13 ms·
Facebook showed me my data is everywhere and I have absolute no control over it
- rogerdickey 8y agoThen leave Facebook?
- p49k 8y agoThese advertisers are running ads using a contact list they or their partner uploaded that includes info about you. This info was collected by the advertiser or their partner. Typically this information is your email address or phone number. I like how they purposely give a couple examples, omitting the targeting factors that are more likely to freak people out, such as targeting by lists of names and dates of birth
- Declanomous 8y agoOn top of that, it's absurd that someone can add my phone number to their advertising platform to get my name. Unlike email addresses, phone numbers are rather finite, and the number itself is tied to a particular geographical area (for the most part). On a related note, Facebook makes it so difficult to unlike things, unfriend people, and opt-out of information from individual advertisers. It's obviously hostile design aimed at making it as hard as possible to reduce your advertising value to them. What Facebook is doing might not be illegal, but I think what they are doing is more unethical than many felonies. The people in charge of these decisions are getting wealthy from them, and they are never going to face consequences for their actions, which is a real shame.
- qnsi 8y agoDo they get your name? Still I hate it when all sites ask for phone to confirm my account and then use it to target me. I use different e-mail for FB and everyday use, yet still there are a lot of companies that target me
- mic47 8y agoThis works as contact matching: they provide list of contacts and FB show to those people ads, so advertiser will not gain access to your personal data.
- throwawayjay01 8y ago> On top of that, it's absurd that someone can add my phone number to their advertising platform to get my name. Advertisers don't get any information about you from Facebook ads unless you click on an ad and tell them it yourself.
- username223 8y agoThat's why I never signed up for FB's 2FA program, and give out random fake phone numbers elsewhere, like grocery stores. I'm sure (987) 654-3210 will save you 10% on your tomatoes.
- mic47 8y agoI don't think you can target people by names or dates of birth at Facebook. IIRC targeting by name (even indirectly) is prohibited by Facebook.
- reaperducer 8y agoLots of things are "prohibited" by Facebook, but slimy ad companies and middlemen do them all the time. Unless they're Facebook "partners," which means more access, but nobody really knows how far that goes because it's all private.
- ACow_Adonis 8y agoreally? that's interesting, because I'm literally running an experiment right now since this whole 'Facebook shows you who's targeting you' thing started. Facebook explicitly has my name, my "second" birthday (I love all my birthdays equally, especially the ones I give to marketing sites) and a special email address I have literally created only to give to Facebook for my account. The rest of my account info is deliberately empty and I've deliberately locked down as much privacy settings as I can, don't use the site from my phone (Honestly I barely use the site at all) and have opted out of everything I can. Advertisers are still showing up (one of them is a liquor store even though I'm a teetotaler and I have selected not to be shown alcohol ads, but what can you do?) either way, something rather fishy is going on.
- kristianc 8y ago> such as targeting by lists of names and dates of birth Typically you wouldn't be able to do this.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoName and birth date is nothing. The freaky shit is that Acxiom tracks women's menstrual cycles. Advertisers tailor their campaigns depending on what will be best received at any given time in the cycle.
- circular_logic 8y agoI tried googling for this but turned up short. Do you have a source for this?
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoI sat in a meeting where this was explained to me. This was before Google existed.
