15 ms·
Why Haven't Voters Been Buying the Case for Increasing Housing Supply?
- uberman 8y agoWhat is the incentive for a voter who currently owns a home in an expensive market to be in favor of more housing?
- troydavis 8y agoThis is arguably the main problem. That said, in some urban areas, renters are the majority. For example, in 2010, 52% of housing units in the City of Seattle were occupied by renters[1], and that’s not counting townhouse/condo owners and supportive home owners. If renters voted the same way on an initiative, they’d set policy. If everyone who doesn’t own a single-family home (renter or not) did so, it would be a landslide. 1: http://www.seattle.gov/opcd/population-and-demographics/about-seattle#housing http://www.seattle.gov/opcd/population-and-demographics/abou...
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> That said, in some urban areas, renters are the majority. For example, in 2010, 52% of housing units in the City of Seattle were occupied by renters[1], and that’s not counting townhouse/condo owners and supportive home owners. The problem with this is that it costs approximately the same amount to rent as it does to own, by the time you take into account interest, taxes, insurance, maintenance, etc. So the people who rent in the expensive area are already the people who can afford to live there, they're just the people who prefer to rent. If you tell them increasing the housing supply will reduce purchasing costs, what do they care? They're not looking to buy. Increasing the housing supply would also tend to reduce rents, but this discussion is usually framed as "people can't afford to buy a home" so many renters may tune out at that point and not comprehend the relationship to rents. Especially when people see propaganda about new developments increasing rents, which only happens if other neighborhoods aren't building enough new housing, because then higher density is valuable when it's scarce. The whole point is to build enough to make it less scarce. Moreover, one of the major reasons people prefer to rent is for mobility, i.e. they expect not to be there in ten years. Meanwhile the people who do want to buy there but can't afford it are the people who currently live somewhere else, which means they don't get a vote.
- jraby3 8y agoWell put. I’d also add that many renters (who prefer mobility) may not necessarily go through the voter registration process in a new city if they don’t expect to stay there more than a couple of years.
- blackflame7000 8y agoThis is it in a nutshell. But as the babyboomer population starts to decline their will likely be some supply increase as millenials don’t have the numbers or the wealth to afford the properties that become available at current market prices.
- mc32 8y agoBoomers aren’t the only owners of housing. Pretty much becoming an owner (whatever stratum) puts you on the other side.
- blackflame7000 8y agoI was simply stating that because there are more baby boomers than the generations that follow there will inevitably be a surplus of houses since not all have children to pass down to or even if they do the children are likely to sell and split the money
- mc32 8y agoThe way I see it, whoever buys from boomers will turn around and become the interested in continuing this trend. In other words it’s not being a boomer or non boomer or being the generation with most housing equity etc but simply being a homeowner.
- almost_usual 8y agoTheir kids get the houses
- dominotw 8y agoMore ppl = more commerce, more jobs, higher property prices. Same reason to support h1b visa.
- nashashmi 8y agoDo voters never think about their own family members or their own kids one day growing up and living next to them? This is a problem when society is becoming less communal and more nimby like.
- rdlecler1 8y agoHigh housing costs are a tax that gets passed on with higher priced goods and services.
- aetherson 8y agoI own a house in San Bruno and I'd support more development. The benefits of higher housing prices for owners are massively overstated: I wouldn't realize any gain until I moved out of the area, which I probably won't do for decades if ever. In the mean time, the housing market just makes more painful for me to move. I don't want the value of my house to crash down to 10% of it's present cost, but I'd be fine with no appreciation for a couple of decades, or a moderate drop in value.
- uberman 8y agoI'm not aware of any intrinsic benefit to a high priced house other than housing being a leveraged investment, but that is clearly a double edged sword. In my opinion. this is the heart of the issue. I want to be clear that there might be many great personal reasons (@raldi has some listed above) to be in favor of more housing stock. However, in the context of the assertion of the original article that voters just don't understand econ 101 supply and demand my feeling is that the majority of homeowners (who are disproportionately voters) understand econ 101 supply and demand perfectly well and that the article does a disservice suggesting that they don't. If I own a highly priced, highly leveraged and, highly demanded investment (such as a house in the bay area), what is my (per the original article) clear as day "econ 101" motivation to help increase supply and thereby reduce the value of this investment? In the context of the original article there is simply no econ 101 incentive for me as a voter to support policies that devalue my investment. Remember, as a highly leveraged investment, a drop in price of just 5% could easily wipe out my entire investment while doing almost nothing to make housing fundamentally more affordable to others. I want to reiterate, there could be many great non-economic motivators for a current homeowner in a high demand market to support more housing. These motivations just fall outside the context of the original article about the unwillingness of voters to understand econ 101 supply and demand.
