7 ms·
A fun lession in dilution: Logan Green and John Zimmer, the co-founders of Lyft, will each have about $500M in stock at $72. (Edit: I miscalculated the holdin
by jedberg 8y ago
A fun lession in dilution:
Logan Green and John Zimmer, the co-founders of Lyft, will each have about $500M in stock at $72.
(Edit: I miscalculated the holdings of the cofounders at $85M because I didn't account for their class B shares. However, I think my point still stands for the most part).
Google holds $900M in Lyft stock. A16Z holds $1B in Lyft stock. GM and Fidelity have $1.3B. Rakuten Europe has $2.2B.
$500M is certainly a life-changing outcome, but it's interesting how we value the capital that those companies put in far more than we value the years of work those two put in.
Edit 2: To be clear, this isn't a complaint in any way. What A16Z and Google and the rest did for Lyft is highly valuable and worthy of compensation.
This is simply a commentary on the relative value of capital vs labor.
- cma 8y ago> far more than we value the years of work those two put in. They did all the work, or they hired employees to do lots of it with the capital?
- jedberg 8y agoThat's fair. How do we figure out the total employee holdings?
- nostrademons 8y agoThe employees got paid in cash, (largely) not stock, because that's the deal they took. Equity investors exist because most people would rather work for cash than for stock. Typically, the way the money flows is that college endowments & pension funds put cash into VC funds in exchange for equity; VC funds put cash into startups in exchange for equity; startups use that cash to pay salaries; and employees who receive those salaries spend a portion on college tuition, gifts to their alma mater, retirement savings, etc. that then gets recycled back into institutional finance. If the startup ends up being worth more than the money put in (either because they turn a profit or because they can convince some greater sucker to take that equity off their hands), the excess is returned to the VC fund in proportion to their ownership stake & liquidation preferences, who take 20% for their GPs and distribute the rest of it back to their LPs, who use it to fund scholarships or buy a new building or pay for your parents' retirement. If you can convince employees to work for you for equity, you don't need VCs at all: you give them shares, and when the company has a liquidity event, everybody benefits. Most people don't take that bargain, though, because they don't have confidence that the equity will be worth anything and need to eat in the meantime. The premium VCs get is precisely because people are risk averse. If all companies were public and everyone were willing to work for equity, that premium would be arbitraged down to nearly nothing, but then we'd probably be complaining about how certain unscrupulous actors managed to convince people to accept equity of their worthless company and now those people can't eat because they were bilked out of just compensation for their labor. (The crypto economy basically functions like this, with various tokens acting as pseudo-equity in the "economy" that grows in value as the surrounding ecosystem grows and these tokens being freely tradeable on exchanges - and it suffers from precisely this failure mode, where it turns out that unforgeable tokens != unbreakable promises.)
- auspex 8y agoAlso, you can't work for just equity in California any more... you have to paid at least minimum wage now, unless you are a founder.
- tomp 8y ago> Most people don't take that bargain, though, because they don't have confidence that the equity will be worth anything and need to eat in the meantime. No, I think the reason is different, and it's quite rational. Diversification. VCs invest in 10(0)s of startups, but an employee is only employed by one, and his/her job depends on the success of that one startup. It makes sense to take whatever money you can, and invest it in other start-ups (or equity markets). It would be much more fair of course if "normal" people were able to invest in start-ups, or at least in VCs. (AFAIK currently only "sophisticated investors" can.)
- wickedsmile 8y agoBut isn't labor a commodity and ground breaking innovation not?
- jonny_eh 8y agoThe employees aren't responsible for any innovation?
- lotsofpulp 8y agoBarring corruption, compensation is usually commensurate with how much risk your capital takes.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoHow many startups are in the latest YC batch? An enormous amount compared to previous batches. “Innovation” is a commodity because it’s just become product market fit testing through brute force.
