12 ms·
Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Reviews Audio
- Despegar 8y agoWell what a coincidence https://twitter.com/matthewstoller/status/1115991653662195713 https://twitter.com/matthewstoller/status/111599165366219571...
- ipsum2 8y agoI don't work for Amazon or Google, but I agree with them in this case. I read through the full text of the bill (http://www.ilga.gov/legislation/fulltext.asp?DocName=&SessionId=108&GA=101&DocTypeId=SB&DocNum=1719&GAID=15&LegID=&SpecSess=&Session= http://www.ilga.gov/legislation/fulltext.asp?DocName=&Sessio...) and it seems like it sounds like the companies can be sued if one user agrees to a written policy, but then is used by another user (e.g. a spouse or sibling or friend), which makes smart speakers basically impossible to exist. (User identification isn't good enough, and even if it were, mistakes can happen) > No private entity may turn on or enable, cause to be turned on or enabled, or otherwise use a digital device's microphone to listen for or collect information, including spoken words or other audible or inaudible sounds, unless a user first agrees to a written policy informing the user[..]
- subway 8y ago> which makes smart speakers basically impossible to exist. Then perhaps in their current form, they shouldn't exist. It's already illegal to record people without their consent in many states. We shouldn't give up this right to privacy for a bit of convenience.
- bduerst 8y agoBy that logic, any device with a microphone and potential to record should not exist. Smart speakers are not telephone calls, and even if they were, federal law only requires consent of one party to record (11 states require all-party consent). In public spaces, you generally lose any right to consent to recording. If you're in someone else's home and they record you with their smart speaker device, then your beef is with that person whose private property you're being recorded on. Same as if they were recording you with their phone's camera in their private residence, vs recording you in a public space.
- tripzilch 8y agoUltimately what that boils down to is that if I don't want to be recorded, I should stay in my own home and not even visit anywhere, because only at home I can expect privacy. That's not privacy.
- subway 8y agoThe telephone is only relevant in some jurisdictions. For instance in Illlinois (an all-party state), you cannot record a private conversation. There's no mention of a phone or telecoms, and you should expect to get sued if you're in a conference room recording folks without their consent.
- bduerst 8y agoPrecisely - the person who owns the conference room and placed the device there should expect to get sued. The person who manufactured the device shouldn't since they didn't use the device to break the law. The owner of the private property did. It's the same with phone and security cameras - the manufacturers are not the ones at fault when the devices are incorrectly used by owners in states with specific legal laws regarding recording.
- subway 8y agoImagine how long the devices would stay on the market if owners started being held liable for what the device does. I'm not suggesting the device be made illegal, but I do think a ton of common applications should be... and without those applications, the device loses viability.
- bduerst 8y agoI imagine they will face the same market consequences that smart phones, security cameras, and other devices that have the potential to be used to record people in private places currently face. Customers with a low tolerance for being recorded simply just won't buy.
- scarejunba 8y agoWait, you can just not give this up by not buying one and not hanging out with your friends who have these. Why do you want to impose this on the rest of us? Why can't I just let people give me this useful service in my own home?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- DaniloDias 8y agoHow does one develop such confidence prescribing what other people should or shouldn’t do? Are you some kind of cop or a priest?
- spunker540 8y agoI think all it means is everyone with a smart speaker should have a sign on their front door informing all who enter that “conversations may be monitored”. Realistically though don’t a lot of stores have cameras and mics lawfully recording for security purposes? Are they all legally obligated to post warnings?
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y ago> Realistically though don’t a lot of stores have cameras and mics lawfully recording for security purposes? Are they all legally obligated to post warnings? Yes, at least here in the UK.
- Varcht 8y agoIn the US there is the concept of "Expectation of Privacy" [0] so it depends. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expectation_of_privacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expectation_of_privacy
- etruong42 8y agoThe link elaborates that this concept is enshrined in the US Constitution Bill of Rights (4th amendment), so it covers government surveillance. It is not directly applicable to private entities using recording devices.
