9 ms·
Stoicism's Appeal to the Rich and Powerful
- coldtea 8y agoBeing rich and powerful is not enough. They also want to signal that they are "stoic", nonchalant bad-assess ready to take on everything fate throws at them -- second rate caviar, aging like everybody else, the $10M condo not being just right, some competitor gaining ground, and so on. They also wake up earlier than common folk, exercise and eat better than common folk, and so on. All of which are easy when you have personal chefs and a big entourage to take care of "details" like washing the dishes, taking the kids to school, preparing your clothes, making breakfast, and so on...
- okr 8y agoYour second paragraph sounds to me like i live. But i am not "rich". I just take advantage of what is out there to make my life easier or to save time. And actually that is all what economy is about.
- coldtea 8y ago>Your second paragraph sounds to me like i live. But i am not "rich". If you're not "rich" I'm not sure how you have dispensed with preparing breakfast, taking the kids to school, clothes, cooking, cleaning the house, driving to work, and so on I've described the rich as having dispensed with. At worse, if you have achieved all of the above, you're better off than 90% of the global population, and probably have no kids, eat out whenever you want, and pay some domestic helper. So, not Bezos rich, but not common folk either...
- k__ 8y agoMost people who are rich say they aren't. In Germany, you are in the top 10% of people with the most income by "just" making 50k€. Just imagine, in one of the richest countries on earth, there are around 70 million people who don't make 50k€ a year. Question is, what is the definition of rich? Having more money than more than half the people on earth? In your country? Around you? Having enough money that you can live of interest?
- LyndsySimon 8y agoI don't know if it matches the "actual" definitions, but to me "rich" is a lifestyle. It means not worrying about having enough to do what you desire to do. "Wealthy", on the other hand, means never having to work again if you don't want to (or if your priorities change). By those metrics, I'm (sometimes) rich, but I'm not wealthy. I'm working on it. My financial goal in life is to build a process that generates enough of a positive income stream in perpetuity to take care of my family, and to be able to leave that process to my descendants. Note that this doesn't necessarily require billions (or even millions) of dollars to attain. I've severely cut my recurring expenses, and categorize them into "essential" and "discretionary". For instance: I spend a lot of money right now on high-speed Internet access. I have 300Mbps at home (Gigabit wasn't worth the cost to me), an iPhone X, and an iPad Pro, all with LTE. My 10-year-old has a 6th-Gen iPad LTE, and my wife has a Samsung Galaxy 10+. Monthly costs for all of that is ~$650 / month... and it's entirely discretionary. I can afford it, but I could also turn it off tomorrow if my financial situation were to change. Meanwhile, my mortgage is $850 / month, and that's "essential". My utilities combined are $125 / month, and those are "essential". Add in food and such, and I'm right at $1,400 / month of total essential expenses - I need $17k / year to run my household at a minimum. In order to make that in interest in a traditional investment account, I'd need $340k. That's obvious back-of-the-envelope and doesn't take into account market fluctuations or inflation, but it goes to show what I mean: I would be completely financially independent with less than a half million dollars in traditional investments. My plan relies on that sort of investment for retirement, because it's a relatively safe platform to build upon. I'm in the process now of saving enough capital to get into real estate in a substantial way. If my planning is remotely accurate, I should be able to use rental properties to grow an income stream there exponentially - barring a major depression, the real challenge will be one of process, not money. Managing a single commercial rental with a long-term lease agreement is one thing; managing a dozen, or a hundred, or a thousand... that's quite another.
- k__ 8y agoI use these two words the other way around.
- okr 8y agoI put "rich" in quotes. I consider everyone in the west "rich", but thats a discussion of its own. I have bought a robot that vacuums for me twice the week. I rent. I spend like 50 euros per week for prepared food. I spend 10 euro/week for scooter rides from/to work,or i walk or bike. I pay like 100 euro per month for washing/drycleaning. Health insurance is paid via salary, so no further costs there. I jump between entertainment formats, so i only pay 10 euro per month for visual entertainment. So, almost everything has been taken care of.
- koolba 8y ago> They also wake up earlier than common folk, exercise and eat better than common folk, and so on. All of which are easy when you have personal chefs and a big entourage to take care of "details" like washing the dishes, taking the kids to school, preparing your clothes, making breakfast, and so on... Marrying the right person and having close family and friends nearby covers all of that regardless of income level. If you live your life as an island then money can buy a lot of those things but IMHO that’s going to be a sad life.
