13 ms·
Panic’s Next Editor
- codequeen 8y agoI'm really curious to see how they will compete with VSCode. I hope they'll let us make plugins for it.
- apsdsm 8y agoI believe it was possible for Coda, so optimistically I would hope so.
- chipotle_coyote 8y agoCoda does support plugins. (So I hope Thing After Code does, too!)
- matchbok 8y agoYes please! Let's drop this electron crap once and for all.
- morganvachon 8y agoI'm not a developer but I use an advanced text editor (Notepad++ on Windows, Geany on everything else) for the little bit of webdev I have to do at work and on side jobs. I've tried every Electron based editor out there, for all the major platforms, and they are always so damn slow and unresponsive compared to a native app.
- ScottFree 8y agoSame here. And yet, nobody I've worked with over the past 2 years feels Electron based editors are slow or unresponsive. I'm not just talking about kids who have never used anything else, either. Some of these people have been programming since the 80s. It's like some people are sensitive to latency and some aren't. I've also been told it's impossible to tell the difference between 60hz and 144hz. I can tell. I know this for a fact because my hackintosh will occasionally "forget" and switch my monitor back to 60hz when I wake it up from sleep. I notice immediately.
- morganvachon 8y agoI'll admit I feel the difference more on my work machine (i5-2400, Windows 7) than my home workstations (i5-6500, Antergos Linux and Slackware Linux). It's definitely there though. Slack is another offender; we use it at work and our few remaining Core 2 machines and AMD A10 machines are brought to their knees with the Slack Electron app. Those users tend to launch it in a Chrome or Firefox window and leave that running. I can also pick up on different refresh rates, and I was extremely sensitive to it on CRTs back in the 90s and early 2000s. I had to run at least 75Hz on a CRT or I'd have too much "shimmy" in the image and would get a headache in a few minutes of work. 60Hz on an LCD doesn't typically bother me unless its grey-to-grey response time is poor, and produces ghosting. Even with that I don't seem to get headaches from LCDs.
- taneq 8y agoI felt like this about microstuttering 10 years ago. My computer was running at 100fps and yet it looked jerky and nobody else seemed to notice, and it was driving me mad. Thank goodness VR came along with its extreme latency-sensitivity and suddenly everyone else cared about maximum frame time too.
- duhi88 8y agoI really wanted to like Atom. I've always felt that with the right attention, web apps can accomplish most things that native apps can. Atom seemed promising and fast enough (I couldn't perceive any slowness), but once I started adding plugins to match the features I liked out of Sublime, I found Atom got really sluggish. I haven't tried any other electron-based editors, but I doubt it has the plugin ecosystem to compete with Sublime to VS, or any other big players. I didn't realize how important having a responsive text-editor is, though. We expect a lot to happen with each keystroke, and we expect it all to happen before we press the next key. This is why I don't think that text editors are best done in JS. That said, if this new text editor doesn't have features that compare with Sublime, then it isn't much better than Atom is to me.
- tingletech 8y agoI learned vi mostly over a 1200 baud modem connection through a crappy ISP. Would get several keystrokes ahead and then have to wait... Got sort of good at editing blind.
- azhenley 8y agoI've never experienced a slow down in VS Code, even with a 5 year old laptop. Atom is another story.
- draw_down 8y agoSublime has been here the whole time :) But, Panic are my friends, and I'm excited to try what they make.
- anderber 8y agoI mean, there's plenty of good non-electron editors out there. Sublime is still the best AFAIC, and actively developed.
- sxates 8y agoFigma has killed the whole 'native mac' benefit in my head. It runs faster than native competitor Sketch, and it does it on any platform, in a browser. Would be amazing to have that kind of portability in a dev environment. But I'm interested to see what they've come up with!
- anderber 8y ago100% agree, I would to see a Figma for code.
- reustle 8y agoPeople already have VS Code running in the browser, so I don't think it's a stretch to see official support (or a fork) for highly responsive editing in the browser.
- anderber 8y agoI meant using Web Assembly, not just web technologies: https://www.figma.com/blog/webassembly-cut-figmas-load-time-by-3x/ https://www.figma.com/blog/webassembly-cut-figmas-load-time-...
