5 ms·
Isn't Heroku really expensive though? I looked at it a few weeks ago and the cheapest plan was $25/month (there's also a $7 "Hobby" plan though, but that seems
by arp242 8y ago
Isn't Heroku really expensive though? I looked at it a few weeks ago and the cheapest plan was $25/month (there's also a $7 "Hobby" plan though, but that seems just for, well, hobby stuff?)
I instead got a Linode VPS at $5/month, which gives me more than the $25 Heroku plan? Setting up a VPS is not very hard either – although this may depend a bit on your environment, my app compiles to a static binary – and a lot more flexible.
My devops stack thus far consists of scp and tmux.
- bgorman 8y agoLook into Dokku, it is a free Heroku clone that you can run on a cheap VPS. I set it up last week and now all I have to do to deploy is type "git push dokku master".
- winrid 8y agoThanks! Maybe it would be worth replacing my 100 line nodejs script that does the same thing with this in the future :) (not sarcasm, if this works the same and adds more value I'd use it)
- rorykoehler 8y agoSecond dokku. Its essentially a 100 line node js script if u remember correctly. Nice eco system growing around it. No scaling though
- 52-6F-62 8y agoI missed this comment and made a similar one up-thread. I’ll second. I’m ignorant as to whether large projects have run using it, but for smaller ones it’s useful.
- dyeje 8y agoI'll second this. Have had a great experience with dokku, about as simple as Heroku.
- kbar13 8y agoi dont get this thinking of how $25/month is considered expensive when heroku has already figured out and abstracted away all the busy work that's required for deploying code
- barbecue_sauce 8y agoHeroku is great, but that's 5x the cost of Linode/Digital Ocean + Dokku.
- onlyrealcuzzo 8y agoUnless you're a pretty large company, 5x the price in server hosting probably isn't worth your time worrying about.
- tracker1 8y agoOr working on a handful of personal projects that aren't revenue generating.
- acdha 8y agoUnless the goal is to get more ops experience, wouldn’t those be an especially tempting place to spend more time on the project and less on support toil?
- marcosdumay 8y agoWhat toil? You put a service up, it stays up.
- acdha 8y agoUnless you’re just dropping a .php file in a shared server account, you have more setup and upgrade work setting up a running service. The first time it fails and you have to manually rebuild it, you’ll learn a valuable lesson about the PaaS value-add, too.
- mromanuk 8y agoTry caprover.com, minimalistic orchestration similar to Heroku or Dokku (but with a GUI). Can scale too with Docker Swarm. I'm using it and it's a breeze, really happy with it. Previously I was using Rancher, but didn't like the switch from Cattle to Kubernetes.
- xtagon 8y agoJust tried CapRover this weekend for a hobby project and it was even easier to set up than Dokku. The NetData monitoring integration is great too, and just as painless to set up. For use cases where support plans and SLAs are not an issue (hobby), it's a great option.
- Smerity 8y agoA third recommendation for CapRover. It's simple, it's beautiful, and it's open source. I've been enjoying it so far :) CapRover also features one click SSL generation via Let's Encrypt, similar to what is offered on Heroku.
- jshen 8y agoLook into google app engine. It’s very similar and much cheaper. For hobby projects the free tier is usually sufficient.
- rorykoehler 8y agoIt gets much more expensive quite quickly
- jshen 8y agoNot really. I run large enterprise apps on it and it’s cheaper than anything else I’ve used.
- caprese 8y agoHeroku's $7 instances and the $25 instances are not very different. There is also the free instance that sleeps for 6 hours. You have to factor in that you get free tiers of many things, all managed together like docker would help with, such as: 30 MB Redis memory cache compute instance for free 500mb Mongo database compute instance for free External logging compute instance for free and a whole marketplace of all these managed services, with the grouping of containers further managed by heroku. A Linode VPS at $5/month does not give you all that. If you like configuring all the above (and of course, assuming your use case calls for it at all), then the $5 plan with 1 GB RAM would let you put in a bunch of 256MB containers if you really wanted. The $10 plan with 2 GB RAM would let you put in comparable 512MB containers, but then you should have just been paying $7/month for Heroku already. Hope that helps! For a long time I struggled with inability to understand my potential costs for server-side projects, and occasionally read horror stories about other devs who got it wrong.
- mslate 8y agoSuggesting that $25/month is expensive illustrates how insanely cost-sensitive this community is. Don’t come to HN for a representative take of how people in US businesses evaluate vendors and their pricing. Do you know how much it cost my employer for me to spend an hour reading about Kubernetes?
- acdha 8y ago> Suggesting that $25/month is expensive illustrates how insanely cost-sensitive this community is. I completely agree but I’m not sure “cost-sensitive” is an adequate term because it’s like a cost on hosting (or an app you’ll use for years) triggers extremely high awareness by people who are extremely blasé about hemorrhaging staff time on support and slipped deadlines.
- zwkrt 8y agoSometimes it can be hard to give up sysadmin work because people consider it to be a core competency and to let that go feels like a loss. Kubernetes hits the sweet spot where you get to use a tool to manage sysadmin work that is at least as much work as hiring a sysadmin.
- privateSFacct 8y agoSo true - billing rates for consultants run 200+/hr. Even a small $1mm expense budget - $25 is not relevant and in my experience you can quickly be at 75%+ personnel cost (w2/1099 + desks / space etc for them)
- Carpetsmoker 8y agoNot all businesses pay $200/hour for consultants. There are a lot of small businesses out there. "A small $1M expense budget" may be "small" for certain companies, but it's more than the yearly revenue for a lot of businesses, never mind people who are trying to start a business and don't have any revenue at all (yet). Of course you need to be reasonable and not penny-pinch or "spend money to save money", but in general I would say that frugality is a virtue.
- koolba 8y agoThe $7 hobby plan is surprising useful if you’re smart about what you’re deploying.