- Varcht 8y agoI am not an attorney but this guy is https://attorney-myers.com/2013/11/surveillance_cameras_reasonable_expectation_privacy/ https://attorney-myers.com/2013/11/surveillance_cameras_reas...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- thatoneuser 8y agoSo? Just because a billionaire tech company is inconvenienced by privacy laws doesn't mean they should be able to ignore them.
- MetalGuru 8y ago> inaudible sounds What?
- ChrisGranger 8y agoHumans have a fairly limited frequency range in which they can hear, typically said to be 20 Hz to 20 kHz, but usually worse than that for most people. There's all kinds of sound in the world that is inaudible to humans.
- ipsum2 8y agoTV ads emit inaudible (to humans) sounds to track which ads are being viewed. https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/11/beware-of-ads-that-use-inaudible-sound-to-link-your-phone-tv-tablet-and-pc/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/11/beware-of-ads-th...
- learc83 8y agoCan average TV speakers emit sounds outside the frequency of human hearing? I didn't think they could.
- godelski 8y agoYes, most speakers are 20Hz-20kHz or better. Here's a pair of $10 headphones that do just that[0]. Most humans have range inside that band. Those both are really the limits of human hearing and as you get older it dramatically decreases. I remember there were those ringtones (IIRC called cricket?) that used high frequencies so teachers wouldn't hear it go off. Some malls also used high frequency sounds so teens wouldn't loiter outside their stores. Most of these were even below 18kHz. tldr: yes [0]https://smile.amazon.com/Earphones-Earbuds-Headphones-Premium-Compatible/dp/B07PT3R6TN/ref=sr_1_4?keywords=headphones&qid=1554964160&s=gateway&sr=8-4 https://smile.amazon.com/Earphones-Earbuds-Headphones-Premiu...
- rmac 8y agoThe Google speech API supports Speaker Diarization and Android supports voice unlock so they are getting to a point where they are able to ID voices and should be able to tell which voice has consented to being recorded.
- cortesoft 8y agoBut doesn't it have to record the voice to be able to identify it? Once the sound waves are converted to a format that the machine can process, it has been recorded.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoTo my knowledge, we've generally recognized a difference between recording and immediate processing. Does a voice changer "record" you, if it adjusts the audio on the fly and doesn't store anything? VoIP phones arguably "record" the audio from your microphone and transfer it over the line to output to another party, but we don't call that recording either. I think the biggest issue here is how smart speakers work: They record your audio and then send it to be permanently stored on Google, Amazon, or Apple's servers, rather than being processed locally and discarded, which we have the technology to do just fine today. The only reason we're retaining voice recordings is to provide valuable data to the companies in question.
- nl 8y agoRecording implies storage. It's possible to do voice ID on device and discard any non-matched data.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- justtopost 8y agoYou can't discard data that is not stored.
- 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gameswithgo 8y ago>which makes smart speakers basically impossible to exist Aha! Exactly. However, you could make a smart speaker that doesn't transmit the audio to a server.
- sys_64738 8y agoIt's usually good for a company to listen to what their customers are saying. This time, not so much.
- nathankunicki 8y agoI mean, is this really news? We know that Amazon records the clips of what you say to Alexa for the purposes of improving the recognition. Everything after you say "Alexa..." How would they tell whether their models are right or wrong without listening and having someone compare? I see nothing in this article to suggest the clips they're listening to are related to an always-on microphone.
- Anechoic 8y agoEverything after you say "Alexa..." It's everything after the product thinks you said "Alexa".
- meowface 8y agoThat's probably one of the only competitive advantages of Bixby. That's likely not going to get misheard very often. Though I guess "OK Google" is probably hard to mishear, too.
- wongarsu 8y agoI use the word google a lot in other contexts simply because they are a big company with lots of services, and they happen to make the (tech) news quite often. So only the word OK would have to be misheard. Bixby seems safer in this regard.
- macintux 8y agoNot so sure about that. Google has now become a verb, not hard to imagine false positives.
