3 ms·
Hmm? This just goes to show that the USA didn't need to manufacture rape allegations in Sweden just in order to get Assange extradited, since their best chance
by foldr 8y ago
Hmm? This just goes to show that the USA didn't need to manufacture rape allegations in Sweden just in order to get Assange extradited, since their best chance of doing so was to extradite him from the UK.
- rndgermandude 8y agoHe was in Sweden at the time. The UK couldn't have extradited him from Sweden to the US. Not saying that the Swedish charges were all manufactured, just following your hypothesis.
- foldr 8y agoOk, you'll have to explain the plan to me. How does having Assange accused of rape in Sweden help the US to extradite him? Assange was traveling between lots of countries at the time. It's not as if he was permanently based in Sweden. And Assange being accused of a crime in Sweden does not in any way make it easier for the US to extradite him from Sweden on other charges. edit: Also, the usual conspiracy story was that the CIA/the Illuminati/whoever had directed Sweden to reopen the rape case after Assange had arrived in the UK. (The case was dropped before he left Sweden, then reopened shortly after he arrived in the UK.)
- rndgermandude 8y agoJailing him undermines him directly by restricting his freedom. A charge of sexual misconduct will discredit him particular in the mostly-left-at-the-time circles that supported him. Having him in jail in a "friendly" nation also gives you time to prepare your proper, "iron-clad" extradition warrant... because if he is free who knows where he will be once you get your stuff ready. PS: the "timeline issue"... asked and answered: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19633178 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19633178
- foldr 8y agoI think you might benefit from looking at the following timeline: https://www.theguardian.com/media/2019/apr/11/julian-assange-key-dates-in-wikileaks-founders-case https://www.theguardian.com/media/2019/apr/11/julian-assange... Note that Assange was in the UK, in full reach of the authorities, for over a year before he claimed asylum in the Ecuadorian embassy. The story you're cooking up simply makes no sense in that context.
- beat 8y agoWhat does "makes sense" have to do with a conspiracy theory?
- ben509 8y ago> A charge of sexual misconduct will discredit him particular in the mostly-left-at-the-time circles that supported him. That was all pre #metoo when the left was happy to give their people a pass for sexual misconduct.
- _emacsomancer_ 8y agoPre-#metoo, I saw many people turn against Assange because of the accusation.
- AsyncAwait 8y ago> How does having Assange accused of rape in Sweden help the US to extradite him? Simple, character assassination is a very effective tool to silence public outrage.
- foldr 8y agoThat's classic conspiracy theory reasoning. "I can think of a reason the CIA might have done it; therefore, the CIA did it." There are far simpler ways of assassinating someone's character than manufacturing rape allegations in a foreign country.
- rndgermandude 8y agoLike? Genuinely curious.
- komali2 8y agoPlanting child pornography on a computer they own.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bellerose 8y agoCode that would modify the browser history to do such a thing was posted on hackernews a couple years ago. I just thought you would find that interesting. I'm undecided on what to think when it comes to julian.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoWell if it's just creating disapproval you want then you only need to plant the story in the press. [Fake] "Wikileaks computer IPs associated with child porn ring: was Assange using Wikileaks as cover for child porn, CIA revealed they found evidence of several Wikileaks computers uploading to child porn sites" That would probably be enough.
- chisleu 8y agoI don't know the truth of what happened either, but only 2 days after he applied for a residency two girls he slept with went to the police to try to "contact him to get him to get tested for STDs" and this turned into "rape and molestation" charges claiming his condom fell off and he didn't stop having sex with them. I can not tell if a condom falls off either unless I look, and I generally don't have sex with the light on. I'm not sure if I'm weird or not, but the investigation was closed. This is months after some of the biggest wikileaks releases including "collateral murder" and heading into the release of the Iraq War Logs and State Department Cables. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_material_published_by_WikiLeaks#2010 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_material_published_by_... Then a couple months later, based on no additional information, they reopened the investigation. He ended up going into the Ecuadorian Embassy soon after the release of "Global Intelligence Files" because the USA and private intelligence agencies were after him. None of this has anything to do with the rape charges though. He is being sent to the USA over the 2010 Manning releases because he was communicating with Manning while she was stealing the docs. If she wasn't such an attention whore, she wouldn't have even been arrested. She bragged about it on IRC...
