28 ms·
Google has no incentive to fix these kinds of problems. It's big enough that when someone complains that a message sent wasn't received, the intended recipient
by reaperducer 8y ago
Google has no incentive to fix these kinds of problems.
It's big enough that when someone complains that a message sent wasn't received, the intended recipient will say, "I never have problems with my Gmail account. It must be you." And the sender has to switch to Gmail to reliably communicate with the outside world.
I wish this was just paranoia, but we've seen multiple discussions on HN about Google programs and policies that alter the internet in ways that only benefit Big G. It's like we're heading back to the days when people didn't know the difference between AOL and "the internet."
- nothis 8y agoThe evil part about this is that it needs no one at any step to say it out loud. It just “happens” as a result of Google being big. Whatever lead to Microsoft being sued for pushing Internet Explorer in Europe and whatnot? Shouldn’t that kick in already for at least some of the recent Google bullshit?
- Nerdfest 8y agoI think it should, or some sort of oversight should be in place. Their filters are extremely aggressive. I have a specific GMail rule in place to ensure that all mail gets through and nothing gets sent to spam, but even with that the occasional message gets sent to spam. It's generally advertising, but never actually spam. There's definitely for GMail to become the new "Windows", with everyone else fighting to stay connected.
- dralley 8y agoThey don't even have to be doing it deliberately; as you say, the lack of incentives to fix such issues will cause a gradual evolution in that direction.
- cptskippy 8y agoI feel like as they leave more and more up to the algorithms, we suffer. I've been having this ever increasing in frequency issue where Gmail Search just doesn't working. Not that it doesn't return search results but rather that it returns what I know to be incorrect results. I have an email with some account information that I access a couple times a year at most but will consistently need at least once a year. Just infrequently enough that I can't remember the exact contents. I know exactly what the subject line of the email is and it's a suggested search query in Gmail but about 2 years ago Gmail just stopped being able to find it. I can navigate to the email via label or star just fine but I can no longer search for it. Is it because it's an 8 year old email? idk what the reasoning is but Gmail as deemed it irrelevant and stopped returning it as a search result. This isn't a platform issue either, it happens in App, or browser on multiple devices.
- FakeComments 8y agoI’ve made a career out of going “a bad business plan + computers is still a bad business plan”. It’s not just Google.
- prewett 8y agoI'm curious how you make of career of not doing a bad business plan.
- FakeComments 8y agoYou get hired to be the subject matter expert on economic models, then you remind executives who consult with you that their plans don’t get better just by adding computers (or fancy math of any form). Eventually, even when you get fired because they tired of you being a nag, you write down all the times your nagging was right, and someone else hires you to be the math nag, because corporations have accepted they need them — even if they’ll also eventually fire you for being right. There’s easier ways to make money with the same skill set.
- cptskippy 8y ago> There’s easier ways to make money with the same skill set. Yes but some people really love to nag. I work in enterprise for similar reason, I really like sighing at things.
- rootusrootus 8y ago> I feel like as they leave more and more up to the algorithms, we suffer. Seems like it ends up working somewhat like China's social credit policy, but without specific intent. As long as you always conform enough to fall into the normal area of the algorithm you're good, but get off towards one edge for any reason and you quietly get [effectively] booted off the 'net.
- busyant 8y ago> I feel like as they leave more and more up to the algorithms, we suffer. With all the hand-wringing about what happens when the "computers" take all of our jobs, I think you crystallized how it all ends for us. It won't be a cinematic extinction of humanity. We will just be ignored--each of us trying to talk to a machine with a human voice, and each of us perpetually on-hold.
- redm 8y agoI wholly agree with your statement. I would add that, sadly, its like this with most things Google: 1) vague descriptions of the problem, 2) impossible to get support or talk to anyone, 3) severe consequences (because of the ubiquity of Google’s platforms i.e. search, Gmail, Android, Chrome). Anyone who’s had a safe browsing problem, an App Store issue, or, heaven forbid, an AdSense issue will attest. As far as it relates to email, this is why platforms like Sendgrid got so popular, they manage the relationship with Google and others for you.
- organsnyder 8y agoEmail deliverability has been a hassle for a long time. 15 years ago, AOL was the juggernaut that made sysadmin's lives difficult. I do agree that Google's outsize influence in so many markets is concerning.