- malvosenior 8y agoI find it amazing that although my list of advertisers is super long, not a single company on there provides a service that's remotely relevant to me or sells something that I would ever buy. In fact, I've never clicked on an ad on Facebook. Not because I hate ads (I'm ambivalent about them) but because I've never seen anything relevant. For all of the hype around how persuasive Facebook advertising is supposed to be, to me their ads and personalization are no better than random noise.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoI found some interesting points in the list. Bear in mind these are advertisers who got your info outside of Facebook. So while car dealerships are fairly prevalent across the board, I found most of them in my list were dealerships from the brand of car I own. Clearly somewhere along the line of purchasing my car, my email address got associated with "people who buy that kind of car", though I found it odd so many dealerships not in my local area were on the list.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kristianc 8y ago> These advertisers are running ads using a contact list they or their partner uploaded that includes info about you. This info was collected by the advertiser or their partner. Typically this information is your email address or phone number. Newsflash, BuzzFeed's ad networks onboard and sync information about their readers in exactly the same way. Do people think that BF loads Quantcast, Scorecard Research etc onto their site for the good of their health? That's not to mention the viral quizzes and other data gathering exercises that BuzzFeed invented and sold as a product. I have no idea why people don't call BS on news orgs that run 'exposes' on Facebook's ad targeting, when they target, track and follow their readers in exactly the same way.
- en-us 8y agoI think it's possible that the author doesn't even know this. Does BuzzFeed have an interface where a user can go to see this information? The level of understanding that most people have about online tracking is just really, really low, and this author probably wouldn't know about any of this if Facebook didn't have that particular page.
- HenryBemis 8y agoEFF's Privacy Badger, NoScript, Unlock, AdblockPlus has many lists, and many many more add-ons can show you all the nasties in each page, and you click-block them once and for all. Same add-ons are also for the Firefox on Android. Edit: yes most likely the author is someone that may be seldonmly writing for the site, or just sells his texts and doesn't really pay attention/care where this is posted.
- hhs 8y agoOP here. Please note that the author is a senior reporter for BuzzFeed News, as cited here: https://www.buzzfeednews.com/author/katienotopoulos https://www.buzzfeednews.com/author/katienotopoulos.
- justtopost 8y ago
- _hao 8y agoI'm curious if I delete (I mean real delete, not disabling) my FB account, do they keep it as a ghost profile of me i.e. Facebook still knows that I exist as a person in the world? I've been thinking about just getting rid of it, not that I use it a lot, but still... One less thing to worry about and less clutter in my life. The downside to this is that FB is my only channel of communication with some people, but then again if they truly want to contact me they can find a way to do so, although that's going to increase their inconvenience and they might decide against contacting me at all haha.
- username223 8y agoThey probably don't delete your profile, but keep it with a "deleted" flag. I'd still recommend getting rid of it. It reduces the noise in your life, and while you will lose touch with a few people, most of the ones who matter will email you.
- fuckBuzzfeed 8y agoSort of like how Facebook stored plain text passwords for eons.
- CharlesColeman 8y ago> They probably don't delete your profile, but keep it with a "deleted" flag. I don't like Facebook, but I'm not so sure about that. I read one article a month or so back where someone paid attention to the targeted ads they were shown after they'd deleted their facebook account. After a few weeks, the targeting got much worse.
- brudgers 8y agoDoes anyone know if there is equivalent transparency for my Google account?
- nukeop 8y agoThere's a section where you can download all the data Google has on you.
- dredmorbius 8y agoSpecifically: https://takeout.google.com/settings/takeout/ https://takeout.google.com/settings/takeout/
- bbulkow 8y agoThe author keeps saying 'my data' when the data isn't theirs. The fact that they interacted with a party, that interaction, and who you are, is thier data. This isn't a theoretical nit pick, this is the law. And it makes sense. If you and i have a conversation, i am free to tell someone else about that conversation, because i was part of it. That is my data, as it is also theirs. In casual use, if we agree not to tell anyone, that is different, but the default is both parties own it. This the simple minded use of 'my data' really wrecks what could be a rather interesting ( but not surprising ) piece.
- coldpie 8y agoI see nothing wrong with calling my contact information "my data," because I feel some ownership over how it is used and disseminated. I strongly disagree with the idea that having an interaction with a business gives them a license to tell anyone anything about our interaction, including (especially) my contact information. I agree it is "the law" right now, but I think that is wrong and should be changed.