- jinglebells 8y agoLike Code Server? https://github.com/codercom/code-server https://github.com/codercom/code-server or https://play.nativescript.org/ https://play.nativescript.org/ sort of thing?
- anderber 8y agoI was meaning more like a native-speed like browser app, specifically using Web Assembly: https://www.figma.com/blog/webassembly-cut-figmas-load-time-by-3x/ https://www.figma.com/blog/webassembly-cut-figmas-load-time-...
- Klonoar 8y agoThe thing about "native Mac" is that the Cocoaheads rarely, if ever, are willing to admit that the platform has an insane number of issues, and making certain things performant can sometimes feel like pure wizardry. The Web has too much engineering power behind the stack to really compete against now.
- simonhamp 8y agoCoda was one of my favourite apps when I first got a Mac. It was such a fresh experience when compared to the dry utilitarian stuff that was available on Windows at the time. I believe that Panic will create a beautiful product and they have many supporters who will happily pay a license fee - I know I will! But it’s not going to be an easy ride. There’s a lot to live up to here and they will need to have some killer features thrown in at the beginning. The hardest part tho will be to make it an approachable tool that can hook the hobbyist but keep them on when they need more. I dropped Coda for a number of reasons, but it wasn’t because it wasn’t a great code editor.
- PunksATawnyFill 8y agoWhat “visual CSS editor” are they talking about? I have Coda 2, and remember wishing it had a visual CSS editor like Espresso’s. Coda also suffered from persistent and potentially damaging bugs, like the failure of its project-files pane to open the “home” directory specified for your project when you opened the project. Instead, it apparently just showed whatever directory it last navigated to.
- Cenk 8y agoCoda 1 had a pretty sweet visual CSS editor, it was dropped in Coda 2.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deca6cda37d0 8y agoI will buy it on day one.
- MoarPanicCrap 8y agoI will waste my money day one. Panic writes pretty garbage.
- azhenley 8y agoIt looks promising. But I'm not sure what features it could add over VS Code for me. I also worry that it won't have the hackability of Electron-based editors. (Before anyone complains about Electron performance, I haven't had any issues in that regard.) I do academic research on code editors.
- JohnBooty 8y agoYeah. I really love Panic, but given the zillions of developer-hours poured into competing text editors, it's super hard to imagine a small team (even a talented one) competing. There is room for innovation in the rest of the web dev workflow, which has gotten a bit weird since almost everything involves a compilation step now. Not sure how this could be achieved, but I guess that's why I'm not the one doing it!
- tambourine_man 8y agoTwo very influential editors come to mind, both developed by a single person AFAIK: TextMate and Sublime Text. It may be hard to sustain it in the long run, but they both changed the landscape at the time.
- tomjakubowski 8y agoSublime Text and TextMate were different developers. Sublime appeared during the extremely long (years and years) development period of TextMate 2.
- tambourine_man 8y agoSure, I meant they were both developed by a one person only shop. Not that they were both developed by the same person. Also, Sublime was Windows only at first IIRC, so I don’t think it was an answer to TextMate.
- johncoltrane 8y ago
- hartator 8y agoDefinitely looking forward to the release. Love Sublime and VSCode. But both still miss something.
- azimuth11 8y agoCare to elaborate?
- chaostheory 8y agoThe real competition may be WebStorm.
- bendotero 8y agoI use PHPStorm more than WebStorm but I know they share a lot of similarities. I love it. Everything from the Git integration to code quality tools, code completion, built in terminal, etc. It's a phenomenal IDE. This new app would have to be really compelling, particularly its build tools support (npm, webpack, sass/minifiers, etc).
- keithnz 8y agoyeah, I tend to opt for a jetbrains editor, if that's not available then I'll use something like vscode. I also like that both are cross platform as I use both Mac and Windows
- ajmurmann 8y agoI'm very partial to JetBrains IDEs. To me it's either a great IDE like the JetBrains products or a great text editor like emacs or vim. I never really understood the folks moving from TextMate to Sublime, to Atom and as of late VSCode. Is it really the low barrier of entry that comes with free and low learning curve? We spend so much time as professional developers with these tools that dropping a few bucks on a IDE or spending some time developing good vim or emacs skills seems like a obvious investment. These lighter editors seem like a low investment, low return choice.