- coldtea 8y ago>Marrying the right person and having close family and friends nearby covers all of that regardless of income level. Provided your spouse doesn't need to work too. And that you're OK not helping her with the stuff. And even then, you've just shared the duties, not eliminated them from your life to some servants that just do anything and you don't owe them nothing but an insignificant amount of your money. In communal traditional societies the above is easier. In modern city life this is all but lost for the common folk.
- 2III7 8y agoWaking up early and getting things done is a matter of self discipline. I had trouble with all of those things until I started going to bed early with my son and wife. Before that I stayed up late and was tremendously tired all the time. Now I wake up at 6 AM without an alarm and just automagically get shit done and have left over time for my side projects, fixing the house etc.
- jmh530 8y agoI woke up yesterday without an alarm at 5:40am and was like, damn I overslept.
- HNLurker2 8y agoWaking up early can be a sign of depression too (3 am)
- ajuc 8y agoFor me the solution was to install software that dims and shifts the screen colors to red with time. It makes me sleepy at around 22:00, so I just go to bed, and wake up naturally at about 6:30. Before that I often stayed late and realized when it was already 1:00.
- coldtea 8y ago>Waking up early and getting things done is a matter of self discipline. Anything a person can do is a matter of self-discipline. I could not have slept for 36 days because of working 2-shifts and still "have the discipline" to go for a run. Slim chances, but it happens. But self-discipline is much easier to muster in "easy mode", when your other duties are taken care of by an army of servants. Talk of self-discipline without talk of environmental factors making people less tired, less stressed, and less concerned with basic life matters to focus on that discipline is moot. And talk of self-discipline should take into account aggregates, to discover what's the baseline for most people under certain conditions, not point at some outliers that did it against all odds and say "Here, anyone can do it" (as if difficulty doesn't matter). That's like pointing out Usain Bolt and saying "here, anyone can run sub-10 secs and if you don't you just lack the discipline". Do you think e.g. a-list actors who trivially lose amazing amounts of weight for roles have "more discipline" that the average folks who statistically fail much worse in their diets? Or that they have personal chefs, trainers, massagers, cleaners, and so on, plus a 5-10 million dollar incentive (to get the next "action" part), siding with their "self-discipline).
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoI’m surprised by the way people are choosing to respond to you. Waking up early is obviously not the point of your comment, but many replies seem to take you literally and act like merely waking up early would be some sort of refutation of the idea you’re describing. One pathology that wealthy people (on a global scale) sometimes fall into is using their wealth and privilege to access behaviors that make them feel more like they’ve personally “worked hard” for what they have, like behavioral status symbols that are far less accessible to people without privilege. Waking up early for purposes of pure self-maintenance, like meditation or high-end exercise, and getting to work very early, are often examples of this. It superficially feels like an accomplishment, like a justifying act of endorsing that you, as a wealthy person, are somehow exceptional and “deserving” (rather that just lucky to have money that buys the freedom to use recreational time like that) and allows you to focus on how your behavior differs from the masses to create a false sense that wealth is “earned” by “working” for it because of these photo-op-like engineered segments of “self-sacrifice.” Less privileged folks may have to get up early just to barely make it to a shit job because of a 90 minute commute or a bunch of child care (or elder care) duties they have to perform. They may eat poorly or miss exercising because of all the obligations they cannot financially afford to offload. I don’t see why anyone is reading a different idea into your comment.
- 2III7 8y ago> Waking up early for purposes of pure self-maintenance, like meditation or high-end exercise, and getting to work very early, are often examples of this. It superficially feels like an accomplishment... There is nothing superficial about those things. By doing those things you gain wealth that is not measurable by any amount of money. > Less privileged folks may have to get up early just to barely make it to a shit job because of a 90 minute commute or a bunch of child care (or elder care) duties they have to perform. They may eat poorly or miss exercising because of all the obligations they cannot financially afford to offload. Less privileged folk also tend to stay up late and fill their minds with mindless media streams (television, social media etc.), drink alcohol to relieve stress to name a few stress relief activities. Daily stress should not be relieved by mind numbing crap, but by taking care of ones mental and physical health or seeking psychological help from professionals. Yes people tend to have too many obligations in which case people should re-assess their values and make sacrifices to not burn themselves out and die early. Life is complicated but we also tend to over complicate it.