- jrace 8y agoYour info is your info. The data they collected about you is their data. Now if only we could oprevent them from sharing/selling their data which contains your info. I realize that in my argument I am being rather pedantic...but in online text based exchange it is what separates us from the barbarians.
- coldpie 8y ago> The data they collected about you is their data. That's my point. I don't think it should be. They can have access to my data to conduct our business transaction, but I disagree with the idea that my information somehow belongs to them just because they had access to it at some point.
- lotu 8y agoI think this was a really good distinction, because it suggests a course of action. It sounds like you would support a requirement in a consumer contracts that a person's contact information may not be used for marking purposes or shared with others to use for marking. This could essentially decimate the direct marketing industry, but that might be the desired outcome. Unfortunately governments don't like to pass laws the decimate any industry no matter how small. I think it is also very valuable because it more clearly defines what you mean by privacy. The privacy violation happens, not when they collect your contact information, or when it is put into a list, it is when it is used to send you advertising which you find unwelcome.
- Causality1 8y agoYou work for an online magazine and you weren't aware of this? If you're not the customer you are the product.
- corebit 8y agoBecause it's not your data. Just because something describes you, doesn't make it yours.
- svachalek 8y ago"Yours" and "not yours" is a really primitive way to look at the problem. Every camera that you have passed in front of has your image, and we more or less accept that if it's in a public place that's OK. But that doesn't mean someone can take that image and put it in a national television campaign for their product. There are shades of ownership.
- corebit 8y agoI agree, ownership is a poor way to look at it. In fact, there is a rich body of property and tort law that address this whole subject in vast detail and has identified a large set of principles and criteria that can and is applied.
- beders 8y agoThe usage of Facebook is free. You uploaded your data voluntarily. How do people think Facebook pays for running its service?!? Of course you are the product.
- nukeop 8y agoBut Facebook also tracks people who do not have accounts, and people who pay for services. No way out.
- alexkavon 8y agoThis isn't entirely true. There is a way out. Media outlets who publish things like "Facebook Showed Me My Data Is Everywhere And I Have Absolutely No Control Over It" could also remove the Facebook scripts and widgets from their sites and write articles to the effect that it's a good decision. The way out of it is to stop with trying to shock people with the fact that they're being tracked and start taking proactive measures to prevent it in the future. There's some logical fallacy at play when people truly believe that Facebook is the sole perpetrator of this issue.
- throwaway2048 8y agoThe logical fallacy is your own, nobody in the article, or the comments believes Facebook is the only party doing this.
- alexkavon 8y agoNo you misread. > that Facebook is the sole perpetrator of this issue Perpetrator. I'm saying we should hold the organizations publishing articles about this kind of stuff accountable as well. They use Facebook tools (like buttons, share buttons, login integration, etc) and encourage use of Facebook to interact with their articles. This is how Facebook sips up and tracks a good portion of the web. The orgs publishing these articles are also perpetrators. > The logical fallacy is your own, nobody in the article, or the comments believes Facebook is the only party doing this. I'm not proposing there's a narrative convincing society that Facebook is the ONLY organization tracking us, that's just silly. I'm saying there's a narrative that is similar to "tracking people is so shocking we just don't know what to do!" Today it's Facebook, tomorrow the article will be about Google, Microsoft, or maybe Amazon. Can you believe no one's going to budge a muscle about it?
- quest88 8y agoJust like your credit report and score, and that's probably more meaningful.
- fuckBuzzfeed 8y agoNot true. But buzzfeed, so handily dismissed.
- YoyoyoPCP 8y agoAt what point does the end user feel accountability for giving a free service all of their information? I get that they employ various unsavory tactics (especially on mobile), but remember that this _is_ the Internet after all.
- bluetidepro 8y agoFWIW, I wrote a little script back in Feb that you can use in the console on that Facebook advertisers page to auto click "remove" on them all for you. Here is the github gist: https://gist.github.com/bluetidepro/bfa60c1d63925180daf3dd53e5ff48ea https://gist.github.com/bluetidepro/bfa60c1d63925180daf3dd53... I run it about every month, and it's crazy how many get added in that time span. There is literally thousands and thousands from brands/companies/etc. that I've never heard of it. It's insane.