- mercer 8y agoI don't think low learning curve has much to do with it (for most of us). I also don't think these light editors are 'low investment, low return' choices. It's all part of a continuum. With Emacs often more on the side of IDEs, and Sublime more on the side of text editors. For me and many others, text editors have been preferable over IDEs for all sorts of reasons, but we do like a lot of the features that IDEs offer. To some extent that's been solvable through plugins, but for many VSCode in particular hits the sweet spot of being a text editor that has a bunch of IDE-like features as first-class citizens on top of the many extensions available. The success of VSCode really highlights why these 'light editors' are so popular, I think. Unlike IDEs, it doesn't offer you every possible feature under the sun in a confusing, often slow package and interface. But unlike Vim/Sublime/Emacs, it does offer sensible defaults, and well-integrated 'core' plugins that most developers will want anyways. And through various plugins we get vim keybindings and many of the other features of IDEs too. It's a bit like the framework/library discussion. The best approach is usually "it depends", but in my experience, for my editor needs, a minimal framework is the sweet spot. I don't want Rails, but I also don't want Express.js. (I really want Phoenix, actually, but that's not relevant)
- revskill 8y agoOne question: Is there any way to drop a file in the project, when clicking it, the editor will open new tab, which is the terminal ? I'm using VScode, i don't know if there's an extension for that yet.
- shawxe 8y agoAm I the only one who is made extremely uncomfortable by the bizarre diagonal margins on the linked page?
- ztratar 8y agoI don't get anxiety, but these margins gave me anxiety.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoI get anxiety, and these margins made me more anxious.
- femto113 8y agoNo.
- vollmond 8y agoI only clicked on TFA due to your comment and now I'm quite unhappy.
- fouc 8y agoIf you reduce the font size a bit, it becomes more tolerable.
- Q6T46nT668w6i3m 8y agoIt's crazy. I read the post because I love Panic, but It made me nauseous!
- atrilumen 8y agoHaha, it's a little skewed. section { transform: skew(-2deg); }
- justinator 8y agoIf you love this, you'll love the comments in https://www.reddit.com/r/mildlyinfuriating/ https://www.reddit.com/r/mildlyinfuriating/
- shereadsthenews 8y agoNot sure how they can claim with seriousness to have written the first editor for web development.
- alekratz 8y agoI thought this too. What about dreamweaver?
- eridius 8y agoDid Dreamweaver support all stages of web development, including uploading to your server? I think that's what Panic is talking about here, how Coda was your one-stop shop for everything, including deploying your site.
- eridius 8y agoI find it really interesting that I've been downvoted into oblivion for asking a question.
- chrismonsanto 8y agoWhen I last used it (early 2000s) it had built-in FTP support
- muglug 8y agoDreamweaver definitely had upload-on-save (not sure if that functionality predated Coda, but it was there the last time I used it in 2008 or so)
- JasonFruit 8y agoWhoa! Look at that goalpost go!
- eridius 8y agoWhat are you talking about? The page was very explicit about what it meant: > It put the tools you needed to make a web page together in one app, and nobody had ever done that before. All I did was ask if Dreamweaver supported one particular aspect of this, given that I'm not familiar with Dreamweaver's features beyond "WYSIWYG editing".
- thomasfedb 8y agoLove the syntax highlighting theme in the screenshot. Anybody know what it is called?
- mosdl 8y agolooks like material ui colos
- andr 8y agoInteresting that they chose to compete on Mac, instead of iPad, as they could have easily commanded the majority of the iOS market share. Coda had some of the best support for editing directly on remote servers, and this would fit the iPad usage model quite well.
- reaperducer 8y agoThere’s already a Coda for iPad and iPhone.
- Pulcinella 8y agoiOS Coda is honestly, embarrassingly bad. It takes like 6 or 7 taps to start actually editing a document and it still doesn’t sync files between devices. An app that is proud of how “native” it is doesn’t support iCloud (or Dropbox, or any other syncing) in the year 2019.
