10 ms·
How does this work financially? I have a lot of vacant retail near me and they're nice spots, but the leases are all sky high. For whatever reason the folks
by duxup 8y ago
How does this work financially?
I have a lot of vacant retail near me and they're nice spots, but the leases are all sky high. For whatever reason the folks making decisions about what goes in there are happy to sit and wait for yet another Noodles & Company or Chipotle, nails salon, but that's kinda it... and if not those places, empty.
I'd love to find good ways to encourage local shops and things beyond just the business with the highest margins.
- intrasight 8y agoIsn't so much "highest margins" as "deepest pockets". I would think that an independent business can have margins as high or higher than a chain.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoAssuming people value the outputs of both businesses the same (i.e. the chain will get paid just as much as the independent business), economies of scale should let the chain have higher margins.
- monocasa 8y agoHere in Boulder, there's a number of retail spaces that essientially can't turn a profit on it's own. Just The North Face, Prana, or Freepeople want a Boulder location so bad for marketing purposes, they're willing to keep the store running at a loss.
- intrasight 8y agoI'd not considered that in a hot location with limited retail space that companies might occupy that space at a loss and treat it as a marketing expense. But upon further reflection, I have to assume that is the case for a lot of business in Times Square, for example.
- ForHackernews 8y agoI've read some articles about that: https://nypost.com/2014/04/26/the-hidden-proof-the-economy-is-still-awful/ https://nypost.com/2014/04/26/the-hidden-proof-the-economy-i... https://www.theguardian.com/business/2017/dec/24/new-york-retail-shops-amazon-rent https://www.theguardian.com/business/2017/dec/24/new-york-re... > In addition, he says, banks will devalue a property if it’s occupied by a small business, and increase it for a chain store. “There’s benefit to waiting for chain stores. If you are a hedge fund manager running a portfolio you leave it empty and take a write-off.”
- duxup 8y agoIt certainly seems to be a nation wide problem. It really sucks as it seems like economic activity just waiting to ... happen, but naw.
- swiley 8y agoThat's so odd. For me personally I'm making a decision about where to move after I graduate and I'm planning on living a little farther from where I work specifically to get away from all the samey chain restaurants (holy cow they're depressing) to be in a more densely populated area with more small businesses. I have a hard time imagining I'm alone.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoOld suburban areas of the Northeast are largely immune to the bland sameness of franchised businesses that pervades the US. There is little space to build out and liquor licensing can be problematic for chain restaurants.
- dilyevsky 8y agoit works because prop 13 (i’m guessing)
- bluGill 8y agoProp 13 is in California, this story is about New York.
- anbop 8y agoThe owners of the building are sitting in the most enviable position in the economy — just by owning the asset, they will get money in the form of appreciation, from work done by other people. The rent is the cherry on top and they’d rather just go for a contract with a safe mega corporation than deal with any actual work in interacting with a business.
- ThrowawayIP 8y agoThis is a great reason to have a local-level tax on vacant space. Both commercial and residential.
- monocasa 8y agoMeanwhile, here in my town, the landlords run the place and got the opposite passed. Commercial retail properties are exempt from property tax while the property is vacant.
- taurath 8y agoThat sounds crazy - I wonder if that causes more or fewer derelict properties.
- monocasa 8y agoMore. What they do is double the rent on businesses when their contract is up, and leave the derelict properties up as an example to the other businesses of "you have no negotiating power. We'll just leave the property empty if you don't pay up because it only has an opportunity cost"
- slavik81 8y agoA vacancy tax seems weird to me. It's effectively the same thing as a higher property tax, but with a discount for non-vacancy. That is, a discount for putting anything in that space. I just don't see why you would give out a discount without ensuring the use of the property is doing something that provides a public benefit.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoThe "For whatever reason" is that the risk reward is not worth it to experiment with independents. Consumers have shown that they like the familiar by rewarding it financially. Real estate owners and fund managers aren't choosing to make less money, they just have data that shows what course of action likely leads to the highest returns. There are a few places with enough density and people that consciously like to go out and experiment with different vendors and whatnot, but not most places.
- duxup 8y agoWhat is the risk exactly? Say a business signs a 2 year lease. They go out of business after 1 year. They got ~1 year of lease payments compared to ... nothing. That still seems like something.
- ghostly_s 8y agoYes, but if $chain does decide to open a location in the neighborhood in month 10 of that 2-year lease, it moves in to your competitor's building across the street, then you're stuck with the empty storefront again in a year while they have a nice indefinite recurring revenue stream.
- perfmode 8y agoThe building across the street isn’t ones “competitor”.
- sbzodnsbd 8y agoFor the property owner they are
- luckylion 8y ago> then you're stuck with the empty storefront again in a year while they have a nice indefinite recurring revenue stream So that risk is worse than ... being stuck with an empty storefront?
- macspoofing 8y ago>How does this work financially? Not well. Retail is hard in the best of times. >For whatever reason the folks making decisions about what goes in there are happy to sit and wait for yet another Noodles & Company or Chipotle, nails salon, but that's kinda it Maybe the owners can't get anyone to rent the properties? I doubt they are 'happy to sit and wait' for anyone. They still have to pay property taxes.
- basetop 8y agoIt probably won't for the long term. These "feel good" stories abound when times are good. Wait a few years and reality sets in ( even quicker if a recession hits ). Maybe if they copy B&N's model and turn themselves into a coffee shop that sells books on the side, it might work. But they'd need the scale of B&N and locations near major universities with wealthy privileged students willing shells out lots of money for lots of books that their professors recommend. In an environment of online shopping and expanding library services, bookstores face a lot of headwind. Why would you go to a bookstore when you can go to the library? Why would you buy can carry a bunch of books home when you can just order it online? If you can solve these problems, you could make a lot of money opening up bookstores all over the country.
- ethagknight 8y agoIt’s less than ideal. Even a small retail shop requires some new investment, and it’s probably coming from the landlord. Spending $100k minimum, probably far more, to outfit a space for a untested or low credit tenant is a gamble with very limited upside. That’s why landlords will sit and wait, and it’s not a pretty situation to be in as investor. A bookstore should be more doable, but it still requires someone to fill the store full of books that it believes it can sell. 10,000 books cost a lot to stock too.
- rfrey 8y agoAt least in Toronto and Edmonton, the two places I have been involved with commercial real estate, I have never heard of a landlord footing the bill to outfit a space.
- vageli 8y ago> At least in Toronto and Edmonton, the two places I have been involved with commercial real estate, I have never heard of a landlord footing the bill to outfit a space. In the United States at least, many commerical real estate owners _will_ perform a build-out conditional on a lease agreement. Of course, if the business folds earlier than expected it is the real estate owners who have to eat the cost.
- mruts 8y agoHave you considered that no one wants to open a local shop in the first place? Chains are the only people in the position to take on the huge huge risk of opening a store. As a store owner, you have exposure to wage laws, property values, foot traffic, etc. I would personally argue that you would have to irrational to open a mom-and-pop store in this day and age.