- meowface 8y agoTrue, I imagine its false positive rate is higher than Bixby's. But I think the specific combination of "o-kay-goo-gull" probably doesn't clash with too many things; even when talking about Google. But my Alexa seems to pick up all sorts of words vaguely sounding like Alexa when I play videos.
- qiqing 8y agoA few choice excerpts: "Sometimes they hear recordings they find upsetting, or possibly criminal. Two of the workers said they picked up what they believe was a sexual assault. When something like that happens, they may share the experience in the internal chat room as a way of relieving stress. Amazon says it has procedures in place for workers to follow when they hear something distressing, but two Romania-based employees said that, after requesting guidance for such cases, they were told it wasn’t Amazon’s job to interfere." "Amazon, in its marketing and privacy policy materials, doesn’t explicitly say humans are listening to recordings of some conversations picked up by Alexa. “We use your requests to Alexa to train our speech recognition and natural language understanding systems,” the company says in a list of frequently asked questions."
- mintplant 8y agoSounds like the setup for a Sorry, Wrong Number [0] of the modern age. > https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sorry,_Wrong_Number https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sorry,_Wrong_Number
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rootsudo 8y agoThis could work as a short film as most of these human labor arbitrage opportunities exist in emerging economies where they're considered "good" jobs. Such as the Philippines, or Eastern Europe.
- mirimir 8y agoPeople sometimes say alarming things as part of sex play.
- starpilot 8y agoSometimes they don't.
- 8y ago
- tibiahurried 8y agoAre people really surprised about this? I never bought and never going to buy any of these devices. I don't use social media etc ... It is that simple.
- monochromatic 8y agoI’m shocked. Shocked!
- anitil 8y agoI don't think the sarcasm is warranted, because as technical people, we already implicitly understand how the system works. I was listening to Reply All [0] yesterday, and one of the hosts had to explain to the other that, of course, the device has to listen to you to constantly in some fashion in order to know if you've said 'Alexa' or 'OK Google' or whatever. It hadn't even occurred to me that people wouldn't know that. [0] https://www.gimletmedia.com/reply-all/139-the-reply-all-hotline#episode-player https://www.gimletmedia.com/reply-all/139-the-reply-all-hotl...
- codedokode 8y agoI think the problem is not that the device is listening. The problem is that users' recording and seacrh queries are saved to the cloud, stored indefinitely and reviewed by other people. And some users might even not realise it and think that they are just talking to a robot, not to a team of Amazon's employees.
- anitil 8y agoYou're right, of course. I think I was just reacting to the tone of the earlier comment
- julienreszka 8y agoWhy do you assume this is sarcasm?
- masko 8y agoNo surprise there
- make3 8y agoI don't mind not buying a Google Home it whatever, but is Google listening on my "Ok Google" enabled Android phone as well?
- nstart 8y agoI can't recall the google settings screen but you can review everything that google has picked up. I reviewed mine and while most were ok there were a good number of private conversations with my wife that google had randomly picked up. Most of them sounded like stuff I was saying while driving. Which means that it was purely based on what android thought it had heard vs any manual input. I can only assume google home will have similar moments.
- NikkiA 8y agoGo to https://myaccount.google.com/data-and-personalization https://myaccount.google.com/data-and-personalization then click on 'Audio and Voice Activity'
- tomrod 8y agoYou should be able to see the services (daemons) in Developer mode.
- _underfl0w_ 8y agoHow else would it catch the words "Ok, Google" in the first place?
- gipp 8y agoAll these things have dedicated low-power hardware that just listens for the trigger phrase and has no network access. That's why you can't choose your trigger phrase.
- make3 8y agooffline (on device) model for that only instead of cloud based. I'm a deep learning researcher, and that can be done for sure
- davidhyde 8y agoThe Bloomberg cookie banner is such a dark pattern (literally) it’s laughable. Can’t tell yes from no with the buttons.
- thatoneuser 8y agoIdk about everyone else here but for a while now and forever more when I see people in the comments justifying tech companies immoral behavior I assume its shills. Whether directly paid or whether the companies have propaganda campaigns that just get idle commenter on their side.
