11 ms·
Can we sue Google when they do things like this? No single entity should wield this much power. And we should rewrite the laws to make this so. Google and Appl
by echelon 8y ago
Can we sue Google when they do things like this? No single entity should wield this much power. And we should rewrite the laws to make this so.
Google and Apple wanted to be in the role of gatekeeper, so they should be beholden to the apps on their platform. We had a web where developers were in control of their own deployment. Everything was decentralized and required responsibility and diligence.
Now the power is out of our hands and its unfair. It isn't our choice.
One might argue this is better for consumers, but I honestly don't think so. Technology could have fixed discoverability and provided sandboxing, networks could provide curation. And there would probably be better privacy in the world where Mozilla won instead of Google.
Edit: I am so happy that GDPR and CDPA have arrived to protect consumers. We need similar laws to protect startups, small businesses, and sole proprietors that rely on these platforms to treat us fairly. They owe us that after haven taken away the nice open web we once had. Maybe laws are how we get back the web we lost.
- joeframbach 8y ago> And there would probably be better privacy in the world where Mozilla won instead of Google. In that world Mozilla wouldn't sell your data to Pocket or Stranger Things or whoever knows a bizdev at Mozilla?
- fiddlerwoaroof 8y agoPocket isn’t the same as stranger things since, iirc, Mozilla bought pocket.
- est31 8y agoYes, they've bought Pocket and the recommendation system is built in a way that your data isn't sent to Mozilla but processed on the device. Quite a cool idea IMO and what we should be doing.
- m-p-3 8y agoPocket belongs to Mozilla FYI.
- Terretta 8y agoYou know Apple initially wanted to make web “apps” a thing, you can still save html apps direct to home screen and run them offline to this day.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoThat was an excuse to have something on ship day because their iOS native API wasn't ready for public release.
- saagarjha 8y agoI don't think they ever intended for there to be a public release until jailbreaks became a thing.
- dspillett 8y agoI thought it was more to reduce their effort: * providing infrastructure for the store etc. * worrying about sand-boxing arbitrary native code (instead just needing to concentrate on work separating the one app, the browser, from everything else) * maintaining a public API instead of one they can change at a whim without backlash because only they use it I don't think they quite saw the scale of the revenue stream potential of the App Store at the time, IMO people give Apple too much credit for that. There was a big push from developers for native apps because: * the web APIs were not particularly ready at the time (arguably some things still aren't now) * a combination of lower CPU power than we have become used to in more recent years, and JS & layout engines not optimising as well as they do now, meant that there was a more significant difference in performance between web-app & native, particularly for games
- KirinDave 8y ago> No single entity should wield this much power. And we should rewrite the laws to make this so. I think in fact a lot of people do want them to do this. Folks complain the Play store is full of malware and spam, and that there are data leaks and deceptive ads. Then Google or Apple goes and removes them, and then folks are mad if that process has errors. It seems like a business where you make everyone mad no matter what you do. [edit: Just to be clear, I'm not a fan of the practice. But an awful lot of folks seem to think Apple and Google SHOULD wield editorial power, if only to stop outright malware. And of course, certain politicians want to make sure that the internet refuses to show content unflattering to people in power]
- echelon 8y ago> I think in fact a lot of people do want them to do this. I, the engineer, do not want them to do this. Before Google and Apple, I didn't have this problem. I didn't have to pay their tax or march to their beat. You might argue that it's their platform and that's the cost for us to pay. But it wasn't always this way! These companies leveraged their advantages to steal eyeballs away from an open web and lock them in their own platform. They could have spent money making the open web work better on mobile. Or designing a portable app framework and runtime for all devices. But we know why they didn't and what the outcome has been. I want them to pay back the negative externalities they've leveraged onto us.
- craftyguy 8y ago> I, the engineer, do not want them to do this Eh, you are but one person, amongst billions. There's a good chance that what you don't want != what others want.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoThat's the problem with targeting the lowest common denominator. Since that LCD is mindless consumption, that's what the ecosystem evolves to. If you have stuff to actually do, you're increasingly out of luck.
- 8y ago
- voldacar 8y ago>No single entity should wield this much power. And we should rewrite the laws to make this so. No single entity, except the laws of course ;)
- ucaetano 8y agoOP doesn't like single entities having so much power, so OP increases the power of a single entity.
- Jach 8y agoGoogle et al. might want to take heed anyway. This all reminds me of a quote I love from the Dark Knight movie: "You squeezed them, you hammered them to the point of desperation. And in their desperation, they turned to a man they didn't fully understand."
- ucaetano 8y agoYeah, I don't think that taking policy advice from movie quotes is a good idea...
- lucb1e 8y agoSmall difference between a big for-profit and an elected government...
- ucaetano 8y ago> We need similar laws to protect startups, small businesses, and sole proprietors Yeah, because laws protecting inefficient business are great for society and consumers. No business "deserves" protection. Consumers do, but not business.