- aetherson 8y agoWell, I'm sure conversation on this thread is super dead, but: What you're saying all makes sense in the context of house-as-investment. But unlike other investments, you need housing, and if your house's value appreciates, you can't just sell and put that money in something else -- unless you're moving out of the area. You could sell your house and rent, but rents and house prices move roughly similarly, so you don't save much doing so. If you sell and buy another house in the area, you just end up moving your money from one "investment" to another and probably have some tax problems (from Prop 13, in California). "Wiping out my entire investment" is less of a concern when all that means is that you can buy another equivalent house at the new price, and appreciating is less of a benefit when it means you need to buy another equivalent house at the new price. Going actually underwater on your loans is of course bad -- though most people shouldn't be so leveraged that modest drop puts them underwater. And those who are about to move out of the area or downsize, sure, they have much more of a traditional investment mentality. But if you're 20+ years from that? If you might never move away or get a smaller house? The value of your house means very little.
- raldi 8y ago* I want to act locally to help fight climate change (by allowing more people to live in a walkable neighborhood within a car-free commute of great jobs) * I want my friends to stop leaving the city and state * I want my daughter to be able to afford to move out of the house in 20 years * I want the lusher culture population density brings (better museums, more art, more interesting foods and shops, a wider variety of orgs and interest groups for me to join...) * I want my kids schools to be less desperate for teachers, who currently are constantly quitting because they either live here and can't make ends meet or they live far away and burn out on their commute * I care about the plight of others
- arcticbull 8y agoOh they get it, they’re just looking out for themselves. Property owners account for 72% of the voting block and have strong roots in the community where renters tend to be more transient [1]. In America, as a property owner, your home is probably your largest investment. The perception here for better or worse is that more housing means less demand for yours, so you lose money. It’s like wondering why the foxes don’t vote for razor wire around the chicken coops. Not in a malicious way, it’s just not in their interests. For what it’s worth I own, and am fine with new development because I think it’s not nearly as detrimental as it’s made out to be. I think the community benefits both directly with diversity of people and indirectly as it supports more jobs but I feel very much in the minority. tl:dr; it’s because renters don’t vote and voters don’t rent. [1] https://www.apartmentlist.com/rentonomics/renters-and-voting/ https://www.apartmentlist.com/rentonomics/renters-and-voting...
- gumby 8y agoCame to say this so thanks for being so clear. In Palo Alto I've seen an additional nuance. When I first moved here (1984) houses were underwater and there was lots of student rental. As Stanford built student housing, most of the houses became single family but there was an aggressive effort to keep the environment diversified (e.g. two SRO hotels downtown, section 8 requirements, and a lower median income than surrounding towns). Then in the late 90s/early 00s the real estate interests took over the city council. It was in their interest to restrict supply for the reasons you stated; if you built it was to build larger, higher priced units as replacement for existing stock which are marketed to newcomers. It's great to have new neighbors, but when you move in and worry about the cost of your mortgage, you aren't really interested any more about the structure and balance of the community. Taller buildings have been resisted as have most new multifamily residences. As a result, the median income has shot up, teachers, cops, firefighters and the like can no longer live here. It's a different and much less interesting place.
- masonic 8y agoa lower median income than surrounding towns The "surrounding towns" are East Palo Alto, Menlo Park, and Mountain View. When has any of these had a higher median income than Palo Alto?
- ineedasername 8y agoAuthor says that increased luxury housing will trickle down to lower level housing. I'm not so sure. I wish I could find it, and maybe it's a bit anecdotal, but I came across something recently that said decent sized chunks of luxury housing in NYC is basically bought and left vacant by people using it essentially as an investment vehicle. If this is the case, additional high end housing will not trickle down to the same net effect on supply & demand as additional low-end/affordable housing.
- crumpets 8y agoThen keep building more. It will stop being such an attractive investment when the supply isn’t constrained.
- MrMorden 8y agoIn NYC those luxury apartment towers get massive property tax breaks, because of course they do. Vacant housing should be charged (a lot) more tax—at eye-watering rates if that's what it takes for it to be rented out—but that's still not a substitute for simplifying zoning, eliminating parking minimums, and everything else that makes it more expensive to build housing without a good reason.