- matwood 8y agoIt's about time management and prioritizing what's important. Are there exceptions like the single parent with 2 hour each way commutes working 8 jobs with 5 kids? Sure, but in general common folk have time to do all the things you list. Throw in IF and they can skip breakfast ;) I know a single parent that trained for and ran a marathons while working full time and raising 2 kids. She was not up to date on whatever TV show was popular, but that's a good thing. Time and food are very similar in this regard. People do not know what they are using and how much until they sit down and do a log for a week. If after logging they find their entire week is full with zero wasted time, good on them. They are already getting it done. But, most people are likely wasting tons of time watching TV, mindlessly scrolling on social media, and/or reading HN (yeah, writing this comment has already blown through my allotted HN time this morning).
- HNLurker2 8y ago>scrolling on social media, and/or reading HN (yeah, writing this comment has already blown through my allotted HN time this morning). Should you beat yourself up for that? Most people here use HN to fill the holes between dullness (of the day) to get in flow.
- jacobmoe 8y agoYou're probably right about signalling, but I think there's a more sympathetic take. The story of the Buddha is of a prince who had all a person could ever want, only to discover old-age, disease and death. He realized that suffering is inescapable and universal and therefore requires a universal solution. I'm not rich or powerful by any means, but I'm doing comparatively well financially and in health. But it's never enough. Systems like Buddhism or stoicism answer the question: "I seem to be doing well in life, but why do I still feel so shitty?"
- mjburgess 8y agoTo put it another way: the basic features of human life are universal. Stress, betrayal, love, trust, anger, loneliness, etc. It doesnt really matter how pretty your rooms are or how much you own, the fundamentals don't change in their existence, only in their proportion. A poor person's life may be more stressful, but very plausibly, less lonely than a rich persons. Stoicism is a universal solution to a universal problem: the vicissitudes of life.
- coldtea 8y ago>To put it another way: the basic features of human life are universal. Stress, betrayal, love, trust, anger, loneliness, etc. Money can alleviate many of those problems -- it's just not a magic want to fix everything. Stress for example: you can be stressed for rent, for the cost of medical emergencies, for providing for your kids, etc. If you're rich, you don't need to stress for any of that. Not only that, you also don't end up homeless, broke after a surgery, and so on. Nor do you have to skip meals. And when money problem come in, even real love and familial relationships (not based on gold-digging) are stressed. Tons of families break and argue about money problems, especially in recessions etc. https://bgr.com/2018/02/13/money-buys-happiness-research-study/ https://bgr.com/2018/02/13/money-buys-happiness-research-stu... >It doesnt really matter how pretty your rooms are or how much you own, the fundamentals don't change in their existence, only in their proportion. Sure, you will still die, get lonely sometimes, or have friends betray you like a rich person. But that's what's common, how about what's much more difficult? If you want to become a scientist but can't afford to go to college, and can't even afford a scholarship because you need to work at the family farm and help the family, it does matter. And that's just one of myriads of examples. How about being lonely, not because you're anti-social or can't get friends, but because you're working 12 hours a day in some sweatshop? Or you're a single mother juggling two shitty jobs? Those are all common situations. And not just in some third world either.
- easytiger 8y agoThe level of discourse on HN around social issues is becoming utterly unproductive and embarassing. This is a 4th rate rant by someone with a chip on their shoulder. You don't need a personal chef to be able to go for a run before work. I dread to think of the personal issues that underlie such a skewed incorrect view of the world
- matwood 8y agoI'm starting to agree with you, and have thought about not reading the comments on these types of articles anymore. These sorts of comments are about protecting ones ego. Instead of accepting the responsibility for not exercising, blaming the lack of a personal chef shifts the responsibility externally. A stoic would look at the situation and figure out what is in their control to change, and then get to work. It could be something simple like no more TV. It could also be a much longer term plan like get additional education in order to find a better job which in turn leads to more free time. Regardless of the plan, the general attitude of figuring out what is in a person's control and then acting is the skill here.
