13 ms·
Mozilla WebThings
- carmate383 8y agoC'mon Mozilla, please. Less projects that will end up like Firefox OS, more work on _Firefox_.
- metildaa 8y agoFirefox OS has been rebranded as KaiOS since Mozilla stopped working on it, and it has been gaining significant market share since then. A $5 LTE bar or flip phone based on a Qualcomm 205 with 128MB of ram isn't able to run Android (especially not in a fast manner), but it will run KaiOS just fine.
- fooker 8y agoCan you link to a $5 flip phone with Firefox OS I can buy today?
- commoner 8y agoThe JioPhone is effectively offered for free, with a ₹1,500 ($21.60) deposit that is refunded after 3 years. To be precise, it's a candybar phone that runs on KaiOS (forked from Firefox OS, closed source). https://www.jiophone.com/ https://www.jiophone.com/
- fooker 8y agoI was looking for an unlocked option that would work in the US.
- kkarakk 8y agoafaik there are no unlocked phones that exist that run KaiOS(outside of tinkerers in shenzhen)
- omnifischer 8y agoYou cant get the source code. Reliance telco does not care - nor does KaiOS people.
- carmate383 8y agoSo you're encouraging Mozilla to create more abandonware?
- ShinTakuya 8y agoIf it has a reasonable chance of not becoming abandonware, sure. I'm sick of people being so pessimistic. Imagine if Google stuck to search and never released new products. Maybe some people would prefer that but personally I can't live without Google Maps for instance.
- carmate383 8y agoAnd how much money do you donate to Mozilla to fund their abandonware habbit?
- Intermernet 8y agoWhy are you being so anti innovation? I could pass it off as opinion for a few comments, but this comment section is now littered with your comments that all seem to say that mozilla shouldn't bother developing anything new. Do you have skin in this game? Did you get personally burnt by mozilla somewhere along the line?
- danso 8y agoSeriously? IoT is a quickly growing, potentially massive and ubiquitous field. Given the shit state of security and technical implementation of its initial era, in very glad that a well-resourced non-profit is helping to create an open standard.
- carmate383 8y agoAnd six years ago, mobile was a quick-growing massive and ubiquitous field. How did that pan out for Mozilla? A failed operating system and the beginning of a huge decline in both marketshare and performance for Firefox.
- greenhatman 8y agoIf we stopped doing things because they might fail we'd be nowhere.
- carmate383 8y agoAnd if Mozilla keeps making the same mistakes it will go nowhere.
- danso 8y agoLast I checked, Mozilla was still a functioning, funded company pushing out regular updates to Firefox, among other projects. Mobile still is a massive and ubiquitous field, and Firefox Mobile is one of Mozilla's ongoing projects. You believe that a failed project means a company should stop innovating and entering emerging fields?
- snek 8y agoIf you somehow feel that firefox is moving too slowly (check the vcs history its very active) you can always contribute yourself, it's OSS :)
- walid 8y agoNo he can't always contribute himself because most people myself included can't contribute to whatever project just because it is open source. You need to have an intimate knowledge of the technology and the experience and since you suggesting that he "can always contribute" I'd ask you: can you?
- blotter_paper 8y agoAn up front cost in learning doesn't mean you can't contribute.
- bepvte 8y agoExactly. Theres plenty of documentation to be written and translating to be done
- themacguffinman 8y agoI guess there's no sense in ever complaining about politics and laws since you can just run for office yourself. Didn't realize upfront costs don't matter :shrug:
- Vinnl 8y agoThe phone OS market was already pretty entrenched when they started on Firefox OS. They're focusing on IoT now exactly to prevent it from ending up like Firefox OS, and to prevent them from ending up in a Firefox Desktop-like situation, where its relevancy keeps declining both because the relevance of desktop is declining, and because people do not use Firefox on mobile and thus cannot sync.
- Fnoord 8y agoWhat kind of work on Firefox are you referring to?
- marcosdumay 8y agoBecause developers are interchangeable gears that can work on any kind of project without any bump, and can be stacked into any number on a shared project without any issue.
- aphextron 8y agoMy first thought seeing this headline: Let me guess, another move from Mozilla to start gathering more personal data. I wish they’d proven me wrong.
- bionicbits 8y agoI thought Mozilla was pro-privacy with all the features they have added to the browser. Have I been missing something? I recently came back to Firefox for their stance on privacy.
- Ardon 8y agoNo, you're right on Mozilla's stance on privacy. I think Mozilla keeps making things that are good for collecting customer data because those are the things that most need an open alternative.
- kgiori 8y agothe WebThings gateway is an opportunity for Mozilla to help protect privacy and security, not copy the approach of industry silo's where devices connect to the cloud. your gateway data stays local.