- whoisjuan 8y agoAmazon apart, what's inmmoral about labeling data that you got with the consent of the user? It's hard to appreciate what you are saying when you're basically judging the incentive of economic/technological progress as an inmmoral behavior (in this case the intention of improving a technology) Labeling data and training a machine learning model sounds far from inmoral. Perhaps for some people the idea of companies developing machine learning models and capturing data to train them is an ethically gray concept.
- AlexandrB 8y ago> Amazon apart, what's inmmoral about labeling data that you got with the consent of the user? They don't have my consent and I'm increasingly surrounded by the damn things. Take a look at the comments about hotels, new condos, etc. that have Alexa or Google Home installed. And, of course, friends and family.
- thatoneuser 8y agoWhen did I give anyone consent? Because I used a monopoly's search engine? Because Facebook has data on me when I don't have an account? And more to the point - what kind of hell is this where getting permission to my data where I have no say on the unethical ways they use it? You're doing exactly what I'm saying with the shilling tho.
- Analog24 8y agoEveryone who disagrees with you is a shill. Got it.
- 8y ago
- jpm_sd 8y agoPeople in the sixties: "I better not say that or the government will wiretap my house." Today: "Hey, wiretap, do you have a recipe for pancakes?" https://twitter.com/andreacoravos/status/999761670540025856?lang=en https://twitter.com/andreacoravos/status/999761670540025856?...
- wise_young_man 8y agoSeems like a false equivalence. First, a corporation is not the same as the government. Second, the government wiretapping your house is a violation of your constitutional rights, whereas you freely choosing to add a smart device into your home is not.
- codedokode 8y agoA corporation can give or sell your data to the government.
- cortesoft 8y agoAlthough Motel 6 just got in trouble for doing that https://abcnews.go.com/US/motel-pay-12m-settle-lawsuit-sharing-guest-info/story?id=62239566 https://abcnews.go.com/US/motel-pay-12m-settle-lawsuit-shari...
- codedokode 8y agoInteresting case. What surprises me most is that the lawsuit was filed by Washington's Attorney General which is technically also a part of the government. Probably that is because he was elected rather than appointed.
- PherricOxide 8y agoIt’s called “supervised” machine learning for a reason... The important part is that tens of millions of people used Alexa everyday and the utterances are anonymized before being used as training data, so you don’t know who said what, just that somewhere someone said “blah”.
- jammygit 8y agoI'm sure their anonymization policy is un-misleading as their terms around whether employees listen to Alexa commands
- jstanley 8y agoHow have we got to the point where someone listening via a microphone inside my house is fine as long as it's not real-time?
- kevinsundar 8y agoEveryone who owns one of these devices has given express permission and must know. Its fine since they have told Amazon its fine
- happytoexplain 8y agoIt's antagonistic and obviously misleading to state that a person has given explicit permission to a company without any further explanation when the reality you're basing that on is that the permission was in the wording of a contract that person clicked "agree" on. You may insist all day that this person was irresponsible in examining the contract, which I will also disagree with, but claiming that they have given explicit permission is a lie on your part, and I would have a hard time believing that you don't know that.
- carnagii 8y ago> utterances are anonymized if only we had some technology that could identify a speaker based on their voice. oh, wait a second. but, lol, no, they aren't anonymized ... "recordings sent to the Alexa auditors don’t provide a user’s full name and address but are associated with an account number, as well as the user’s first name and the device’s serial number"
- tomrod 8y agoHotels in Seattle used for flyins by $bigtechco have Alexas. I unplugged it for one flyin. The housekeeper plugged it back in while I was out. I unplugged it again. Why in the world would I want any of these smart speakers?
- stock_toaster 8y agoAgreed. It's almost spooky how friends, family, hotels, and other places that used to be considered "private/semi-private" now have microphones listening all the time, in plain sight. Most people don't even notice or seem to care.
- wingerlang 8y agoThey probably trust that the company doesn't use it for bad stuff, combined with the fact that they likely have pretty "normal lives" I guess.