- confiscate 8y agoya, but testing for product-market fit is much more uncertain than buying/providing labor. It's still harder
- mathattack 8y agoThe lesson here is that the business was very capital-intensive. In these situations, an overcapitalizdd company beats an undercapitalized one. The founders could have kept a larger share of a much smaller pie.
- gcbw2 8y agoThe work they put in still can't solve the constant need for cash to keep the lights on, so?
- jedberg 8y agoI'm not denying that the capital has a ton of value for the company. Without it the company would have failed long ago. But I'm just making a commentary on the relative value of the capital vs. the work.
- zaroth 8y agoTwo people. Working for less than 10 years each. Spending billions of dollars of other people’s money. Speaking as a Founder myself.... Honestly their stake is too damn high. They didn’t do 0.001% of the work required to build the company. Could you make the case they even had some unique skill or insight that meant they were providing even 1% of the business value? They were just first. And they weren’t even the first with the idea of how to build a “Lyft”. They were just the first on this particular cap table.
- pytyper2 8y agoThey also owned the company, this means something.
- empath75 8y agoThe capital invested represents the accumulated work of a lot of other people.
- wickedsmile 8y agoAnd capital is acquired for free? Think it this way, the work of founders which got them their share of capital will be used as investment in some other company. Or are you trying to claim the capital invested in this company by investors was acquired for free without putting in any work or risk?
- ykevinator 8y ago
- nodesocket 8y agoHuge win for A16Z. Logan and John ended up owning the same amount of shares each all the way through the rounds, is that typical?
- mrnobody_67 8y agoYou don't lose shares with funding rounds... new shares get created, thus lowering the percentage ownership of everybody.
- smallgovt 8y agoI'm confident these guys already cashed out a large fraction of their holdings in prior rounds.
- jedberg 8y agoSure but let's assume they already cashed out even $85M. They still made way less than the investors. So we still value the investors money a lot more than the founder's time.
- kgwgk 8y agoWhat ROI got those investors compared to a typical investment? How much did those founders get for their time compared to the average person selling their time?
- goatherders 8y agoOf course they made less than investors. Capital is worth a LOT more than time and energy and ideas.
- idlewords 8y agoThey put that work in to create a company that loses nearly a billion dollars a year, so it kind of make sense to me that the people throwing money on this bonfire should be valued higher than the ones who lit the match.
- wp381640 8y agoover a decade on this site i've watched comments from people being cynical about the value of Google, Facebook[0], Amazon, Uber and many others At what point of seeing this same story over and over again and realising that funding growth is a viable strategy do the cynics just let go? [0] heaven forbid you ever take investment advice from dhh https://signalvnoise.com/posts/2585-facebook-is-not-worth-33000000000 https://signalvnoise.com/posts/2585-facebook-is-not-worth-33...
- idlewords 8y agoThe sites you mention (aside from Uber, which does not make a profit) found their way to profitability by building out and then cashing in from an apparatus of mass surveillance unparalleled in human experience. So if I'm critical about the "grow while burning money" strategy, it's because I've seen the damage the eventual successful business model does to civil society. It's a bait and switch that we don't have to continue falling for.
- simonebrunozzi 8y agoAnd yet, the mechanisms at play make it so that this system survives and thrives. How would you end it?
- idlewords 8y agoTax the wealth and put it to productive use that helps a broader group of people (mass transit, health care, education, climate mitigation).
- likpok 8y ago
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoThis article in NYT puts Green and Zimmer's value much higher, at $603 and $416 million, respectively: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/business/dealbook/ipo-investors.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/business/dealbook/i... . And considering Lyft was/is a hugely capital intensive business that is still losing billions, I'm not surprised the capital investors came out with more equity in this one.
- chemeng 8y agoThis is incorrect. Green and Zimmer have moved material amounts of shares to trusts, other vehicles, etc. If you accumulate their owned or controlled shares, Green is around 500MM and Zimmer around 350MM https://www.businessinsider.com/lyft-ipo-paying-off-big-time-for-these-10-people-2019-2#logan-green-cofounder-and-ceo-1 https://www.businessinsider.com/lyft-ipo-paying-off-big-time...