- john-radio 8y agoNice job. It looks like Facebook Purity has this built in also.
- bbcfake 8y agoWhy nobody sue this criminal ?
- maxxxxx 8y agoI wonder how it would be technically feasible to instead of copying data to other parties to just grant them access for a limited time and being able to revoke that access. This would be perfect for a lot of data sharing but I guess there is no way to prevent copying of digital data once somebody can read it.
- PopeDotNinja 8y agoOne thing I don't quite understand is why Facebook's data about me is my data? In my opinion, it's not. I've never put a single thing on Facebook with the expectation that I'd own it or control it.
- vmateixeira 8y agoYou know that Facebook still collects information about you, even though you may not even have an account, right? [1] http://fortune.com/2018/04/11/mark-zuckerberg-facebook-data-testimony/ http://fortune.com/2018/04/11/mark-zuckerberg-facebook-data-... [2] https://newsroom.fb.com/news/2018/04/data-off-facebook/ https://newsroom.fb.com/news/2018/04/data-off-facebook/ [3] https://www.wsj.com/articles/you-give-apps-sensitive-personal-information-then-they-tell-facebook-11550851636 https://www.wsj.com/articles/you-give-apps-sensitive-persona...
- PopeDotNinja 8y agoI understand what you're saying, and you're not wrong. I just find the concept of data about me being "my data" to be strange. If someone takes a picture of me, it's their picture. If I use your website, and you collect information about me, it's your information. Maybe I just don't care what you know about me. I know the REALLY good stuff about me, and I ain't sharin' that with anyone!
- 2_listerine_pls 8y agoIt's not your data, but it's data about you and it better be under your control. Your data might be used to target your with information in order to change your political views, to increase your insurance pricing, to decline a loan, etc...
- astura 8y agoWhy should it be "under my control?" This is not how I understand the world to work. If I get caught, say, drinking and driving then I don't get to control if newspapers, courts, police, etc, share it with others. If I go to a party and take a shit on the floor I don't get to dictate what the other party attendants do with that information. I don't get to demand they don't take that information into account when deciding to invite me to another party. Also, insurance companies and loan companies don't use Facebook data (nor are they legally allowed to).
- fixermark 8y agoIf that headline accurately describes the situation, in what sense of the words is it "my data" instead of "data about me?"
- Yhippa 8y agoMildly ironic since this site uses tracking ads that were blinking in and out of existence all over the page as I was scrolling down the article. I had to stop reading because it was so annoying.
- NightlyDev 8y agoThe garbage site this content is on is made by idiots. First I get one pop-up, and as I'm about to cross it out another pop-up appears on top of it with the accept button at the same position so that I accidentally press accept. Stop with the fucking pop-ups if you don't know how to do it!
- daphneokeefe 8y agoThis is why many of us use ad blockers.
- apeace 8y agoThe Cambridge Analytica scandal was super interesting to me because it reflected an entirely standard and unremarkable data-collection process that I'd seen several times. And yet it filled international headlines. Congress was interested. It's easy to do. You create some app that has "login with Facebook". That's great for users, right? One less password for them to remember. Then as soon as they log in you make a quick call to the Facebook API, get all their friends, and dump it in some database table. Even if only a few people log in to your app, you can get a database of thousands of real people. I don't work for that type of company anymore, but I've been many places where that was bog standard, the very first code you write for a new product. Does anyone know if the Facebook API has changed now?
- hallman76 8y agoTangent: This is a side-effect to how Facebook exposes Facebook ids. They expose system-wide identifiers. LinkedIn's API exposes user ids that are transformed based on whoever is interacting with the API. My network graph could overlap with your network graph, but the overlapping people would have different ids.