- epanchin 8y agoIsn’t it crazy how worked up people get about Alexa, etc., conviently forgetting about the always on microphone they’re carrying around with them every day.
- thatoneuser 8y agoDeliberate obfuscation is the only way to have privacy...
- jumbopapa 8y agoI know people that have said "I don't care about my Alexa because I have my phone all the time anyways", but I think this is really the wrong way to approach privacy. They're just accepting their fate without any type of recourse. I am a fan of Android and it's what I use, but I don't like the privacy concerns. Maybe I'll switch to iOS soon. I'm not patient enough to try to use a device like the Librem phone either.
- stock_toaster 8y ago
- rocky1138 8y agoEarlier today someone made a tongue-in-cheek comment about https://notnews.ycombinator.com https://notnews.ycombinator.com. I thought it was flippant, but here this article's title proves that it was prescient, instead.
- intopieces 8y ago>Millions more are reluctant to invite the devices and their powerful microphones into their homes out of concern that someone might be listening. Sometimes, someone is. This wording is misleading, because it sounds like someone is listening through the device as the speech is being picked up by it, but in fact it's recordings.
- jakevn 8y agoWhat is a recording? Does a 10 millisecond delay mean it is a recording? What is the legally binding lock-out time for this audio stream before a human can listen to it?
- intopieces 8y agoA recording is end pointed audio captured and stored on a server and reviewed later. There is no legally binding lock out time because there doesn’t need to be. Live-listening is impractical at scale and also worthless for what the article is describing they do with the data. Remember, this work is being done to make it so humans don’t have to be in the loop.
- jakevn 8y agoWhy is live-listening impractical at scale? How can Discord provide such a service? You seem to be conflating Amazon's intent with the unknowable intent of anyone that can touch such data, which is a common fatal flaw in reasoning.
- intopieces 8y ago>Why is live-listening impractical at scale? Because there is no value in doing so. A person could collect all the spare change thrown into fountains at shopping malls, but they don’t.
- julienreszka 8y ago
- matz1 8y agoAs a user its not just I don't mind but I expect them to do so, at least to improve the product.
- AlexandrB 8y agoAs I bystander, I expect them to never record my voice since it's against my express wishes. Only one of us ever gets what he wants. Doesn't seem fair.
- cortesoft 8y agoThis is the case all the time, though. You get recorded by CCTV cameras everywhere you go, even if you don't want them to.
- baroffoos 8y agoIn a public place I expect some level of privacy intrusions. CCTV cameras aren't so bad in public as long as the recordings are only stored for a few weeks and the data is not analyised unless there is reason to believe it contains evidence. For example its acceptable to access the video to prove someone stole from your store but it is not acceptable to use facial recognition on your cctv to see who your best customers are.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sp527 8y agoIt is in my opinion absolutely unacceptable that this submission was originally the article title and that was subsequently changed, presumably to defuse it. Someone needs to clarify when the norm of using the submission title applies, when it’s thrown out, why it’s thrown out, and who gets to decide. In my opinion, the only sensible approach is for the title policy to be unilaterally enforced. Any departure from it will invariably involve someone’s subjective ‘political’ stance on a matter. As it stands, it looks as if someone at Amazon applied pressure to have this changed. I really hope that isn’t the case because it’s almost too shady to be believed.
- HNthrow22 8y agonvm
- whoisjuan 8y agoI agree with you to certain extent. I think the problem with titles directly out of the article is that many times they are bait. The writers of those articles are purposefully leaving key information out, to grab people's attention and likely force them to read the entire article to find the missing information or fulfill the title entice. In this case I think the change of title is definitely defusing the article, but it's also giving the key information that was left out in the bait title. I agree with you because changing the original title feels like a disruption of the discourse and opens a bias door for whoever changes the title. But, I also believe that bait titles erode the quality of the content and make harder to consume and evaluate information. It's a hard problem.
- sp527 8y agoI disagree almost entirely on the basis of that being a ludicrous sort of infantilization, as if this community can’t be trusted to sort fact from fiction and must instead be coddled towards the “correct” interpretation.
