35 ms·
EU gives 'high-level' protection to whistleblowers
- sschueller 8y agoWhat about protection from extradition to the United States for bogus charges? Whsitleblowers need protection from cooperations and nation states.
- vkou 8y agoAssange isn't accused of being a whistleblower, he's being accused of actively aiding Manning in breaking into a computer. It's the difference between a journalist interviewing a burglar, and a journalist offering to hold the prybar, while the burglar is at work. His supporters are currently going through the most amazing calisthenics to justify that behaviour.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- GordonS 8y agoYes, but he did so to reveal war crimes that the US had buried - doesn't this still count as whistle-blowing?
- scottie_m 8y agoHe’s not being charged for what he published, he’s being charged with conspiracy to “hack” as it were. If you’re asking whether something stops being a crime because you did it for virtuous reasons, obviously the answer is no from a legal perspective.
- GordonS 8y agoThat is what I'm asking - Assange aside, surely this can apply to any number of whistle-blowing scenarios, and whistle-blowing laws should provide protections from law under certain circumstances? Don't the ends justify the means, especially if far greater crimes are revealed as a result?
- akerro 8y agoOnly will give extra protection if US agrees to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evo_Morales_grounding_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evo_Morales_grounding_incident
- walterstucco 8y agoYou can ask Ecuador or Russia to help, like Assange and Snowden did. I'm sure your freedom will be top priority there
- ben_w 8y agoThe trouble with trumped-up charges, is that often outsiders don’t have the capacity to determine that they’re bogus. I mean, the point of extradition is a trial, and the point of a trial is to determine guilt. Of course, as you seem to he referring to Assange, just remember the UK is (it claims) leaving the EU, and is currently run by people who don’t really know what they want but are fairly sure that whatever it is involves getting on well with the USA.
- mrec 8y ago> and is currently run by people who don’t really know what they want but are fairly sure that whatever it is involves getting on well with the USA Bit offtopic for this thread, but I'd call that a very peculiar read of the situation. The Withdrawal Agreement that May is pushing involves a permanent de facto customs union with the EU, ongoing regulatory alignment with the EU, and military integration with the EU. That doesn't leave a whole lot of room for the US.
- ChrisSD 8y agoVery off topic, but the backstop is only meant to take effect if no other agreement can be made by the end of the transition period. If it does take effect, it's meant to be temporary until such time as a more permanent deal is agreed (although it's true it could last indefinitely if no such agreement is ever made).
- mrec 8y agoYes, but the EU has both the ability and every economic incentive to refuse any permanent agreement that doesn't give them at least the same level of UK lock-in. The "temporary" is a figleaf to try to sell the WA to domestic voters and MPs; I don't think anyone takes it seriously.
- pergadad 8y agoYou're reading too much bad/biased reporting. Anyone who ever worked in international relations or trade knows that the worst case is uncertainty. It's neither in the UK's not in the EU's interest. It's quite weird to see how much the news and information cycle in the UK is based on rumours and quotes of random MPs. Like, seriously, try to think for a second from the EU's perspective and it's just plain obvious how it's not in the EU's interest to keep the UK in an arrangement that it's uncomfortable with and that has no clear legal standing. Everything gets more costly and complex - think just of external trade negotiations, import taxes, quality standards and norms, etc which all fall into a place of uncertain "could change at any minute" state in such a situation. The EU is not some weird evil creature.thstsboutnto get you. The EU is the set of countries that for decades have been your closest allies. No one is trying to rip you off. Except, it seems, for the Tories that prefer to divide the UK and insult all their allies over internal power struggles, rather than actually try and act in the country's interest.
- thefounder 8y agoAs far as I know if the action is not a crime in the home country there is no extradition process.
- mpweiher 8y agoGermany does not extradite its citizens to the US. It used to not extradite its citizens at all, but that was loosened so extradition to EU countries and international courts is possible. Furthermore there are limitations, I think these apply fairly generally: - the alleged crime must be a crime in both jurisdictions - no death penalty - no torture - a fair trial must be ensured - unusually harsh punishments would also be a blocker
- gsnedders 8y agoAll but the first would be held by the ECtHR to be in violation of accused's human rights, therefore no signatory of the ECHR can extradite in any such case.
- ChrisSD 8y agoIf the charges are deemed to be bogus then the extradition request won't be granted.