- reaperducer 8y agoI've used it for emergencies a few times, and you're right that it's a bit cumbersome to get going. But I've never had a problem with syncing between iPhone, iPad, iMac, and MacBook Air. I'd also like it to use iCloud for sync. Panic explained a little bit about why it uses its own platform in a blog post I found recently, but it was kind of vague.
- azimuth11 8y agoCompeting solely on Mac seems strange. I’ve used vscode on multiple operating systems for a bunch of languages/deployments/use cases, and the speed and availability of plugins is great. There is room for niche stuff, but this blog post is too vague to determine what niche they are now trying to fill. As a previous coda user and someone whose spent a considerable amount of time with many IDEs/text editors, it looks like they forked vscode and are trying to see if people want them to develop a new app. If they are actually using something internally that was good, then, as a development software selling company, they would be promoting the product’s actual benefits instead of writing this fluff about considering/reluctantly releasing their ‘awesome internal tool’. How many companies make their own internal editors anyway?
- nvr219 8y agotransmit gang
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- BenoitEssiambre 8y agoScrolling down that page seriously made me feel dizzy and nauseated.
- TecoAndJix 8y agoI loved it!
- Octoth0rpe 8y agoIt's hard to take them seriously when they make claims like this: > Twelve years ago we introduced Coda, the world’s first web development editor. It's hard to come up a charitable definition of 'web development editor' (inbuilt css editor? browser preview?) that wouldn't likely cover Dreamweaver.
- dangerface 8y agoIIRC The first web browser (Mosaic) was able to edit websites.
- mmanfrin 8y agoI really liked Panic's products, but I really did not like their approach to dealing with a person they didn't like playing their video game (they used the copyright system to take down videos of a streamer playing their game, which is in my eyes a deep abuse of the copyright system). I don't care for the person they targeted, but I care for the casual abuse of a system that is already hurting content creators.
- yoz-y 8y agoI wonder if in that particular case the demand came from Panic of from the game studio (Campo Santo) they were collaborating with. It's even worse since they explicitly allowed anybody to stream and upload videos using the game and then renegged on the agreement.
- geowwy 8y agoIt was Campo Santo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sean_Vanaman#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sean_Vanaman#Criticism https://twitter.com/vanaman/status/906983575337107456 https://twitter.com/vanaman/status/906983575337107456
- deanCommie 8y ago> a deep abuse of the copyright system Actually... https://twitter.com/vanaman/status/906984704892477440 https://twitter.com/vanaman/status/906984704892477440
- rayiner 8y ago> That’s a fair question. Many of our competitors are free, and we really rely on, well, revenue. After a decade on Mac, I finally bought a Windows laptop. The think I miss most is the quality software. Apple users are willing to pay for software, so you have great apps like Scrivener, OmniFocus, Coda, etc. But the culture of “free” has overrun Windows, and for the most part, it’s a disaster. There is no revenue potential in many areas of software, especially B2C software, and it shows in a lack of quality.
- duxup 8y agoWhat is frustrating is the chicken and egg problem on Windows too.... I'll pay, but hard to find software / not many good recommendations for software. I'm speaking more generally rather than any given product.
- xpaulbettsx 8y agoAs someone who wrote Indie Windows software, it's not only the problem of supply vs. demand (I'd actually argue that there are a fair amount of people who are happy to pay Coda-levels of money for software), the biggest problem is marketing. If you're an Indie macOS or iOS dev, you've got so many places to drum up news about your app. If you're on Windows? There's Windows Central, and a few smaller blogs (and Reddit, but rules against self-promotion in most subs mean you're very likely to get your post whacked). Promotion is a huge challenge for Windows desktop devs
- duxup 8y agoYeah that seems like a legit issue. Like where can I as a user find quality news about it, and if you're the dev... no way for you to reach me either.
- themodelplumber 8y agoI too feel similarly. I was disappointed to have to leave Coda behind when I started using Linux more often than Mac OS. On Linux you are rewarded for using the tools that other Linux users celebrate. Life just becomes easier that way. So some of the bells and whistles of Coda and other commercial packages like some of the mind mapping apps are missed, but somehow life goes on. I am much happier now in my desktop environment overall, though.
