12 ms·
We couldn't stop it. :| Back when it was announced, several people brought concerns up with the supposedly open AMP project, and they were closed or locked, an
by ocdtrekkie 8y ago
We couldn't stop it. :|
Back when it was announced, several people brought concerns up with the supposedly open AMP project, and they were closed or locked, and the head of AMP blocked us. During that time, we found out that while AMP was supposedly "open", Google teams such as Gmail and Search would implement it however they wanted, and that no open governance would impact them at all. In essence, the idea that it was open was only so far as Google would also like you to implement whatever Google was already doing.
- jasti 8y agoThe spec has support from Outlook, Yahoo and others: https://blog.amp.dev/2019/03/26/building-the-future-of-email-with-amp/ https://blog.amp.dev/2019/03/26/building-the-future-of-email...
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoThe problem with monopolies is that nobody else has a choice. If Outlook or Yahoo were to fail to adopt the proprietary Gmail standard, they would eventually end up incompatible with the now-proprietary format of email. Whilst AMP4Email can fall back to HTML, the reality, as with text-only emails after HTML, that many providers will not bother sending multiple formats. Your team has repeatedly refused to address criticisms of AMP from users and the community at large, and continued forward with a program that nobody wants[1]. There's still no way for someone to opt out of AMP as a whole except to use a search engine that doesn't support it, and Gmail seems to lack an AMP switch in settings, so I'm guessing you currently have no plans to let Gmail users escape it either. [1] https://twitter.com/googleampsucks https://twitter.com/googleampsucks - Endless retweets of people's thoughts on AMP.
- fixermark 8y agoOr, based on the evidence... ... Microsoft and Yahoo think it's a good idea and want to support it. There's no particular reason email needs to sit around in the gutter while the rest of the web gets more multimedia and more performant.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> There's no particular reason email needs to sit around in the gutter while the rest of the web gets more multimedia and more performant. Email is not part of the web, and more multimedia and more round trips is not more performant, it's the opposite.
- fixermark 8y ago> Email is not part of the web Content-Type: text/html seems to disagree with your assertion.
- mftrhu 8y agoThe HTML documentation sitting in my /usr/share/doc does not make it part of the web. The output from man -H is not part of the web, no matter what its mime type is. HTML is not the same as the web.
- jxdxbx 8y agoEmail should be plain text. HTML in email itself was a terrible idea, though not as bad as AMP in email.
- felixfbecker 8y agoSome HTML in email is fine, I would say the subset that can be expressed by markdown. Making text bold, italic etc should be possible. The real problem I have is how limited email HTML/CSS and email clients are compared to the web, so that every "rich" email will use table layouts that render terribly on mobile.
- Aeolun 8y agoBut still better than anything else that could reasonably be achieved. Tables are pretty much the only cross-platform/client way to format email.
- 8y ago
- cjhopman 8y ago> and continued forward with a program that nobody wants Don't presume to speak so for others.
- jakubp 8y agoIt's an obvious generalization. Everybody else gets what he meant, don't you?
- craftinator 8y agoSeems the majority gets it.
- wan23 8y agoGoogle doesn't have a monopoly on email. Check your (personal) inbox - I'd bet the majority of emails on the first page are not from Gmail users but rather from various companies and organizations. Even among individuals, while many people get their email from Google, the most popular client (which is what's relevant in this case) is the mail app on the iPhone. Microsoft and Yahoo still have decent market share as well, though much less than I thought before I started writing this with 12-18% between them according to my not-super-rigorous Google search.
- JohnFen 8y ago...and the contagion is already spreading. This effort destroys half of what makes email useful. I know that moving forward, I won't accept amp emails. If anyone sends me one, I'll just have to tell them to please send me a plain-text copy if they really want me to see it. On the plus side, this could make spam much easier to detect: if it's amp-based, then it's most likely to be spam.
- TomMarius 8y agoI am already not reading HTML emails if I'm not expecting them (e.g. confirmation link).
- JohnFen 8y agoYes, I disallow HTML as well. Well, technically, I don't allow HTML to render. If the email is important, then I'll read the HTML source myself and extract the parts that are important.
- EGreg 8y agoWhy??
- bildung 8y agoBecause HTML mails are almost always spam anyway.
- floren 8y agoAnd disabling HTML should help you avoid tracking pixels which tell the sender if you opened the email or not, etc.
- rypskar 8y agoYou don't need to disable HTML for that. Thunderbird blocks remote content in HTML by default and only displays images embedded in the email. Isn't the tracking pixel mostly snake oil since it mostly tell if the user use gmail (preloading images) or an email client that block remote content by default?
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoSo the spec has support from those most likely to benefit from email tracking and walling off. Will email go the way of xmpp?
- TazeTSchnitzel 8y agoWhereas Fastmail think it is a bad idea (unclear if they'll support it in future): https://fastmail.blog/2018/02/14/email-is-your-electronic-memory/ https://fastmail.blog/2018/02/14/email-is-your-electronic-me...
- hw 8y agoThe future of email should be a deprecation of email. Email is an archaic system, where different clients implement their own versions of rendering or sanitizing email. Some platforms don't even include proper email headers. Now there's this 'AMP' that's being shoved up our throats. Not to mention the nuances around deliverability like spf records and dkim. There's also the issue of spam. I'd love to see email go away and more modern messaging platforms take its place. Having worked on apps and platforms that work with and parse email, email is not the future.