- rjf72 8y agoThis is an idealistic world view. In reality many high profile cases are determined primarily by the political clout of the entities involved. When it comes to nations such as the US we are going to get what we want on issues that are deemed significant. The recent Huawei case had a particularly interesting illustration of this. Under US instruction Canada arrested Meng Wanzhou, the daughter of the founder of Huawei and a high ranking executive of the company herself. Following this event John McCallum, Canada's ambassador to China, stated that Meng Wanzhou had a strong argument against extradition for reasons including political interference from Donald Trump, the extraterritorial nature of the charges and the fact that Canada is not party to American sanctions against Iran. For context one one of those points, Trump himself has publicly stated he'd be happy to "intervene" in the case in exchange for a favorable trade deal from China. Following internal pressure John McCallum released a message stating, "I regret that my comments with respect to the legal proceedings of Ms Meng have created confusion. I misspoke. These comments do not accurately represent my position on the issue. As the government has consistently made clear, there has been no political involvement in this process.". He was then fired by Canada's prime minister Justin Trudeau. This does not speak to whether the charges are legitimate or not, but rather that people involved in cases like this are often in positions of immense pressure that undermines the entire system. McCallum had a 20 year political career. It's likely that his firing has now come with an implicit political black listing as well, ending that career. Such can be the cost of honesty in such cases. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/26/john-mccallum-canadian-ambassador-to-china-fired-huawei https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/26/john-mccallum-... https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/25/i-misspoke-canada-ambassador-to-china-regrets-saying-huawei-chief-had-strong-case https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/25/i-misspoke-can...
- Hamuko 8y ago>What about protection from extradition to the United States for bogus charges? Don't worry, the US now just has to wait until Halloween.
- nocturnial 8y agotldr: No idea From [1, page 6, 25]: "Effective enforcement of Union law requires that protection is granted to the broadest possible range of categories of persons, who, irrespective of whether they are EU citizens or third-country nationals, by virtue of work-related activities (irrespective of the nature of these activities,whether they are paid or not), have privileged access to information about breaches that would be in the public’s interest to report and who may suffer retaliation if they report them." So there's some form of protection for non-eu citizens, but I have no idea how far it goes or how the rules will be interpreted in those cases. [1] www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/docs_autres_institutions/commission_europeenne/com/2018/0218/COM_COM(2018)0218_EN.pdf
- Proven 8y agoBureaucratic gimmicks. Whistleblowers, just like everyone else, already have full natural rights. There's nothing they need from Brussels except to stop violating their rights (try to whistleblow on the EU and see where that gets you)
- toyg 8y agoI thought this was good news and worth of attention. My mind went immediately to Ed Snowden. It would be nice if an European country decided to use this directive as political cover to grant him asylum.
- angott 8y agoThere was a lot of discussion on this matter in Germany and other European countries, back when he left Hong Kong and got stuck at the airport in Moscow. But nothing came out of it really. Despite many EU countries having laws that would have allowed granting him asylum, there was too much pressure due to the fear of U.S. retaliation if any country decided to go ahead with that move.
- TomMarius 8y agoNATO was a common argument (most EU countries are not spending the required 2% of GDP on army)
- MichaelApproved 8y ago> most EU countries are not spending the required 2% of GDP on army Because the 2% requirement doesn't kick in for another 5 years.
- TomMarius 8y agoHmm, is that true for any EU nation? I'm almost sure it's not true for the Czech Republic. At least our politicians are using it as an argument nearly every day and no one had yet made that point.
- MichaelApproved 8y agoPossibly but you made the initial affirmative statement of 2% of GDP. You should be able to source that and get the answer to your question about Czech.
- growlist 8y agoInteresting - will the EU apply this to themselves? 'Mr Watt claimed that corruption was "permitted to flourish to the benefit of all the institutions' elites" and said that despite his action and that of other "whistle-blowers", the EU accountancy system was now "so degraded it cannot police itself".' 'According to Quatremer, severe pressure and even harassment is an ongoing problem in the European Commission, and several officials in the Commission’s legal service are reported to have committed suicide in the last years.' http://www.againstcorruption.org/BriefingsItem.asp/?id=12647 http://www.againstcorruption.org/BriefingsItem.asp/?id=12647 http://www.brusselstimes.com/eu-affairs/14535/senior-official-at-the-european-commission-commits-suicide-following-hiring-scandal http://www.brusselstimes.com/eu-affairs/14535/senior-officia...