- echelon 8y agoApp stores are monopolies, and their governance leaves much to be desired (as is the subject of this article). I'm fine paying the AWS tax. It's a generic utility more or less and I can just as easily use Azure or Google (assuming you're not baked into certain offerings, but that's out of scope and honestly is a choice.) If you want on Android there's no choice. You play by Google's rules and pay their tax. People get up in arms when ISPs try to pull this (net neutrality). This is the same pattern. Phones, OSes, etc. should be "dumb" pipes. (The analogy isn't elegant here, but you get it.)
- ucaetano 8y ago> App stores are monopolies That is a huge claim, thrown around by you with no backing. You could get a few economists to discuss that for ages without reaching a conclusion. Unless you're talking about the layman's definition of monopoly, which means "whatever I want it to mean". This is particularly relevant when there's the Amazon app store, and app preloads, and the Korean app store, and Fortnite isn't available on the Play store. And that's before we get into the fact that iOS competes with Android, and that includes the app stores. This would be like complaining that to get a product to be sold by Walmart, you need to get Walmart to sell it. No matter how you look at it, consumers never had so many choices, prices have never been this low, and app distribution has never been so easy.
- supermatt 8y agoIs the market the common market, or is the android market? Is the commodity mobile apps, or android apps? Google have absolute monopoly of android apps in the common market, and a monopoly of mobile apps in the android market. The EU already ruled this http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-18-4581_en.htm http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-18-4581_en.htm I really don't understand app-store apologists. Its abuse of dominance, plain and simple.
- joshmn 8y agoNot a lawyer, but anti-trust could apply.
- iamthirsty 8y agoNo it can't, Google isn't the only "App Store" in town, and you are not forced to use them, so it in no way could apply.
- balls187 8y ago"Could apply", and "likely to win in court" are two VERY different arguments.
- supermatt 8y agoGoogle is (by far) the dominant supplier of android apps, so it very much applies. We can debate this forever, the only thing that will prove it either way is a legal ruling - and I hope that happens soon, and results in a modernisation of competition law.
- iamthirsty 8y agoBut Android is not a technological monopoly, and Google has not monopolized all Android apps. You might have low standards for the application of anti-trust laws, but the government does not.
- supermatt 8y agoThe EU has already ruled on exactly this.
- iamthirsty 8y agoThe EU is much more neo-liberal than the U.S., and as a Libertarian, I'll wait and see what I trust is a more "valid" ruling — the opinion of a U.S. federal judge. If he/she rules a monopoly, and their opinion stands, I'll come back and give you kudos — alas, I don't think it will happen.
- dahfizz 8y agoWhen there are free and open source alternatives like fdroid, I don't see how the law could force Google to host an app that they don't want to. Google only gatekeeps what they host, not what exists on the platform. I do think there is a case here against apple because they do gatekeep what the user has access to, but people love to fine Google way more than they do apple, even tough apple is infinitely more anticompetitive and anticonsumer IMO.
- rswail 8y agoHow is Apple anti-competitive in terms of iOS? They onbly supply iOS to themselves and the App Store is only available to Apple products. You could argue that they take advantage of the desire of app developers to access their market, but that's not "anticompetitive". It's unfair, but life wasn't meant to be fair.
- dahfizz 8y agoGoogle has been fined before for optionally bundling free apps with Android. How is that anticompetitive when apple forcibly bundles thier software and ecosystem with thier hardware? IANAL but I think it's an unfortunate result of how the antitrust laws work. Because Google provides a free OS and works with partners to make handsets, etc, they fall under extreme scrutiny. But apple doubles down on being a walled garden where you must use only thier hardware, software, and app platform. Because they don't have any partners like Google does, there's no interactions that apple has that can be taken as anticompetitive, even though the way they force thier users into thier ecosystem is very anticompetitive imo.
- bitL 8y agoIf Mozilla folks weren't so inflexible, we could have had writable local file access long time ago (Google was pushing that actually), making PWAs with WebAssembly viable desktop app replacements, rendering walled gardens useless. Yet here we are when a heuristics in a bot causes false positives with far reaching consequences and customer support is ran as an automated joke as well, making innocent victims helpless.
- chessturk 8y agoCan you elaborate / link me to more info on this? I'm curious about this WebAssembly-PWA-everywhere land I don't live in.
- ams6110 8y agoNo you can't sue them. Nobody has a right to publish apps on Google Play. They can be as arbitrary or incompetent as they like in what they do. As long as they aren't violating some protected class criteria, there's not much a court is going to do. Google hasn't taken away anything. There is still a web and you're free to deploy what you want there on your terms. (Edits to correct Google's autocorrect errors.)
- sverhagen 8y agoDidn't they take away the level playing field when they created the playing field?
- ams6110 8y agoThey built a nice new field with a wall around it and guards at the gates. The old open field with all the weeds and litter is still there.