- rainonmoon 8y agoI don't disagree that there's room to move away from email, but how do the current crop of messaging services promise to overcome the problems you mentioned? They all seem as varied in their implementations as you suggest email is. I'll also add that I think if something were to replace email, hopefully it would incorporate the slow response expectation of it. IM etc usually implies an expectation of an immediate answer; the length and expectation of not receiving an immediate reply afforded by email is immensely valuable.
- taeric 8y agoHaving different clients is probably an anti fragile mechanism of email. It literally helps keep it around and mostly working. I think the single worst thing to happen to email is the consolidation to so few vendors, ironically. This move is not changing my view. Does make me think heavily of ditching Gmail as a client. I was using emacs, but can't with advanced protection turned on. :(
- progval 8y agoI'm worried that if email gets deprecated, it will be deprecated by a proprietary service because it's more convenient for users (or worse: several incompatible services, most of which proprietary). Like IRC mostly got replaced by Slack and Discord.
- gumby 8y ago> Email is an archaic system, where different clients implement their own versions of rendering As opposed to web browsers which all perform identically?
- discordance 8y agoAgreement between big corps on specs hasn't stopped dominance by one player in the past. Look at HTML5 for an example, with Edge now running on top of Chromium.
- bitpush 8y agoI disagree. I think its a good idea to have safe options, and let developers come up with creative ways of building things on top of it.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoNothing about AMP for Email is safe. It introduces new ways for senders to revise history after an email has been sent. Sent an ad claiming that you had a given price for a full week, and then decided you didn't want to sell it for that anymore two days later? Handy that you can remove all evidence of your advertisement after you sent it. It also introduces an entirely new playground for phishing scams, which I think you'll see using an abundance of new tricks, after Google has extremely unwisely made users comfortable entering data into emails they receive. The head of the AMP project threatened to "enforce the CoC" on people who brought up these valid concerns.
- bitpush 8y ago"Sent an ad claiming that you had a given price for a full week, and then decided you didn't want to sell it for that anymore two days later?" How is that different from - I saw a price for a flight on the website, but now its gone. If it was going to change, why did they show it to me?
- ceejayoz 8y agoThere's a reasonable expectation that a website may get updated. The same is not true for mail.
- cramforce 8y agoEmails already support updating by including external image references inside the email. AMP for email makes json requests proxied by the email client. Your client can decide to only make these requests once and then keep them stable or to show you a version history of the state of your email upon every time you opened it.
- ucaetano 8y ago> while AMP was supposedly "open", Google teams such as Gmail and Search would implement it however they wanted, and that no open governance would impact them at all And that's exactly how any open standard works, isn't it? Or were you expecting that some standard board would have power over Google (or any other company) and be able to dictate how Google (or any other company) can implement the standard or not?
- zamadatix 8y agoYour statement is overly broad, open standards bodies certainly can and have shaped how Google and others implement things, and will continue to do so. Standing up an open standards body in itself does not create pressure though it has to be stood up with backing by different groups with vested interest in guiding the design. This is where the AMP open standards group failed.
- Ajedi32 8y agoDifferent groups such as... Yahoo and Microsoft? https://verizon-postmaster.tumblr.com/post/183699380323/amp-support-in-yahoo-mail https://verizon-postmaster.tumblr.com/post/183699380323/amp-... https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/Outlook-Blog/Support-for-AMP-HTML-preview-in-Outlook-com/ba-p/382832 https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/Outlook-Blog/Support-...
- zamadatix 8y agoUsers of AMP do not necessarily have a vested interest in the design beyond "I'm able to use it if I want". This is e.g. the difference (or at least was for the last ~decade) between mail.yahoo.com using a web feature vs Firefox/Chrome/IE/Safari implementing a web feature.
- Ajedi32 8y agoHow about this then? There are members from Microsoft, Twitter, and Pinterest on the project's technical steering committee: https://github.com/ampproject/meta-tsc https://github.com/ampproject/meta-tsc
- skybrian 8y agoIt seems unsurprising that joining a project with the purpose of stopping it would fail. Wouldn't that be the case with any open source project? The goal is that people who want to work on a thing together can collaborate, not to come to agreement with all the other people who hate the whole idea?
- wmf 8y agoProper standards bodies generally have a "should we even create this standard?" stage but AMP skipped it.
- skybrian 8y agoThey do, but it's also common for some major players in an industry to form an organization to standardize something and for other players (who disagree or don't care) not to join. In the end, it's about market acceptance. If few people use it, it's likely that Google will eventually cancel it.
- dmitriid 8y agoGoogle has monopoly in search, and near-monopoly in desktop email. People are forced to use it, whether they like it or not.
- Ajedi32 8y agoNobody's "forced" to use it. Users can turn off AMP in Gmail, and email authors can continue to just use HTML emails if they don't like AMP. HTML emails will continue to display in Gmail just fine for the foreseeable future.
- dmitriid 8y ago“Forseeable future”. Aka “as soon as Google decides they benefit more from AMP”. Much like “we won’t ever use AMP to rig search results”. And yes, users are forced to use AMP through their search, for example.
- anth_anm 8y ago> In essence, the idea that it was open was only so far as Google would also like you to implement whatever Google was already doing. Standard for anything google makes open. Which is why being "open source" is not enough.
- pmontra 8y ago> During that time, we found out that while AMP was supposedly "open", Google teams such as Gmail and Search would implement it however they wanted Reminds me of the doc/xls formats with the difference that those were proprietary and become (controversially) open as a response to the standardization of the odt/ods formats
- ionised 8y agoSounds like Chromium.