- coldtea 8y ago>You don't need a personal chef to be able to go for a run before work. Which is neither here, nor there. I didn't say you need one. I said that those things "are easy" when you have that kind of aid (versus not having it). Is that somehow controversial? I like how my statement (widely upvoted) is a "4th rate rant", but this content-less response managed to get what I wrote wrong on the one small sentence it intended as a counter-argument.
- easytiger 8y agoYea, you are correct, it's fifth rate Little more than a rant designed to frame anyone with more money than you in a negative light > Which is neither here, nor there. I didn't say you need one. I said that those things "are easy" when you have that kind of aid (versus not having it).w No, you didn't, you explicitly and literally stated that is the reason for certain attributes, as if it were common > They also wake up earlier than common folk, exercise and eat better than common folk, and so on. All of which are easy when you have personal chefs and a big entourage to take care of "details" like washing the dishes, taking the kids to school, preparing your clothes, making breakfast, and so on... You are very clearly trying to dehumanise a certain quarter of society. > They Application, repeatedly, of a pronoun with no specification or example concrete of the target of your ire. It is abundantly clear that you need to invent fantasy to make political targets of perfectly average individuals
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lordnacho 8y agoMaybe what's useful is that even when you have a ton of money, you still have problems. Not just absolute ones that nobody can help (your friends and relatives dying, illness), but also problems that people who don't have a load of money think you ought to be able to do something about: kids not using the chances you give them, issues with your reputation, status compared to other rich people.
- paol 8y agoInteresting article. I'd like to encourage people to read more stuff from her blog, it's absolutely excellent. I'm currently reading this piece[0] (teaser quote: "then, in the early seventeenth century, Francis Bacon invented progress."). Then there's the series ostensibly about Machiavelli[1], but that is actually a whirlwind tour of Italian renaissance history, philosophy, intrigue and eventually, yes, Machiavelli. [0] https://www.exurbe.com/on-progress-and-historical-change/ https://www.exurbe.com/on-progress-and-historical-change/ [1] https://www.exurbe.com/machiavelli-s-p-q-f/ https://www.exurbe.com/machiavelli-s-p-q-f/
- supergilbert 8y agoStoicism is gaining popularity now because it's a counter reponse to the constant stimulation we are put under. Non stop food, entertainment, plus the feeling on not being able to have any effect on the global system. Stoicism is way to stay sane. I believe this trend will end and we will see a regain of existencialism and romantism.
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoHow does stoicism counter overstimulation?
- Emma_Goldman 8y agoIt invites you to step back from the mundane and consider your life, its infinitesimal place in the universe, its ultimate transience, and the kind of attitude and virtues you want to practice. It's a form of deep reflection that places your life in a cosmological perspective. In that respect it serves a similar function to prayer and the contemplation of the divine in some religions.
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoI don’t think stoicism is related to those things. Those sound like nice meditative things to do, which are compatible with a wide range of different philosophical schools of thought, but none of that sounds like it is actively connected to the defining characteristics of stoicism.
- Emma_Goldman 8y agoI disagree. I have only read parts of Epictetus' Discourses and Aerelius' Meditations, but I think it is borne out by both texts. I don't have them to hand. But quickly looking through an online edition of the Meditations, I am faced with a great many passages matching the stated views. For example: 'Though thou shouldst be going to live three thousand years, and as many times ten thousand years, still remember that no man loses any other life than this which he now lives, nor lives any other than this which he now loses. The longest and shortest are thus brought to the same.' 'How quickly all things disappear, in the universe the bodies themselves, but in time the remembrance of them; what is the nature of all sensible things, and particularly those which attract with the bait of pleasure or terrify by pain, or are noised abroad by vapoury fame; how worthless, and contemptible, and sordid, and perishable, and dead they are- all this it is the part of the intellectual faculty to observe.' Both quotes are from this online edition: http://classics.mit.edu/Antoninus/meditations.2.two.html http://classics.mit.edu/Antoninus/meditations.2.two.html
- dalbasal 8y agoStoicism was "originally" a philosophy of (mostly) the rich and powerful of Rome, so it's unsurprisingly compatible. It's moderate, in that it doesn't prescribe any big external changes to your society or any particular lifestyle. It also reminds me somewhat of deism, which was a popular elite philosophy around the time of the US' founding. Secularism in all but name, with a moderate's concern for the implications of being too extreme. God exists, but let's set that aside. This is relevant, because the dominant philosophies at the time (and always) were religious. Some of the completing philosophies mentioned, were much more prone to conflict with the religious order. For example, to this day, the conflict between Jews of the time and "Hellenisers" is a taboo subject in religious circles. These were secular philosophies that became popular in Roman Judea, often among the more internationally minded elite, encroaching on religious monopoly of certain subjects. Epicorus (mentioned here) is a Talmudic villain, and will still get a rise out of many rabbis.
