19 ms·
Life of Brian at 40: an assertion of individual freedom that still resonates
- rick22 8y agoThe degree to which the nations majority religion can be criticized is a good indicator of the individual's freedom. UK and US has the most individual freedom then as may be india has a lesser degree and then the middle east has almost zero individual freedom.
- chriselles 8y agoI coincidentally watched it with my two sons(13 & 12) the other night. They loved it!(thankfully) Especially, the part where the crowd yells “We’re all individuals!”. And one lone voice peeps, “I’m not.” Often silly, frequently smart, and occasionally dark irreverence.
- gmueckl 8y agoThis is the one moment that contains the whole message of the film condensed into a brief gag that seems so silly on the surface, but goes surprisingly deep. This is easily my most favorite scene of that movie.
- dwd 8y agoThat was the one scene that stuck with me when I first saw it in the early 80s when it came out on video. It's still probably my favourite scene.
- KineticLensman 8y agoSomewhat superbly, the “I’m not” line wasn’t actually scripted. It was shouted out by a quick thinking crowd-scene extra. The pythons liked it so much it was kept in and he was mentioned in the credits. Source - memory from reading one of the pythons’ biographies a few years ago.
- sundvor 8y agoThanks for posting that quote, it's one of my all time favourites. "You might all be individuals but I'm not", to quip. It's funny and deep at the same time.
- basetop 8y agoIt's funny when you watch it as a youth. It's get even funnier and more poignant and insightful when you watch it as an adult. You catch so many historical, political, cultural, linguistic, etc references that you missed as a kid. If you teach your kids latin, they'll appreciate the movie that much more.
- wallace_f 8y agoGreat quotes from the article: >Kant put it in 1784, “‘Have the courage to use your own understanding!’ — that is the motto of enlightenment.” >The virtue of the film today is its capacity to offend a whole new generation of viewers for different reasons. I wish that in 2019 we were not so quick to personally attack for unique or politically incorrect ideas.
- inflatableDodo 8y ago>I wish that in 2019 we were not so quick to personally attack for unique or politically incorrect ideas. I don't think we do that any more now than we used to, is just that as what is considered politically incorrect changes some people will think that there is an increase due to them personally getting more shit, where there is actually just a change in focus.
- wallace_f 8y agoYea, I meant we should have made progress, maturing past it, but people are the same as always.
- inflatableDodo 8y agoAs far as progress goes, I kinda agree with John Gray - https://www.vice.com/en_uk/article/qbwqem/john-gray-interview-atheism https://www.vice.com/en_uk/article/qbwqem/john-gray-intervie...
- acqq 8y agoHe has a lot of valid points ("we outsourced the slavery and pollution") but he somehow likes religions more than atheism, which is definitely inconsistent: he recognizes the "false beliefs" in the everyday Western world (keeping the eyes closed about the mentioned "outsourcing"), but then avoids to treat the same the religions which obviously can't all be true. Only atheism is consistent with the existence of all other religions (simply claiming that it's the humans who invented various mutually conflicting stories about one or more "deities"). He also claims that the atheism "is a religion" which is by definition false: "disbelief or lack of belief in the existence of God or gods." Moreover, the changes brought by enlightenment were actually revolutionary and immense. But what is his correct observation is that no rights are fixed and that the most of the humans who have them now can as well lose them fast.
- inflatableDodo 8y agoGiven this article, I really don't think that they deserve their self appointed strapline; 'Academic rigour, journalistic flair'. From the crude and inaccurate broad brush descriptions of modern attitudes to blasphemy, through to presenting the song 'Always look on the bright side of life' as an example of nihilism, this reads like a poorly researched high school essay, with a Kant quote thrown in at the end to try and make it sound clever.
- senectus1 8y agolol, welcome to "The Conversation"
- inflatableDodo 8y agoJust noticed that that the author is Emeritus Professor in the History of Religious Thought from The University of Queensland. I might drop him an email to enquire how that could have possibly occurred and if anybody has yet noticed their mistake.
- marcus_holmes 8y agoreferencing the Philosophy Department at the University of Woolloomooloo perhaps? *https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bruces_sketch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bruces_sketch
- inflatableDodo 8y agoGood idea, he isn't even called Bruce.
- BLKNSLVR 8y agoIt's a confusingly desert-dry article about an oceanically-wet piece of classic cinema. It's almost worth reading the article to see how someone can turn a hugely fun and enjoyable film into such a bland review. I expected wolf-nipple-tips but was delivered stale bread.
- juliangamble 8y agoI showed my kids the falling from the tower scene, including the commentator on the landing. They cracked up.
- NeedMoreTea 8y ago"the BBC famously televised a debate ... Each side totally failed to understand the other" Hardly. Palin and Cleese seemed to perfectly understand the ridiculous childishness of the comically pompous bishop and Muggeridge who both repeatedly avoided engaging and simply derided the film as "tenth rate" etc. A curiously empty article about a film, which like Holy Grail has barely dated in the intervening decades. For a more interesting take on Life of Brian at 40, see yesterday's "How we made": https://www.theguardian.com/film/2019/apr/16/how-we-made-monty-python-life-of-brian-michael-palin-terry-gilliam https://www.theguardian.com/film/2019/apr/16/how-we-made-mon...