- jedberg 8y agoI got the numbers from the S1, which is supposed to include all beneficial trusts. I may have read it wrong though.
- chemeng 8y agoThe S-1 is a bit opaque as it doesn't list out Class B ownership in the table. Lyft class B's are convertible to Class A at any time. If you follow to the table footnote for Green's entry you'll see: "Consists of (i) 4,663,809 shares of Class B common stock held by El Trust dated August 3, 2015, for which Mr. Green serves as trustee, (ii) 675,564 shares of Class B common stock held by The Green 2014 Irrevocable Trust dated June 12, 2014, for which Mr. Zimmer serves as trustee, (iii) 360,979 shares of Class B common stock held by The Logan Green 2016 Annuity Trust, for which Mr. Green serves as trustee, (iv) 360,979 shares of Class B common stock held by The Eva Green 2016 Annuity Trust, for which Mr. Green’s spouse serves as trustee, (v) shares of Class B common stock issued pursuant to the Founder Option Net Exercises and (vi) 1,180,329 shares of Class A common stock underlying RSUs for which the time-based vesting condition would be satisfied within 60 days of December 31, 2018 and assuming the satisfaction of the performance-based vesting condition. Subsequent to December 31, 2018, a portion of the shares described in this footnote were transferred between the trusts described in this footnote for estate planning purposes."
- jcfrei 8y ago>[...] but it's interesting how we value the capital that those companies put in far more than we value the years of work those two put in. "We" value taking risks more than working. An investor in Lyft carries much more risk than the founders - who would quickly find new jobs. But if the company goes bust the investor's money is gone.
- dv_dt 8y agoThey put in capital, true, but it wouldn’t be available unless this was the most likely fit for their investment profile, vs say low yield treasuries. The investors are just playing maximization game and have much more security than the lyft founders even if they lose ecery cent. We lionize the “risk” of VC investors far too much.
- ryandrake 8y agoAlso, let’s get real: VC investors are rich. They were rich before the investment, and they will be rich afterwards, regardless of the outcome. Maybe they will be ultra-rich after an exit, or they’ll be simply super-rich after a failure. Either way, they are already in the “set for life no matter what” category, so really, are they taking that much of a personal risk?
- dv_dt 8y agoThat's what I mean, the investors are so rich, it makes complete sense to take a portion of their riches and invest in high risk high reward states where most of the outcomes will be every cent is lost. It's not only set for life type money, but so much money that hiring teams of people to figure out how to even invest the proceeds in a rational way, of which VCs are just one subset of the team (outsourced, insourced, or otherwise).
- jiveturkey 8y agoI'm not sure that dilution is really the word you're going for here. Dilution implies / has the connotation that it is foisted upon you unwillingly and unknowingly, as in employees "get" diluted. The founders chose to get diluted at each round. And you're ignoring that at each "dilution", the value went up. The company didn't start at $24bn and at each round the founders got their value diluted, down to around a mere $500mm. The founders started at 100% of $0 and got "diluted" up to $500mm each. I'd call it a fun lesson in meteoric wealth growth for 2 guys starting with just an idea. $500mm/7yrs = $70mm/year. That's remarkable.
- mrnobody_67 8y agoThey earned less than any of the top 20 hedge fund managers: https://www.forbes.com/hedge-fund-managers/list/#tab:overall https://www.forbes.com/hedge-fund-managers/list/#tab:overall top pay : $1.7b for 1 year for #1 spot to $100m for spot #20.
- kgwgk 8y agoThey also earned less than The Rock. They earned less than Messi. They earned less than Mayweather in one single fight a couple of years ago. For the hedge fund managers note that this is not just "pay", it includes as well the returns on their own invested fortunes. The #1 in the list is not even working (he's 80 and he retired 10 years ago). They may make billions, but they also may lose billions: since 2011, John Paulson's estimated wealth is down from $15bn to $5bn.