- Ericson2314 8y agoYeah I'm surprised the article didn't bring up design. Shit like Hudson yards is so bad that the New York Times calls it a "Neoliberal Zion"[1]. Anything that comes off primarily as a "fuck you" status symbol is not going to inspire popular support. Just compare the street level unit density of old new buildings anywhere in the city. Absolutely none of the relearned lessons of walkability, integration with the rest of the city, etc., being applied. 1: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/03/14/arts/design/hudson-yards-nyc.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/03/14/arts/design/h...
- treis 8y agoFrom the article: >[The Vessel] ... ruinously manspreading Is that what passes for journalism these days?
- ineedasername 8y agoMight not significant improvements in mass transit might help this problem quite a bit as well? If a commute from 20-30 miles away was trivial, more people on the lower end of the economic scale could live further from urban centers where housing prices are at their peak.
- losteric 8y agoYes, but if you're far enough that the housing pricing works out the density will also be too low - translating to many stops or areas feeling underserved.
- ineedasername 8y agoVery good point, that is in fact what happens after about 40 miles out from NYC. In fact a bus company recently tried a new direct route from a town at the 39 mile mark and cancelled it after 5 weeks when the average ridership was 10 people (on a 53 seat bus). Some mornings there were none. Just a little closer, around 30 miles, is still viable though. And three spidering train routes service a large population between 5 and 30 miles out, and around which townships have flourished over the last few decades. I think it's common for people further out from the train line to drive to it and park and ride. That does add to the commute time though. Much as I have mixed feelings about Elon Musk these days, his Boring company gamble does seem to have potential to leapfrog current bottlenecks on mass transit.
- sanxiyn 8y agoYes, mass transit is one answer because it warps geography of time. It is also why it is so political: route of mass transit has massive impact on nearby housing market.
- aetherson 8y agoBut in California, major transit extensions take a decade or more to complete and cost tens of billions of dollars. It would be hard to build enough housing to make a serious effect on prices: it's probably five times harder to build enough transit to have a serious effect on prices.
- Cyclone_ 8y agoIf only luxury housing gets built eventually the amount of middle class housing will become too scarce. This is quite apparent in Boulder, when I lived there the citizens were quite good at banding together to prevent any development that wasn't going to be upper middle class and above.
- burlesona 8y agoYes..... but historically a lot of middle class housing was luxury housing 20 years prior. You can see this in older areas all the time. I think a place like Boulder - smaller city, with most of its wealth and housing problems coming from national recognition and “lifestyle appeal” - is in a slightly different boat than most places.
- Lazare 8y agoOn the face of that, this seems like a nonsensical objection. In my view, obviously "middle class housing" is just "average quality housing"; as more luxury homes are built, existing housing stock will start to be considered as middle class or working class. Further, this is how things have worked historically; in most cities I have been in, the working class housing stock is invariably older, and was originally built for other purposes, eg, a mansion now turned into apartments, or a middle class house now turned into a duplex, or simply a bunch of originally middle class tract housing now that the middle class can afford better. We have not historically, nor are we now, building large amounts of purpose-built working class housing. > If only luxury housing gets built eventually the amount of middle class housing will become too scarce. If housing of any type is built, then housing will not be scarce. If no housing of any type is built, then housing will be scarce. Worrying about the type seems like misguided micromanaging.
- andrewflnr 8y ago> If housing of any type is built, then housing will not be scarce. If no housing of any type is built, then housing will be scarce. Worrying about the type seems like misguided micromanaging. TFA is devoted entirely to debunking this idea and explaining in detail why worrying about the type of housing is very important. IMO it did a pretty solid job. If you have an actual counter-argument, let's hear it, but don't just assert it.
- burlesona 8y agoOne reason this is less of a problem in Texas is the high property tax rates (about 3% per year vs. 1% here in California). Combine that with no prop 13 and you have homeowners with mixed incentives — yes, equity appreciation is nice, but ouch the tax bill! Thus you have a lot of home owners who support keeping costs down via supply growth. In Texas, taxes are heavily leavied against _wealth_ and _lifestyle_: high property tax, high sales tax (but none on staple goods and tax holidays for back to school etc.), and no income tax. Conversely in CA, the tax structure makes it easy to shelter wealth (low property taxes AND they never increase), with moderate sales tax and high, almost flat income taxes (the brackets ramp quickly to 9.5% at $45k then are flat to $1m/yr). Not surprising so many people are moving to Texas in search of an easier ladder to climb. Having made the opposite move for a big tech job, the headwinds here against upward mobility are really striking.