- wishinghand 8y agoUntil an editor starts integrating some of the features of aneditor that Gary Bernhardt talks about here[0] I won't believe any talk of a "new" or "next step" editor. 0: https://www.destroyallsoftware.com/talks/a-whole-new-world https://www.destroyallsoftware.com/talks/a-whole-new-world
- bch 8y agoNice, but I think I can raise you. That talk mostly seemed pretty predictable (though I incorrectly guessed gfx via sixels[0], not a(nother) terminal emulator). If your interest was piqued with that parent video though, prepare to have your mind blown with this[1], who’s thesis maybe similar in the sense of “stop _just_ simply working”. Bernhardt seems to be saying don’t be afraid to take time and think deeply and “go deep”, while Victor is explicitly saying make it count by way of targeting with intention what’s important to you. A sort of “fight the good fight.” [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sixel https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sixel [1] https://youtu.be/PUv66718DII?t=625 https://youtu.be/PUv66718DII?t=625
- nodesocket 8y agoCoda was my primary editor up until around 2011 when I switched to Sublime Text. The built in FTP/SFTP transfers was a really big time saver and key feature. Things have changed quite a bit since then in the editor landscape, curious to see what comes. I primary do DevOps today, and I think if their new editor implemented some DevOpsy features could be huge selling point. Remote SSH and running commands, terminal integration, git integration.
- mattlondon 8y agoSsh, terminal, git integration etc sounds precisely like what vscode offers to me. Good luck to them, but I don't think vscode is doing well because it is free. It is genuinely a very good editor.
- millstone 8y agoVSCode is a good editor, but it's very much in the JS-camp of stuff sort of works once you've fought through configuration and dug through SO. Also it's manifestly un-Mac-like in noticeable ways. For example it's hard to know if I've saved a file, because Command-S doesn't highlight the menubar, no matter how many times I press it. Basic Mac features, MIA. I'm ready for something that just works, so you'll find me camping outside Panic's digital store.
- MoarPanicCrap 8y agoOh good, more garbage from Panic that they're happy to charge you for, support not-at-all, and then move onto the next project. What a waste of talent.
- danso 8y agoI applaud a new commercial application bringing competition to the editor field. But does anyone else think that building exclusively for Mac is a risky strategy? I’m a diehard Apple user and hope I never have to compute in an era when Apple still isn’t producing Macs. But even I see the writing on the wall that Windows is becoming more and more developer-friendly, with VS Code and cross-platform Sublime vastly reducing the friction in moving from MacOS to Windows. Even if the new Coda was heads above the pack, I would be very reluctant to put money and learning/muscle-memory time into a new app that could easily go the way of Textmate after a couple of years.
- whalesalad 8y agoWalk into any coffee shop in America and you'll see every hacker inside using a Mac. One or two odd ducks will have some kind of nix ultrabook setup. Even here in SoCal you can go into a Philz and see 5 people coding on a Mac w/ VS Code and Slack open at some time or another. So I don't think targeting macOS is by any means a bad idea. Based on the echo chamber that is HN you'd think everyone was jumping ship to Surface tablets and WSL but it's really not as common as you think.
- danso 8y agoAs someone who’s worked on both coasts I can definitely attest to seeing Macs dominate. When I taught at a university I always fretted about making a Windows version of my keyboard-shortcuts/install process guides until the first day and invariably just 1 out of 20 students would be on a non-Mac. But that’s not the way it is everywhere (was just at a Chicago hack night). And Windows is not only still the dominant base, but Microsoft’s direction is more trending toward in favor of everyday developers than Apple’s. It’s not just a matter of market viability, but having enough of a user base to create and perpetuate a good ecosystem (e.g. plugin development) around the app.
- nfoz 8y ago> Walk into any coffee shop in America I consider Dunkin Donuts a coffee shop, which drastically changes this picture.
- smoyer 8y ago"First web development editor" - not by a long shot!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bdefore 8y agoI'll tip my hat to Panic for the humility and respect towards existing Coda users by going with a new name. I'm not sure how many those amount to today, but it's a kind gesture.
- _bxg1 8y agoThe hardest part will be keeping up with the rapid clip of today's web without the backing of an open source community writing extensions in JS itself. Supporting the babels, TypeScripts, and Flows of the world as they pop up with only an in-house team will be difficult.