- chrismeller 8y agoIt's interesting that you bring up AOL, because I remember dealing with this kind of crap with them. It was annoying, but didn't feel like it was as big of a deal. I guess the only real difference is that with AOL it was less insidious... You knew it was only for aol.com emails and that you weren't dealing with business info. Not that emails to personal addresses aren't important, but at least it wasn't suddenly SomeRandomFortune500Customer.com that sales is trying to email a proposal to right before the deadline that "is make or break for the entire company!"...
- hitpointdrew 8y ago>It was annoying, but didn't feel like it was as big of a deal. Perhaps because email itself wasn't as big of deal back then? Phone calls and snail mail were used with a lot more regularity back then.
- chrismeller 8y agoHeh. I’ll be honest, that sounds a lot like a millennial projecting onto all the old people in this thread. Sure there’s an element of truth to it, but email was insanely popular before the iPhone too...
- linuxftw 8y agoDefine 'people'. We're already there IMO. The kids today don't have any particular understanding of what the internet is and how it works. They view it through walled gardens via the app store.
- arkitaip 8y agoGoogle has a long history of "oopsies" where they deliberately cripple the competition and blame it on unintended consequences [1]. [1] https://www.computerworld.com/article/3389882/former-mozilla-exec-alleges-google-torpedoed-firefox-with-oops-excuses.html https://www.computerworld.com/article/3389882/former-mozilla...
- sproketboy 8y agoGoogle is doing the embrace and extend - same as Microsoft did in the 90s.
- khawkins 8y agoI'm now regularly seeing search results bury political pages which seem to run counter bay area political views. I'll search the terms on Bing and DuckDuckGo and the page I'm expecting will be the first hit, but on Google it'll be on page 3 or 4. Clearly they keep the hit in the search results for plausible deniability, but they're trying to influence people by suppressing speech. Given that Google is becoming synonymous with the internet, like AOL, this is a very concerning trend.
- hedora 8y agoAny examples? (DDG fan here; curious to know if it is filter bubbling, or something else.)
- nekitamo 8y agoOne example is the story of the sons of John Kerry and Joe Biden partnering together to form a private equity fund which received money from the Chinese government, and then using that money to acquire strategically sensitive assets, in some cases partnering with firms accused by the US government of hacking US companies for intellectual property: https://nypost.com/2018/03/15/inside-the-shady-private-equity-firm-run-by-kerry-and-bidens-kids/ https://nypost.com/2018/03/15/inside-the-shady-private-equit... They did all this while their fathers were undertaking sensitive high-level negotiations with the Chinese government. If you try Googling for keywords related to this story, Google will claim to have indexed thousands of related pages, but will only serve 33 search results: https://www.google.com/search?q=biden+kerry+Rosemont+Seneca+Henniges https://www.google.com/search?q=biden+kerry+Rosemont+Seneca+... If you enter the same keywords into Bing you will be served thousands upon thousands of search results without any of Google's limiting or censorship: https://www.bing.com/search?q=biden+kerry+rosemont+seneca+Henniges https://www.bing.com/search?q=biden+kerry+rosemont+seneca+He... One interesting thing to note is that most of the websites which picked up this story are right-wing, and that Google appears to simply be blacklisting non-mainstream right-wing websites from its search results. Whether or not this is due to any implicit ideological bias on Google's part is uncertain.
- 8y ago
- bachmeier 8y agoRule #1 if you're applying for jobs or graduate school - Don't use gmail for your email address. Source: Led a hiring committee this year. Interview invitations and job offers went straight to the junk mail folder. Also serve as Director of Graduate Studies. Admissions and funding offers, as well as general inquiries about availability, all went straight to the junk mail folder. We're not going to change our email service.
- awinder 8y agoThis may be a fair sentiment for an educational institution (you're not directly making money from email sending / hopefully admissions marketing doesn't have this problem), but as a candidate I'd be extremely concerned if a company I was going to work with A) couldn't deliver to gmail and B) held the view that it was everyone else's problem. As it is you're statistically leaving half the candidate pool at the door, which is recoverable. A biz that can't deliver to gmail is a terrible smell though.
- brlewis 8y agoIn the past year or so, pulling non-spam out of my gmail spam folder has become routine. Previously it was very rare that legitimate mail ended up in my spam folder, including personal mail from my father from an email address he's been using for decades. A biz that call's gmail's problem gmail's problem is not a terrible smell.
- sergiosgc 8y ago
- awinder 8y agoYou don't have to switch to gmail, you can pretty reliably switch to a myriad of service providers. You could even solely switch your SMTP server to something hosted and retain message storage on your end if you wanted. It has become very difficult / unwise to host your own SMTP server, though, but that's been true for ages now. Gmail's marketshare is going to make that veeeery obvious, but it really has been a bad idea for the better part of a decade, at least.