- wuliwong 8y agoI was wondering if there is any legal recourse for a situation where: 1. I create a business that operates inside a marketplace that you own. 2. We have an agreement that says you will allow me to operate as long as I don't violate your terms of service. 3. I am kicked out of the marketplace but did not violate the TOS. If there was a line in the agreement that the either party could terminate the agreement at anytime for any reason, I guess the TOS doesn't really matter. But is that what exists right now in these app stores?
- untangle 8y ago> Can we sue Google when they do things like this? No single entity should wield this much power. Of course you can. This is America and anybody can sue anybody for anything (with few exceptions). Winning the suit is another matter. Unless you have smoking-gun evidence of discrimination or some such, I'd say the case would be DOA. Of course, the costs of the suit would likely be prohibitive as well. I don't think that many lawyers would take a case like this on contingency. Maybe pro bono.
- doodliego 8y agoThis is why class action lawsuits exist.
- hedora 8y agoSo far, the law has been doing everything it can to make these problems worse. The DMCA outsourced due process for copyright infringement. SOSTA did it for illegal advertising (really, for policing morals, in general, but even the title of the bill agrees it was outsourcing sex trafficking law enforcement to private entities). The CLOUD act did it for illegal domestic searches and also foreign espionage. Caveat emptor — the big internet companies that lobbied so hard for these bills (or built businesses on them) got some short term platform lock-in, but they also guaranteed that their business models would be morally reprehensible moving forward. We’re starting to see the fall out with Facebook, but they are not the only bad actor in this space.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> The DMCA outsourced due process for copyright infringement. No, it didn't. What it did was protect online service providers from liability for either hosting or removing allegedly infringing content if they took certain action when notified of potential problems from either side (to the extent the results seem asymmetrical, it's because the pre-existing legal risk was asymmetrical.) > SOSTA did it for illegal advertising SESTA/FOSTA was kind of the opposite of DMCA; instead of creating a safe harbor that protected firms from existential risks that were starting to drive them out of hosting user content, it creates new holes on an existing safe harbor and drove providers out of carrying broad categories of user content around the area legally targetted.
- cdf2theworld 8y agoRegarding the DMCA, I think you need to insert the word "intended" in there, in order to make it a try statement. The DMCA was intended to provide those protections... It has become a channel for baseless abuse.
- eridius 8y agoMost of the "baseless abuse" actually isn't DMCA, it's abuse of systems that services like YouTube set up to make it easy for copyright holders to submit takedowns without going through DMCA.
- Simple_Guy 8y agoImagine you started a really cool walled garden, invited everybody over, and they all enjoy it. Then you kick out a few trolls, and one of them thinks that the government should come in and forcibly allow the trolls back in. It's my garden, my choice. You are still allowed to publish your app on the web.
- hayd 8y agoIf you kicked out African Americans would you say it's your garden, your choice?
- mav3rick 8y agoNo because discrimination based on color is forbidden by the law. Discrimination on clearly set rules by the company that are not against fundamental laws is allowed. Also, your analogy is way off the mark. Comparing throwing of an app to racial discrimination weakens the very point you're trying to make.
- kuschku 8y ago> Discrimination on clearly set rules by the company that are not against fundamental laws is allowed. Unless (in the EU) the company holds a significant market position, which Google does. In that moment they become subject to antitrust and monopoly laws, and can’t choose with whom to do business anymore.
- mav3rick 8y agoThe HN bubble is real. At this scale it's hard to make everyone happy. Go have fun with your negativity.
- Simple_Guy 8y agoYes. In a perfect society, one would be free to invite whomever one wants to one's walled garden party without fear that a mob would form to lynch you because your walled garden party does not have a trans-species potatokin.
- Old_Thrashbarg 8y agoI totally agree. I think people have a lot of status quo bias though so will argue that 2 corporations controlling all apps on mobile devices is actually a good thing. If that had never come to be and it was decentralized instead, no one would be lamenting that corporations weren't in charge. For example, few people think it would have been good if a corporation had beat out the WWW. On a side note, it's important to appreciate where companies didn't win and not take it for granted: online encyclopedia, email, many programming languages, anything where an open-source solution won.
- User23 8y agoYou can sue Google whenever you like. If you can afford it.
- apatters 8y agoThis is just another example of how crappy Google's customer sevice is. News flash, monopolies always have crappy customer service, duopolies and oligopolies are almost as bad. Phone OSes and app stores are a duopoly, Google and Apple are the only games in town, what the US needs to do is look at its antitrust and pro competition laws, figure out if they make sense for the information age and then apply them. This might be happening in the very early stages now, when Trump appointed Rohit Chopra as an FTC Commissioner last year one of Chopra's first moves was to hire Lina Khan, an antitrust academic who is critical of the FAANG companies and has clashed with Google very publicly. I can only think of one reason the FTC would hire Khan, to find reasons for going after the tech giants.