3 ms·
Hits the nail on the head. For me the main uses of FB are now: 1) Rolodex of friends, with reminders from the ones who actually use it. 2) Bad version of stu
by lordnacho 8y ago
Hits the nail on the head.
For me the main uses of FB are now:
1) Rolodex of friends, with reminders from the ones who actually use it.
2) Bad version of stumbleupon. Seriously large amount of unuseful content, but it does kick up something interesting now and again.
3) Reasonable funnies stream. There's always someone with a good meme.
There's no real content though. All the news commentary is simply terrible. Loads of people trying to be funny. An enormous number of flamewars. Very few people who know anything at all, not just in politics but science as well. The actually insightful comments are drowned out completely.
Other things:
- Loads of comments are just people tagging a friend so they see an article. FB could fix this very easily, I don't really care if Richard Head wants his friend James Smith to see some article.
- Autoplay videos are annoying
- Obvious parasite accounts aren't dealt with. I know my dad hasn't started a new account with the same pic and added me. Do something about it.
All in all, I'm not sure FB would have become FB if its product was what it is now 10 yers ago.
- azhenley 8y agoI really don't understand tagging friends in a comment on FB and IG. This is precisely what the share feature is for!
- warp_factor 8y agoSimply put: UX is bad and most people figured out this was an easier way to do it. (Also something that comes to a shock to people working in the Bay: Most people are really not that good with computers). Also, basic behavior mimicry. You see other people do it so you also do it.
- revvx 8y agoPeople do it because every other option sucks. Sharing to someone else's timeline is way too invasive, sharing to your own timeline and tagging the person is weird, sharing via message is too disruptive. What people is looking for is a "Show it to a friend" button that just creates a notification on the person's bell icon and allows them to respond in any way they want.
- albertgoeswoof 8y agoBut would it increase engagement? Number of comments is one way we measure engagement and you’re advocating for a feature that would take away 90% of those comments away? Increase engagement at all costs this is the only way.
- azhenley 8y agoEasy and expected solution: they should count the number of Share via Message into the share count (even if it is shared privately). Are shares not as good of a metric as comments (even though most comments are effectively shares, making them even more noisy)?
- azhenley 8y agoI share via message. It essentially just creates another notification like you suggest.
- HenryBemis 8y agoNice alternatives for (3) are 9gag and imgur. They got the 'typical': connect.facebook.net, google-analytics.com, googletagservices.com, gstatic.com, imasdk.googleapis.com, scorecardresearch.com, platform.twitter.com, amplitude.com, amazon-adsystem.com, googletagmanager.com but once you block them with Privacy Badger and/or NoScript (or add them to your hosts file), they are an endless source of memes and other funnies.
- andrepd 8y ago>but once you block them with Privacy Badger and/or NoScript or run uBlock in dynamic filtering mode.
- saagarjha 8y agoI don't want to sound like a snob, but 9GAG and Imgur are pretty awful communities with content taken from Reddit–which itself "steals" content, but it's less horrible about it. Both of these communities are heavily moderated and most users don't actually realize where their "fresh memes" are coming from: 9GAG's moderation team actually sways voting to control what hits the front page and immediately bans accounts that mention "Reddit" in any way.
- yjftsjthsd-h 8y agoI don't disagree, but ... should I care? I personally don't care where my funnies originated, only that I get them. If 9gag is a nice skin over ripping off reddit but preselected, why shouldn't I use that?
- revvx 8y agoMarketplace is useful if you want to sell things locally.
- TheSpiciestDev 8y agoRecently "live comments" were introduced and I cannot read a simple body of text without it constantly being bumped around because of loaded comments from timeline entries above.
- zikzak 8y agoI normally use FB as a birthday reminder and sometimes group chat with friends who mainly use it to stay in touch. I recently joined a neighborhood group because there's been a bunch of property crime and we're all sharing camera footage and so on. Anyway, 85% of every thread is just other people's names. However, I don't seem to get email updates about these comments, just the more substantive ones. To me, it looks ridiculous and amateurish but at least I'm not getting tons of email spam.
- dgudkov 8y ago>Rolodex of friends, with reminders from the ones who actually use it. Check out personal CRMs out there. They are still in their infancy, but already usable.