17 ms·
To build the cities of the future, we must get out of our cars
- growtofill 8y ago> they’d no longer segregate rich from poor Should people who want to spend more on housing be automatically labeled “rich”?
- bogle 8y agoShould people who can't afford housing be automatically labelled "poor"? It's certainly one indicator. Not segrating people improves the world. Segragating them introduces division, self-evidentially. Something to be avoided, then, and worked against. Planners will try to mix properties in a new development, if the local politics is to provide for everyone fairly.
- growtofill 8y agoI didn’t think about segregation on planning phase, thanks for the insight. Answering your question: yes, I believe not being able to afford housing categorizes a person as poor. “Provide everyone fairly” is a touchy subject and depends on how limited do you want your goverment to be. I’d rather choose where to live myself, based on my own means.
- bluGill 8y agoYou cannot mix a new development like that. Building a house is expensive, so only the rich and upper middle class can afford it. The poor always have and always will live in the houses the above lived in some years back and left for something newer. What planners need to do it make sure that when the rich vacate the neighborhood they left behind is good. Part of that is making sure that some of the rich decide to rebuild their current house instead of leaving thus mixing the neighborhood a bit. Cities are a long games. The "ideal" state you plan today to build tomorrow is not the end state. That means your plans need to account for change. New development will be old in 20 years, what then?
- pjc50 8y agoHouse price in many places is not linked to age so much - houses don't depreciate like cars - as location. Terrible houses and tiny flats in desirable places sell for huge sums.
- ozzyman700 8y ago"Mixed Income Housing" is becoming more and more prevalent, it decreases segregation by forcing proportions of new development to include low income housing. Possibly your statement: "You cannot mix a new development like that. Building a house is expensive, so only the rich and upper middle class can afford it. The poor always have and always will live in the houses the above lived in some years back and left for something newer." could be a bit of an absolute.
- bluGill 8y agoOne of two things are happening: either the mixed income is richer and middle class - as I already said; or the rich are paying extra for their house to subsidies the house of the poor. Probably a mixture of each.
- rootusrootus 8y agoIt is difficult to enforce this without politicians ignoring the will of the people. Which in turn tends to keep them from being reelected.
- paganel 8y agoThat's generally how it works, yes, you have more money you're seen as rich, especially nowadays when housing is so expensive compared to one's average income.
- Tepix 8y agoNot exactly rocket science. Many cities around the world have figured it out already. To me it seems that the US went to the other extreme and is only slowly turning around. I remember reading "Das neue Universum"² in the early 80s where they proposed large skyscrapers connected by tubes. No cars in sight. Oh and don't miss "Das Neue Universum Volume 84 (1967)": http://klausbuergle.de/buergle_verkehr1.htm http://klausbuergle.de/buergle_verkehr1.htm - Click on the bottom left image - looks a lot like Hyperloop, doesn't it? The text even mentions that the tubes contain a vacuum! -- ² https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Das_Neue_Universum https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Das_Neue_Universum
- mtberatwork 8y ago> the US went to the other extreme and is only slowly turning around. US car manufacturers are doubling down on large trucks and SUVs and the current administration continues to thwart progress on tackling climate change and other societal concerns. I would say the US, at least on a macro level, is still on the "other extreme" path.
- RickJWagner 8y agoI don't believe there is a nefarious scheme in play. People who live in cities don't need cars. People who live outside cities still need cars. The manufacturers try to fill that need. The manufacturers, sellers, etc. make the economy go 'round. It will all change if/when economic forces bring it about. Directly forcing it through politics probably isn't the right approach.
- bogle 8y agoI don't think too many trust the market to make their decisions for them. The purpose of politics is to represent the people and, ideally, do what is best for them. That's definitely not what the market is for! Get involved in politics if you want to bring about change in the world because companies whose job it is to sell more cars certainly aren't going to be helping improve the environment.
- Shivetya 8y agoCars are not the cause of the issue with cities, cars are symptom of bad zoning and regulation which more times than not prevents owners of property from doing what they want. when every new building requires effectively bring special interest groups, politicians, regulatory boards, and unions, their due is it a surprise cities are not getting better. they are serving a politically connected elite, not the people who live there or want to live there.