- whyaduck 8y agoApologies to the poor folks reviewing audio, but the only room my Echo is allowed in is the bathroom.
- culturestate 8y agoNo joke, part of me believes that bathrooms (and kitchens, to a lesser degree) are the first places voice-controlled smart home tech will really take off. My place is about as smart as it can be today but it's still mostly a novelty. Once people can perform actually useful tasks with their voice - "hey siri, turn the shower on to 40 degrees" or "alexa, preheat the oven to 300" - while their hands are full doing something else it'll kickstart the whole field.
- julienreszka 8y agoThis sounds dangerous.
- culturestate 8y agoHow so? The device could always require confirmation for hazardous commands - "are you sure you want me to turn the oven on?" Most already do this for e.g. deleting calendar appointments anyway.
- julienreszka 8y agoThis could be hacked and burn you.
- culturestate 8y agoI mean....there will be a future in which voice data is processed locally rather than in the cloud. Nobody said this stuff has to be connected to the internet.
- julienreszka 8y ago
- torqueTorrent 8y agoShouldn't people be having fun with or trolling these always-listening systems by speaking gibberish, in tongues or reciting custom sea shanties that reenact purely fictional accounts of high crimes on the open seas?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- api 8y agoI was reading a while ago about how many nukes we set off in the 50s and 60s and thought: what are we doing today that future generations will think "what were they thinking?" Surveillance capitalism was the first thing to come to mind.
- gipp 8y agoFor better or worse, I expect the opposite will happen. Future generations simply will not have the same expectations and fears around privacy. The modern Western conceptions of privacy are relatively anomalous from a historical perspective. There's nothing to stop them from changing again.
- api 8y agoWhat's happening now is totally different from the lack of privacy experienced in a tribe or a close knit village. This is top down panopticon surveillance where an opaque eye spies on everyone on behalf of a complex of corporations, advertisers, criminals, and governments. The lack of privacy in a village was reciprocal. This is completely asymmetrical and exploitative.
- novia 8y agoYou might find this video interesting: https://youtu.be/LLCF7vPanrY https://youtu.be/LLCF7vPanrY Shows every nuke set off between 1945 to 1998.
- julienreszka 8y agoWhy did you add capitalism to surveillance?
- api 8y agoI was using it as a technical term more than a political one. Capital is a rough synonym for assets, but "surveillance asset accumulation" is clunky. The capital being amassed here is information about people. That capital can be leveraged to control and manipulate for both economic and political reasons and can be used by both (politically) capitalist and less capitalist authoritarian regimes.
- tamaharbor 8y agoI used to listen to cell phone calls on my scanner. Fact is, most people are pretty boring.
- throwawayjay01 8y agoThere's an interesting disconnect from pieces like this and those demanding that tech companies monitor every piece of content on their networks.
- OrgNet 8y agoAmazon products are the worst if you are concerned about privacy (their tablets are awful)... Google probably comes at a close 2nd and Huawei maybe 20th? (that's a wild guess but Amazon is hard to beat)
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoPresumably Apple are the best in your totally impartial and unbiased opinion, right?
- OrgNet 8y agoApple is better at PR for sure... but we have seen in the past that they lie about sharing your information with the government...
- sib 8y agoWow - really? I'd say that Facebook is far, far, far worse than Amazon. And Google is certainly worse as well. Look at the data collection on Android phones, for example. At least Amazon, from day 1 of the Echo/Alexa launch, noted clearly (not in small print, but right there in pictures on the product detail page) that the user's voice was going up to the cloud. And provided a microphone-off switch right on top of the device. Where's the mic-off button on your (typical) Android or iOS phone?
- lfaoro 8y agoHave you thought how funny it is that Amazon is using people in order to train AI to get a competitive advantage?
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoHow else would they train AI?
- visarga 8y agoNo, I haven't, because that's how all ML models learn. It's called supervised learning and supervision comes in the form of labels produced by human taggers. It's not something special that only Amazon Alexa does. Tagging is as necessary in ML as data entry in accounting.