- bluGill 8y agoIt is a bad idea to host your own SMTP, but only because you need to keep on top of maintaining it. Most of that effort is the same if you have one user or a million, so it is more efficient to outsource that maintenance. However if you are willing to pay the price in time there is no reason you shouldn't be able to maintain your own server. I use fastmail. They have humans that respond quickly when I have a problem (twice in 10 years)
- OldSchoolJohnny 8y agoDifficult to host smtp?! That's absolutely not true and has never been true. It's difficult to configure and set up in the first place but after that it's just updating. Source: personal experience for decades.
- Chlorus 8y agoIt's not like you'd notice the email you're not receiving, so I'm always a little leery of these "it works perfectly for me!" stories for email stuff.
- jake_the_third 8y agoI though the issue was with getting your mails accepted. Even gmail has no problem sending email to a server that isn't properly set up as long as it is willing to accept. Can you mention (or link to) situations where gmail refuses to send mails to another domain?
- 8y ago
- Arnt 8y agoI too self-host and have done for decades. When I had a problem that may perhaps have been like this, Google disabled the relevant part of them spam filter and made an issue in some internal tracker. I write "Perhaps" because my report was a lot more specific. Google sells mail+spam filtering+more as a product, with a seven-digit number of paying customers, each of which pay per month and user. What more incentive could they have?
- CyberShadow 8y ago> I write "Perhaps" because my report was a lot more specific. How did you even get your report to be read by an engineer at Google? This seems impossible unless you have some kind of business connection.
- Arnt 8y agoThat bit is easier for me than for you, perhaps, since gmail implements about four RFCs I've written ;) That bit isn't the MSB, though. The MSB is that they do care about fixing interop problems with everyone, they just don't read mail from randoms. I think they assume is that if a problem is their fault it will show up on their monitoring graphs, and watch their error graphs instead of their postmaster inbox.
- bko 8y ago> It's like we're heading back to the days when people didn't know the difference between AOL and "the internet." Why is this no longer true? IMO, other competitors came along offering a better service/experience and AOL just couldn't compete. At the time, you could not know what this better product looked like. I believe the same will happen with the internet giants of today.
- sixothree 8y agoTime to break them up.
- Tepix 8y agoThe right response to this problem - for gmail users - would be to switch to a different email provider. After all, if you are not receiving important mails because Google decides to block them for inexplicable reasons, you are getting an inferior, faulty service. (For me gmail is inferior regardless as my privacy is violated)
- vbezhenar 8y agoCan you suggest free email provider with similar level of service which allows to use your own domain?
- bencollier49 8y agoFastmail [EDIT: Sorry, missed the 'free' in there. Guess you get what you pay for]
- monocularvision 8y agoI would love to pay FastMail for my family’s email. I have myself, my wife, my four children, one family address and one other generic address. 8 emails would cost me $240 a year at a minimum. If they could solve for my situation and not charge me that kind of money, I would switch from Gmail immediately.
- PaulHoule 8y agoI find it astonishing how much people devalue software and information services. The same people who have to have a $1500 phone and seem to think nothing of dropping $150 a month on Verizon or AT&T won't spend $5 on any cloud service. This is why Google keeps winning and everyone else is losing, particularly the people who get the "free" services but don't have any say about those services. The real numbers might be different, but I heard that Google gets about $100/yr in ad revenue per user. That is, they are getting $800 a year for all of those people. Everything you buy is $800 more expensive and there is no way you can say no to that!
- elagost 8y agoThese days many people don't know the difference between Facebook and "the Internet". We've handed the reigns to our communication and culture into the greedy palms of about five mega-corporations that put profit above all else. Much better to use community software and platforms - things that people run for people, not companies running for profit.
- hedora 8y agoIn an attempt to avoid google, I kept a non-gmail address that I don’t administer, and instead forwarded it elsewhere. The administrators of the account decided to outsource the smtp relay to google. It is ridiculously unreliable, and regularly sends “no such address” responses to my synology NAS (which emails me periodically). Similarly, when I used gmail’s IMAP gateway for work, it was regularly down. I’m pretty sure Google will succeed at killing email. I hope gmail also goes down in flames if they succeed.
- monocasa 8y agoTotally. I think that we need to start conceiving of email as the first widely used social network, in terms of the tendencies of large companies to try and balkanize the internet, and what a decentralized social network can look like.