- kumaraman 8y agoThey mention they're not trying to be the biggest code editor, and I think they have a fighting chance against Webstorm. Also they can create a plugin system similar to Sketchapp that exposes a JavaScript API.
- dmitriid 8y agoHow can you have a chance against WebStorm by not being the biggest editor? WebStorm is IntelliJ Idea. It’s a full IDE with capabilities beyond that of a simple code editor: code analysis (for multiple languages), smart refactoring (for multiple languages), extensive plugin support, an extensive range of support for anything from eslint configs to understanding things like “oh, it’s an Angular app, let me help you connect all the pieces together”, etc. etc.
- huxflux 8y ago"just for the Mac" bye.
- aficiomaquinas 8y agoI actually loved Coda back in the day. One of my coworkers still uses it a lot, but his entire workfow depends on editing code on smallish production sites via (S)FTP. I find that approach fatally flawed for modern front-end and/or not-so-small projects. I really wouldn't go back from my Webpack + Production CI/CD to editing live websites. Many of the performance improvements needed to achieve very fast websites these days depend on tasks that belong more to the CI/CD than to your local development environment. For instance the generation of critical CSS and webpack's production build, which is slower if it includes the JS and CSS optimizations. Finally, a deterministic (or as much as possible) process to upload the changes to production. I find Sublime Text better as an editor for that kind of front-end workflow and there's quite some good extensions I've favored throughout the years that don't exist in Coda. I'm curious and optimistic about this new Panic editor, let's see how it goes!
- besulzbach 8y agoEven if I don't plan on using this anytime soon, competition is always welcome.
- genmon 8y agoReading between the lines, looks like they were paid for the name? > And then, incredibly, a new Coda arrived on the scene — a reimagined document at coda.io — and we reached an agreement to let them have the name. And the email newsletter has a strong "last chance to buy" call to action so maybe there's a time limit on how much they can market around it? Not saying this like it's a bad thing: a new name makes good strategic sense. If it also makes commercial sense because, so much the better. Here's the new Coda name-holders: https://coda.io/ https://coda.io/
- doh 8y agoI've never heard of them before (coda.io). Seems like they raised a lot of money [0] and are generally competing in the space of airtable [1]. More surprising, coda.io is still free and has no pricing [2]. I get that they are in land grab, but I would be afraid to put my work on a platform that can come out anytime and charge essentially any sum of money. [0] https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/coda-add7 https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/coda-add7 [1] https://airtable.com https://airtable.com [2] https://help.coda.io/faq/pricing-for-coda https://help.coda.io/faq/pricing-for-coda
- mercer 8y agoNot to mention that the lock-in is much bigger with Coda.io than it is with Airtable.
- tobr 8y agoHappy to hear from Panic about this. I used to use Coda all the time and loved it. I can’t be sure that I will switch to using whatever this new thing is, but I’m confident that it will be lovely, as nearly everything Panic makes. Somehow the letter feels very defensive, like someone accused them of being hopelessly behind and having no chance to ever be relevant again.
- rado 8y agoUsing Coda since 1.0 all day every day. 'Next' also looks great.
- bluegreyred 8y agoI enjoyed Panic's polished applications since way back when but the way they simply drop paid for apps with an existing userbase due to "lack of revenue" (Status Board [1], Transmit on iOS [2], Unison [3] and Audion [4]) really left a sour taste in my mouth. Transmit for iOS was a particularly big loss for me, so much so that I personally am going out of my way to avoid their products. [1] https://panic.com/blog/the-future-of-status-board/ https://panic.com/blog/the-future-of-status-board/ [2] https://panic.com/blog/the-future-of-transmit-ios/ https://panic.com/blog/the-future-of-transmit-ios/ [3] https://panic.com/blog/the-future-of-unison/ https://panic.com/blog/the-future-of-unison/ [4] https://www.panic.com/extras/audionstory/ https://www.panic.com/extras/audionstory/
- eps 8y agoThey also pulled original Prompt from the AppStore because, apparently, it completely impossible to rebuild it for the x64 target. "Luckily" it was replaced by Prompt 2 that was basically the same thing slightly improved (but "rebuild from the ground up" for reasons unknown) that you had to buy afresh. That was not nice.