- ahoy 8y agoI'd like to offer the argument that automakers/sellers are a "special interest group" who has had an outsized impact on the shape of american cities for the past century.
- knowuh 8y agoWhy is this the top comment? It hasn't been edited. I can't even decipher it.
- linuxftw 8y agoI agree. Cars are a solution to a (set of) problem. Remove the problem(s), remove the cars. Cars, also, not really that big of a problem in themselves. Commuting is the problem. This is a symptom of depressed wages; people are willing to spend extra time (commute) in place of extra money (rent).
- bluGill 8y agoPeople are willing to spend time on the car commute because zoning won't allow you a good job to exist within walking distance of a house. Shopping isn't allowed within walking distance of either of the above either. We are back to square one: zoning won't allow anything other than car oriented lifestyles. It is a self reinforcing vicious cycle. You can break it anywhere. I recommend started with breaking zoning because it is least painful. If you eliminate cars people who currently depend on cars will be in trouble since they cannot live their life. Eliminate the need far cars is a much slower thing that won't have any noticeable affect for 20 years, but it is a much less painful transition.
- bluewater 8y agoCool little post by Mr Money Mustache about a twitter post he put out describing a future city without cars. Media picked it up as reality, pretty funny stuff. http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2019/02/27/how-to-create-reality/ http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2019/02/27/how-to-create-real...
- lazyjones 8y agoImproving life in cities is a matter of fixing existing problems, like poor public transport and pollution from combustion engines and heating. Building a "feel good" fantasy around the hatred of cars isn't going to improve anything, it'll just replace the current best choice for individual transport with something inferior, as well as destroy the economy (which depends on roads for logistics and public services).
- benj111 8y agoI don't think its a hatred of cars. Its just cars are so entrenched in western cultures that its easy to overlook all the problems. All those things you cited are all exacerbated by the car. Electric cars will solve the pollution issue, but they are still cars, with all the issues they bring.
- lazyjones 8y ago> I don't think its a hatred of cars. Its just cars are so entrenched in western cultures that its easy to overlook all the problems. They are entrenched for a reason: because they are extremely useful. Without cars and the individual transport methods they superseded, many of our cities wouldn't even exist. What this and many other articles do, is to decide first what the problem should be and then build a case around it to show it in a bad light. That's not how you improve life in cities, it's just how you get rid of cars and with them all the benefits you've overlooked. Proof: you can get all the benefits of cars without the drawbacks by putting all the infrastructure for cars underground and using EV. None of these "visionaries" consider that, because they hate cars.
- benj111 8y agoI don't think there are any cities that wouldn't exist without cars, the shape of cities would change yes, but that is one of the problems of cars. Cars are useful yes, doesn't mean we shouldn't question them. Just like we should question trains, bikes etc. Re putting cars underground. Yes you could, are you going to support the taxes to pay for it? "What this and many other articles do, is to decide first what the problem should be and then build a case around it to show it in a bad light." Why don't you decide on the merits of the argument rather than perceived motivation?
- bitxbit 8y agoI’d argue that cities will shrink over time. It’s going to become easier for people to live in rural areas. I don’t think there is some magic formula to manage the inevitable congestion (not just traffic). Edit: It’d also be interesting to see the environmental impact of mega cities. And what about cities like Portland where they have put in a lot effort to plan around growth? Is it working?
- adwww 8y agoIt's not happening though. My parents live in a beautiful part of the rural UK and have super-fast fibre to the premises internet, next day Amazon prime available, online food shopping from 4 or so supermarkets locally, etc. Basically everything you'd think you'd need to live away from the city, but still the area is depopulating rapidly. Younger people don't want a life of car dependancy and social isolation.
- shawabawa3 8y agoI think there's a chance that remote working might really take off. From a cost-saving perspective it makes so much sense - we already went from offices -> open plan, if we go from open plan -> remote being the new norm, suddenly there will be jobs everywhere, and that will change everything
- asdff 8y agoNot every job can be remote if people need shared equipment or resources. There's a lot of intangible benefits to having everyone working nearby. I get a lot of help from people just because they are nearby and I can ask them a question about something or their advice, and I think that alone outweighs for me being able to sit on my couch in sweatpants with my laptop.