- Tomte 8y agoHow do you reconcile your "only to tell him to get tested for STDs" with today's announcement by one victim's layer that she wants the rape case re-opened?
- chisleu 8y agoI don't need to reconcile the two. It's fact what they went to the police for originally. What they want now, is very different.
- tdcbfdct3 8y ago> claiming his condom fell off and he didn't stop having sex with them. One woman claims he intentionally tore a condom. That was a lesser charge whose statute of limitations expired a while ago. The other claims that, after insisting reportedly they use a condom, he waited for her to fall asleep and then started having unprotected see with her -- something he knew she would not consent to. That's the rape charge. > Then a couple months later, based on no additional information, they reopened the investigation. The alleged rape victim was initially overwhelmed (not uncommon for a rape victim) and didn't want to press charges. A few days (not months) later, she hired an attorney to represent her who got the case reopened. Almost all the information the public knows about the case has come directly from Assange (and thus supports his conspiracy theory explanation), since the Swedish protecting authority doesn't comment on pending cases.
- thefounder 8y agoOr could say USA tried all the dirty tricks
- foldr 8y agoThey tried the more complicated route before they tried the simple route? Assange was in the UK for approximately two years before he went into the embassy.
- throwawaylolx 8y agoPerhaps at the time that was the simpler route. It's been reported that the US intelligence agencies have been working on the extradition process in 2018, so the fact that this was easily done today doesn't mean it could've been done as easily then.
- foldr 8y agoWhy would extraditing him from Sweden be simpler? Under international law, the US would still have needed the UK's (as well as Sweden's) permission to extradite him from Sweden if he'd first been extradited from the UK to Sweden to face rape charges.
- throwawaylolx 8y agoNot simpler to extradite him then and there, but simpler to extradite him at some point in the future, assuming the investigation would've been successful Edit: HN doesn't let me reply so deep in a thread unless I wait like 20 minutes. It'd have been simpler if he were detained as they'd have had a guarantee of his jurisdiction and plan accordingly. I imagine having him arrested in a country that had allowed CIA extraordinary rendition would've been better for them than having him protected in Ecuadorian embassy.
- foldr 8y agoWhy would it be simpler in the future?
- armitron 8y agoThe rape charges helped to chip away at his character, isolate him and erode popular support. It's not hard to believe that intelligence services could do something like that. That's their MO.
- sneak 8y agoOne point, for accuracy: There were no rape charges.
- nikdaheratik 8y agoOr maybe he actually did it and deserves to go to prison for it. Hiding in a cupboard for seven years rather than going in and facing the charges is a good way to look guilty. Blaming "foreign spies" in an attempt to hide what you did so that you don't look as bad is the kind of thing an narcissistic toolbag might do. It is possible for Assange to be a bad guy and also for the U.S. going after him after all this time to also be unjust and bad. Not everything is a conspiracy and you don't necessarily have any "good" people when you start messing with international espionage and related areas.
- SkyBelow 8y ago"Need" and "helps improve the PR image of the action" are not synonymous. I am not saying it was the case or that the argument has merits. I am saying that the argument I've heard concerning this incident is not being fairly represented by the claim that the USA needed to manufacture crimes allegations in Sweden.
- boomboomsubban 8y agoWithout the rape allegations, what crime would have led to the UK arresting Assange, enabling him to be extradited? Even with the allegations, the process of extraditing him to Sweden took ages.
- DanBC 8y agoThe computer misuse crimes which the US is currently using to try to have him extradited on?
- foldr 8y agoHe can be arrested directly as a result of an extradition request. (If this weren't possible, it would rarely be possible to extradite anyone.) I think you're perhaps unaware that an extradition request is required to present evidence that the person in question has done something that is a crime under both US and UK law. It is not merely a request to move someone from one country to another.