3 ms·
>I don't care what studio makes funny_show (either when deciding what to subscribe to, or when trying to figure out what app to launch to watch it), I just want
by SilasX 8y ago
>I don't care what studio makes funny_show (either when deciding what to subscribe to, or when trying to figure out what app to launch to watch it), I just want to watch it.
There's a joke that this is exactly what cable TV was.
Back then: "This is ridiculous! I'm paying for all these channels when I only watch two or three of them. I should be able to pay for just the ones I use."
Now: "This is ridiculous! Every time I find something I want to watch, I have to subscribe to a new service!"
- rcxdude 8y agoThe problem being you still can't just subscribe to one show (or just buy it outright). You're still buying bundled deals, they've just fragmented so it's even worse.
- ghaff 8y ago>The problem being you still can't just subscribe to one show (or just buy it outright). You can in some cases though the pricing tends to be relatively high compared to streaming unless you really only want to watch a show or two.
- rhino369 8y agoPeople seem to hate bundles. And they love a huge catalog for one price like Netflix used to have. I think most people would hate paying per show. And I don’t think the pricing per show would be much of a discount. I’d imagine the median number of shows HBO viewer actively watches is 1-3. And the cost of giving you access to shows you don’t Watch is actually less than nothing since it would take resources to lock you out of it.
- ghaff 8y agoPeople do pay for a la carte content. With a few exceptions, it's how people buy books. And a lot of films are paid for a la carte in some form or other. But the expectation is certainly shifting towards subscription streaming services and there's probably a difference between renting a new film release and paying to watch some random TV show to relax after work.
- crisnoble 8y agoNow: "This is ridiculous! I'm paying 10 bucks a month to Hulu for thousands of shows, movies and kids content so I can watch Handmaid's Tale with commercials."
- mavhc 8y agoJust buy the blurays
- ghaff 8y agoThe situations aren't quite comparable. But yeah. I imagine if there were an "all content" streaming channel for $100-$200/month, a lot of people would think that was outrageous pricing because they want to watch so little of that content. Personally, I'd probably be happier watching a lot of content with a la carte pricing but TV shows in particular seem to be at something of a premium with that model. (Assuming they're available.)
- croon 8y ago> The situations aren't quite comparable. But yeah. I imagine if there were an "all content" streaming channel for $100-$200/month, a lot of people would think that was outrageous pricing because they want to watch so little of that content. There are always outliers, but very few people would watch $100-200 "worth" of content. Netflix is basically a walled off Spotify, where your $10-15 goes to whatever shows you watch because the rest get cancelled if they can't sustain a critical number of subscribers. But I want more than just the Netflix-content, but let's say I can only reasonably watch $30-50 "worth" of content each month, so give me access to everything and allocate my subscription accordlingly, sort of like Spotify.
- ghaff 8y ago>very few people would watch $100-200 "worth" of content And, yet, that's in the range that a lot of people did (and do) pay for cable or satellite TV and that didn't even include on-demand content.
- croon 8y agoYou paid for a lot more than content then. Unless Netflix is burning someone elses money I'm assuming they're getting by on their subscriptions. They also have a much larger user base than specific cable/sat companies, so they win on scale. I'm not saying people can't pay more, I'm saying they don't have enough time in the day for the amount of content that could be produced by that amount of money.
- nradov 8y ago
- notyourwork 8y agoHilarious how the op and others have come full circle. I think what people want is something more akin to cable 2.0. Better interfaces and browsing but consolidation of all content so avoid this fragmentation we are moving closer and closer to.
- mrguyorama 8y agoThere's also the fact that cable was always absurdly expensive
- diogenescynic 8y agoDoensn't that already exist? Sling and DirecTV Now are basically just cable-lite services that you stream. I actually like these better than Netflix or Hulu.
- beatgammit 8y agoWhy can't we have both? I loved the idea behind Sling TV, which let you buy buckets of channels. I wanted that, but more granular. Ideally, I'll have a single platform that I like, and I can subscribe to producers, individual series, or something in between (curated buckets of series?). For example, I like Netflix because the interface is pretty good and I've never had a problem with buffering or lost connection. I want to be able to pay a little extra to get access to, say, Disney or HBO content, and perhaps buy access to some other series. I hate jumping between streaming platforms, so I've gotten to the point where I just don't watch things if they're not available. I pay for two platforms, and that's about all I'm willing to do. I just can't watch some things I know I'll like because I don't want to have to remember which platform has which series. However, buying individual series/movies also too expensive IMO. My budget for video entertainment is $20-30/month, and I watch maybe 1-2 hours/day (mostly my kids, but we have movie night twice a week); that's about the cost of two unlimited services, 4-6 movie rentals, or 1 season of a series. I could consider spending up to $50 or so if it was good value (e.g. don't have to jump between services), but that's not a thing, so we get 2 subscriptions for the family and spend the rest of my time and money on immersive video games, which ends up being far cheaper per hour of entertainment. The movie/TV industry is just ridiculous, and I'm getting tired of it. I'm not surprised that piracy is getting more common. I can afford to spend more, but I choose not to, and I completely understand the mindset of pirates; if I wanted access to more content, it would be less work to pirate than work more to be able to afford more content.