- AJRF 8y agoDoubling down on a mac only editor seems super weird. At a time when Apples actions seem like they are de-prioritizing the line, Panic are going all in? It would seem a better investment to make the go to IDE-y thing on iPad Pro.
- zapzupnz 8y agoOne of the secret reveals they do later could be it's made in Marzipan, so easily ported to iOS.
- F30 8y agoPanic's experiences on iOS have been somewhat unsatisfying: https://panic.com/blog/the-future-of-transmit-ios/ https://panic.com/blog/the-future-of-transmit-ios/ It seems that (at least up to January 2018) the market for (relatively expensive) pro apps on iPad is just too small.
- coldtea 8y agoDepends on the pro apps. In the age of iCloud, Dropbox, and 200 other services and alternative ways to move stuff, why would one want to use a FTP client (like the Transmit above) on the iPad? The market for FTP clients is small enough on the desktop... (Heck, I'm a developer, I have a Transmit license since 2006 or so, I work with dozens of remote machines, and seldom ever use it. It's either sftp on the command line, or something like an Ansible wrapper etc).
- milgrim 8y agoTransmit on iOS is not only a FTP client and I never used it for that. The integration into the iOS share sheet with SSH file transfer support is perfect for me and I use this all the time. Are there any reliable alternatives that are still actively developed?
- coldtea 8y agoYeah, I know, I have a license for it on OS X. It also does SCP/SFTP/S3 and others. But in the end it's still a pretty limited offering, for special cases (geeks wanting to use the iPad for administration or development, for example). Not the kind of mass market app the general iPad users would buy en masse.
- z3phyr 8y agoIf my memory is correct, wasn't Microsoft Frontpage old when something like Coda appeared? Given I do not know what Coda is as compared to another all in one app for web development..
- allan_ 8y agoSooo, native apps are `hyper responsive` these days, made me LOL.
- rvanmil 8y agoVery excited about this. Let's see if they can beat Sublime :)
- throwaway400 8y agoHopefully they will support the LSP.
- dagw 8y agoI'm sure their products are great, but what kind of hubris and/or complete lack of historical perspective do you have to have to write this with a straight face: "Twelve years ago we introduced Coda, the world’s first web development editor. It put the tools you needed to make a web page together in one app, and nobody had ever done that before."
- benfrain 8y agoVS Code has some good features and rapid iteration but it is slow. Slow to start, slow to render pages when you switch tabs. Sublime Text may not have BBedits ability with massive files but for 99% of the time it is lightning quick and rock solid. As such, I think a natively coded Mac editor could nail the requisite speed but also enjoy some novel features beyond the spartan default environment of Sublime. I’m looking forward to it.
- ivyirwin 8y agoI'm super excited by this announcement. Yes, I'm a Panic fanboy and have been since I first used Transmit over 15 years ago. I've long since moved away from Panic software – as the development process changed I didn't feel like their solutions were as relevant anymore. But that's what excites me about their announcement – they're admitting things have changed so much that an incremental release won't cut it, they have to go back to the drawing board. And when they do that, great things happen. There's a lot of skepticism in the comments about the size of the undertaking and their ability to produce something significantly different in a crowded market. Isn't that what we all do to some degree? And I would argue they have a proven track record of doing that repeatedly (with some flops mixed in as well). Transmit didn't invent FTP interfaces, but the ease of use and speed were head and shoulders above the existing clients. They're getting some flack for their claims about Coda, but it really was a giant step forward over existing editors at the time. One of the reasons I've always liked Panic is that they dog food their products and it shows. They have always been at the edge of web design and development (including the controversial margin on this page) and that comes from building and using an advanced toolset. Can't wait to see what comes next.
- erickj 8y agoI've never heard of Panic. I've never heard of Coda. I don't develop on a Mac and I'll likely never be in their target audience. But reading this product announcement gave me a real feeling for the genuine care and quality that these people put into their work that I'm curious enough to figure out a way to try their product. As banal as another editor might seem to some, the care of craftsmanship that this post exudes is refreshing.
- azimuth11 8y agoThe post feels good because it is mostly just smoke and mirrors. They’re talking about a lot of problems and offering no products or solutions.