- tribeofone 8y agoyou've got to be a moron to have one of these in your house
- Arn_Thor 8y agoAnother reason to support on-device audio processing coughApplecough
- paulcarroty 8y agoFacebook is using smartphones to listen to what people say: https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/news/facebook-using-people-s-phones-to-listen-in-on-what-they-re-saying-claims-professor-a7057526.html https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/ne... A lot of people said Facebook ads suggest them products or services debated on phone calls. If you have Echo or Kindle Fire TV, guess it can be easily reproduced when Amazon really listening and analyze your voice.
- skocznymroczny 8y ago"A lot of people said" is not enough for a proof. What might be happening, is that Alice and Bob are friends. Bob spends some time researching a topic, say looking for a new car of brand X. He calls Alice and tells her about him wanting to buy a car of brand X. Some time later, Alice sees ads for car of brand X. Now, it could have been FB listening on the phone call. But there's another possibility - FB knows that Alice and Bob are friends, and it knows Bob likes brand X, so it assumes that a friend of Bob will be interested in brand X.
- everydayworks 8y agoI could see it working like that. However, the best way to figure out is to just test it. Talk about something random and see if those ads popup on your feed. I did it on my own and well, the results came out to be true or a really big coincidence.
- lm28469 8y agoI think people underestimate the number of data points fb/google has access to. Many of these examples can be explained by other things. Receiving baby items ads while no one knows your wife is pregnant ? Well maybe she googled a brand of baby strollers and fb used its graph + the fact that you're at the same location everyday after work to determine you're her husband. Receiving ads for a small music band you only heard at that open mic night you randomly joined 3 days ago ? There probably was an event on fb with the list of bands that played that night + logged in the bar wifi. With the number of people in the "hacker" community who want to prove fb and google are bad we'd already have real technical proof of it happening. Either they send the data back to a server and process it there, or process it on the device directly, both of which should be fairly easy to detect.
- gerbilly 8y agoAi is so pnambic right now.¹ We are flooded with hype about AI, but they seldom mention the armies of people it takes to get it working and to keep it working. Even members f the public are recruited to train AI system without their knowledge, i.e.: captcha google translate suggestions. Sounds more like a smokescreen for normal human intelligence to me. 1: http://www.jargon.net/jargonfile/p/pnambic.html http://www.jargon.net/jargonfile/p/pnambic.html
- b_tterc_p 8y agoI know someone who does this. Some people use Alexa to text so they get a bunch of sexts. Many, many people just like to say the worst things they can think of to try and get Alexa to say something anti Semitic or what not.
- dekhn 8y agoI think this sort of process, assuming the privacy and security teams have their say, is an absolutely legitimate part of product improvement.
- neilv 8y agoDon't the people developing these speech/AI methods generally have advanced degrees? In that case, shouldn't they be aware, from the same grad school training that prepared them for this work, that a (genuine) human subjects board would require informed consent for this, at the least? Do they have informed consent?
- dekhn 8y agoI am both an Ex-Googler and a PhD researcher (working with human data). You don't require informed consent in this case, it's not human subjects research, and the terms of service cover this already. What is being done is completely legal and if people don't like it, they're free not to use the service.
- neilv 8y agoHow is this not human subjects research? And is modern consumer "terms of service" the human subjects ethical standard for corporate researchers?
- dekhn 8y agobecause humans aren't the subject of research here, instead they are data providers. The alexa product is the subject of research here (and it's not research, it's product improvement). I don't understand your question about terms of service and ethics here. I work with real human subjects research data and it's a completely different field that does not apply to this situation.
- rogerdickey 8y agoIs this supposed to be sinister? They need to QA the product they are building so it's a better experience for customers.
- Simulacra 8y agoI accept that Amazon, Google, etc. are likely listening to me with computer AI, but the fact the employees could pass these around causes some worry. It's like when I worked my first job at AOL and people would read Rosie O'Donnell's mail and chats. The human element is more troubling than the AI.