- prlambert 8y agoI'm one of the PMs for Gmail and hang around HN quite a bit. This is my personal take, not an official reply. It's simply not true we have no incentive to fix this. Here are a few: Firstly, Gmail's success is entirely predicated on the health of the global email ecosystem. Gmail does not, inherently, have any network effects (unlike FB, messengers, any other comms tool of Gmail's scale). Email itself, of course has a huge network effect, and that is because you can email anyone in the world, regardless of what email system they use. It's because email is open. If we lose an open, healthy ecosystem with many providers, we'll destroy the base we stand on. Secondly, we care deeply about having positive relationships with developers and all our users. I can tell you it definitely makes me sad to see articles like this. There are going to be false positives, we will make mistakes, but we certainly care a lot about fixing issues like this when we hear about them. I agree Postmaster tools has been underinvested in and we could do much better there.
- marktangotango 8y agoSecondly, we care deeply about having positive relationships with developers and all our users. This is so deeply disingenuous and at odds with so many peoples experience it’s absurd. Or satire?
- deelly 8y agoProbably key point is "..with developers and all our users.." but not individual developers and individual users.
- megous 8y agoKey point is that words don't matter unless they're backed up by some concrete action. The worst thing about this blocking is that you often times don't get to see what's wrong. So you're running around in circles, trying to use various mx tools on the internet to find the problem. This is not just gmail issue. Though with many smaller providers you'll at least get something like "your blocked by XYZ blacklist".
- StreamBright 8y ago> Google has no incentive to fix these kinds of problems. You mean not to try to actively sabotage the internet that we once knew?
- B-Con 8y agoYou're over-thinking it. GMail's market pretense is large. The number of edge cases like this in the entire world combined is a rounding error to them. It would likely be easier to fix problems to minimize bug reports and keep community good standing than increase GMail's user base by 0.001%.
- Zelphyr 8y ago> It's like we're heading back to the days when people didn't know the difference between AOL and "the internet." I hate to say it, I really do, because I used to respect Google and liked their products, but if you imagine combining the perception of "AOL is the internet" with the way Microsoft acted up to the mid-2000's and I think you have Google.
- jrnichols 8y agowe're definitely there in the K-12 market. The only email kids know is Gmail. The only browser they know is Chrome. The only OS a lot of them now know is ChromeOS, on the Chromebook their school was basically given "for free." their editors are Google Docs, Google Sheets, they use Google Hangounts to chat. Their phones are Android with all of the Google services. They know YouTube, Google Play, Google Music, etc. YouTube again for music. Some have iPhones .. and their Apple ID is a @gmail.com address. It terrifies me just how deeply Google has entrenched itself in the K-12 education market. At least when Apple was everywhere, we still had Microsoft Office vs Appleworks/etc. Google is now more "the internet" than AOL could have dreamed of.
- ddalex 8y agoThe question now is fight them or join them. On Microsoft people had chosen to fight, because the tech was horrible in effect, and Linux made much nicer server platforms. On Google, I'm not so sure. The tech is nice, and everything works beautifully for 99% of the users
- SlowRobotAhead 8y ago>It's like we're heading back to the days when people didn't know the difference between AOL and "the internet." You’re right. And it’s a small thing, but I’ve really been trying to correct myself when I use google as a verb. I’ve been trying to say “search it” instead.
- rock_artist 8y agoExactly. Like Google's services compatibility with non-Chrome browsers.
- sumosudo 8y agoMaybe AI/ML is actually broken..
- int_19h 8y agoIt's not broken. It's just hyped well beyond its constraints.
- tyingq 8y agoFunny you mention AOL. There used to be a magic formula for how many concurrent SMTP connections, how many emails/minute, etc, you could pump at them before you silently went into spam. I worked on a team with a large (real double opt in, not spam) email list. We had to pay for a bunch of AOL accounts to figure out the trigger points, so that we could get our email updates out overnight without tripping AOL's spammer logic. And there was a time when they had dominant email share like Google has now.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- flyGuyOnTheSly 8y ago> Google has no incentive to fix these kinds of problems. Even worse, they have incentive to create these problems. Gsuite is extremely profitable for them, I am sure. Charging $5/user/month for hosted email must make them a pretty penny. I would guess that no gsuite sent emails are ever blocked with this suspicious message 550 error.
- petre 8y agoThis is precisely why we should block gmail (and microsoft) in retaliation - because gmail users will start having problems with their accounts.