5 ms·
I recall family members being concerned about this. And based on my rudimentary understanding of the plot, I'm not really surprised. This stands under my gener
by ocdtrekkie 8y ago
I recall family members being concerned about this. And based on my rudimentary understanding of the plot, I'm not really surprised.
This stands under my general concern that tech companies are neither cognizant of nor culpable for the impact they have on society.
- malvosenior 8y agoThis seems more like a media company thing than a tech company thing. Surely there have been other depictions of suicide in the media? Did they have the same corresponding uptick in suicide rates? That would have been a good addition to the article. That being said, I really don't think we should dumb down or "tame" our art for the sake of safety. It's important to allow artists (the show creators in this case) the ability to tell any story that speaks to them, especially when that deals with sensitive issues like suicide. The warning before the show seems like a good idea though.
- TazeTSchnitzel 8y agoArt shouldn't be free from criticism though. And the ways in which this particular work is poorly executed do to some degree line up with why this work can be harmful (or more than it should be), so I don't think dealing with these criticisms and making good art are mutually exclusive.
- malvosenior 8y agoI haven't seen the show so can't comment on my opinion of it, but this is a personal choice. Almost certainly there are many people who enjoy the show in its current form. Parents shouldn't let their children watch shows they don't approve of. For everyone else, just don't watch if it bothers you. Yes, it's fine to criticize and comment, but creators are under no obligation to listen to the critics and in most cases are better off sticking to their original vision.
- DanBC 8y agoThis isn't people being offended by content. This is a show that causes harm. The scientific consensus is that this show has harmed people.
- malvosenior 8y agoI didn't say it was about people being offended. My point is that we shouldn't expect art to be bland and harmless. Some art will cause harm (just like tons of things in our society do: alcohol, gambling...). We collectively need to toughen up, accept that not everything is safe and enjoy the multitude of choices we have in how we live our lives.
- DanBC 8y ago> alcohol, gambling Both of these are strictly regulated, right? I don't think you're suggesting that media companies should be similarly regulated, but I don't know why you'd mention them. >We collectively need to toughen up Unfortunate phrasing in the context of vulnerable children killing themselves.
- ergothus 8y agoYou're skipping the concept of communal concepts though. I have the message I get from my parents, the message I get from "everyone else" (which is really several messages from various groups), and the message I determine for myself. That latter is heavily influenced by what the other messages say. (See the other current HN article about student drinking being decided by how much they think others are drinking). To simply say "Choose for yourself and your children, I'll do the same, and we shouldn't talk about it" is a de facto declaration that society as a whole approves of the behavior/activity. On this particular issue I honestly have no idea where I stand...I know of and believe the impact that (deliberately or inadvertently) "encouraging" suicide has (or even just coverage)...but I also don't like the idea of being against discussing and exploring ideas. The solution is to DISCUSS what to do, not just pretend we're all fully informed individualists.
- 8y ago
- bauruine 8y ago>Surely there have been other depictions of suicide in the media? Did they have the same corresponding uptick in suicide rates? Yes.[0] Newspapers try not to cover suicide whenever possible and when they do they always also write about emergency suicide prevention hotlines. At least in switzerland. [0] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-suicide-media/suicide-details-reported-by-the-media-may-lead-others-to-copy-idUSKBN1KK1ZU https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-suicide-media/suic...
- TazeTSchnitzel 8y agoI understand there are also certain other guidelines about how to report such stories as well.
- DanBC 8y agoHere's one from the UK National Union of Journalists. https://www.nuj.org.uk/news/mental-health-and-suicide-reporting-guidelines/ https://www.nuj.org.uk/news/mental-health-and-suicide-report... I use this one because they're journalists and so understand the balance of freedom of speech with not causing harm. They're quite old. The BBC also has guidance here: https://www.bbc.co.uk/editorialguidelines/guidelines/harm-and-offence/suicide https://www.bbc.co.uk/editorialguidelines/guidelines/harm-an... They've unhelpfully put them in a section titled "harm and offence", so if I ever contact the BBC about poor reporting I have to say that I'm not bothered about offence, I'm letting them know about something that may cause harm.
- Circuits 8y agoOh really and how far are you willing to take it? For instance, should child pornography also be untamed so long as it's known as art?
- malvosenior 8y agoThe line is at consent. You can consent to watch something, child pornography most definitely does not have the consent of the people in it and is rightfully illegal.
- x2f10 8y ago>This stands under my general concern that tech companies are neither cognizant of nor culpable for the impact they have on society. I have to imagine this is not a new phenomenon. How many young adults have listened to music and been persuaded (or influenced) to commit suicide?
- vkou 8y agoWhy do we credit the last thing that a suicidal person listened to, and not the long line of shitty life events that lead them up to that point?
- TazeTSchnitzel 8y agoWhy shouldn't we examine the last thing as much as the others?
- __s 8y agoBecause there may be 100 things before it, so it's only 1% of what lead up to the event. & the things which came earlier had a longer time to cause impact. ie a series of early events can lead to a result, whereas what is the actual percentage of people immediately committing suicide after listening to something suicidal? Better to focus on how to mitigate people reaching this point, as opposed to the straw that broke the camel's back
- Circuits 8y agoI agree but mitigating the risk of breaking the camels back is worth it if the only side-effect is one less crappy Netflix show.
- vkou 8y ago> as much as the others Which is to say, not at all? Nobody takes the mental health of students seriously. If we did, our schools would look quite different.
- ohithereyou 8y ago
- scotty79 8y agoWhat makes it strange is that suicide spike after releasing popular work of fiction featuring suicide is an effect known at least since https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sorrows_of_Young_Werther https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sorrows_of_Young_Werther
- diminoten 8y agoSo does that put stories about suicide off limits, then?
- DanBC 8y agoNo, but it means media companies have a responsibility to their users to handle these carefully.
- terryschiavo22 8y agoNo one would care if this were just a story about suicide. This is a story that sympathetically portrays a girl who kills herself to make others feel sorry for her.
- SkyBelow 8y agoIt serves as a very interesting test, either for those who want to limit some rights for safety reasons who fail to apply that logic here or for those who want to limit suicide as a topic for safety reasons but fail to apply it to other rights.
- scotty79 8y agoProbably needs a bit more research what kind of portrayals of suicide have that effect. Then yes. Content is banned from most impactful media channels for less.
- cmg 8y agoI work for a crisis hotline specifically for transgender people of any age. Suicide contagion or "copycat suicide" is a very real thing. Addressing it requires a concerted effort by media and everyone involved when reporting or talking about a suicide to help contain the effect. When there is a situation that is already getting a lot of attention (in our community or nationally/internationally), we are very careful with how we spread even messages of love and solidarity. I haven't looked to see whether our numbers reflect any trend from that time period two years ago, but I'd be curious to see at some point.
- paxys 8y agoDo you really think the tech part of Netflix had any involvement with this show?
- smolder 8y agoIt's not just tech --there are huge companies across many industries which are culpable for societal harm but not held accountable. When you have company so large as to have an unassailable position, there is no incentive to put ethics ahead of profit. (Outside of following the law, which can also be changed with some political campaign investments.)