- nostrademons 8y agoIt shows how important avoiding competition by being in an overlooked industry is, or selling quickly before it becomes a slug-it-out battle between well-capitalized growth companies. By contrast, the 3 GitHub founders each took home about $1.25B from their $7.5B acquisition. Mark Zuckerburg's Facebook stake was worth about $20B in 2011, out of the roughly $85B market cap. Larry & Sergey own 11% of Google today, 15 years after it became a public company. Kevin Systrom netted about $400M from Instagram's $1B sale. The three YouTube founders took home around $700M of YouTube's $1.65B sale. Jan Koum and Brian Acton together took in about $11B of WhatsApp's $19B sale, including continued stock incentives (they may've forfeited some by departing FB early). AFAIK Markus Frind took home nearly all of the $575M that PlentyOfFish sold for. I was also surprised at how low the founder ownership stakes were for Box (3% IIRC) and PayPal (Elon Musk was the largest founder shareholder at about $85M of the $1.5B purchase price). It really does pay to keep capital requirements low, profits high, and get on the hyper-growth curve before taking lots of capital rather than taking lots of capital so you can get on the hyper-growth curve.
- jedberg 8y agoThis is an interesting take on it. Thanks.
- bredren 8y agoSure, it "really does pay" so long as you can run a company lean into hypergrowth. Recall the number one reason startups fail is they run out of cash.
- Gabriel_Martin 8y agoAlternately, one could translate that instead to mean the number one reason is unsustainable over-scaling too early is what causes failures, not the lack of cash.
- amvalo 8y agoIsn’t that sort of like saying most humans die because their heart stops beating?
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoOne other perspective: Each of those companies--Google, A16Z, GM & Fidelity, Rakuten--are comprised of, what?, tens of thousands of shareholders. If we include mutual and indexed funds, and the retail investors who buy in to those, then probably millions of shareholders. Versus two.
- throwaway5752 8y agoA fun lesson in taking other peoples money? The capital is arguably more valuable in this case. Lyft is just a copycat of Uber, what did the founders bring to the table? I'm playing devil's advocate [more than] a bit. I'm happy for Green and Zimmer, and they are both making FU money from this so I'm not sure what the complaint is.
- jedberg 8y agoNo complaint, just a commentary on the value of capital vs labor.
- throwaway5752 8y agoThat's a bit glib, though. They are the 2nd mover in a capital intensive business. Kalanick did better, in a pretty direct comparison. Anyway, I'll drop it. They have set up their families for centuries, build a huge company in extraordinary little time, made a lot of their employees rich, made life a lot better for people trying to hail a cab, and I don't want to rain on their well-deserved parade today.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tonyhb 8y agoI agree with your devil's advocate. Not to downplay Lyft, though... Lyft started in 2007, two years before Uber — and so was doing ridesharing beforehand. Uber snuck in with a taxi model that was legally gray which opened the doors.
- malandrew 8y agoSo basically it's about about execution, not timing.
- caprese 8y agoYes, it is fascinating. I would say this is more related to cultural understanding and values, than how to just do something profitable. The cognitive dissonance comes from valuing work, and getting affirmation from others that your work was worth more because of your efforts. But this has nothing to do with math and accounting.
- shrimpx 8y agoAnd there are a bunch of suckers who put in X% the work that each cofounder put in and are getting (X/1000)% of that 500M. It's because they assumed 1000x less risk presumably.
- yks 8y agoActually, what is the 1000x risk for SV startup founders? They are not risking their own money and apparently not even their reputation (failed VC-backed founders tend to be able to get VC capital again) so on the face their risk is just to lose a job, same as for any other employee.
- shrimpx 8y agoYeah exactly. Many of these founders are on their 2nd startup and are already millionaires. Some poor nth employee is in fact risking a lot by e.g. quitting their nice life in a city by relocating, or quitting a promising career. Yet the founders' massively disporportionate ownership is chucked off to "risk". I for one hope for market forces that will rebalance these discrepancies. Talented 1st employee shouldering most of the technical brunt taking <1% plus dilution is selling oneself to the dogs.