- ben_w 8y agoIf I were a head of state, I would want all the organisations which constitute a non-trivial part of my budget [1] to have good accounting practices and, by extension, whistle-blowing protections. Is there any reason why someone who is more interested than me in becoming a head of state may think otherwise? [1] which I define politically as “could I get a headline out of lowering income tax, national insurance, or non-UK equivalent term, by cancelling this line item?”, and I think the EU counts as such for the UK. 1% GDP, IIRC.
- craftyguy 8y agoTo play devil's advocate: heads of state are usually ultimately in charge of these departments, and if some corruption were to be exposed by a whistleblower it might be bad for their re-election bid. They may see it as a potential way to self-incriminate, even if they personally had no involvement. To claim they had no idea is just as bad, it shows voters they are a weak leader who has no accountability in the departments they are ultimately responsible for.
- mcv 8y agoHeads of state are rarely in charge of anything. Heads of government are. Heads of state are quite often figureheads with mostly ceremonial functions. Particularly among western democracies, France and the US are the exception rather than the rule.
- nilskidoo 8y agoI could see this as a prompter to get folks to police themselves, like to rat each other out over the articles 11/13 crap, similar to how the Americans were offering terrorist bounties in Afghanistan, prompting folks to falsely accuse annoying neighbors and the like. But I really want to see it as a political fail-safe against multinational corporations.
- hartjer 8y agoIronic given the recent arrest of Julian Assange. Last time I checked, Brexit was in the future, not the past.
- nocturnial 8y agoThey even give an economic argument for this law. In a report to the EU commission they estimate this will result in potential benefits in the range of 5.8 to 9.6 billion euro.[1] This is only for public procurement. The two main conclusions of this study are "There is a strong economic case for whistleblower protection" and "Whistleblower protection must be effectively be implemented to reap the rewards" [1]https://publications.europa.eu/en/publication-detail/-/publication/8d5955bd-9378-11e7-b92d-01aa75ed71a1/language-en https://publications.europa.eu/en/publication-detail/-/publi...
- wallace_f 8y ago>if no appropriate action is taken or in cases where reporting to the authorities would not work, whistleblowers are permitted to make a public disclosure – including by speaking to the media. Shouldnt public disclosure be the first thing which is protected?
- maxheadroom 8y ago>Shouldnt public disclosure be the first thing which is protected? Largely, this depends on your perspective of whether or not the entity (or government body) should be allowed to make a good-faith effort to rememdy/rectify/fix the egregious behaviour before you go running to the media. It's the same principle behind CVD (Coordinated Vulnerability Disclosure).
- Teknoman117 8y agoThis article explicitly lists corporate whistleblowing, not government whistleblowing. I keep seeing comments drawing parallels to Snowden and Assange, but they were leaking government wrongdoing (should I say perceived?) publically, not corporate wrongdoing. Nothing in here suggests that if some EU nation was committing some crime that you could parade the facts around publicly with no ramifications. Even the US has a fair amount of protection for corporate whistleblowers, however they don’t take kindly to people revealing government secrets publicly. There are ways to whistleblow internally, assuming that said thing isn’t something the whole government is in on (such as the Snowden leaks).
- basetop 8y agoUntil these whistleblowers expose EU beauracrats. Everybody claims to love whistleblowers and truth until they are the target of the expose. Take Assange and Manning. He was loved and praised by the left when he exposed war crimes primarily of the bush era ( iraq, afghanistan ). The right hated him as a foreign spy and hacker. A few years later, Assange exposed the left and now the left hates him for being a foreign spy and hacker and the right ( at least some of them ) loves him. These "high-level" protections is meaningless if the whistleblowers target the truly powerful. Then all kinds of accusations and charges will be used to take down the whisteblower.
- rorykoehler 8y agoI would classify myself as fairly left and I am a big supporter of Assange. Scum hate him. Nothing to do with left or right.
- JetSpiegel 8y ago> A few years later, Assange exposed the left and now the left hates him for being a foreign spy and hacker Bernie and a bunch of Democrat front-runners criticized his arrest. Corbyn did too. Hillary Clinton hates him (for showing her dirty tricks on the DCCC), but not exactly "the left".
- denkmoon 8y agoStates do not protect their adversaries.
- maxheadroom 8y agoThe title of the article and the comments here show that most haven't read the actual text of the agreement[0]. This has nothing whatsoever to do with government whistleblowing but is about creating and safeguarding protections of whistleblowers under certain key aspects (e.g.: public health, corporate taxes, privacy/personal data, etc.). [0] - https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/A-8-2018-0398-AM-155-155_EN.pdf https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/A-8-2018-0398-...
- Animats 8y agoThere should be prizes and awards for whistleblowing.