- rzr 8y agoyes, This is what I call privacy by design: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Privacy_by_design https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Privacy_by_design ps: I am a contributor of it ;)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- walid 8y ago"another move from Mozilla to start gathering" What do you mean by "another move" here? Mozilla isn't gathering anything!
- 8y ago
- arthurcolle 8y agoSorry for the aside but what CMS does Mozilla use for these publications? Just out of curiosity
- the8472 8y agoDoes it use multicast discovery?
- rzr 8y agoyes mDNS
- lousken 8y agoWould this be compatible with Turris Omnia?
- kgiori 8y agoThat's one of the targets for OpenWrt support, yes.
- VectorLock 8y agoWhat products support WebThings right now?
- kbumsik 8y agoHere is the maintained list of supported hardware: https://github.com/mozilla-iot/wiki/wiki/Supported-Hardware https://github.com/mozilla-iot/wiki/wiki/Supported-Hardware
- giancarlostoro 8y agoThis is the Mozilla I love. I wish they did more projects like this, it's a shame Firefox OS went away, especially in this world of PWAs. I do love that this dashboard can even be ran on your router. Also the web UI looks really clean.
- metildaa 8y agoFirefox OS has been rebranded as KaiOS, and its eating marketshare with $5 LTE bar and flip phones. Said devices are pretty minimally specced with a Qualcomm 205 and 128MB of Ram, but Mozilla did a great job optimizing for low end devices.
- jrochkind1 8y agoI only know of one flip phone sold in the U.S with KaiOS. I had one. It was a terrible flip phone. And I know flip phones. Like, the flip phone of 10 years ago did not give you a delay every time you pressed a button. The KaiOS one did. It also did not have installable 'apps' as was the original promise of KaiOS. It's UX was generally very confusing (yes, flip phones have a UX; you notice especially when it's a bad one). I don't know if it's doing better in non-US markets. But I don't think so; someone else _did_ take the Firefox OS source code which of course had an open source license, and adopt it and rebrand it as KaiOS. I am not sure what their aspirations for it are. Currently, I do not think it is the promise of what people hoped FirefoxOS would be (and may or may not ever have been).
- carmate383 8y agoSource for the supposed "eating" of global marketshare? I can't find any marketshare report that even mentions such an OS.
- commoner 8y agoKaiOS is relatively successful in India, with 15% market share for mobile devices in 2018 (second place). https://www.bgr.in/news/jiophone-kaios-surpasses-ios-india-second-most-popular-mobile-operating-system-android-smartphones-feature-phones-jio-4g/ https://www.bgr.in/news/jiophone-kaios-surpasses-ios-india-s...
- hathawsh 8y agoWhoa, at the end of the article there's an announcement about "WebThings Gateway for Wireless Routers". Is this the beginning of apps for routers? I've talked about the idea before: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18887403 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18887403 I'm excited to hear more.
- doctorpangloss 8y agoDocker for NAS devices is the de facto App Store. The most compelling applications are for media consumption / piracy.
- flipper_c 8y agoI’ve been looking into this lately for mine. Definitely need to invest more time. What NAS are you running?
- graton 8y agoI'm not who you asked but Synology is pretty nice. Runs Docker nicely and lots of applications available for it. Recommend an Intel CPU based vs the ARM based Synology NAS systems. I use it to run various software for my home network.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoI second Synology. Runs my ArchiveTeam docker container, any docker container really without issue. Also accepts TimeMachine backups from my Macs and backs everything up to Backblaze B2.
- tomjakubowski 8y agoWhy do you recommend Intel over ARM?
- gervase 8y agoI wouldn't say this is a universal "ARM vs Intel" claim, just a specific heuristic for this company's products. Synology's ARM line is generally underpowered compared to their Intel offerings, in terms of clock speed, memory capacity, and core count. They also tend to gate additional features (e.g. hardware-accelerated encryption) behind their Intel offerings. edit: We're mostly talking Atoms / Celerons here, so not exactly screaming performance either way.
- canada_dry 8y agoTook a quick breeze though the intro and maybe missed it... Where's the love for IoT DIY/tinkerer gadgets though? i.e. Arduino, Beagle bone, ESP8266/32?