- geocar 8y agoIf you don't mind: Which part of the rural UK is this? I live in London and have pants for Internet (oversubscribed FTTC).
- cageface 8y agoIn Orson Welles' classic film, "The Magnficent Ambersons", one of the original inventors of the automobile predicts the changes, many negative, that the automobile will bring to civilization. Almost exactly 100 years later it sounds quite prescient: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fTTF2QIHDCM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fTTF2QIHDCM
- jak92 8y agoMy City is double decking highways all the while building zero new rail and or bike lanes. They are doubling down on stupid.
- kortilla 8y agoThey are doubling down on what a lot of their population wants. A lot of what gets left out of the discussion of cities in the US is that tons of people have no interest in public transportation due to bad experiences or preconceived notions. People need examples of good public transportation in the US beyond NYC or Chicago because those cities come with a lot of other baggage (high taxes, high rent, high CoL in general). Without an example, it looks to a suburbanite like the trade off is they lose their yard and 75% of the square footage of their home for less flexibility and a dirty transportation experience. These people do not marvel at the efficiency of the Yamamote line as people are shoved in by train operators during rush hour. They hug the steering wheels of their luxurious personal space SUVs. What makes it worse is that prominent politicians in the US on the side promoting public transport don’t bother to use it when slightly inconvenient (e.g. the “scandal” of AOC using a minivan when she could have taken a subway). Even people on the “left” aren’t leading by example.
- licyeus 8y agoAOC is mobbed like a celeb when in public and has received death threats online, yet you fault her for no longer taking the subway? Regarding realistic trade-offs: I live in Seattle in a 1200 sq ft townhome. I commute 20-25 mins on public transit (where I read or otherwise zone out). For what I pay in rent, I could move to the suburbs and get a 2000 sq ft house. But that comes with a stressful 60 min commute in traffic and $15 a day for parking.
- makerofspoons 8y agoIf our species is to survive this century we have to get out of our cars. There is no way to sustainably build billions of electric cars- we need to consider that our existing ICE fleet needs to simply be retired and not replaced. Cars are one of the ultimate symbols of the consumption that needs to end if we are to address climate change. Between the asphalt and concrete needed to build infrastructure for them to the plastics, rubber, and metals used to manufacture them cars are rolling ecological disasters.
- rootusrootus 8y agoAny solution which requires people to give up convenience in the name of saving the environment is dead on arrival. This is human nature, we have never before managed to conserve our way out of a problem, we innovate our way out of it or we will die trying.
- darepublic 8y agoI wonder if we can get people out of cars unless cities themselves are completely redesigned. We committed ourselves to a harmful design pattern but unfortunately everyone is heavily invested in it. Need to have a city design that will work, and then draw up a series of implementation steps to move existing cities to the new design. Would require a ton of central planning/control though, doubtful we could pull it off unless things got drastically worse to motivate people.
- bombingwinger 8y agoWell said! I'm glad someone understands humanity.
- isostatic 8y agoI'd love to have a shared car pool situation with an automatic driver booked via an app that takes me door to door with say 5 minutes notice for a short trip (say upto 5 miles), and half hour notice for a longer trip (say upto 50 miles), and maybe 5 hours notice for a 500 mile trip. One that's clean, reliable, has appropiate child seats. That's not happening in the next 20 years. My country is still going down the protectionism route when it comes to the taxi industry. The child seats is the problem though -- as an adult in a city I can easily hail an uber or whatever to get me where I want to go. With kids in tow I'm limited to mass transit, as I can't rely on getting a cab with 2 car seats that will fit. This itself limits the amount of stuff I can take and places I can go. Perhaps if I had no need for local trips (like yesterday when we went to a canal-side pub 4 miles away for dinner) I could live with simply renting a car for the larger trips -- but to rent a car it involves a walk to the station, an hourly train into the large town, then walk to the car rental place -- all between 8AM and 6PM, then do the reverse on monday morning to drop it off.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoThis is one of the reasons the self-driving craze in tech is so silly: We have vehicles you can commute in and not drive called public transit. Self-driving cars is desire for public transit that doesn't have your rich self sitting next to a poor person on the way to work.