- inflatableDodo 8y agoI can't remember which exactly, though I think it was the bishop, but one of them afterward admitted to have missed the start of the film and therefore didn't know that it was made clear that Brian was not Jesus in the opening scene.
- simonh 8y agoThe thing is the film is nothing but respectful to Jesus, who does make a few brief appearances, and in fact what is presented of Jesus' teachings and example in life is wholly reverent. What they do mercilessly lampoon are all the hangers-on, unthinking followers, ungrateful beneficiaries and various religious functionaries that follow rules before they follow principles. Those people get a proper drubbing.
- inflatableDodo 8y agoThat's true and it may more properly explain why it annoyed Malcolm Muggeridge and Mervyn Stockwood quite so much. I looked it up and apparently it was Muggeridge who had skipped the beginning of the film. Perhaps he had also skipped the bit in the bible about bearing false witness, it is quite a large book after all.
- Gupie 8y ago
- lb1lf 8y agoThis film was initially banned in Norway due to alleged blasphemy (!). The Swedes loved it; their movie posters dubbed it 'The movie which is so funny, it is banned in Norway!'
- nintendo95 8y ago/cynical/ So sad that nowadays Swedes can't have a say about radical immams. /cynical/ How cool it is to have fun of Jesus but to have fun of Mahommed? How "far" we have "progressed" ;-) In 40 years from having fun about religious leaders to burning heretics like witches. Wouldn't it be fun to watch movie having fun about Mohammed in Sweden? Or we became some kind of cultural caliphat in the mean time? Joking about Jesus respecting Mohammed? There is a reason for which our era is referred to as "new middle-ages" by some philosophers. Sad. By the way there is much more comedy material in Mohammed case too. As we know since Freud hypocrisy is this what makes the best jokes. I.e. saint God messiah who is a war lord and peadophile in the meantime. Try making movie about that.
- dvfjsdhgfv 8y agoNowhere in the world can we have a comedy about Mohammed because the comedians want to live (a funny life), too. In a few progressive countries people tried to make fun of Mohammed and they're, for the most part, dead. (And The Life of Brian doesn't make fun of Jesus in any way, that's what people who haven't seen the film think.)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pbhjpbhj 8y ago>doesn't make fun of Jesus in any way, // Whilst they're careful in the action of the film to make it clear Brian isn't Jesus, surely the central premise is that "Jesus is Brian", that his presentation as Son of God is a [comedic] mishap, or misunderstanding.
- 8y ago
- Amendeson530 8y agoThere’s one background note I read once, about the filming of the crowd scenes. In Tunisia, where the extras were the local people. Who did not speak English. So that when the soundtrack of a crowd scene says “we are all individuals”, watch the mouths of the extras. Not saying that in English, I’d suggest. A piece of passing trivia.
- peter303 8y agoLandmark arts chain here is having a showing Holy Thursday April 18.
- QuamStiver 8y agoIs thinking for ourselves really such a good distinction for ‘modernity’ from past generations? Belief is belief afterall, whether religious or not we’re all still swayed by our cultural biases and popular opinions. If Monty Python were to stay true to form in the modern day, I might say they’d oppose our supposed “woke” generation’s self orientation. Author quoted Kant almost in a context of Nietzsche at the end there, but what I think Kant (and the movie) meant by this phrase is that we should each consider our religion realistically, not that religion is an intimation of the unthinking.
- DeveloperMan 8y agoI would highly recommend anyone with an interest in Monty Python to watch "Holy Flying Circus". It's a hilarious docudrama about the time leading up to the TV debate.
- dekhn 8y agoOver time, I've come to like the Holy Grail less and less, and this movie more and more. It's the latin lesson (making fun of schoolteachers in england), the witty banter about the naming of the revolutionary front (sorry, People's Liberation Front of Judea), and a number of other ideas in the movie that were so ahead of their time.
- leephillips 8y agoThis paragraph from the article is odd: ‘Still, as gender transitioning becomes culturally mainstream, the desire of the revolutionary Stan (Eric Idle) to be a woman, to be called “Loretta” and to have babies, will strike a chord.’ In fact, actual the scene from the film will be highly offensive to anyone who has accepted the pro-trans dogma. “Loretta”’s companions point out to him the absurdity of his decision to “be” a woman, and Loretta’s comments could have been transcribed from the Twitter feed of any trans woman yesterday. They are kind to Loretta, and spend the rest of the film trying to treat him as he wants to be treated, and frequently apologizing when they forget. But there is never any doubt that this is the kindness of friends towards one who is just very confused.
- favorited 8y agoWhat is "the pro-trans dogma" that you describe?
- leephillips 8y agoThat humans can change their sex. Here is the scene, by the way: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PObBA2wH5l0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PObBA2wH5l0
- inflatableDodo 8y agoI look at the pace that gene tech and organ printing is going and can't help but think that these discussions will eventually seem embarrassingly obsolete. People will instead be getting outraged about the blue furry winged people with clitoris implants on their earlobes.
- _bxg1 8y agoMy favorite bit of commentary was this scene: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ka9mfZbTFbk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ka9mfZbTFbk I was raised protestant and my girlfriend Jewish; after this scene I leaned over and whispered, "this is why there are too many denominations to keep track of".