- mintplant 8y agoCheck the "Arduino" tabs on the WebThings Framework homepage [0]. See also the Supported Hardware list [1], which includes ESP8266, ESP32, and Raspberry Pi (among many others). [0] https://iot.mozilla.org/framework/ https://iot.mozilla.org/framework/ [1] https://github.com/mozilla-iot/wiki/wiki/Supported-Hardware https://github.com/mozilla-iot/wiki/wiki/Supported-Hardware
- ousta 8y agoit seems to be mostly for domotics right? what about IOT for other things like medical devices for instance that would be a good area to open source
- kgiori 8y agothe W3C Web of Things framework is agnostic to use cases and devices. Mozilla's WebThings framework can work in medical, industrial, etc. It's just that Mozilla's focus is to put people first. (Plus it's easiest to invite makers and community dev when contributors can use it themselves at home). All the code is open source -- I've already seen some industrial companies pick it up and customize for their needs.
- dccoolgai 8y agoMy first reaction is "wtf? What about WebBluetooth?" That is an open standard that supports tinkering, integrates with Permissions api, etc. And it's been withering on the vine with no help from Moz... this looks like a poor alternative, tbh, unless I'm missing something.
- kevingadd 8y agoWhat does Web Bluetooth have to do with IoT? Bluetooth is a short range, low-bandwidth protocol for 1:1 pairing of devices, isn't it? That aside, Google's approach to introducing experimental APIs like Web Audio, Web USB, Web Bluetooth etc has been... less than ideal. Having been involved in it, I don't think it's surprising that other vendors are not interested in helping.
- z3t4 8y agoBluetooth can be used to connect to wireless speakers etc. There exist many cheap Bluetooth speakers which are perfect for iot.
- coupdejarnac 8y agoI'm making an IoT device that connects through web bt. Web bt allows us to circumvent having to publish mobile apps, at least for Android and desktop OSes.
- kevingadd 8y agoSounds like a cool use case, it just sounds nothing like what WebThings does.
- coupdejarnac 8y agoIt pretty much covers the same use case, except my device doesn't use wifi directly to access the interwebs.
- revskill 8y agoEverytime i see a Mozilla product announcement, i feel hope. The hope for a better Internet. It's opposite feeling with Google.
- zachguo 8y agoGoogle has done a fairly amount of work to help the world wide web survive while more and more gated mobile platforms are created, because their revenue still depends on it.
- askvictor 8y agoThis looks like a competitor to homeassistant/Hass?
- anyzen 8y agoYes, it looks this way to me too. Interesting that they didn't join forces.
- tornadon 8y agoThanks it took me way too long to figure out “what” this thing was.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cptskippy 8y agoI'm glad they didn't. HASS isn't very user friendly to setup and very unstable in use. I spent far too much time trying to maintain a setup of HASS. It's schizophrenic with it's MQTT support and the two paths don't play well. It "supports" SSL through Let's Encrypt but it was problematic with MQTT. It's kind of awful to configure with files being scattered all over the filesystem. It frequent updates and frequently breaks configurations. It also has weird limitations with certain Smarthome integrations (e.g. Insteon) that make it unusable.
- pagutierrezn 8y agoI expected to see MQTT as an integral part of the WebThings Gateway but haven't found it so far
- IshKebab 8y agoMQTT is kind of crap so I'm not surprised.
- Uberphallus 8y agoWhat's the problem with MQTT? It's basically the interconnecting standard for all things IoT. I mix and match IoT devices, and everything is fed into Home Assistant through MQTT, plus logging to InfluxDB. I'm familiar with the protocol and haven't found any wart; the biggest problem is how to run it with redundancy and at a scale.
- kbumsik 8y agoAFAIK there is no IoT data exchange format standard over MQTT. Every vendors has its own data format. It is not simple to normalize the data to match other standards like Zigbee profiles. You should manually code for every MQTT devices.
- musingsole 8y agoI cannot stand debugging MQTT devices. From establishing a connection to sending data, it is consistently difficult to pinpoint where the failure in a system is occuring. Contrast this with HTTP and WebSockets that are extremely simplistic to use. Largely by virtue of bigger communities using them, but so it is. Where's the benefit of MQTT? The code is just as large and more opaque by being an uncommon standard (compared to HTTP). Everyone says bandwidth, but that's hardly a concern often and when it is...I can never seem to find the numbers of how much data usage MQTT would save for a given application.