- syshum 8y agoOr you know people that value their time... For me to use Public Transport here would increase my commute time to work by order of magnitude, not to mention all the places I go weekly that is not on a public transit stop or would require multiple line hops and be many times more time consuming than if I just drove directly their in my own personal vehicle Public transport only works in area with High Population Density
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoThere is probably a ton of room for improvement and disruptive innovation in public transit, in terms of improving speed, available endpoints, etc. It's true public transit will never really be valuable for extremely rural areas, but we should be working to ensure that in anywhere there's a significant quantity of people, that public transit is the cheapest and most convenient way to travel. Public transit isn't going to win by banning cars, it's going to need to win by improving lives.
- Sacho 8y agoI can't imagine how bad public transport must be to increase your commute time by an order of magnitude. I use public transport precisely because I value my time - it takes longer(around x1.5) than using a car, but that time is relaxing, can be used to read a book, listen to a podcast or just order your thoughts. Time spent in a car is stressful and requires your focus and attention. I'm not sure what kind of population density you need to make public transport workable, but it's a blessing when you have it available. There's some sample math at the end of this article(https://www.ptua.org.au/myths/density/ https://www.ptua.org.au/myths/density/ - technical appendix) which concludes that you don't really need that high a density(it focuses on Melbourne), as long as people actually prefer to use the public transport service over their own cars.
- betandr 8y agoWe really do have to radically re-think our cities but the biggest issues aren't going to be practical but emotional. In London parents drive their children around in 4x4s, knowing that their vehicle causes the pollution that is affecting their own children's health. I'm not sure how you even start to get around that but to some extent you will never persuade everybody to reduce their damaging behaviour. You need to enable people to travel in non-damaging ways; cycling and walking primary. That should be the first priority, although fighting the ingrained car culture will be the hardest battle.
- czechdeveloper 8y agoYou can get easily insulted for proper choices. Homophobic comments on cycling and veganism are common. I rather believe that we are doomed - that we will destroy nature sufficiently for it to stop producing enough food to sustain us as species - than that we will change.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoHumans tend to make changes when there are no other options... and often, after significant damage has been done. Presumably if we "stop producing enough food to sustain us", a lot of humans would die off, but some would survive on the reduced food supply, and make changes to prevent further loss of food. Bear in mind, it's incredibly unlikely that all possible human food sources die off simultaneously. A good example of change in behavior to ensure survival, is that major powers used to go much more openly to war for territory and resources right up until those powers got the ability to utterly destroy humanity. While there are still countries who are enemies of each other, and who fight small proxy wars and the like, nobody in their right mind would stage an invasion of another major power, likely ever again.
- cr0sh 8y ago> nobody in their right mind ...until you have a world leader who wonders why we can't use them if we have them.
- 8y ago
- jimmaswell 8y agoI'd hate walking everywhere, having to get tiny amounts of groceries every day instead of stocking up every 2 weeks, etc. Walking/standing all day at conventions feels like death and a half a mile trip to the fast food places around here turns from 2 minutes to 10 minutes if I walk, which I tried when someone from Europe said that's walking distance. Walking such distances just makes me constantly wish I was driving or something. I find the drive thru experience really nice - bring the dog along in the passenger seat, get a burger, eat in the parking lot and give her some of the beef, whole trip takes under 10 minutes. A joy instead of a drag like walking is. If a city of the future must abandon cars then the way I'd like it is if there were equal or less walking compared to driving. Futurama tubes would be great. Side note: "No walking is a prescription for obesity" - exercising for weight loss has been thoroughly debunked. [1] 1: https://getpocket.com/explore/item/why-you-shouldn-t-exercise-to-lose-weight-explained-with-60-studies https://getpocket.com/explore/item/why-you-shouldn-t-exercis...