- al_chemist 8y ago> Stoicism was "originally" a philosophy of (mostly) the rich and powerful of Rome Stoicism was originally a philosophy of a poor shipwreck survivor from Cyprus. It was made popular in Greece and then imported into Roman culture.
- dalbasal 8y agoHence the "quotes."
- sigi45 8y agoI actually like to see proof that it is now a realy thing on Wall Street and Silicon Valey. Just because one person mentions it somewhere, doesn't mean a relevant portion is actually doing / living it. But yes as a software engineere and growing up in a modern socieity, reading about Stoicism comes close to how i perceive my life. But there have probably always been people thinking in that direction anyway.
- keiferski 8y agoOver time, I've noticed that Stoicism appeals to two broad types of people: 1. Successful people that like to think that they are entirely responsible for their own success. "I am successful because that is my nature." 2. Unsuccessful people that seek reasons outside themselves as to why they are unsuccessful. "I am unsuccessful because that is the nature of the world."
- taberiand 8y agoHopefully there is room for a third, 'My duty is to go where fate leads me and fulfil the role I find myself in, in order to provide for the betterment of society' Revelling in your success or stagnating in your failure doesn't feel very stoic to me.
- AmazingAtalanta 8y agoAgreed. I do not have a very strong understanding or experience with stoicism, but I never really considered stoicism to be some kind of resignation to your fate just because you can't control it. It is to actively embrace it and remind yourself that when you have successes or failures, those things were sort of "part of the plan" and you know the best thing is to trek on. I don't necessarily even think that an "unsuccessful" person would accept themselves as an unsuccessful person, but just know that they are on a path they cannot see, but trust that what they are going through is net positive for society, the world, etc.
- salty_biscuits 8y agoSort of not surprising, Seneca was fabulously wealthy and politically powerful.
- roel_v 8y agoI've been trying to read Marcus Aureleus for a few years, but it feels like wading through a swamp and I generally give up after 10 pages. Any recommendations for an annotated version for today's readers?
- glaberficken 8y agoSorry for being just a +1 but I would love this exact recommendation as well =)
- enchiridion 8y agoHaving a newer translation helps with this. One of the ideas he pushes is plain speech. I felt silly reading about that in a translation with lots of "thous" and "shalls".
- 131012 8y agoIt is not what you asked, but maybe try to read with a pen & paper. Take notes, it will help with the swamp feeling. I personally find this trick does not really work with a text editor.
- newsgremlin 8y agoAnd use a highlighter or just write on the book to refer back to bits when writing notes. If it's just a standard paperback I'm sure most won't have reservations for writing on their books.
- mr_t 8y agoNot sure if it's exactly what you're looking for, but I really enjoy 'The Daily Stoic' by Ryan Holiday [0]. There's a page for each day of the year (so ideally you would read a page per day). Each page has a short quote from Seneca, Marcus Aurelius and others, together with an interpretation of Ryan Holiday. For me, this wa an easy way to get started with the whole topic of Stoicism and some of Senecas and Aurelius ideas. [0] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/29093292-the-daily-stoic https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/29093292-the-daily-stoic
- 8y ago
- pretty_bubbles 8y agoI always had the impression that stoic virtues mandate that someone who has power to bring change and improve the lives of others also has a duty of doing so. I guess the problem with any philosophy is that humans tend to pick and choose the parts that are convenient. In any case, I still think stoicism teaches invaluable skills in today's society.
- qaq 8y agoAny chance it's people who are stoic have a higher chance of moving up to become reach and powerful?
