16 ms·
Something on Mars Is Producing Gas Usually Made by Living Things on Earth
- manjana 8y agoMostly old news really..
- droithomme 8y agoYes, it's been known for decades. Perhaps the new news is the latest sighting and that now it's accepted as fact. It peaks in the warmer months. Many Martian meteorites have been found on Earth, and it's likely that earth meteorites have made their way to Mars. We know that algae can survive in space and extreme conditions. It would be unexpected if simple life from earth had not made its way to mars from time to time. It would be interesting if it continued to survive there. The methane and its seasonality is possible evidence of this. Reasonable targets for future Mars missions are craters where methane is known to accumulate.
- dekhn 8y agofor life to have moved from one planet to another is unlikely: it's the product of life being on the rock on the source planet in the first place, multiplied by the probability the rock gets ejected into space, that the life survives a journal, and that it lands on a planet where it can survive. All of those are extremely tiny probabilities (but nobody denies the mass exchange between planets).
- bluGill 8y agoSlow down. There is life pretty much everywhere on earth. The probability the life is on a rock ejected into space is nearly 100%. Only when we get to life surviving the journey that we have and doubt, but even then there are a lot of different single cell lifeforms on that rock and we only need one to survive. If that one survives the space journey odds are it can survive on mars as well.
- novaRom 8y agoI cannot read this article because of: "You're in private mode. Log in or create a free New York Times account to continue reading in private mode". How NYTimes knows I am in private mode?
- karmakaze 8y agoGoogling "detect incognito stackoverflow" finds a question answered "The FileSystem API is disabled in incognito mode."
- mcv 8y agoMaybe they shouldn't disable it, but simply fake it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- munk-a 8y agoNow that people are using it to detect incognito mode they probably should...
- vinniejames 8y agoThey plan to deprecate it
- ForHackernews 8y agoNo cookies? Access to local storage disabled?
- wanone 8y agoWorked for me in Firefox private browsing
- gibybo 8y agoAlso worked for me in Chrome's incognito
- aranw 8y agoSpace cows
- interfixus 8y agoIf life - present or past - is one day found on Mars, I shall be hugely surprised if it doesn't share our basic DNA. Interplanetary pollution - pollination, if you will - or common influx from somewhere entirely else.
- karmakaze 8y agoHistory repeats itself. So many times a group of people on earth thought they were alone (a tribe, a region, an island, a continent), they were wrong. Earth is our current island, scale it up. Chances are when we find other life, it will share a common source with us. There's likely other life that doesn't but the closer ones probably do.
- everdev 8y agoMaybe we are the "uncontacted tribe". I wonder at what point when you're observing an isolated tribe do they demonstrate enough advances that it's OK to contact them? Or do you just wait until they discover the observer?
- bluGill 8y agoI doubt we are observed. Space is really really big - even bigger than that... Are first radio signals have barely reached 100 light years by now (you a great antenna to received them). All other intelligent beings know about earth is what they can infer from how our gravity changes the sun, and other such indirect measures.
- karmakaze 8y agoIf we're not currently odds are we will be--given N tribes, we're only 1.
- Symmetry 8y agoOn the other hand we haven't been able to establish a firm minimum amount of time from when Earth got oceans to when it got life. It took a long, long time to add photosynthesis to cemosynthesis, a long long time to create eukaryotes, and a long, long time to create multicellular life. I made a timeline: http://hopefullyintersting.blogspot.com/2018/03/the-drake-equation-again.html http://hopefullyintersting.blogspot.com/2018/03/the-drake-eq... Interplanetary pollution seems to happen pretty quickly compared to the history of life but I'm not sure we can say that it happens quickly compared to the start of life. Of course for all we know the reason Earth developed life so quickly was that it was seeded by the quicker-cooling Mars which had had Oceans before Earth did. More research is needed!
- rjf72 8y agoOne of the many things that really reemphasizes how limited remote technology such as probes and rovers really are. As the article mentions this has been known about for about 6 years. Having rovers do what they were designed to do is very difficult, having them try to explore previously unknown phenomena is generally just not really possible. Consider for instance water on the moon. When was this discovery finally confirmed once and for all? It didn't happen until 2009! [1] And the discovery of water-ice only happened in 2018. These are 'obvious' surface level characteristics, yet we're only confirming them some 60 years after our brief dalliance with manned exploration. It's incredible to think about all the things that we've yet to discover but eventually will once we start getting indefinite bases setup across various destinations. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_water https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_water
- sfifs 8y agoMaybe something went via the numerous landers that have visited Mars over past 4 decades?
- sholladay 8y agoIt annoys me that there wasn't even a mention of the mere possibility that we may have contaminated the planet with the microbes in question. Sterilizing complex machinery is difficult and absolute sterilization of spacecraft has never been a goal of any space agency. Then we find out the microbes are probably in an area where one of our rovers has been exploring for a few years and you have to wonder. Granted, it does seem unlikely, and perhaps the microbes are indeed under the ice and have been since before we got there. But it seems irresponsible to not even consider contamination as a potential cause when we can clearly connect the dots to how that could have happened.
- ConfusedDog 8y agoIt could also be other aliens contaminated Mars. Just saying... if we are talking about possibilities rather than probabilities. If it is us, we probably will find out later anyway, no need to get too emotional about an article.
- hughes 8y agoWhatever process is causing the presence of methane can apparently produce hundreds of thousands of tonnes of the gas in a relatively short timeframe. Considering that spacecraft have only landed on Mars in the last few decades, a contaminant microbe would have to truly thrive in an extremely inhospitable Martian environment, survive spaceflight and decontamination, yet also be undetectable in the places on Earth where the spacecraft was constructed. Yes, it's possible, but it seems so beyond the realm of probability...
- strlen 8y ago> contaminant microbe would have to truly thrive in an extremely inhospitable Martian environment, survive spaceflight and decontamination, yet also be undetectable in the places on Earth where the spacecraft was constructed To be fair, if those possibilities are true, they would also be revolutionary and should be considered (e.g., do they imply a mechanism that makes panspemria feasible?). Likewise for an previously unknown mechanism of methane production - this itself would help us understand the origin of life. (This is one explanation, "geological" one, mentioned in the article.) "Single celled microorganisms found to exist in conditions on Mars that mirror some of the conditions in which single celled microogranisms exist on Earth", however, seems to be a more boring one - if turns out not to be true, understanding why that happens to be the case, is also valuable.
- LifeLiverTransp 8y agoImagine there are ozeans, and they slowly dry away, evaporatintg to space. The water gets more saltier with every season, uvw rays grill what ever is left of your living space. All you can do is sleep through longer and longer winters in this brine, waiting for the sun to thaw the salty mud. Or you retreat, using some weak smoker in the depths as a provider of energy, following it ever deeper down, the world freeze drying behind you. I know its frowned upon by some, but imagine we could create a sort of floating spirondella, and set them free in venus atmosphere. Venus beeing a dead planet, cooled by a floating forrest sounds actually more realistic to me terraformingwise then changing mars.
- m_mueller 8y agoThe problem with Venus cloud cities is the cost of getting any solid material and lack of exploration. The technological threshold to reach sustainability seems much higher, even though initial conditions are better, especially gravity.
- LifeLiverTransp 8y agoI think life would pretty much solve that problem rather quick (on a cosmic scale) - life has been regulating pretty well here on earth.
- Fej 8y agoWhat's the chances that bacteria from Earth made it over on the rovers? I understand that NASA takes great pains to prevent this but they can't get every single one, surely? Especially extremophiles?