- option 8y agoNo, the property tax is not low in CA. What you pay is tax_rate*assesed_value. Because value is high what you actually pay is huge amount of money on what is considered a very modest house in other places
- klipt 8y agoBut if you bought your $2 million house for $200k a few decades ago, you're still paying taxes on it like it's $200k (plus some tiny increases that fall well below inflation). Thanks Prop 13!
- option 8y agoyes, thanks to the prop 13 a teacher or retired couple are able to keep the house the’ve lived in for a huge part of their lives. And even with prop 13 the taxes are increasing every year (by~2% I think)
- SamReidHughes 8y agoTexas also has a law about that for retired people. But they only defer the taxes until death.
- charlie0 8y agoAs someone who recently moved out of Los Angeles in search of more affordable housing and a better traffic situation, I would vote against building more housing in Los Angeles due to overcrowdedness. There's just simply too many people living there and the traffic is insane. The city should work on fixing other issues first, like public transportation and mixed zoning rather than allowing more housing to be built.
- burlesona 8y agoSerious question, why should they ban more housing and not ban more jobs instead? I’ve never heard anyone suggest restricting job growth when a place is “overcrowded,” but why else do people move there?
- almost_usual 8y agoNice year long weather, beach access, other amenities, etc
- BurningFrog 8y agoThe way California works, housing is an economical loss for local governments while jobs are a profit center. This in itself fully explains the absurd California job/housing situation. If we changed those laws, it would solve itself just through the greed/invisible hand of local government.
- charlie0 8y agoI've been asking myself this question as well. Despite the high rents and the insane traffic people still keep coming. Either that or the millennials never moved out. I know plenty of people, some are family, where 5 or 6 adults live in a 2 bedroom home. That's why street parking is hard to come by. Again, this is my own experience from living in a working class neighborhood.
- BurningFrog 8y agoBuilding more housing near work locations should make traffic less insane. Or is that maybe what you mean by "mixed zoning"?
- narrator 8y agoRents are super high in New York and Hong Kong and they are high density.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoThat's an interesting point. For example, whenever people talk about increasing road building to alleviate traffic these days on places like Reddit, they are immediately lectured to about how more roads just cause induced demand and they don't actually cause traffic to go down. For highly desirable cities I have to wonder if the same thing is true for housing. I mean, it feels like even if you doubled the amount of housing in SF that you would just cause more people to want to congregate in SF while 3rd tier cities and rural areas would empty out even faster.
- wbl 8y agoAnd that makes all the new people better off. But we can measure this effect and I recall the city economist found every 3٪ increase in housing stock dropped rents 1%.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> For example, whenever people talk about increasing road building to alleviate traffic these days on places like Reddit, they are immediately lectured to about how more roads just cause induced demand and they don't actually cause traffic to go down. People misunderstand how that works. If you have a road which is excessively congested, the congestion suppresses demand. Nobody wants to sit in traffic for two hours, so people stay home or make use of flexible hours to commute at what would otherwise be less convenient times etc. If you add capacity to the road then the congestion gets better, but not by as much as you would have expected if you looked at the existing traffic, because the fact that it got better caused some of the congestion-suppressed demand to return, which made it less better. So the net result is that it got a little better when you expected it to get a lot better. But that doesn't mean you can't fix it by adding supply, it just means you need enough supply to satisfy the whole demand, including the demand that was suppressed by the high congestion (or in the housing case by the high prices). Of course, in the road case there are also alternative ways to satisfy demand, like building more housing so that people can live closer to where they work and don't have to drive as many miles.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- remote_phone 8y agoIncreased housing in high cost locations DOES NOT decrease prices. This is a complete fallacy. The problem is that the supply is limited and it solidifies comps and makes people more sure that high prices are legitimate. Look at Bay Meadows in San Mateo. An entire community has been built in the last few years. There are a ton of condos, townhouses and single family homes built in quite frankly a well thought out community. Townhouses are over $1.5M and SFH, which are yards away from the Caltrain are over $2M. This is entirely new supply and their prices are higher than existing houses. The prices in the area didn’t go down, they went up because this legitimizes the high prices and solidifies them. The only way you get lower house prices is by killing demand like during the housing bust, not by increasing supply because supply doesn’t happen at the scale that is required to decrease prices.