- DanielBMarkham 8y agoFor those not wanting to wade through this, the thesis seems to be "...Stoicism caught on among Roman elites because it was the one form of philosophical guidance that didn’t urge them to renounce wealth or power....can be used to justify the idea that the rich and powerful are meant to be rich and powerful, that the poor and downtrodden are meant to be poor and downtrodden, and that even the worst actions are actually good in an ineffable and eternal way. Such claims can be used to justify complacency, social callousness, and even exploitative or destructive behavior." I love philosophers, history, and philosophy. I consider myself an existential stoic. (How I reconcile these philosophies I will save for another day) The problem I had with this essay is the same problem I have with a lot of philosophy: it takes itself far, far too seriously for my tastes. Do the rich adapt stoicism because of the underlying metaphysics in much the same way that powerful Romans did? Did powerful Romans even adapt it in this way, or are we left with various interpretations depending on which sources we use? More to the point, when you pick up a philosophy, decide you like it and want to apply it in your life, is this decision akin to adopting a new religion, becoming part of a cult? Or is it more like entertaining some useful concepts that you play on playing with to see how useful they may be to you? It's not a facile question. If we adopt philosophies in the same we adopt worldviews, then the history and inner conflicts can be quite important. If, however, we adopt philosophies in the same we might pick up a grape Slurpee at the local seven-eleven, then not so much. Philosophy tends to take itself far too seriously, and it tends to take a few really good ideas and beat the living heck out of them until they don't work anymore. I doubt the thesis here. Or rather, it's overstated by a significant degree.
- paol 8y agoThat is not the thesis of the article, and misrepresenting it that way is doing it a diservice. It would be better to "wade" through it in full than to mis-sumarize it.
- DanielBMarkham 8y agoIt would be good for both of us, along with the other HN readers, if you provided what you thought the thesis was. I'm happy to be corrected, but if all you provide is disagreement, it doesn't do anybody any good.
- AlexTWithBeard 8y agoMany rich and powerful are extremely ambitious. They aim high and get very upset when they don't get what they aimed for. The higher you get the less if your endeavors will succeed. Stoicism is a good way of accepting the failure and preserving one's sanity.
- bjornedstrom 8y agoI like the slightly provocative title. To the stoics themselves, wealth and power are indifferent: neither good or bad. I say that the title is provocative because wealth and power often provoke people, as can be seen in this very discussion (here on Hacker News). Depending on where you come from and where you are in life, a phrase such as "rich and powerful" may call forth the negative stereotype of evil wealthy people, or it may call forth the positive stereotype of Hacker News style entrepreneurs. It is much easier to be indifferent to wealth and power if you already have it. My take on the supposed rise in popularity of stoicism is not that it appeals to the "rich and powerful" per se. I do however think it appeals to people who have found themselves in a situation when they no longer have obvious things to live for, which is certainly the case for these people. If you suddenly find yourself with free time and autonomy, philosophy is a pretty good thing to fill the void with, I think.
- zcid 8y agoI have found a stoic attitude a great method by which to weather the ups and downs of life. Whether that means stubbing my toe, dealing with death, or finding myself without an income or a place to live, acceptance of the situation as it is prevents wasting time and energy railing against the inevitabilities of life.
- sankoz 8y agoDo you have small kids? Just curious, because having a small helpless human dependent on you for their survival and well being has made me change my attitude towards life a bit away from Stoicism.
- NeoStoic 8y agoThere is a certain hipster Stoicism out there yes. But Stoicism is also a valid response to the chaos and overwhelming hedonic treadmill of the 21st century. Look at the book below for how Stoiscim can help [1]: "Anton shows how today's consumerist lifestyles distort and trivialize the need for self-worth, and he argues that each person faces the genuinely heroic tasks of contributing to the world's beauty, harmony, and resources; of forgiving the cosmos for self-conscious finitude; and of gratefully accepting the ambiguity of life's gifts." [1] https://www.amazon.com/Sources-Significance-Rejuvenation-Philosophy-Communication/dp/1557535612 https://www.amazon.com/Sources-Significance-Rejuvenation-Phi...
- elchief 8y ago"In a rich man's house, there is no place to spit but his face" Diogenes Stoicism is popular in a variety of communities on reddit, so I bet its popularity in SV is related A Guide to the Good Life: The Ancient Art of Stoic Joy is an easy introduction to Stoicism https://www.amazon.com/Guide-Good-Life-Ancient-Stoic/dp/0195374614/ https://www.amazon.com/Guide-Good-Life-Ancient-Stoic/dp/0195...