- pushtheenvelope 8y agothis has been changed for facebook to use app-specific IDs for many years now
- qwertox 8y agoWeren't you able to also pull infos like birthday, posts, likes and the online-status of friends of the one who used Facebook to log-in into a 3rd-party site? I think they then limited this to just the list of friends.
- InternetUser 8y agoIt became a massive "scandal" because it was part of the ongoing Facebook-scapegoating campaign that began the day after Trump won the election. There have been like 7 separate episodes in that scapegoating saga over the oas 2 years, and Zuckerberg has had to go public a bunch of times with some new vow to do something to get Facebook under control so that something so heinous doesn't happen again, lol... CNN and MSNBC viewers cannot understand how someone can support Trump unless than person is a white supremacist Nazi or whatever. All I know is that I have a nice $1,500 wager with a relative (who bet me last time as well) that if Trump is IN the election, he will win again. The only thing that could stop him is if he is simply not a candidate on Election Day. I think the main thing that could stop him is his own cholesterol; celebrity physician Dr. Oz said, in a show WITH Trump in September 2016, that Trump has too much of the "bad cholesterol." https://static01.nyt.com/images/2018/02/18/opinion/sunday/18zimmerman-print/18zimmerman-print-articleLarge.jpg?quality=75&auto=webp&disable=upscale https://static01.nyt.com/images/2018/02/18/opinion/sunday/18...
- fixermark 8y agoIt's always interesting to me the number of people who come out on HN to advocate vociferously for ownership of their private data, given that HN doesn't even let you delete your account ;) https://jacquesmattheij.com/the-unofficial-hn-faq/#deleteaccount https://jacquesmattheij.com/the-unofficial-hn-faq/#deleteacc...
- privong 8y ago> It's always interesting to me the number of people who come out on HN to advocate vociferously for ownership of their private data, given that HN doesn't even let you delete your account ;) It's true HN doesn't let you delete your account, but I'm not sure most HN account information is really "private", since submissions and comments are all public. Maybe a user's voting history is more sensitive. But it's not like HN (to my knowledge) is aggregating data on its users from other sources.
- Sir_Substance 8y agoI can't speak for anyone else, but when I signed up to HN I made the naive mistake of assuming that of course a pure tech website would be implemented correctly. I was surprised and disappointing when I found out it didn't support deletion, but I'm kind of stuck now. Maybe one day I'll scramble my password and never come back, that's about the closest I can get to a deletion I guess. I check all new websites more carefully these days.
- Ndymium 8y agoTrue account deletion was one of the first features I implemented into my web service. I don't think any non-government site that doesn't offer it has a valid excuse. For example with npmjs.com you have to contact their customer support to delete your account, that's just bad UX.
- why-el 8y agoit also requires almost no private info, so, technically, you can stay anonymous (modulo a dedicated adversary). Granted, I agree with your point. HN should try and mask deleted account, but the website is public, and therefore the point is moot.
- seoguru 8y agoreminds me of this fascinating video about how buzzfeed is playing the system perfectly: Capitalism, Cultural Disintegration, and Buzzfeed https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9srhgHzUFd4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9srhgHzUFd4
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoAbsolutely no control? Don't use social media and lock down your browser to limit fingerprinting. Your remaining big threats are phone apps and traditional data brokers profiling your credit card usage. Cut out all unnecessary apps, block everything else with a firewall and pay cash. You will then be far more opaque to the private surveillance apparatus than most first-worlders.
