12 ms·
Many people are getting rare cancers in a small Georgia town
- mieseratte 8y agoThe answer to the clickbait headline is "pollution," and the town is Waycross, GA. Here's your "money" paragraph: > In late 2015, the Georgia Department of Public Health said it could find no link among the children’s cancer cases. Then it backtracked and said more investigation was needed. In December, the federal government stepped in. The Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, an arm of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, said it would work alongside state officials in evaluating contamination at the railroad yard as well as an Atlanta Gas Light property that once held a power plant, which was torn down after closing 60 years ago.
- delinka 8y agoWhat's the town?
- madcow2011 8y agoWaycross, GA
- athenot 8y agoI wouldn't call it clickbait. It's a longform piece telling the story in a way that reflects the uncertainty that the locals feel.
- mieseratte 8y agoI called the headline clickbait. I never said TFA is garbage, but the headline certainly is.
- athenot 8y agoThe headline mirrors the article's portrayal of the quest to find out the truth. If the article was just a few paragraphs long, I would have felt slighted. But as such, it read more like a mini-novel/documentary.
- mrob 8y agoAnd of course, it's pure coincidence that the headline is perfectly tuned to cause fear to small-town Georgia residents and to their friends and family elsewhere, and the extra page views and ad revenue from people worried if it's their town are of no relevance whatsoever.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoIf there were a viable news business that allowed local journalists to investigate the issue, perhaps this wouldn't have happened, or have been uncovered earlier.
- jcranberry 8y agoThe point is it's an investigation not a conclusion. The author heavily focuses on pollution in the area being a possible cause, and points out inadequacy in investigation performed on and arguments against pollution being the cause. But all her evidence is anecdotal. The point isn't to assert that she is certain of the cause, it's to provide a spotlight on evidence which she has seen which has not been given adequate examination and the resulting suffering from what could possibly be preventable. The title is appropriate, not clickbait.
- mrob 8y agoThe title is clickbait, because it deliberately withholds key information to force readers to click. A non-clickbait title would be: "Pollution suspected of causing rare cancers in Waycross, GA"
- 8y ago
- SolaceQuantum 8y agoAdded nuance: A government-sponsored investigation using a narrow data set generated by a company responsible for the cleanup of a single site, of which Waycross has multiple under investigation, decided there was no conclusive evidence of Waycross having abnormally high levels of cancer, excluding diagnoises of cancer that occured outside of the town even if the diagnosises were on town residents. Also: A town newspaper did not cover this, and the head editor as well as the mayor believes this is a case of "Facebook moms" and overly-concerned parents using personal griefs to wreck Waycross's tenuous economic bounce back.
- mieseratte 8y ago> excluding diagnoises of cancer that occured outside of the town even if the diagnosises were on town residents. That's a pretty big exclusion. It's not as if pollution gives a damn about political boundaries.
- DoctorOetker 8y agoit's also clearly irrelevant from a medical standpoint where the diagnosis was made... unless there's local bribing of doctors going on! so why insist on only counting local diagnoses? EDIT: perhaps there are regulations that mandate doctors to diagnose similar percentages, to prevent overdiagnosis... and perhaps this is being weaponized against discovering localized exposure to carcinogens?
- strainer 8y ago> "On the cancer cluster question, ATSDR cites data from the Georgia Comprehensive Cancer Registry to make the case that there isn’t one. GCCR data from the past decade shows childhood cancer incidence has been below the state average here. GCCR’s Waycross-area data, however, "doesn’t include people who are diagnosed at hospitals in other cities", as Lexi, Harris, Gage, and Raylee all were." Charitably, I guess the researchers just don't have resources to locate patients more accurately than by their diagnosing hospitals location. It's a huge amount of noise on top of patients actual location history, which would seem to make their survey only capable of detecting persistent hotspots that span the location of many hospitals.
- Aloha 8y agoit does not appear to have been a power plant, it was likely a coal gasification plant
- 8bitsrule 8y ago"The power plant helped light Waycross from 1916 to 1953. Along the way, it discharged coal tar—a thick, black byproduct of converting coal to fuel—into the canal system. Prolonged exposure to coal tar has been linked to various types of cancer...." The first half of the article also calls out multiple toxic organic chemical contaminants from several operations including a railroad and a waste-processing plant ... severe enough to require Superfund remediation. In that era ('Better things for better living through chemistry') most people were unaware of the dangers of industrial chemicals in the air, water and soil. They got little press, at least until 'Silent Spring'.
- Aloha 8y agoCoal Tar is the prime byproduct of coal gasification- the timeline is right too, most coal gas plants were shut in 45-55 timeframe.
- psychometry 8y agoAs always, it's important to remember that even in the absence of environmental factors, the probability of a particular town of this size having cancer rates this high might be very low, but the probability of there existing such a town in the U.S. might actually be high. This is simply due to variance.
- hammock 8y ago"Variance" does not give people cancer. But pollution does. The nuance is lost in your comment, and what you might more accurately say is "statistics/variance predicts that there is a high probability that somewhere in the US there is a town that has enough pollution (or other cause) to create cancer rates this high. It happens to be Waycross, GA"
- gowld 8y agoGenetics also gives people a chance. There is some probability that somewhere in the US there is a town that has enough people with cancer-prone genetics to create cancer rates this high.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- DoctorOetker 8y agothey would be getting the same set of rare cancers
- DangerousPie 8y agoNo, that's not what "statistics/variance predicts". What statistics predicts is that even if there was no pollution whatsoever in the entire country we would still see some towns with increased cancer rates. That said, I didn't do the math and it's entirely possible that the rates in Waycross are way above what one might expect by chance.
