5 ms·
I do believe these sorts of "Amazon is amazingly smart" posts. But they are hard to reconcile with why Amazon keeps showing me a rice cooker ad, after I buy a
by tyingq 8y ago
I do believe these sorts of "Amazon is amazingly smart" posts.
But they are hard to reconcile with why Amazon keeps showing me a rice cooker ad, after I buy a rice cooker from them.
- sokoloff 8y agoAmazon seems to think that I’m a real vacuum aficionado/collector as well. It’s quite possible that those are still the best items to recommend to us, to mop up any “unhappy with the one they got, so save them with a return/rebuy” sales.
- Declanomous 8y agoI wouldn't be surprised if the actual reason was they are capturing extra sales from people who bought something, liked it a lot, and then bought another to give to their kids or for their second home. My mom buys me random chotchkies all the time after she bought them and liked them, and if my parents were well off I could easily see her buying me a vacuum or a new mattress after she got herself one. For 99% of people that probably doesn't happen, but the people with the money to do that probably spend a TON of money, so they are worth targeting with ads.
- dearrifling 8y agoSo they are misattributing the additional sale to their suggestions instead of the product being an advertisement for itself.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoI suspect adtech industry would shrink down half its size if it could accurately attribute sales to ads. It sometimes smells as if it was standard practice to convince the client (intentionally, or unintentionally by also convincing yourself) that correlation is causation and therefore their success is attributed to ad spending.
- imtringued 8y agoThe working vacuum in your house is a significantly better ad than whatever amazon shoves down your throat.
- ThrustVectoring 8y agoIt doesn't take that many people buying ten (or a thousand) rice cookers for that ad to make sense.
- ehsankia 8y agoMaybe you'll find it so useful that you'll want to gift it to someone else also?
- serioussecurity 8y agoBecause ad click through rates are so low and the signal is so incredibly sparse. It's all measured against a test set which the researchers rarely look at directly (because the data set is so large). So if something lifts ad vlicks by 1% and that's from 100 in 10k to 101 in 10k, they don't really care if 9k of the ads get appreciably dumber.
- cryptonector 8y agoSure, but if you buy a rice cooker, maybe the ads to show you are for: rice, cookbooks (featuring lots of rice?), pressure cookers, cast iron pans, sous vide recirculators, and so on. I mean, you have a rice cooker, you won't want another, but chances are you'd buy other things you don't already have.
- nmjohn 8y agoWhat is the ratio between people who viewed a rice cooker (the group I'm assuming they target with ads) vs. those who actually bought a rice cooker? Is it possible the ratio is so large to where while it obviously could be optimized to exclude people who have since purchased said item - the optimization is only a rounding error, and may not turn out to be worth it?
- ericd 8y agoWell, I buy things from Amazon very frequently, and I have a high conversion rate between searched-for-category and bought something to satisfy the search, so Amazon ads are for things I've already taken care of >90% of the time. I'm guessing they're leaving a lot of money on the table from me because of it. But maybe I'm unusual in my shopping patterns.
- ahmedalsudani 8y agoIt's not as simple as that. There are multiple ways to figure out which ad to show to a user, but I think the most efficient way (development and compute) is to put a user in segments (e.g. lives in area X, searched for Y, age Z, ...) and then do the bidding magic. There are tight tolerances for bidding--you want it to happen within a fraction of a second so the ad quickly loads for the user. Feeding purchase data is likely something that requires a bit of work, and I imagine the ad team at Amazon doesn't see enough value to prioritize it (especially since they make money either way--the advertisers pay for the ad with a higher CPC). One thing to keep in mind is that the purchase data is per-user, so it's different from the segment approach I was mentioning above. It would require a whole new schema* that is queried whenever bids are processed for an ad event. * Sorry for using the word schema here. It was used a lot on a team I was on in a similar context, and it bothered me at first but I got used to it. What I mean by schema is a "blob" with purchase data that is periodically processed by the bidding subsystem to add bid exclusions per user.
- harryh 8y agopatio11 has a good tweetstorm on why Amazon doing this is perfectly rational. https://twitter.com/patio11/status/875629380105416705 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/875629380105416705
- rorykoehler 8y agoI read somewhere (can't remember exactly where) that this happens because people are most likely to buy the same item they just bought due to not being happy with their original purchase.
- kevcampb 8y agoThey've probably modelled the failure rate for the first one you bought.
- baxtr 8y agoReminds me of booking.com that keeps on sending me hotels in small towns I just visited once (for a weeding, driving thru) etc. I don’t why they get smarter than that
- raxxorrax 8y agoOr they know something about that rice cooker that you don't know yet.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- aeternus 8y agoI think this makes sense. Maybe you like it and want to buy another for friends & relatives? You might not be happy with the purchase and on the lookout for a better model.