7 ms·
There's a few ways to justify it I imagine. One is "it saved $130M from being spent again on the same thing". And sure there are arguments against that justifi
by pbhjpbhj 8y ago
There's a few ways to justify it I imagine. One is "it saved $130M from being spent again on the same thing".
And sure there are arguments against that justification (and for it).
- NicoJuicy 8y agoIt's called R&D, spending too innovate is what it does. Stealing it, is not R&D, it's theft and punishable by law. Eg. Nintendo Wii, Xbox Kinect and PlayStation Move are the same concepts with a different approach.
- geofft 8y agoIs the world a better place because of that? What if the Kinect and Move had spent their research budget building on top of the Wii instead of reinventing it? Would the world be a better place? (Personally, I find it baffling to see people espousing "research should be private because it yields better outcomes" on a site for an industry so deeply indebted to open source. We have empirical evidence about which approach works better, and it's not the closed private research lab one.)
- 0815test 8y agoStealing and violating privacy via industrial espionage is not "open source". You're free to make your own research public, or to pay a company for full IP rights on their research and then release the results openly. But what the Chinese are doing is not the same. Even making access to their domestic market conditional on releasing proprietary IP, is in fact a hidden tariff which is not in line with free and fair trade.
- geofft 8y agoYes, I'm not claiming that violating the laws and norms is a good thing. I'm asking if the laws and norms are defensible and produce a better society. If not, then the argument needs to be "We follow unjust laws for the sake of the broader principle of the rule of law, and we work to change unjust laws so respect for law is maintained," not "These outcomes are bad."
- 0815test 8y agoThe problem is that we're not just talking about a relatively-benign violation of things like copyrights, patents or trade secrets ("IP"): Chinese hacking is a severe violation of privacy; and their practice of forcing IP releases from foreign firms is blatantly unfair given that no reciprocity is involved, and indeed China apparently claims that they're uniquely allowed to engage in such policies because of their status as a "developing country" - itself a rather dubious claim given their reported economic performance. Privacy (and protection of physical property, in general) and fairness in trade are basic principles and far from "unjust".
- geofft 8y agoPrivacy of companies or of individuals? I don't think privacy of companies is a right, so that argument isn't convincing to me. (Specifically, I believe companies have no particular inherent right to existence the way people do. Companies are creations of law to serve specific goals that benefit people; we should give them whatever privileges are necessary to accomplish that, and not what's not. Privacy of certain things like customer data and things like HR conversations seems pretty clearly helpful, but mostly because that's a proxy for privacy of individuals, not because violating it would violate the company's "privacy.") There's an easy solution to reciprocity: abandon IP protection in the US, too. My entire claim is that that would lead to a better world. If we want to not do that, we should either defend that it would lead to a worse world, or admit that we're not making arguments based on what's best for society. That's why I found the argument about "but IP protection brought us Kinect and Move" unconvincing: it's not clear at all to me that the outcome was better than in the world where the US didn't recognize IP protection.
- NicoJuicy 8y agoA better world by removing IP protection or the cheapest copycat wins by removing IP protection. I just think it has to be tweaked for preventing abuse. But it had it's advantages. If you remove IP protection, why would a company spend millions on research on R&D to innovate something. Look at the products that got copied from Kickstarter by China before they launched, those people really got their dream crushed. Ps. Kinect was just an example, look for the bigger picture ;)
- NicoJuicy 8y ago1) Why would the world be a better place? What a nonsense question that has nothing to do with anything. I said: the consumers have more options. Personally, I prefer the Kinect. So yes, I'm for diversity. 2) In a forum of "open source" people. What does this has to do with it? I find it baffling you don't see the difference. How do you earn your money? Work at a traditional company or did you create you own open-source product with donations? I'd be damned if you are one of the 0,01% here that earns all his income through open-source. I find it baffling you don't see the simple difference between software parents and IP ( without software). Fyi. You are not earning your money through open-source. Otherwise you would know that if not the golden life either. 3) Research should be public? Wtf? So every company should share everything? Wtf? How realistic is that??? Answer: it's not. It's never going to happen. Stop dreaming and come back to reality please. ---- In a lot of the responses here, I honestly think that I have to explain it to a 12-year old. Because they don't seem to grasp reality. Or trolls, or Chinese state sponsored propaganda. I really don't understand the low quality of responses, constant Whataboutism ! Unrelated responses). That baffles me at this moment.
- 0815test 8y ago> Research should be public? > Wtf? So every company should share everything? > Wtf? How realistic is that??? That's not what "research should be public" means. It just means that the existing institutions which the public funds for research (universities and research labs) should have their remit expanded to include "private" R&D for public benefit; and that, additionally, the public sector should routinely buy out valuable private R&D, perhaps via formally-established "prizes" - instead of merely allowing it to be monopolized via IP protection. We spend a lot of tax money already to fund private R&D by firms, that could instead be directed to fund these mechanisms.
- NicoJuicy 8y agoWe are talking about Samsung's research in the thread. Please don't change to subject to your liking. Private firms are mostly subsided by government for employment, not for their research
- 8y ago
- greedo 8y agoIn your world, we wouldn't have multiple terminals in *nix, cuz why wouldn't open source devs just expand on vi instead of wasting resources and time on developing emacs...
- geofft 8y agoThat doesn't follow - both vi and emacs have been able to be aware of each other and if necessary incorporate techniques from each other, and yet they both exist separately. At no point did I argue that we should prevent people from making two separate products if they want. I only argued that we should prevent people from keeping research and discoveries secret, and gave an example that different products could build on each other. vi and emacs have in fact had that opportunity, so this example supports my point that it's a reasonable way for the world to work. Sometimes building on each other means collaborating; something it means friendly and open competition for the sake of taking multiple approaches to a goal (which is different from competition-for-the-sake-of-competition by forcing your competitors to walk the same path you already walked, but several steps behind you). Also, spacemacs.
- PedroBatista 8y agoI’m sure you don’t mind if I break into your house and start living there. I mean, you already spent the money there’s no need for me to spend it again on the same thing.
- AsyncAwait 8y agoThat's a terribly poor analogy. If you break into my house and start living there, you occupy space and resources I could use myself, IP theft does not deprive the originator of the invention or even first mover advantage profits. It just prevents IP from being used to keep 3rd world nations there. The U.S. did the same to Europe in the 17/18th centuries when IT need to bring itself up to par, so did Japan in the 70s/80s - so did the Europeans to the Chinese before that. China will, (and already does to an extent), innovate and enrich the world, it just needs to catch up fast and this is the best way to do it.
- PedroBatista 8y agoBut I wouldn’t kick you out of your house, I would just be there chillin’. Now seriously, you’re trying to justify theft using the old “we’re so little and innocent and they are so powerful and evil”. Just stop.
- AsyncAwait 8y agoIP theft would be like looking at my house and building a very similar one, or perhaps even peeking inside via the windows to note down the exact furniture. I'm not trying to say that it is a flawless way to go about it, or that anybody's 'evil', but please stop pretending that it is not a stage of every country's development at some point. Europe did it, Russia did it, the U.S. did it, Japan did it and now China does it. Perhaps that should tell you something. In the end, this helps a country to move past sweat shops and the like faster and am certainly not going to protest too loud against that.
- z3phyr 8y agoI would not mind if you copy my house internals and my way of life in a cheaper and more efficient manner. I would also not mind if you improve upon those designs(I would encourage you to do so). Find and Reverse Engineer my designs and improve them. I would mind if you break into my house.