7 ms·
This is described in the book called "the checklist manifesto". Very good book by the way. https://www.amazon.com/Checklist-Manifesto-How-Things-Right/dp/03124
by ekianjo 8y ago
This is described in the book called "the checklist manifesto". Very good book by the way.
https://www.amazon.com/Checklist-Manifesto-How-Things-Right/dp/0312430000 https://www.amazon.com/Checklist-Manifesto-How-Things-Right/...
- dotancohen 8y ago> This is described in the book called "the checklist manifesto". You might notice that the book was written by Dr. Gawande, who implemented the checklist in the fine article!
- _Codemonkeyism 8y agoI second that, excellent book.
- ysr23 8y agoI've also read it, for anyone thinking about buying it, i think it can be completely summarised by: 'checklists are very very good. You should really use checklists' Now if you require further info on why they are good, by all means read the book, i just found it was a blog-post, if not a tweet, expanded to a book, YMMV.
- pamplemoose 8y agoThat's exactly what it was. Atul Gawande wrote a column in the New Yorker [0] and was presumably offered a deal to expand it into a book. [0] https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2007/12/10/the-checklist https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2007/12/10/the-checklist
- MR4D 8y agoI kindof agree, but he also had other interesting nuggets such as having all the medical staff introduce themselves and why they are there in the surgery room before any cutting begins. It's interesting to think how often dumb errors can be caught just by making sure everyone in the room is there for the same surgery (i.e., repairing a joint, not cutting off a limb). Correcting that confusion before cutting makes me feel better.
- rtkwe 8y agoThat's the basic gist of all productivity and business how to/advice books. They're all a fairly simple set of ideas with 100 examples and testimonial style stories about just how revolutionary it is or how much it changed executive XYZ's life.
- regularfry 8y agoYes, and that's a feature. Human brains are swayed by narrative, not by rote facts. If you want to get a positive change implemented, you need to tell a story.
- FabHK 8y agoI think that you're right, yet the book may still be valuable. I have, for a while, read summaries of business (and other) books by getabstract.com. These cover the main points of the book, but what happens is that you read it, it all makes sense, and a day later you've completely forgotten of it. The book, on the other hand, yes, expounds on the very same points again and again, with different examples, under different circumstances, highlighting different aspects, and then, having had the same message hammered home so many times, there's a faint chance that a month later you remember some of it. (Great books change the way you view things forever, but that happens rarely, and never with business books, I'd say :-)
- rtkwe 8y agoYeah I'm not really saying it's useless just that it's the basic format of those books. I think the best way to read those is to skim the various testimonials to get an idea what they're talking about and get to the author's point then read them as they spark your interest or seem relevant. I get why they're in there, it's one of the few ways to argue the actual effectiveness of whatever advice the author is giving. It just seems excessive sometimes how much of the books are just 'I swear this works look at these important people it worked for.'
- ekianjo 8y ago> 'checklists are very very good. You should really use checklists' If you stop at that you miss a big part of the book where he describes that not all checklists are equal, what makes checklists useful (i.e. you should not state the obvious in a checklist and he goes at length to explain why), and how you spread the usage of checklists in an organization. That's a lot more important than "checklists are very very good".
- FabHK 8y agoPlus the whole spiel about CRM (crew resource management), eg that the entire team should introduce themselves, that the nurse is as entitled to speak up and ask questions as the Prof. Dr. surgeon MD Esq., etc. etc.
- throw0101a 8y ago> I've also read it, for anyone thinking about buying it, Or perhaps see if your local library has it. I've reduced my book purchases, and generally only consider buying something nowadays if I still enjoy it after the second/third reading (from the library).
- copperx 8y agoBuying a book before reading it is almost always a bad decision, even if it has rave reviews. And even if you love the book, owning it serves no practical purpose unless you constantly re-read it. The only good thing is that they serve as visual reminders of the books that you've read; otherwise it's easy to forget the titles and authors.
- bluGill 8y agoNote that rereading a book doesn't have to mean cover to cover. If you look things up in the book once in a while you should have it. It doesn't need to be you who reads the book either, it could by your personal library and you lend it to friends interested in the same subject. Public libraries will get rid of unpopular books so having a personal library of obscure subjects you care about is useful. (The internet does not have everything)
- throw0101a 8y ago> The only good thing is that they serve as visual reminders of the books that you've read; otherwise it's easy to forget the titles and authors. It's possible to create an account on Good Reads or Library Thing to keep track. There's Delicious Library as well (for Mac?).
- duckmysick 8y ago> owning it serves no practical purpose unless you constantly re-read it. I disagree. I write a lot on the margins of the books I own - notes, personal observations, questions, criticism. I highlight interesting passages. It helps me understand the book deeper and retain its ideas.
- Haegin 8y ago
- jrib 8y agoOne additional thing I got out of it that wasn't totally obvious to me beforehand about checklists is that they work better if they don't attempt to be exhaustive. Focus on the major items that should be "checked".
