5 ms·
How come such vaccines are not mandatory? Shouldn't the parents be held responsible for endangering their children and potentially killing them?
by csomar 8y ago
How come such vaccines are not mandatory? Shouldn't the parents be held responsible for endangering their children and potentially killing them?
- dvdkhlng 8y agoMaybe they should also be held responsible for causing harm to other people, teachers, pupils their kids come in contact with?
- kypro 8y agoI dislike the antivax movement but mandatory state injections would be a huge violation of liberties in my opinion. Just because most vaccines are safe and worth while getting don't mean they all are, or always will be.
- krapp 8y ago>I dislike the antivax movement but mandatory state injections would be a huge violation of liberties in my opinion. That's true, but if we consider any violation of personal liberty to be harmful, then we're left with primitivist anarchy. We've decided, collectively (albeit not individually and not always voluntarily) that it is beneficial in some cases to abridge the rights of the individual for the sake of society. We invented systems of laws and courts because we consider a fixed set of common laws and a controlled system to adjudicate them to be more just and fair on average than retributory violence and clan based tribalism, despite the existence of the state and its monopoly on violence being an abridgement of personal liberty. We've also decided that, while scientific inquiry has its faults, it is preferable to assume that the premises of science (specifically, epidemiology and the utility of vaccines) hold sound, given the evidence, despite this amounting to an appeal to authority for most people, who aren't likely to be willing or able to do the work of personally validating all of the claims ever made by a particular scientific field. In the case of vaccines, we have ample historical evidence of the effect of epidemics and a lack of preventative measures on human populations, and of the improvements made to society as a result of vaccination and preventative measures. The choice here is not between potentially harmful vaccines versus a healthy life in their absence, rather, between between an abstract threat (vaccines) and a concrete threat (disease.) So, yes. Mandatory vaccines are a violation of liberty. We didn't spend the last several millennia laying a foundation of civilization and scientific progress just to subject ourselves to the blind malice of nature for the sake of a few people who don't like the government telling them they're not allowed to catch polio if they want to.
- swarnie_ 8y ago> a huge violation of liberties in my opinion Usually when your actions (or inactions) endanger others in an unreasonable way we write laws to force the individual to act a certain way for the greater good of society. I don't see how this is any different to drink driving laws.
- formerentourage 8y ago> Mandatory vaccines are a violation of liberty. They are not. Not vaccinating is a means of harming and killing people around you, which is not within boundaries of personal liberty. Theoretically, if you spent whole your life in wilderness far from other people, you could risk all diseases you want. I strongly dislike this normalizing language of giving up some liberty "for greater good". All things that superficially look like this should be really either a defense of liberty or autonomy of others, or an exercise of collective political liberty of the people to shape the world around them. The latter is subject to political change if people change their minds, and still has to respect personal liberty as the primary aim of free society. We should not equate progress with imposing more and more restrictions that are supposedly objectively "good" in some abstract way, as determined by some people. This loosens the principles at best. Some people can reject them, but we should be clear when they do that.
- gowld 8y agoThe US government has an admitted history of running fake vaccine programs and intentionally cultivating syphillus in non-consenting vulnerable populations. The US government lost its vaccine-mandate legitimacy through its own crimes against humanity.
- toomanybeersies 8y agoI don't want to do the whole "think of the children!" thing here, but: It's children we're talking about. Forced immunisations in adults is absolutely a violation of civil liberties. They are an adult and they can decide whether they consent to being immunised or not after making a choice on the matter. But children have none of those rights or responsibilities. Why should a child suffer and/or die from a disease preventable by immunisation because of the actively harmful choices of their parents? It's literally child abuse. Refusing to immunise your child on some completely false belief that it will harm them is no different from letting your child play on a busy road.
- kypro 8y agoSure, I completely understand where you're coming from because I share your concern, but if you truly believed a vaccine wasn't safe and that it had a significant chance of side effects, wouldn't you feel differently? You seem to be making the assumption that researchers always get things right or that there isn't sometimes unexpected consequences. I'm saying this as someone who is extremely happy my parents vaccinated me and wouldn't hesitate to vaccinate my own children, but that doesn't mean I can get on board with forcing parents to inject their children with something they feel could be dangerous. Just look at the state of the opioid epidemic, or the medication of conditions like depression. Medical professionals don't always know what's best for every individual, and arguably if you live in a rural area and home school your children, it's not so important to vaccinate your child. I believe strongly that children are the responsibly of their parents, not the state. I really dislike how the state is becoming the defacto parental figure in most childrens lives.
- raxxorrax 8y agoExactly. Plus, it would be unnecessary. Vaccination quotas are still high and got as high as 98% in the past. Without mandated vaccinations in many cases. So it is possible to get there without decreasing liberties any further. We are on this course of decreasing liberties for decades now and it ruined trust in government and societies. Guess what? If that happens, we see more esoteric fringe groups. Geniuses...
- tomatotomato37 8y agoIt's like nuclear power. It's a great technology that is a net positive to society, but you have one accident and people start rioting
- matwood 8y agoIn some (most?) states vaccines are already required for a child to attend public school. There are some religious and medical exemptions though.