priorities). But at any rate, if I were more price-conscious, repairability would matter much more than a longer warranty, since with repairability I could fix problems that are my own fault just as well as ones due to normal lifespan issues. Do other people have different experience? How long would an iPhone last without abuse?
- Animats 8y agoThe next step is probably hermetically sealed phones. With the headphone port gone and wireless charging, just seal the thing up at the factory, filled with dry nitrogen.
- bsmith 8y agoI don't see why anyone feels the need to compel Apple to make their phones "repairable" in the first place. If you want that feature, I'm sure Samsung or myriad other manufacturers would gladly sell you their handsets instead. Maybe you could make some sort of anti-trust arguments about the probably-a-little-too-tight relationships between wireless carriers and the device manufacturers, but there are a lot of handset makers to choose from and the market can choose who wins.
- ajross 8y agoThat logic only works if iPhones cannot be repaired. Obviously they can be. The demands in the various Right to Repair bill drafts never talk about changing the design of the phone, only about requiring the information and parts necessary for repair be available to the public.
- intopieces 8y ago>only about requiring the information and parts necessary for repair be available to the public. The parts and information are already available to the public, as noted by the article. The Right to Repair bill would compel companies to provide that information and parts directly.
- simcop2387 8y agoThis isn't always true. Take a look at the whole thing with Linus Media Group's iMac screen repair. The screens are not available publicly, only to approved apple repair centers (which didn't even exist at the time of LMG's fiasco). They didn't give details in the video where they finally repair the thing, but strongly hint that they actually ended up getting the replacement part essentially off the black market of apple parts. Along with this Apple has a history of having customs destroy third party refurbish parts when being brought into the US. [1] final repair video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EdwDvz47lNw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EdwDvz47lNw [2] first video about it https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EdwDvz47lNw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EdwDvz47lNw
- intopieces 8y ago>”The issue is that many of these companies operate in a grey area because they are forced to purchase replacement parts from third parties in Shenzhen, China” What is the grey area, here?
- detaro 8y agoBuying parts that "got lost" from the official supply chain at some point, are knock-offs of unknown quality or legality (where patents etc apply), ... Lots of parts in such devices that aren't standard components that you can just buy from the maker or an intended distributor. Recycled parts might be legally clean, but how do you know that's what the parts you're buying are?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- exabrial 8y agoI don't imagine this will sit well. The government wants a monopoly on running people's lives.
- rrggrr 8y agoAnyone interested in this should view Louis Rossmans many YouTube videos on the topic.
- snarfy 8y agoHey HN mods, why was this buried? Posted 3 hours ago and now it's gone from the front page.
- segmondy 8y agoApple cares for the consumers so long as it's in alignment with profit. Never solely for the happiness of the consumer, but for profit.
- smsm42 8y agoI am not a handy man at the least. Pretty much anything beyond hammering a nail into a wall is beyond my skills. I've just repaired my Motorola phone using a kit from iFixIt and an online video, and it took me 15 mins. Yes, the phone still works. That's why I am never buying an iPhone (one of many reasons, to be sure).