- impostir 8y agoWhy are you assuming that a removal of cars means there will be no mechnism that would replace its functions? Many people benefit from a car's cargo potential and their need for this function wouldn't disappear with the cars. I can't say what the particular method could be, maybe medium-sized autonmous vehicles, but I would be surprised of nothing was created.
- jakeinspace 8y agoSounds like my experience living in Houston. Of course I'd hate living here without a car, I did it for a few months and it's ridiculous. But compared to Montreal, Sydney, Toronto, or even Philadelphia (my points of reference), this is far and away the worst living experience. My commute to work is 15 minutes, which isn't too bad. It used to be a 10-minute bike ride or 20-minute walk, which was both healthier and more enjoyable, not to mention more environmentally friendly and free. I enjoyed getting groceries every few days: picking up some produce and bread on the way home from one of the dozens of businesses on the way was delightful, and meant I could always have fresh food. Living in suburban America (it's hard to call Houston a city in the same sense as the ones I mentioned above) is emotionally draining. Yes, there are positives: good food, good beer, cheap cost of living. However, I don't feel like I'm part of a community. I feel like I live on a small island in an archipelago of disconnected islands. It feels like everybody here who hasn't lived in a walkable dense urban city doesn't know what they're missing, there are intangible psychological benefits. Of course, these are just the thoughts of an east-coaster.
- crimsonalucard 8y agoMost cities don't need cars. It's already like this you don't need to go to the future. Suburban layouts were actually the new thing that came after cities. The reason why we need cars is because of suburbia. For suburbia to function you have to live very far away from work and in very very low density neighborhoods where public transportation is virtually impossible to build. See Los Angeles.
- TausAmmer 8y agoI hate cities and love driving my truck, take that old boy in mud and have something I enjoy in life. There is plenty of these stories. Will one give up himself to go on as husk.
- Taylor_OD 8y agoEventually, cars will become a shared resource right? If cars can drive on their own then you could rent your car out while you're at work to lyft or uber. Eventually wouldn't most people do this? Eventually, wouldn't there be a multitude of cars roaming the city? Why would you need to own one? I live in a fairly walkable city but it still seems odd to me that people hold such a personal connection to their cars.
- swift532 8y agoWell, I also use my car as a giant man-purse. Furthermore, sometimes you want to travel out of the beaten path and it's possible that the only way you can get there is with your own car.
- ngngngng 8y agoI'm not sure these articles are good for my mental health. I live in Utah Valley, which has the worst air quality in the United States. I'm on the train right now as I type this, it takes twice as long for me to get to work this way but i'm trying to increase train usage. People here are just so invested in making their hour long commutes with their gigantic trucks. Trucks are ridiculously expensive even before you factor in the prohibitive cost of gas and maintenance for them. It still doesn't seem to dissuade anyone. I'm considering protesting for more environmentally friendly city designs and transportation decisions. I could find an extremely congested intersection and protest by just pressing the walk sign and marching back and forth. Annoying, but probably effective at getting my message seen. I imagine that's the kind of protest that would get me arrested for being a nuisance.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoUtah Valley (and Salt Lake Valley) trap pollution. There's no getting away from that. But the worst air quality in the US? After Geneva Steel closed? Worse than, say, San Bernardino, where the wind tends to trap LA's smog? I'm kind of skeptical. (Or do you have hard data, which I admit that I don't?)
- ip26 8y agoIt's been in the news many times. I'm not sure if they have the highest average levels or the most #1 days, but they top the chart periodically through winter.
- bbradley406 8y agoIt can change depending on the season and weather, but it is seriously bad and hit #1 for a day in 2017. [1] The geography does trap the pollution, but having refineries and mining operations just north of the city doesn't help. There are also loads of 18 wheel trucks coming through, since SLC is a bit of a hub area in terms of highways. Despite the city being pretty walk-able with decent (by US standards) transit, lots of people have at least one large 4x4 vehicle to get up into the canyons. It hurts to see since I understand the appeal of outdoors activities, but this way of approaching them will degrade and ruin the outdoors long term. [1] https://kutv.com/news/local/salt-lake-city-has-the-worst-air-quality-in-the-nation https://kutv.com/news/local/salt-lake-city-has-the-worst-air...