- cletus 8y agoYou're talking about a community of 2000 residents [1] out of over 7 million residents in the San Francisco Bay Area [2]. Do you really expect it to change the housing cost equation at all? In a largely unregulated market land use is largely dictated by how expensive that land is. Developers don't otherwise just decide to build high rises, mid rises, townhouses or SFHs. It's why the 3-6 story condo complexes you get in, say, Santa Clara County you don't get in Manhattan. Now obviously this is complicated by regulation, demand in different market segments, what the infrastructure can support, etc but the prices you give seem to suggest the land value is extremely high. Building low density housing on that is going to lead to really high prices. [1] https://baymeadows.com/2017/12/22/2017-lets-do-the-numbers/ https://baymeadows.com/2017/12/22/2017-lets-do-the-numbers/ [2] http://www.bayareacensus.ca.gov/ http://www.bayareacensus.ca.gov/
- crooked-v 8y ago> Increased housing in high cost locations DOES NOT decrease prices. This is a complete fallacy. [citation needed]
- Camillo 8y agoA couple of observations: 1) In the segmented model, the cross-segment elasticity limits the impact of high-end supply on lower-segment prices, but that applies just as much to the impact of _high-end demand_. Yet the same people who reject high-end supply as a solution are much more likely to believe in high-end demand as a cause (those damn techies pushing housing prices up!). 2) There is a significant number of singles with high-paying jobs in San Francisco who are living with roommates, in tiny studios, etc. These people who would live in much larger and better housing in any other city. Thus there is a good reason to believe that the cross-segment elasticity in San Francisco is actually quite high. 3) In general, nobody believes in Economics 101 when it comes to policy, unless it aligns with their other preferences.
- duxup 8y agoOutside of urban areas or even just urban centers....I don't think it really is a big topic.
- eldavido 8y agoGreat article that adds a lot to a nuanced and controversial topic. I'm surprised they don't consider time as a dimension of market segmentation, i.e. what is "luxury" today might become "standard" or even "basic" as time progresses. Even things that you'd think would stay static over time don't -- houses are larger today than they used to be, and I could very much imagine people standing around 100 years ago talking about only "the rich with their luxury running water" can afford to live in a certain area. I think long-term the solution really is just to build, and build, and build. Over time, if builders consistently add supply to the top of the market, it will gradually slide downmarket as it ages and its amenities become more standard. I think the biggest problem is that in California, the normal process of adding luxury units has been paused for 20 years due to anti-developer sentiment, and they're trying to make up for it now, at all once. I'm reminded of a saying: the best time to plant a tree is 20 years ago, but the second-best time is today. Another thing, and I wasn't even going to mention it, but any Bay Area real estate developer will tell you [0], it's very difficult adding supply to the middle of the market here because things are just so damn expensive. Affordability is not and never was the priority. It's 500K to build a middle-market affordable unit before the developer makes a cent of profit. For that, thank buy-local regulations, environmental legislation like CEQA, organized labor, huge "developer impact fees", extremely long wait times (years) for permits to get approval, and now "inclusionary housing" requirements that force developers to cross-subsidize below-market rate housing by jacking up the prices of the market-rate units. It's madness. [0] I'm married to an architect working in the Bay Area.
- Animats 8y agoBecause the US doesn't have a housing shortage nationally. The vacant houses and the jobs are in different places. If you want a cheap foreclosed house in San Bernardino, CA, here's a list.[1] That's in Southern California, not too far from LA. It's not Cleveland or Detroit. Developers overbuilt in the last boom. [1] https://www.zillow.com/san-bernardino-ca/foreclosures/ https://www.zillow.com/san-bernardino-ca/foreclosures/
- pcwalton 8y agoThere's a reason why those houses are cheap. Commuting from the Inland Empire to Los Angeles is miserable. It's an hour if there's no traffic, which of course is never the case in Southern California.
- jimmaswell 8y agoWe need some way to incentivize companies to spread out more instead of overstuffing these same places more and more.
- Ericson2314 8y agoNo cities are far more efficient (engery, economically, culturally...). Suburbs are massively subsized miserable alienation farms that only appear cheaper.
- jimmaswell 8y agoThere are more cities out there than what you find around SV, and there are middle grounds between super-dense and rural.
- burfog 8y agoThe problem may have been created by our norm becoming the 2-income household. Previously, one would simply move to the location of a suitable job. Now, the pair of people must find a pair of suitable jobs. It is easy to find a small city with a job for one person, but not easy to find a small city with a pair of jobs that might be wildly unrelated. For example, one person is a petroleum engineer and the other person is an avionics repair technician. Finding one job or the other in a small city is easy. Finding both in the same small city is hard.