- dzek69 8y agoI'm rarely using Facebook. I have an account, even some photos, but that's it. I may scroll the wall from time to time, usually readings arists posts and stuff, as my friends are just like me - not posting anything about them anyway. I'm a heavy user of privacy extensions. Currently using uBlock Origin + uMatrix. Most sites I run can't store anything (like cookies) or has access to scripting. I'm having an unique e-mail address for every service I register to (thanks to catch-all on own domain). The above are available to everyone. Additionally, I'm manually fixing broken websites, that can work without JS but refuses to - this however requires some skills. When I really want to see the website that refuses to work with all these protections - I'm opening it in incognito session. Result: On my accounts (both fake and real) these Facebook advertisers lists are empty. The only list that's not empty is advertisers I decided I don't want to see ads from. Of course I know this doesn't mean I'm anonymous and nobody knows anything about me. A lot of services know. These protections listed above aren't the silver bullet. They can still track me, they just won't tell me everything. Most of my data are stored with Google. I let them store my location history (they probably would do it anyway). They know all my searches. They know my entertaiment interests (Youtube history, likes, dislikes). Well... You can track me too. I'm not using unique nicknames usually. You can find my contact info on the internet, on my website and other places. You can find my home address. You can know where I work. But these were my choice. But I still have to remember I can't take that back, "Internet won't forget". So yeah. You have the control. Just stop giving yourself away, protect yourself from automation. Share yourself with people offline. That's all.
- makecheck 8y agoData retention and sharing should be illegal because it’s like a dam bursting when any actor, anywhere, lets your data out. You could literally do everything right for decades as far as safeguarding your data, and then one slip-up could leak it ALL and let services connect you to ALL the other information about you.
- fxbl0i 8y agohttps://static01.nyt.com/images/2019/04/05/business/00chinadebt-5/merlin_152925999_408c1f92-9433-432e-ad7d-e6312d601ef5-superJumbo.jpg https://static01.nyt.com/images/2019/04/05/business/00chinad... Really man, can't you iron your sweater? It's disgraceful.
- austinheap 8y agoAcxiom opt-out: https://isapps.acxiom.com/optout/optout.aspx https://isapps.acxiom.com/optout/optout.aspx Oracle opt-out: https://datacloudoptout.oracle.com/optout/ https://datacloudoptout.oracle.com/optout/
- geekamongus 8y agoOn that Advertisers settings page, it is really lame you cannot click through the list of advertisers in one fell swoop, disabling ads from all of them at once. There is no "select all." No, you have to click the X in the corner of each one, then click View More after every 12 you have disabled. I got through about 140 before giving up. I think this was intentional.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Lowkeyloki 8y agoIf your data (or at least data about you) is everywhere, there's only one thing left to do. You'll have to engage in a misinformation campaign about yourself. Send advertisers so much conflicting information about yourself that they can't distinguish the signal from the noise. That way they won't be able to target you. This may sound ludicrous, but there actually is a browser plugin out there (I don't have a link handy, unfortunately) that confounds meaningful tracking efforts by clicking on each and every ad on every page you view. The pages the ads link to aren't actually displayed to you. Like I said, it's a crazy tactic but it makes perfect sense. Overwhelm them with data. Google strongly opposes it, by the way. So it must be on the right track.
- InternetUser 8y agoI think it can be gone quite a lot more simply: Register on each service with a different first and last name and birthdate, linked to a throwaway email address with its own different name and birthdate. Then register on another service with another, and so on. I'm a white American guy, yet because I've watched some Spanish pop videos and used Google Translate for Spanish translations (and done other things, not as part of a concerted mis/disinformation campaign), my Android phone believes I'm a Latin woman, and I even get a mixture of Spanish and English ads and pre-roll commercials on YouTube videos, and some of the ads are for women's clothing and makeup.
- tluyben2 8y agoWhat I never understood, when I still used FB, they knew everything about me and yet I have not once been presented by ads I was even mildly interested in while on Google it is always spot on... Not sure how they can be so bad to get 0 clicks from me while having all that info. It is like this person: getting car and mortgage ads while fb knows i could not care less about either. Getting rich quick packages, again I do not care about as far as they can see from comments etc. Flights to Thailand for next week while they know I am currently in Thailand. It is the worst targetting I have seen: not unlike the ads of the late 90s.