- Matthias247 8y agoSome issues that come to my mind with MQTT: 1. Most implementations are quite weak. E.g. the Paho implementation for C can't send and receive at the same time, can't publish multiple messages concurrently, and will block it's only execution thread for lots of seconds until the server might response. That might be ok for very low-throughput devices, but in general it's neither performant nor resilient. Libraries like these also don't track whether subscriptions already have been performed or not, don't perform retries, etc. 2. The specification has a few warts, that imho make things like QoS1 and above impossible to implement correctly. E.g. if a message is sent with a certain messageId and the server doesn't respond within a timeframe, the client can't really time-out only this publication. If the client forgets the messageId, continues to work and later on publishes a new message with the same Id (there are only 64k of those), then any ACK for that is ambiguous and the client couldn't tell for sure which delivery was ACKd. That basically voids the at least once delivery property. I don't any implementation out there blacklists the IDs in order to avoid the ambiguity (which would also not work long term anyway, due to the low address space). 3. Most applications want some kind of transactional or request/response semantics. Of course that can be implemented on top of MQTT in the application layer, but it's more tedious and error-prone than using a protocol which already enables it. 4. Lots of applications also want to stream bigger amounts of data for some use-cases. Implementing a multi-megabyte upload or download with MQTT requires to build a custom flow-control, retransmissions, buffering for out-of-order messages, etc. Or in other words: They are required to implement the equivalent of TCP on top of UDP. Overall my opinion is that it can be used for certain applications, but it's actually a far weaker option than assumed. Due to the issue 1) and 2) I would recommend to mainly use QoS0 if talking to a MQTT broker is a requirement - and to move all reliability concerns into the application layer instead of relying on MQTT doing it right.
- josteink 8y ago> We’re also excited to share that we’ve been working on a new OpenWrt-based build of WebThings Gateway, aimed at consumer wireless routers. I’m impressed. Almost sold, even. All I’m left wondering about is device-support. How does this compare to (for instance) Home Assistant?
- xiaomai 8y agoI've been using Things gateway for probably a year or so now (I'm just using z-wave devices, but Things supports lots of other types as well). The main thing I see missing that most home automators will want is support for locks/garage door openers/etc. The interior stuff like lights/alarms/plugs/sensors/etc. is all great. A lot of emphasis is on their Web of Things protocol that looks really cool and would be fun to play around with if you wanted to add your own home-made device (or hopefully more vendors will be adopting that protocol soon).
- white-moss 8y agoA competitor, Samsung SmartThings has sandboxed-app system. It enables users to operate IoT machines with groovy based programming language. Things Gateway also can control IoT machines, but its simple rule-based system. It is currently losing point and improvable feature. I'm very excited with Things Gateway philosophy, so I can't wait for its next evolving.
- hutzlibu 8y agoOk, so if I would like to have a motion sensor (and maybe a camera) attached to a server on a rasperry pi which sends alerts to my smartphone ... how much work and tinkering can I expect at the current state, if I am very good in javascript, node and linux, but not at "low level" things?
- kgiori 8y agoTry either the e-mail sender add-on or the twilio add-on, then create rules that notify you via one of those methods. Camera integration is tricky, mostly due to the lack of standards around data streams and extra sensors/actuators, dealt with in different ways by different vendors. Other binary sensors or variable sensors can be triggered easily with rules to notify you of things you care about.
- James_Owens_69 8y agoThe same mozilla that censors free speech?
- wayneftw 8y agoAre there any Mozilla projects that have any sort of market share and make money or are they mostly just living off that sweet Google cash for their ~10% Firefox market share? Any chance Google stops funding them soon? (Wow, a question was asked. Better censor it Mozillans!)
- sciurus 8y agoThis is a fair question, albeit off topic. You can see Mozilla's latest annual report report at https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/foundation/annualreport/2017/ https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/foundation/annualreport/2017/ And the latest public financial statement at https://assets.mozilla.net/annualreport/2017/mozilla-fdn-2017-fs-short-form-final-0927.pdf https://assets.mozilla.net/annualreport/2017/mozilla-fdn-201... (Disclosure: I work for Mozilla, but not on WebThings or producing those reports)
- robotron 8y agoYou also asked a question with a lot of editorializing in it. I wouldn't call downvotes censorship.
- wayneftw 8y agoExactly what part of it was editorialized? Is getting $500 million dollars a year from Google not a sweet deal?
- scriptkiddy 8y ago> Are there any Mozilla projects that have any sort of market share and make money or are they mostly just living off that sweet Google cash for their ~10% Firefox market share? Is that a relevant question considering that Mozilla Foundation is a non-profit organization? > Any chance Google stops funding them soon? Probably, but that won't stop them from doing what they're currently doing. Also, Google doesn't "fund" them so much as pay them for search integration. > (Wow, a question was asked. Better censor it Mozillans!) The question was not presented in good faith. In fact, it's clear that you weren't actually asking a question at all. You were stating your opinions sarcastically in the form of a question.
- yallegoheadz 8y agothis thread further illustrates the dumpster fire of self importance that is HN
- detaro 8y agoAny particularly good tutorials exploring it? How well does it integrate with existing tech, both closed and open? (E.g. in open-source Home Automation, MQTT seems to be the glue of choice)
- robotron 8y agoAre there docs for setting this up on a pi without flashing it? I want to run this alongside a few other things on my pi.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]