- snovv_crash 8y agoWhat you're risking is your health, physical and mental. Being a founder is a hugely stressful job, and everyone I've seen spend 5 years as a founder has aged more like 10 years in that time.
- Zarath 8y agoThat's how capitalism works?
- lexs 8y agoand you don't see a problem with that?
- willart4food 8y agoIt's the Golden Rule: He who has the gold makes the rules!
- zby 8y ago"This is simply a commentary on the relative value of capital vs labor" - what this capital was spent on? Overwhelmingly on labour I guess.
- khazhou 8y agoIf the founders have $1B between the two, then employee #1 would have (guesstimating) on the order of $10M, assuming the standard employee#1 == 1%. Of course there's the initial investor share and option pool to account for, but we're still in the right ballpark. Employee #20, who joined maybe a few months in, and then put in seven years, is gonna be at order of magnitude down, $1M. Employee #50, who put in six years, is the hundred thousands, and we keep going down. Yeah, fantastic money, but pales compared to founders. Lesson: don't not be a founder.
- lukejduncan 8y agoThis math feels off. It’s hard to imagine employee #20 making “only $1m” when there are engineers at Lyft getting $1m+ equity packages as offers today. Maybe their initial grant would be worth that much but for sure there would be a large number of subsequent grants since joining at #20.
- hawaiianbrah 8y ago$1m+ equity offers today? Hmm... that sounds pretty high.
- dannyw 8y agoNot unsurprising, 1M equity over 4 years at today’s valuation is fairly common.
- paulddraper 8y agoLesson 2: don't not be successful as a founder.
- vecter 8y agoCompletely wrong assumptions.
- khazhou 8y agoWhich assumption is wrong? Employee #1 @ 1% equity is very common. You very quickly get into .5% and .1% after just a few employees.
- quickthrower2 8y agoThis is a winning horse. But investors also back losers. On average they hope to come out on top.
- jliptzin 8y agoUnless I’m mistaken Lyft came after Uber right? They built a good product but nothing unique other than being “not-Uber.” In that sense you can think of Green and Zimmer as being hired by their investors to produce an alternate Uber. They executed very well against their task and everyone got a nice payday for it.
- xenospn 8y agoAs far as I can recall, Uber used to be a service where you could rent professional drivers to drive you around with big black SUVs, and Lyft started ride-sharing, which Uber shortly followed with Uber X.
- pathseeker 8y ago>how we value the capital Who is "we"? The founders are who agreed to those terms. It's how they valued the capital.
- malandrew 8y agoThat capital paid for all the labor of the engineers and ops folks that built the company and all the promotions to build the buy side and sell side of a two sided market place. It's done more than either of those two have done. It's not even like they brought much creativity and gumption to the table like Kalanick. They just followed the Uber and got lucky when the Uber went through a bad year.
- skrebbel 8y agoI'm confused how anybody can pitch "personal net worth went from negligible to half a billion" as a negative thing. When they started they had 100% of nothing. Now they have $500m. Wow.
- black-tea 8y agoCapital is important because it represents work that has already been done. What's always disheartening, though, is that capital is always raised from private investors and they then use the stock market to cash out. The stock market was invented to raise that capital in the first place which gives the public an opportunity to see these kind of gains. Now there's just no chance.
- ves 8y agoIt’s much more difficult and expensive to list on a public exchange than it is to raise private capital. Also the SEC kinda forbids this situation to further the aim of “protecting mom and pop investors.”
- fasfhfjashdf 8y agoA $500 million payday for building a company that loses $1 billion a year sounds like a pretty freakin' great outcome to me.
- ddalex 8y agoA masterful exercise in hype. Lyft and Uber are PR companies in the personal transportation domain.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]