9 ms·
BlackBerry cofounder Jim Balsillie is sounding the alarm about surveillance
- batbomb 8y agoI’d be afraid of Google if I had worked at Blackberry too, just look at the destruction they did.
- na85 8y agoEh, I think blackberry's destruction was of their own making. They had a huge head start but failed to embrace apps. The onboarding process for developers was painful and their devices were chronically underpowered. They failed to read the winds of change that saw Bring Your Own Device come to the workplace and thought they were safe with enterprise and government users.
- capsulecorp 8y ago>The onboarding process for developers was painful and their devices were chronically underpowered. I can resonate with this. I worked for a major bank developing their blackberry app. It was amazingly painful to develop on their platform, its a literal mess.
- realusername 8y agoAndroid wasn't that great technically at the time either, I was actively avoiding mobile app development at that time due to how crappy the SDK was, thankfully it's not that bad anymore, Google put a lot of work on Android since then but was Blackberry really worse?
- jayd16 8y agoIt was night and day. Imagine Android dev with worse documentation in Java 5, (somehow!) more fragmentation, less hype so less stack overflow articles but with stricter than Apple submission hoops and no xcode to help you stumble through it.
- protomyth 8y agoLooking back, I’m more and more convinced it was Verizon’s need for an iPhone clone that killed them. The book Losing the Signal: The Untold Story Behind the Extraordinary Rise and Spectacular Fall of Blackberry goes into a lot of detail about their decisions and that looked like the big problem. Something like the Passport earlier would have been a better bet than any Storm model.
- jayd16 8y agoTheir developer tools were laughably painful in the iPhone age.
- 29083011397778 8y agoJim Balsillie actually tried to change course, open up, and monetize BBM. He was shot down hard by the rest of the board, who thought hardware was the way to go. I can't imagine how much that would sting, considering a couple years later Whatsapp would be sold for billions. Taken from the book mentioned in the article actually, Losing the Signal, before anyone asks for a source.
- na85 8y agoI was an avid bbm user and when they brought in the monetization changes I quickly grew to detest the app. If that was his vision at work, then I'm not surprised it failed. Monetized bbm was/is a spammy, irritating mess.
- otabdeveloper1 8y agoThere's only two possible ways to survive in the commodity phone hardware world: a) Price dumping and giving out a free OS to Chinese OEM's. b) Making a "luxury" product to differentiate against Chinese OEM's. Neither of these two paths was open to Blackberry. Sorry.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Zhenya 8y agoPretty rich, coming from the co-founder of a company that willfully handed over encryption keys of user data to authoritarian and brutal governments[1]. [1]https://www.reuters.com/article/us-blackberry-saudi/rim-to-share-some-blackberry-codes-with-saudis-source-idUSTRE6751Q220100810 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-blackberry-saudi/rim-to-s...
- devoply 8y agoWhataboutism. Regardless, his point is that comprehensive surveillance of the Sidewalk project is bad. > Sidewalk’s proposal is peppered with phrases like “comprehensive data collection,” “an enormous amount of data,” and “fine-grained data.” The data it desires runs from environmental (localized weather conditions, noise levels, and pollution) to social ( everyday actions that paint a detailed picture of what residents are doing and when ). It looks like Google's vision for the modern city is to turn it into the Sims where Google can peer into everything. If you want to live in that world be my guest, but he's absolutely right. This is not something which is good in many ways. Where Google is monitoring everyone all the time. I mean even in Star Trek the computer isn't monitoring everyone all the time.... if it were then many plots could be resolved with the surveillance log on everyone's actions.
- Zhenya 8y agoNot whataboutism at all; with historical context you might be able to see that this isn't a principal stand but possibly has some, yet unknown, commercial reason.
- kbenson 8y agoIt's somewhat whataboutism because the whether the message is truthful does not rely on the source. i.e. Hitler could say genocide is bad, and he would still be correct even though he's Hitler. It is relevant to the discussion to point out Jim Balsillie's relation to this topic. It's not a refutation of the point being made though. It's entirely possible that he has ulterior motives for making this argument that aren't based on it being morally (or event factually) correct, but it may be correct (or incorrect) separately from that.
- devoply 8y agoIn the future we are Sims running on Google's computers.
- AFascistWorld 8y agoAny of these big tech companies is not your friend.
- aresant 8y agoThis article is a long winded view of the sophisticated behavior modeling ad-targeting networks that google and others employ - long on hand wringing and short on solutions. Stratchery published a beautiful, irreverent proposal earlier this week to address this very challenge through a regulatory framework that actually feels like it could work and I encourage all HN users to absorb: https://stratechery.com/2019/a-regulatory-framework-for-the-internet/ https://stratechery.com/2019/a-regulatory-framework-for-the-...
- maksimum 8y ago> platform providers that primarily monetize through advertising should be in their own category: as I noted above, because these platform providers separate monetization from content supply and consumption, there is no price or payment mechanism to incentivize them to be concerned with problematic content The article does a good job of explaining why YouTube and Facebook don't currently do a good job of currating content, or whether that should even be their responsibility. It's not about machine learning, it's about price incentives.
- nnq 8y agoMaybe forcing separation of content providing companies and advertising companies should be the modern equivalent of separating State from Church. An advertising company would always want to get more and more infos about the users that it sees as "resources" instead of customers. A content providing company would be forced to treat its users as actual customers and respect their rights at least a bit, and would push back against the advertising company asking for more surveillance data. Now, unfortunately this can't actually work because the more an advertising company makes, the more it can afford to pay the content creators/channels/providers, and everyone just wants more $. But if anyone has any idea how to make it work, do share!
- spaced-out 8y agoI've read a lot of these types of articles, which are heavy on hand-wringing and light of suggestions that would actually help things. I think the core problem is that under our current model of free-market capitalism, there really is no way to constrain what companies like Google and Facebook are doing. You can add on some additional privacy protections like Europe does, but it only goes so far, since the core model of these companies is to make products that people want and give them away in exchange for data. Google and the like will continue to get the data they want because people will keep giving it to them voluntarily. Me personally, I don't want to give up my free gmail, or my free maps app. I was on a trip in Japan and Google Translate works amazingly well. Way better than a few years ago, and also free. Even if I am uncomfortable with some of Google's practices, I'm not going to stop using their products.
- guntars 8y agoDoes a day go by when an article about some version of Google Is Evil doesn’t make it to the top of Hacker News? It’s ruining the site, imo.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dosy 8y agoit's pretty funny as blackberries used to be the phone of choice for intelligence services. but now their business has failed he's against people who are exploiting data. I know he's talking about a different type of data but it's still funny. as an aside I'm wondering when the the last nail in the coffin is going to laid for one of these big tech services. and how are these huge tech companies going to respond to this increasing government interference. I'm sort of waiting for one of the big five to go full early-airbnb or Uber and just start circumventing. a part of me would find this big tech versus big government civil war out in the open pretty funny. plus big tech being distracted and hammered by government would provide more opportunities for startups.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- IshKebab 8y agoI got many paragraphs in with no new information given. Yes we know that Google allows targeted advertising. It's how they make money. We also know that they don't sell user information. Neither does Facebook actually - they just had a stupidly permissive (and free) API in the past.
- frolig 8y ago"Free as in puppy" is something people say? I don't like this meme.