- aitchnyu 8y agoWhat is the story of Seneca running a brothel with his slaves? I can't seem to Google it.
- istjohn 8y agoTL;DR: Because I think it’s important that we mingle some Voltaire in with our Seneca, and remember that stoicism’s invaluable advice for taking better care of ourselves inside can–if we fail to mix it with other ideas–come with a big blind spot regarding the world outside ourselves, and whether we should change it.
- hprotagonist 8y agoHere is the failure mode, aptly summarized by someone who knew. You can weaponize any faith or metaphysic this way; some are more obvious than others. As a personal way of thinking about your own circumstances, it’s fine as far as it goes. As a social ethic for how it’s OK to organize a society, it can quickly descend into something that, well: For my part, I would say, welcome infidelity! welcome atheism! welcome anything! in preference to the gospel, as preached by those Divines! They convert the very name of religion into an engine of tyranny, and barbarous cruelty, and serve to confirm more infidels, in this age, than all the infidel writings of Thomas Paine, Voltaire, and Bolingbroke, put together, have done! These ministers make religion a cold and flinty-hearted thing, having neither principles of right action, nor bowels of compassion. They strip the love of God of its beauty, and leave the throng of religion a huge, horrible, repulsive form. It is a religion for oppressors, tyrants, man-stealers, and thugs. It is not that “pure and undefiled religion” which is from above, and which is “first pure, then peaceable, easy to be entreated, full of mercy and good fruits, without partiality, and without hypocrisy.” But a religion which favors the rich against the poor; which exalts the proud above the humble; which divides mankind into two classes, tyrants and slaves; which says to the man in chains, stay there; and to the oppressor, oppress on; it is a religion which may be professed and enjoyed by all the robbers and enslavers of mankind; it makes God a respecter of persons, denies his fatherhood of the race, and tramples in the dust the great truth of the brotherhood of man. Frederick Douglass, 1852
- ripsawridge 8y agoNice. All philosophies (or religions, what have you) must be pursued with kindness for all beings first, last and middle.
- HNLurker2 8y agoJust like Russel said not to take any philosophy for granted (at that time Marxism philosophy was mainstream): https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=fb3k6tB-Or8 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=fb3k6tB-Or8
- LifeLiverTransp 8y agoAvoid feeling guilt or empathy towards those who you ripped off on your way up with these easy steps
- helloindia 8y ago"Stoicism was likely influenced by Buddhism through contact with India during the wars of Alexander the Great, and shares a lot with Buddhism: the whole universe is one vast, living, divine whole." Universe as a "divine whole" is a concept found in Advaita vedanta, not in Buddhism. “Life is full of suffering, but that suffering is a path to understanding a larger good.” Again wrong. Understanding true nature of reality, any experience happiness,suffering, neutral is considered a path. Not just suffering.
- Roxo 8y agoThis article is okay, but contains some misinformation about the origin and principles of Stoicism. The NYT article itself was an absolute disgrace, completely misrepresenting what Stoicism is.
- waynecochran 8y agoOne could easily write and an article titled “Stoicism’s Appeal to the Poor and Disenfranchised.” Power and wealth is orthogonal to Stoic Philosophy. It counters much of today’s culture of blame of jealously of others and offers a more fulfilling and pragmatic outlook on one’s circumstances, rich or poor.
- curuinor 8y agoBut the article's point is that its social ethos consists of just justifying the way things are. Two millenia later, we figured out that we can improve many of the way things were, we nearly abolished chattel slavery, we abolished a few diseases, we replaced debt slavery with bankruptcy...
- waynecochran 8y agoThere is a difference between justifying and accepting. The article seems to confuse the two.
- bovermyer 8y agoThe short version of the article is this: Stoicism is a wonderful tool for improving your inner peace, but be careful, lest its focus on acceptance prevent you from working to improve the outside world.
- HNLurker2 8y ago>Stoicism was likely influenced by Buddhism through contact with India during the wars of Alexander the Great, and shares a lot with Buddhism So is it directly influenced by Buddhism or we presume. I find both Buddhism and stoicism similar in the sense of self (seeing yourself as a bigger just oneness basically mysticism Bertrand Russel talked about(1)). (1) Mysticism and Logic and Other Essays https://g.co/kgs/UQD6H4 https://g.co/kgs/UQD6H4