- myself248 8y agoFunny how the loudest voices in these sorts of articles are always from places with temperate weather.
- rootusrootus 8y agoAnd places that are already dramatically denser than the vast majority of the developed world. Over the weekend I found myself looking for a place in Europe in satellite view, outside of an urban core, and I was struck by how many single-family houses there were, complete with driveways and cars. Here on HN I have been led to believe that Europe is a utopia of forward-thinking people too concerned about the environment to pollute it with a car that might also kill innocent pedestrians who just want to walk to their local grocery store. HN readers have created a lovely bubble for themselves.
- TheCoelacanth 8y agoBy definition, places with high population-density are the places where a lot of people live. It is not a "bubble".
- rootusrootus 8y agoThe bubble is here on HN where people routinely talk about America as if it is one big suburban hellhole and Europe as if it is one big metropolis paradise.
- adrianN 8y agoHalf the people in Berlin don't own a car. 45% of the commutes in Copenhagen happen by bicycle.
- rootusrootus 8y agoOver half the people in NYC don't own a car.
- asdff 8y ago
- a13n 8y agoShow me a carless city with nice weather most of the year that I can easily get a visa to live in, and I'd strongly consider it! Bonus if it's in US/Canada.
- asdff 8y agoPortland, OR
- techntoke 8y agoWe need to expand the remote work force and create AR devices that can replace mobile phones to make collaborative sustainable living a reality.
- jayalpha 8y agoThis link was once on HN The Real Reason Your City Has No Money https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/1/9/the-real-reason-your-city-has-no-money https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/1/9/the-real-reason...
- qwerty456127 8y agoObviously.
- PorterDuff 8y agoIn addition to convenience, habit, and layout of cities and living areas, I'd say that a big push for cars is personal security.
- Symmetry 8y agoHonestly one of the bigger potential benefits of self-driving cars would be the decreased need for parking and resulting increased density.
- scriptkiddy 8y agoI live in Los Angeles; The Mecca for the automobile. Back in the early 20th century, the city was trying really hard to invest in public transportation through the use of electric street cars. Unfortunately, car manufacturers were able to weasel their way into the pockets of the city planners and put a stop to that. We have a problem in Los Angeles. And that problem is that it's almost impossible to live close to where you work. Most white collar jobs here require an hour or longer of commuting time. Sure, it's possible to find jobs closer to your home, but when you are a professional in a specific field, your choices are restricted. I live in North Hollywood, which is just West of Burbank in the San Fernando Valley. It's actually miles from Hollywood despite what the name may suggest. I work in El Segundo. Before that, I worked in Culver city. It would take me 4 or more hours and several metro -> bus -> metro transfers to get to work without driving. The city is working on several new Metro lines and Bus only lanes, but it doesn't solve the problem of everyone being so spread out.
- 0xffff2 8y agoDo you own your house? I'm curious because you speak as if "where you live" is an immutable fact, whereas my solution would to be to move closer to work.
- Mister_Snuggles 8y agoFor some people, moving isn't very easy. If you have kids there's the whole issue with switching schools, etc. If you tend to switch jobs frequently it may be a case of just getting settled and now you're in a new job. Moving is also, for many people, a gigantic pain that they'd rather avoid, even if it means suffering through traffic every day.
- 0xffff2 8y agoThe original comment says "it's almost impossible to live close to where you work". None of the things you mention come anywhere near the bar of "nearly impossible" in my book. As far as I can tell, it's completely possible.