- deleted 8y ago
- DINKDINK 8y agoFor the same reason "all the best schools are small" but aren't really [1]. It's the "Law of small numbers" that is: scale-dependency of variance. It's much easier to get an large variance if you sample in small sets. [1] https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2010/09/the-small-schools-myth.html https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2010/09/th...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- wil421 8y agoHere’s a good point near the end of the article. >On the cancer cluster question, ATSDR cites data from the Georgia Comprehensive Cancer Registry to make the case that there isn’t one. GCCR data from the past decade shows childhood cancer incidence has been below the state average here. GCCR’s Waycross-area data, however, doesn’t include people who are diagnosed at hospitals in other cities, as Lexi, Harris, Gage, and Raylee all were. I’m a Georgia native but from Atlanta. I’ve never been to Waycross. I lived in South Georgia for about a year a couple hours away. For anyone who read the Vidalia Onion article on the front page it’s about 1.5 hours north of here. There’s a beautiful college in Valdosta an hour away. The region is nice because it transitions into more of a Florida type of landscape.
- mcguire 8y agoSo they're saying hospitals cause cancer? 8-0
- jraines 8y ago> Florida type of landscape So flat as a pancake and hotter than Hades? :) The Gulf cloudscapes, though, are something to behold.
- grayed-down 8y agoHey, c'mon now... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Florida%27s_highest_points https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Florida%27s_highest_po... And compared to say Venus, FL's pretty comfortable!
- smileysteve 8y agoThis is a reminder that coal, operating under regulation releases more radioactive material over a few decades than a Nuclear power plants worst failure mode.
- mattigames 8y agoYep, the most recent power plant disaster at fukushima (2011) didn't have a single fatality death due radiation (the fatalities have been attributed to non-radioactive causes such as building collapse, fire smoke, etc)
- patrickg_zill 8y agoAre you sure about that? https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/05/world/asia/japan-fukushima-radiation-cancer-death.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/05/world/asia/japan-fukushim...
- lostlogin 8y agoTrue. On the down side, it’s hard to see a failure mode for a coal plant that leave such a massive area devastated for so long, or one that’s so costly to manage.
- OrgNet 8y agoThe coal/natural gas plant near me was burning what appears to be some nasty coal just yesterday (bright yellow smoke)... is the smoke color a good indicator of it's toxicity? (most of the time, the smoke is white, not sure if it is because they were burning natural gas at that time)
- abeppu 8y agoZooming out from this specific town and article, it's kind of interesting to look at regional differences in cancer incidence. Like, I get that people live very different lives in different places, and that states have different resources to bring to public health problems, but the areas of red in the midwest, northeast and gulf coast are quite striking. https://statecancerprofiles.cancer.gov/map/map.withimage.php?99&001&001&00&0&01&0&1&5&0#results https://statecancerprofiles.cancer.gov/map/map.withimage.php...
- opportune 8y agoI would be curious to see this alongside / with some relative derived metric for life expectancy. To my knowledge cancer can definitely be influenced by environmental/lifestyle factors but its incidence would also be increased by the relative age of the people in an area. For example if everyone dies by 50/60 of alcoholism, addiction, diabetes, or work-related injuries the cancer incidence would be lower than expected even though the people there are definitely unhealthier than the general populace Actually, I see that the stat is age adjusted. So not sure what effect that would have on the comparison that I described
- hikarudo 8y agoBeware of the sample size issue. The Midwest has lots of low-population counties, for which a single cancer case plus or minus makes a great difference in the incidence rate. See also: Bayesian Data Analysis, Gelman et al., 2nd edition, section 2.8.
- Zhenya 8y agoMy uncle who grew up and in his Kate years moved back to a tiny town right next to waycross. He also died of a strange, quick and rare cancer. I wonder how much of these findings are liability protection for large lobbying corporations that operate in these towns.
- CptFribble 8y agoIt probably goes the other way: the responsible company's legal team determined they can't avoid liability any more, so they get some favorable studies to mitigate the consequences/reduce the size of the potential class action.
- watersb 8y agoWhen we lived there, a very large drainage canal ran along our property. Certainly needed it for summer rainstorms. Never occurred to me that it could be carrying dangerous toxins too.
- 420codebro 8y agoI hope you and your family are healthy. After reading the article, if I lived there, I would be very paranoid until I was checked by a doctor. Cheers.
- _bxg1 8y agoEven without the pollution, I'll never understand why people in dead towns don't just move.
- lukewrites 8y agoThe CDC ruled that there isn't a cancer cluster in the town. > On the cancer cluster question, ATSDR cites data from the Georgia Comprehensive Cancer Registry to make the case that there isn’t one. GCCR data from the past decade shows childhood cancer incidence has been below the state average here. GCCR’s Waycross-area data, however, doesn’t include people who are diagnosed at hospitals in other cities, as Lexi, Harris, Gage, and Raylee all were. My blood boils.
- dsswh 8y agoIs it the same as the radon map?
- stevespang 8y agoRail yards use very toxic chemicals to treat the RR tie wood, many other cases of disease and cancer in other locales. The RR lawyers are all powerful and have beat down a lot of court cases.
- sctb-wow 8y agoHey sctb, do we need to read this shit, when it’s only relevant to the person you’re playing good cop/bad cop with?
- raarts 8y agoI have to bring up Erin Brokovich here, very relevant for this situation and one of my favorite movies.