- squirrelicus 8y agoBecause for the government to have an effect on the housing supply, they need to find a way to lower the price. At best homeowners risk losing their equity, at worse they become upside down and are subidizing the new construction with their own martgage losses.
- chrisbrandow 8y agoThis is great work. It does a great job bridging the gap between the true but l overly simple supply and demand arguments with the complex dynamics of housing markets. Bravo to the author!!
- eecsninja 8y agoRemember when Tokyo was expensive? https://www.ft.com/content/023562e2-54a6-11e6-befd-2fc0c26b3c60 https://www.ft.com/content/023562e2-54a6-11e6-befd-2fc0c26b3...
- rjf72 8y agoI think supply + demand oversimplifies one major issue. Wages are extremely inflated in certain hotkey areas with housing issues. There was a story somebody shared a couple of months back on here about somebody in the Bay Area working at a cafe unable to find affordable housing on the $75k he was taking home. The point of the article was supposed to be pointing out that even such high wages don't solve the problem, but I think the more salient point is that high wages cause the problem. Cafe work is relatively low skill. When you can take home 250% the median personal income for low skill work, you're never going to find affordable housing. Such high wages are already driving seemingly endless economic migration with unaffordable housing. Add in reasonably affordable housing and you just exponentially increase the demand. The point of this is that I think it's questionable about whether or not you can build your way out of this. There are two examples we can look at for lessons: Hong Kong and Tokyo. The current situation is that both are extremely densely populated areas. Hong Kong has 17,552 people per square mile, Tokyo's at 16,121. Hong Kong is extremely expensive whereas Tokyo has become a somewhat reasonably affordable place to live. Many people have tried to attribute this to various programs the Japanese government has carried out. In reality, one factor plays a dominant role. In the 90s many expected Japan to become the world's leading economy. They were actually far ahead of the US in terms of GDP/capita. Since then they've gone through decades of something between recession and stagnation. Their GDP was higher in 1995 than it is today. Hong Kong, by contrast, is much more like all the other areas facing housing pricing issues. Their GDP continues to exponentially accelerate - far more than doubling since 1995 with a continuing exponential growth. Japan, in general, became affordable because it became economically less desirable. And ultimately I think that is the only solution - but it's one few would ever lobby for! On the other hand if your goal is not to actually create affordable housing, but instead to simply maximize your GDP then things become much more interesting - but that's an entirely different topic.
- homerhomer 8y agoChinese investment buyers can't be helping the situation. https://www.cnbc.com/2019/01/08/chinese-middle-class-buying-up-american-residential-real-estate.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/01/08/chinese-middle-class-buying-... Vancouver B.C. had it so bad that they had to tax foreign investment purchasing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_28_(British_Columbia) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_28_(British_Columbia)
- crb002 8y agoNIMBY voters. The issue is 100% local zoning to allow less parking spaces, efficiency units, inlaw apartments in suburban houses, allow multi-family housing, and allow zoning of nearby grocery stores.
- whydoineedthis 8y agoTo summarize: voters aren't dumb, they do do economics, and the economics clearly spell out that building luxury housing isn't in the majority interest, but building anything else isn't in the developers interest. Is this really rocket science?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Ericson2314 8y agoA land value tax should never brought up as it has wide support among economists for precisely the purpose of improving land use necessary to make building more housing most productive. Maybe it takes a huge amount of luxery housing before another type gets "naturally" made, but with good land use at least the rest isn't stuck with crippling commutes. If we had good land use, we could probably get away with saturating the luxery housing market and not sticking everyone else with terrible commutes.
- purplezooey 8y agoRemember that middle-aged guy that lived next to that lake house that Tony Soprano wanted to buy? All city councils are made up of that guy.
- jldugger 8y agoHere's just a sampling of the rhetoric I see on Nextdoor in Silicon Valley: > See where the Wheels and Deals is going to be torn down and have another living complex built there? And the old nursery, a pre-school as well! It's never going to end until all of El Camino is a mess of roaming cars and people. Our whole area is going to be turned into an over populated dump. And in case you weren't clear on who's doing the over population, the poster later makes clear their opinion on the subject: > These living places aren't being built at the alarming rate they are because there's a line of people waiting. NO sir.....there being built to ATTRACT them here. WHY.. would we want that? Politicians can shove all their forced urban developments. They're not living in them. > And for the record, the state of California and it's past buffoon elected officials are the ones to blame. If they weren't so busy preaching sanctuary state they would have come up a population control plan. That's whats needed. Not trashing cities with every element that has little to offer.