5 ms·
> An Amazon spokesperson confirmed to Business Insider, "Approximately 300 employees turned over in Baltimore related to productivity in this timeframe. Why do
by neilv 8y ago
> An Amazon spokesperson confirmed to Business Insider, "Approximately 300 employees turned over in Baltimore related to productivity in this timeframe.
Why do they talk like that? I think they're erasing doubt that this is a corporatist nightmare place to work.
- lordnacho 8y agoYet another instance of Newspeak. It's quite common nowadays in the real post-1984 world. The good news is people can recognize it for what it is.
- Splognosticus 8y agoBecause the sort of person who thinks it's okay to rely on an algorithm to fire people doesn't care about their employees, but cares a lot about not getting called out for it. They think they're clever but I'll be damned if I'm ever going to work for a company like that.
- jcadam 8y agoYou should always be required to a look a person in the eye when you fire them. There are way too many managers who will do anything to avoid uncomfortable situations (for them). So we end up with things like this... "Computer says you're fired" is the new "Computer says no."
- cosmodisk 8y agoAnd the best is when the cowards send an SMS instead of just saying it face to face..
- lozf 8y agoOr by robo-call as in The New Deal's "Exciting New Direction" - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z0pmNDIXymc&t=2m37 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z0pmNDIXymc&t=2m37
- Aeolun 8y agoIt’s much easier as a company to introduce a system to automatically fire people than it is to teach your managers how to fire people without taking their own comfort into account (e.g. not firing because it’s a pain).
- sct202 8y agoAlso this is an easy way to claim that people were fired fairly and they weren't picked out because the manager didn't like them or was racist.
- sigi45 8y agoIt's a warehouse. We life in the 21th century. In theory if we would sit together and structure the existing workforce without all the bullshit overhead of accounting, bullshit jobs and priorities life quality and sustainability, no one would need to work and we could achieve this in the next 5, 10, 50 years. I get that amazon should pay there workforce properly and as long as we have this, it should be something people can and should do in a social way but Baltimore is a US City, they don't even have a working health care system. A warehouse job is a warehouse job. No education needed, why wouldn't a computer system should not fire people on simple productivity numbers?
- alex_young 8y agoI guess it depends on how great you are at guessing what to optimize for. If you make a machine that just rewards completing tasks, maybe you'll get poor quality. If you add quality to the mix, maybe you'll fire everyone who has experience and you'll be left with only those yet to make a mistake.
- nkozyra 8y ago> A warehouse job is a warehouse job. No education needed, why wouldn't a computer system should not fire people on simple productivity numbers? Increasingly, this viewpoint bothers me. To be honest I don't know the ins and outs of working in an Amazon warehouse but I suspect it's not as brainless a job as you imply. Further, why does that attribute make this ok? Why wouldn't it similarly be ok if the computer could fire people automatically if a threshold of unit tests failed or if a developer failed to meet LOC quotas?
- gambiting 8y agoBecause there's more metrics to programming than LOC and if a company treats it like the only metric then they deserve to go under. Working in a warehouse does not have multiple dimensions to it. You are paid to pick up things, put them in boxes and then pick up more things. That's it. It's easy to measure. For comparison sake, I know someone who runs a company sorting refuse. Each person in the warehouse needs to sort through 500kg of refuse every day. That's it. Literally nothing else matters. It's not a complex job, so the metric is not complex either.
- croo 8y agoTo derail on the sentence: "Approximately" so later they can say that it was actually 200 or 400. "related to productivity" hints that they turned over some more but not related to productivity as to lower the precision of this number even more. "in this timeframe" put all this in a timeframe said by someone else. Every part of the sentence works hard to make the number 300 more imprecise. I think he talks like this because he has no idea about the actual number.
- rasz 8y agoThose are just datapoints, whats the big deal? It only becomes real when finally touching you directly, as some journalist learned recently #LearnToCode.