5 ms·
Why is it a fine? Why not a tax? Taxing unused spaces sitting idle makes a lot more sense than income (ie: people’s work).
by Scoundreller 8y ago
Why is it a fine? Why not a tax?
Taxing unused spaces sitting idle makes a lot more sense than income (ie: people’s work).
- chii 8y ago> Why is it a fine? Why not a tax? what's the difference?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Scoundreller 8y agoTraditionally, you only pay a fine if you’re caught.
- i_am_proteus 8y agoCynically, one could claim the same about taxes.
- CydeWeys 8y agoNot paying taxes is a criminal matter, though. The fines being assessed are civil matters.
- anticensor 8y agoFines are usually neither civil nor criminal, they are administrative matters.
- baroffoos 8y agoIf you park in a car park for too long but no one notices you can drive off and be totally fine. If you don't pay taxes someone could work it out and look in to history to catch you out.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Why is it a fine? Why not a tax? Fines (at least, non-criminal ones) and taxes, while sometimes procedurally distinct, are essentially functionally equivalent.
- jfim 8y agoIn general, taxes are deductible whereas fines are not.
- Scoundreller 8y agoAnd you usually don’t self-assess fines, but you do self-assess taxes. Leave the fines for when taxes aren’t self-assessed.
- opportune 8y agoYeah let's just get rid of income taxes and have an empty-building based economy that makes a lot of sense
- alanlamm 8y agoWhile we are at it, lets tax the vacant hours of the unemployed - those evil speculators who are consipiring to restrict the supply of labor. That will encourage them to work and thereby be able to afford all that brand new housing!
- marnett 8y agoWe call it the opioid tax and it works pretty effectively at eliminating the unemployed.
- alanlamm 8y agothe objective of the tax would not be to eliminate the unemployed, but rather to put them to work
- Scoundreller 8y agoLazy athletes performing 2-3 hours a night for 75 days a year and retiring at 35.
- Scoundreller 8y agoOr lower one with the revenue from the other... I also prefer sales taxes over income taxes with cheques to counter their regressive nature. And carbon taxes over sales and income taxes. Taxing destruction is a good thing.
- opportune 8y agoThat's fair but I don't think, at least with empty buildings, the revenues would be anywhere close to being able to replace a significant portion of income taxes. The scales are vastly different. But I should apologize for an overly snarky initial comment.
- KorematsuFred 8y agoMuch easier to beg for votes saying we "fined these evil landlords" instead of saying increasing taxes on empty buildings. I think there will be many fires in Barcelona this year.
- Scoundreller 8y agoIf the tax %age on the empty buildings is high enough, voters will like it. I fear it won’t be big enough so they didn’t say it, but I don’t know Spanish culture.
- longerthoughts 8y agoMaybe fines offer more discretion for officials (easy to impose, revise, and target specific landlords) as opposed to a tax which would be more rigid (slow to implement, difficult to change)?
- leetcrew 8y agois it good that fines allow them to target specific landlords?
- Const-me 8y agoCan be either, depends on society. Bad if the officials are corrupt and will use that power to extort money for personal profits. Good if the officials are democratically elect, supported by the public, do what people want them to, and the public is mostly good people. Have no idea about Barcelona's officials nor society.
- colechristensen 8y agoFines seem to be more flexible in their enforcement and cancellation, possibly as negotiation tactics. The label, as opposed to 'tax', comes with the idea of punishment and can more logically be increased to higher levels in ways not possible if considered a cost of doing business.
- CydeWeys 8y agoRelatedly, it'd be interesting to see a tax with a built-in ratcheting up effect each year. Imagine if you had a tax that doubled each year a property remained vacant -- that'd be similar to how they're using these fines.
- cortesoft 8y agoSounds like how the repeater tax works in the NBA; each year you are over the salary cap,you have to pay a penalty per dollar over, and you pay a higher percentage each time you are over. Once you get under the cap, it resets. The money gets split amongst the non-tax paying teams, with the idea of balancing competition between wealthier teams and poorer teams. http://www.cbafaq.com/salarycap.htm#Q18 http://www.cbafaq.com/salarycap.htm#Q18
- kradroy 8y agoIn the US fines are not tax deductible, so that's one fiscal difference between taxes and fines. I have no idea if Spain considers fines to be tax deductible or not.
- RHSeeger 8y agoInterestingly, tax refunds are not always tax deductible, either. I paid federal taxes on the previous year's state tax refund this year. How does that make ANY sense?
- CydeWeys 8y agoIt makes sense because you didn't pay federal taxes on that amount last year. Ideally your withholding should have been perfect last year and your refund would have been $0, and then you would have paid the federal tax amount on it last year. Relatedly, I got a ~$5k state refund last year and I'm not paying additional federal tax on it this year because the SALT deductions are now gone under Trump's tax changes, so my state tax burden doesn't affect my federal tax burden anymore.
- toast0 8y agoInto the weeds a bit here, but if you deducted your payments to the state in 2017 on your federal 2017 tax return (filed in 2018), and you got a refund from the state in 2018, you should be entering that on your federal 2018 tax return. Since you won't be deducing SALT in 2018, any state refund in 2019 wouldn't be reportable for federal tax year 2019. If this were otherwise, people would have purposefully massively over pay to the state in 2017, claim a large deduction in tax year 2017, get a large refund in 2018, and not have to pay back the deduction they didn't really deserve.
- CydeWeys 8y agoYup. I happen to be in an AMT situation where the state refund from last year isn't taxable this year, but it might still be for others as you point out.
- conanbatt 8y agoSpaces dont pay taxes. Only people pay taxes. Taxing it through estate or through income is not taxing space vs taxing human beings.