6 ms·
Brave is just an intermediary that replaces ads with other ads. It's an adnetwork delivered as a browser that creates ad inventory on top of the page instead of
by manigandham 8y ago
Brave is just an intermediary that replaces ads with other ads. It's an adnetwork delivered as a browser that creates ad inventory on top of the page instead of within it.
That being said, the tokens are basically worthless. This is not what the digital advertising industry wants and Brave is not going to get any decent advertisers with this. They'll end up with the same shady affiliate/performance marketers running CPA ads currently infesting all the 'content recommendation' widgets.
- sbarre 8y agoThis was tried during the first dot-com boom as well! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AllAdvantage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AllAdvantage
- ChrisCinelli 8y agoI remember some friends using it with some tools to move the mouse around so they could get paid without staying in front of the computer. But it was very little money and it was probably costing more electricity than the money they were getting but for a teenager it was ok.
- toast0 8y agoI managed to get one or two checks, I tweaked the programs I was running anyway (AIM, mIRC, etc) to have Internet Explorer in the window title, so I got credit when I was doing whatever I was going to do anyway. Sometimes I moved the ad window off screen with LiteStep though :D
- Scoundreller 8y agoAnd that was probably the lower end of things. On the higher end, users would artificially generate hundreds of fake referrals and auto-surf for them, generating large amounts of referral revenues.
- aestetix 8y agoIt was more money if you set up a bunch of computers all doing the same thing.
- nostrademons 8y agoIt's different from AllAdvantage with the addition of market mechanisms to correctly price the attention consumed by ads. That's why users get tokens for viewing, why users can turn the ads off entirely, and why the tokens are tradeable on exchanges. It creates a built-in feedback mechanism. If BAT is priced too low, then everybody will opt out of ads (because it won't be worth it to them), very little BAT will be available on the market, and advertisers will have to bid up the price of BAT to run their ads. If BAT is priced too high, there will be excess ad inventory, no advertisers will buy in, and the price of BAT will fall until it reaches an equilibrium. AllAdvantage.com failed in a large part because they mispriced the rebates going back to users. They burned through all their VC cash, didn't provide enough value to advertisers, and went out of business. Brave avoids that by letting the market make the pricing decisions. This is something that couldn't have been done at all before cryptocurrencies, which is what makes this project somewhat interesting.
- manigandham 8y agoWhy would advertisers bid higher when this is not the only channel and comes with less targeting and increased fraud potential? Why would users opt-in at all to see ads when they're already blocked? There seems to be missing component of why both sides want to interact through the Brave network.
- nostrademons 8y ago> Why would advertisers bid higher when this is not the only channel and comes with less targeting and increased fraud potential? Brave's model - like all ad-supported ones - depends upon them getting very big, enough that they get a substantial fraction of total user attention. They're going for this by blocking all existing ads, which in today's web makes the browser significantly faster and less annoying. They're at about 5.5M users as of January 2019, up from 3M in July 2018. That's still a long way to go, but it's growing fast. > Why would users opt-in at all to see ads when they're already blocked? Because they get money for it.
- manigandham 8y ago
- quotemstr 8y agoIt's another sign that we're heading for 1999 part 2. I remember what the end of the last boom felt like, and I'm definitely getting the same tingly feeling now.
- rvnx 8y agoTime to setup your autosurf and get some crypto ;)
- rayiner 8y agoRegardless, Brave is a pretty great browser. It increases battery life on my machine by an hour or two compared to Chrome by blocking all those ads.
- RandomBacon 8y agoHow is the battery life of Brave comapred to Chrome with an ad-blocker? How about the more privacy-respecting Firefox with an ad-blocker?
- atomical 8y agoIf everyone uses either of your suggested options the publishers go broke and there is no content to view. Brave has a plan for that. So yes, they are farther along than any idea you have presented.
- RandomBacon 8y agoThere are websites that sell static ad space and don't use third-party tracking tools. I'm not saying that is the answer, or that Brave/BAT is not the answer. I'm just saying if battery life is what you care about, there are better alternatives.
- atomical 8y agoBrave doesn't block those ads.
- RandomBacon 8y agoOkay. Neither does my "suggested options".
- paulryanrogers 8y ago> I'm just saying if battery life is what you care about, there are better alternatives. There's no evidence that ad blocking can scale. Seems a bit like suggesting reducing the cost-per-mile by blocking a car's licence plate and skipping out on paying for gas. It's technically an alternative, but not one that can work for everyone.
- trevelyan 8y agoI think Saito (saito.tech) has the better approach. Surely the problem with the Brave model isn't that they are hijacking the browser so much as that they're just replacing who is in the monopolistic position. Better to let anyone in the world setup an advertising network and let anyone receive adverts from anyone else.
- ralphstodomingo 8y agoShouldn't you make a disclaimer you're part of their team?
- nilkn 8y agoWhy is this such a bad thing, though? That's the critical part missing from your post. It seems to me that the idea is to replace unethical opt-out ads with ethical opt-in ads that don't track you. Besides that, Brave is a browser first, currency layer/ad network second. It doesn't need advertisers. It needs users. The more users it has, the more value there is for advertisers too.
- shostack 8y agoTo be fair, the general cycle is that any ad network/publisher platform tends to get started with the shady affiliate and performance marketing scene, and then as they grow, they gradually get on the radar of more "reputable" advertisers, and eventually costs rise and they begin actively pushing the smaller ones out for brand safety reasons to let them drive up their CPMs for big brands.
- manigandham 8y agoDoesn't that only work when the users have no choice (other than the trade for content)? Would you enable ads if all you got was scammy links? How many users would enable to get to that critical mass?
- shostack 8y agoCompeting on features and winning in the marketplace can be enough. Facebook wasn't the first social network. Google wasn't the first search engine. People had plenty of choice.
- everdev 8y agoMore than that, it's just a Chrome browser with Ad Block by default.
- drb91 8y agoI was under the impression you could also pay the content producer directly to bypass ads, which is IMHO the ideal solution. Is this no longer viable?
- manigandham 8y agoNo it's still possible, but doesn't seem viable. Microtransactions have been tried several times. We experimented ourselves. Very hard to get users to pay for something that has always been free, especially when the ads are already blocked.
- michaelbrooks 8y agoViewing ads is completely optional and is off by default. All website ads are still blocked, the ads you are seeing are built into the browser.
- rchaud 8y agoIt works when "pay the producer" is the default option, and not something you have to opt into. Also helps if you are serving a niche audience rather than a general one. The Stratechery website charges $10/mo for what is essentially a tech consultant's take on SV company product strategy. This is a narrow niche, and the site isn't one that will get millions of ad views. So there aren't any ads at all, and as a bonus, there aren't any throwaway blog posts designed to be shared on social media.
- Tsubasachan 8y agoReplacing ads with other ads. Genius. I use ad blockers because advertising doesn't add anything meaningful to my experience. I don't think there are a lot of ublock users who actually miss seeing ads.