- falcolas 8y agoIMO, the real problem is that they're all services - cable, Hulu, Netflix, it doesn't matter. The dream was being able to pay for only what you watch, but that's not really an option in many cases. You're still being forced to pay for content you don't want to watch. This bundling of extra content was tolerable at the Netflix price point - when you were paying < 10% of cable - but it's back to being intolerable now that it's comperable to cable prices once more.
- pmontra 8y agoI'm willing to pay 1 Euro per episode, but I don't want to care about which service streams what. Just a big container of every present and past show or movie, on demand and pay per view. The current model is not interesting. I don't want to pay a monthly fee for something maybe I don't have time or the will to watch that month. Obviously those services are doing well with the customer that fit into their sales model. I wonder if somebody would build a meta service and pay fees to the sub services (Netflix, Amazon, etc.) They probably don't want to be commoditized.
- HappySweeney 8y agoWhat if a new model appears, in which you get the first few episodes free, and then pay €4 per episode thereafter? I ask because many shows will need to charge something like this in order to survive low ratings.
- em-bee 8y agoi came to a similar price point after experiencing an internet service that charged $1 per GB and i found it worth the price.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- overthemoon 8y agoThat's sort of two ways to frame the same objection: I don't want to pay for all the extra shit I don't care about, whether that means a bunch of channels or a bunch of garbage programming across a half dozen platforms.
- SilasX 8y agoI don't think that's the objection: it's that there's a certain pain/annoyance with having to judge whether the new content will actually be worth the $X extra you'll pay, but it's in direct (economic) conflict with "I just want to pay a flat fee and not think about each little thing".
- logfromblammo 8y agoI have many lights, gadgets, and appliances in my home. But I only have one power meter. Which I flip a switch or push a button, different things can happen, but the meter just counts the watts, and at the end of the month, I pay one bill. That's convenience. Everything I own takes 120V 60Hz AC power, and I pay one monthly bill to run all of it. The convenience problem with the fragmented streaming services is that everyone wants to run their own wire to my house and put their own meter on it. They need to agree to use the same wire, adhere to a common protocol, and allow resellers to act as their meter reader and bill collector. That didn't work with cable companies because of locally-granted monopolies that prevented the signal reseller from experiencing competitive pressures, but if everyone can choose between DirecTV Now, YouTube TV, Roku, Sling, Netflix, or even RQ Hacker's Streaming TV Reselling Service, then the consumer is still in control. Partially. Cable could force you to get 100 channels when you only wanted 5 of them. There was no one else around to sell a package with fewer channels, or even to go full a la carte. But even then, content owners could still strongarm content distributors by selling their channels to the cable companies and satellite distributors as one package. Now it's just the same thing all over again, with the consumer cutting out the middleman, and finding out that it was the supplier that was screwing us from the source all along. The copyright holders name their price, and those who want to watch have to pay it. What we really need is for someone to undercut Disney by ripping off their format. Bowdlerize the folktales and fables by taking out all the viciousness and cruelty, create a few trademarkable characters out of them, write a few catchy original pop songs, and stitch together into 90 minutes of family-friendly video entertainment. Throw public domain in one end, turn the crank, and get intellectual property sausages out the other. It would probably only take a few billion dollars to make an impact. Or... maybe take a hammer to the copyright law that Disney bought, and blow the dust off the anti-trust laws. Maybe draft a new law such that no content owner can sell a bundled package of works unless they already distribute each component individually, and it must be priced such that the price of the bundle must be within a certain percentage, plus a constant, of the sum of its components, purchased/licensed individually. The ultimate source of the fragmentation problem is the copyright laws. It will never go away until they are reformed. So I'm not surprised that the fragmentation is apparently promoting piracy.
- pbhjpbhj 8y ago
- Razengan 8y agoThe ideal, at least for me: • I learn about shows I haven't seen via word-of-mouth or online forums. • I preview them on sites like YouTube. • I stream a few episodes online in low/moderate quality. If I like something enough, I download it to a personal disk in the highest quality, where it will always be available for me to watch without ever requiring an internet connection. I understand that the companies and people who make these shows have to make money, so I'm willing to make a few compromises: • Let me pay a SINGLE monthly fee to stream ANY show in a video player of MY CHOICE. • Let me permanently purchase specific episodes/seasons. • Let me rewatch my downloaded videos without an internet connection for a while, but it’s alright to require me to connect every N days to refresh the DRM license or whatever. So far, Apple's iTunes Store is the best platform which delivers most of that.