- Maximus9000 8y agoThe only addition I would have to that summary is: "And yet, most people think checklists are beneath them. They are insulted that someone with as much experience as they currently have would require a checklist."
- dd36 8y agoHere is a Hidden Brain episode on it: https://www.npr.org/2017/10/30/559996276/the-trick-to-surviving-a-high-stakes-high-pressure-job-try-a-checklist https://www.npr.org/2017/10/30/559996276/the-trick-to-surviv...
- arkades 8y agoThe medical community uses checklists. They've been using checklists for a while. A number of studies found that they only help for a few months, while they're new. That said, "the medical community" is not a homogeneous monolith, and you can absolutely find regional variation in what checklists are used for, how detailed they are, how closely they're followed, how people are accountable for keeping to them, etc. "The Checklist Manifesto" chose to overlook the studies about how transient the benefit of checklists is.
- justaguyhere 8y agoAre these paper based? Any checklist apps out there for our daily use?
- Someone1234 8y agoKanban boards e.g. Trello, Kanbanflow, Microsoft Planner, and others. They all support checklists, and you can categorize/organize as you need.
- mike22 8y ago“A simple, free and powerful way to manage your team's recurring checklists and procedures“ https://www.process.st/ https://www.process.st/ Paid features include 3rd party integrations. (Disclaimer: neither a customer nor employee of the company.)
- ghostly_s 8y agoDo any of these let you re-use your checklists, though? Planner at least is pretty useless for this, as I don't think there is a 'reset all items to un-checked' feature, or even basic stuff like re-arranging your list.
- Someone1234 8y agoClick the "..." and Copy Task. It will generate the checklist again without anything checked, then just mark the old as complete. You'd need some system to mark when one list ends and the next begins, KanBan just treats them as individual tasks. > even basic stuff like re-arranging your list. All of them let you re-arrange your list. Is this a mobile specific issue?
- jammygit 8y agoAgreed, the book was very well written and the audiobook had a great narrator. Because of that book, I'm not surprised that the checklist reduced deaths, but its a bit shocking that its by a third. Then again, the base rate was very low to begin with, showing that surgery teams were already doing a seemingly good job: "The death rate fell to 0.46 per 100 procedures between 2000 and 2014, analysis of 6.8m operations showed." Still, over 6.8 million operations, is that 15,000 survivals? Wow.
- FabHK 8y agoOne big difference, I've always suspected, is that a plane crash is very visible and affects hundreds of people at once. Somebody sick dying in hospital, on the other hand, is just something that happens, and draws very little attention - even though way more people are affected than in plane crashes. So, the clustering and visibility of plane crashes leads to excellent check list discipline and other best practices in aviation, by and large (CRM, Crew Resource Management, is another thing Atul Gawande brings up in The Checklist Manifesto, and also eminently transferable to surgery), while I suspect that in surgery it is easier to drift away from best practices again without anyone noticing. That's why these large studies and the educational efforts of Dr Gawande and others are so important. edit: typo
- pimmen 8y agoYes, that’s probably the reason because mistakes in health care is an absolutely massive killer. In the US alone it’s responsible for about as many deaths as if two jumbo jets collidee with each other every day. The number of people dying from the simple fact that health care practitioners are humans and humans get tired, drunk, angry, careless or just plain stupid for random reasons is mind boggling. If we saw a midair collision of jumbo jets every day however the public would never accept it. https://catalyst.nejm.org/medical-errors-preventable-deaths/ https://catalyst.nejm.org/medical-errors-preventable-deaths/
- Tomte 8y agoRead this: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2007/12/10/the-checklist https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2007/12/10/the-checklist Same author as the book, but earlier. Contains all the meat, but none of the repetitions and the tenuous analogies. Gawande had enough for a long-form article, but not for a book, and IMO it shows. The book isn't bad. It's just that the essay is better.
- gowld 8y agoThere seems to be minimum book size that forces inflation in a whole genre of self-help books that genuinely have good advice. I've read books where all of the advice I need is in the end-of-chapter checklists. On one hand, it's good to err on the side of too-long a book, as it's easier to skip fluff than to seek out more details, illustrations, and alternative phrasings that aren't in the book. On the other hand, it's annoying to have the extra weight in volume in one's book collection.
- wizzard 8y agoI was lamenting this exact thing to a friend the other day. Books are just too long for most self-help advice and it ends up being 80% filler. The worst is when the first three chapters are about how rich/smart/successful you'll become by reading this book! (Except for the first three chapters, of course, because those are just advertisements for the book you already acquired.)
- pcollinsmokonut 8y agoTo solve this I subscribe to blinkist where they have summarized every self help book into a 15 minute read. It costs money but the summarization of content is worth it. I've read hundreds of self help essays (books) with blinkist.
- Celexior 8y agoDoes not the book also give more insight about how applying the principles to someone everyday life ?
- 8y ago