- 8y ago
- JDiculous 8y agoI see it less about eliminating cars (though that would be awesome if possible) and more about giving people alternatives (public transit, walking), which you don't have in American suburbia. Much of the rest of the world has already figured it out. I'm in a "suburb" of Seoul right now. I can get to Gangnam in 30 minutes door to door via the subway (subway ticket is ~$2 each way). I'm a short walk (< 5 mins) to grocery stores, restaurants, coffee shops, etc. It's all apartments here, which is why everything is so walkable. Of course this means less space than a house, but it's quiet and there are plenty of parks/green and a big lake nearby (5-10 minute walk). Meanwhile back at my parents' house in the suburbs of Washington DC, the closest commercial business I can walk to is a gas station 20 minutes away, next to an ugly car-ridden highway. The nearest grocery store would require crossing that wide road and walking an additional 10-15 minutes through a massive parking lot. There is no viable public transport - if I want to take the subway into DC I need to drive 15 minutes to the nearest subway station (subway ticket is ~$5-8 I believe). Although my immediate neighborhood is very nice in the sense that there are a lot of trees, there actually aren't any parks (unless you count the local elementary school) or businesses of any form, including simple convenience stores (something I noticed is commonplace in most of the rest of the world). Everytime I'm at my parents' house I'm completely dependent on having a vehicle to do anything, and bored out of my mind within about a week because it's extraordinarily isolating. I get very little exercise because I end up just staying in my house all day because there's little to do. On the other hand I can be in "city"-like suburbs like the one I'm in now and not feel lonely even if I don't talk to anyone because I can just step outside and there are people everywhere, or go walk to one of the million coffee shops nearby that are always packed with people hanging out. I despise American suburbs. Who decided that the "American Dream" is owning a single-family home in the suburbs? I guess I'm just not enough of a hermit to enjoy that lifestyle.
- afettere 8y agoIf you are interested in learning more about how cities are dealing with the myriad of challenges outlined in the National Geographic article, I encourage you check out UrbanFootprint (https://urbanfootprint.com/ https://urbanfootprint.com/). Building off our background as urban planners, the UrbanFootprint software platform helps communities, cities, and regions deal with the challenges that they face. We bring data, analytics, and most importantly, actionable insight to problems such as congestion, pollution, accessibility, and risks like flooding, sea level rise, and fires. The software is used by public jurisdictions across the country, the private consultants who consult for those jurisdictions, and by others in real estate, finance, and new mobility modes.
- raphar 8y ago> In the 1990s Calthorpe scored a breakthrough: He helped persuade Portland, Oregon, to build a light-rail line instead of another freeway and to cluster housing, offices, and shops around it. Mr Calthorpe is playing simcity in Real Life, ENVY!
- jalessio 8y agoHi HN! I'm the Director of Engineering at UrbanFootprint (https://urbanfootprint.com/ https://urbanfootprint.com/), one of the companies featured in the National Geographic article. Peter Calthorpe is a cofounder of the company. The El Camino corridor is highlighted at the beginning of the National Geographic article. If you want to dig into more details on that please take a look at our blog post on the topic from last year (https://urbanfootprint.com/can-one-street-solve-the-san-francisco-bay-area-housing-crisis/ https://urbanfootprint.com/can-one-street-solve-the-san-fran...). At UrbanFootprint, we provide data and tools for urban planners to assess and compare the impacts of land use and transportation decisions. A basic use case is a city updating its General Plan, which would start with a forecast of how much population growth is anticipated / needs to be accommodated. A planner then needs to assess where new residents will live, work, shop, and play. Perhaps even more essential, how are people going to travel between all of these activities? Will the new growth be auto-dependent, transit-focused, walkable? Is any of the existing or planned development in hazard areas such as flood of wildfire? What are the energy and water use impacts of the plans? We’re using Python and Postgres/PostGIS on the backend to answer these questions and a React SPA to serve it up and make it interactive in a browser. It's a lot of fun getting our hands dirty with data describing the physical world in which we live in now, in addition to modeling the future of cities. If this type of work interests you please get in touch - email me at hn@urbanfootprint.com. I'm always interested in hearing from folks who want to use technology to improve cities.
- Ericson2314 8y agoWhat gets me about these densification of suburban center proposals is that they don't come with racing the sprawl. If you just create more "central", well assuming some x-far-from-center contour lines distribution you might be creating more sprawl too. We need to demolish our mistakes not just build new non-mistakes. We need fractal density so everyone gets both green space and high density very close, and reclaimed nature and super density not far away either. Go to inwood Manhattan to feel what reclaimed natue is like.