7 ms·
Descartes was wrong: ‘a person is a person through other persons’ (2017)
- Laukhi64 8y agoI don't see anything that I'd explicitly disagree with, but I also can't help but have a feeling that something is lost in translation. I'm not sure that Descartes and African philosophers are talking about exactly the same thing when they say something like "person".
- techbio 8y agoSomeone like Descartes is not plumbing the depths of mathematics, or the soul, as a group activity. But anyone since, who reads or is read to about theories that have carried on, becomes that informed person because of exposure to these ideas. The ivory tower is just a prison if it exists without a press.
- ordu 8y agoOf course they told about different things. Distinction between self/other is a definition of a person. But at the same time they spoke about the same thing. If you killed a person, you would be a murderer, and it doesn't matter what definition of a person you use. There are some small differences though, like killing a toddler seems not so bad, if toddler is not a person yet. I personally believe that toddler is not a person yet. Homo Sapiencs pup becomes a person somewhere between 1 yo and 3 yo. At 1 yo she learns to walk, and gets location independance, she needs some time to learn to be independant, and then at 3 yo she get into psychological crisis, when she learn what the difference between "Me", "Parents", "My desires", "Parents desires", "Rules" and so on. So 3 yo is absolutely the point where she is a person already. While less than 1 yo she is not a person, but external and disconnected physically limb of her parents.
- hopler 8y agoFor everyone's sake, don't test your theory on any toddlers. Why draw the line at age 3, and not 9 (Age of Reason) pubescence (Coming of Age), or post-pubescence? People under the age of maybe 30 universally have terrible misconceptions about how the universe works, making them dangerous if they are given full freedom.
- technothrasher 8y agoFor everyone's sake, don't test your theory on any toddlers. Amen to that! Why draw the line at age 3 I believe because the original poster was positing that self-awareness is the dividing line between person and non-person, and was claiming that this happens at age 3. Of course, the real world isn't that simple. Not only do newborns show some simple self-awareness (See Rochat's 'Five Stages of Self-Awareness'), but some animals also show various levels of self-awareness (Gallop's Mirror Test, and others) and I'm not sure most folks are prepared to give animals personhood.
- ordu 8y ago> Of course, the real world isn't that simple. Yes. Any our theory is a simplification of reality. > I'm not sure most folks are prepared to give animals personhood. Yeah. This is a problem I think. Is there is any way to define a person, which can justify human right to eat a chicken. Self-awareness seems the most promising.
- gowld 8y agoWhy do you have a human right to eat a chicken, or a cow, or a pig? https://www.reddit.com/r/likeus/ https://www.reddit.com/r/likeus/ Why do you not have a human right to kill a person, when push comes to shove comes to bullets?
- ordu 8y ago> For everyone's sake, don't test your theory on any toddlers. I do not kill dogs belonging to other people (or any dog, to be clear), why should I kill toddlers belonging to other people? And if I claim that toddler is an external limb of parents, than killing toddler means damaging parents, it is like to cut off their arms or something like. It is a good enough reason to not kill toddlers, isn't it? > Why draw the line at age 3, and not 9 (Age of Reason) pubescence (Coming of Age), or post-pubescence? Because the line between a person and not a person is drawn to separate humans from other animals. To make humans special and to give them rights to kill animals, to own animals. We need a way to justify our denial of animal rights on land or on any other kind of property and so on. So we should try to draw a line such a way, that reflects specialty of humans.
- Y_Y 8y agoThis is very close to one of the main theses in Hofstadter's "I am a Strange Loop", that your existence/consciousness must extend into the minds of people you know and interact with.
- ElBarto 8y agoThis profoundly misunderstands Descartes. Descartes is about proving existence through doubt. If you start doubting everything around you, what is left is your own mind that must exist since it is thinking and doubting. It has nothing to do with being a 'person' as a social construct, or about who I am.
- scooble 8y agoThis. There may be an interesting thread to pull about whether a western philosophical tendency to focus on an idealised rational individual confronting the world has led to a particular idea of the self. Though I'm not sure whether this has been the dominant view in analytic philosophy post linguistic turn, or whether it has ever been the mainstream in continental philosophy. This would need a lot more work to unpack. Trying to construct a conflict between Descartes sense of self in the cogito(which as far as I can see amounts to nothing more than 'I exist') and African philosophy seems deeply odd. If Descartes 'sense of self' is mere existence (and I think this is a very odd reading of the cogito), then are we supposed to say that African babies don't exist until they become part of society?
- ElBarto 8y agoMy understanding is that the cogito isn't mere existence but that it is proof of mere existence. A baby, like everything else in the world, is something you perceive through your senses and that you can thus never be sure really exists. Let's say that Descartes laid the premise for the Matrix.
- tomlock 8y agoI disagree, Descartes believes that he had proven the existence of "a priori" thought, a place from which thinking could be conducted without doubt - that was the point of his project. That place is also the only reliable locus of personhood in his view. Future thinkers who talked about "embodied" thinking, were conceiving of a personhood that could exist before that a priori consciousness, rather than as a doubtful thing perceived by it.
- 8y ago
- mac_was 8y agoThis is environmental determinism and it is an old concept. Obviously we live with others and other can have impact on us but it is still up to us if are impacted by them or we are self contained human beings which decide for themselves.
- Geimfari 8y agoThat we are self contained human beings isn't obvious to me. All of my opinions, thoughts, and actions are a reflection of my surrounding social group.
- mac_was 8y agoSo if all your friends starts killing would you start as well? I believe you have free will, your imagination, a brain and you can assess for yourself what actions you eant to perform.
- jrootabega 8y agoNo one has to be wrong. It seems like there are at least two overlapping questions here. "Am I?" which links to Descartes (at least the modern popular distillation), and "how am I?" which links more strongly to this piece.
- amelius 8y agoSo in a hypothetical situation where all people except one are wiped out, then that one remaining person is not a person?
- mbrock 8y agoThey might remain a person insofar as they think in language and in other ways exist in reference to a community even if everyone else is dead—in this view, they might also lose their personhood as they become another kind of being after dissociating from human community.
- lioeters 8y agoThe idea of selfhood emerging from the context of relationships reminds me of the Japanese word for "human", 人間, which literally means "between people".
- bitxbit 8y agoChinese.
- seltzered_ 8y agoSorta related there’s a book called “Descartes Error”: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Descartes%27_Error https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Descartes%27_Error https://www.ianwelsh.net/review-of-descartes-error-by-antonio-damasio/comment-page-1/ https://www.ianwelsh.net/review-of-descartes-error-by-antoni...
- cdoxsey 8y ago> Accepting that others are vital to our self-perception is a corrective to the limitations of the Cartesian view. This brought to mind John Calvin's Institutes. In the first chapter he suggests that knowledge consists primarily of two parts: knowledge of self and knowledge of God, and oddly, the best way to know oneself is to know God: > If, at mid-day, we either look down to the ground, or on the surrounding objects which lie open to our view, we think ourselves endued with a very strong and piercing eyesight; but when we look up to the sun, and gaze at it unveiled, the sight which did excellently well for the earth is instantly so dazzled and confounded by the refulgence, as to oblige us to confess that our acuteness in discerning terrestrial objects is mere dimness when applied to the sun. Thus too, it happens in estimating our spiritual qualities. So long as we do not look beyond the earth, we are quite pleased with our own righteousness, wisdom, and virtue; we address ourselves in the most flattering terms, and seem only less than demigods. But should we once begin to raise our thoughts to God, and reflect what kind of Being he is, and how absolute the perfection of that righteousness, and wisdom, and virtue, to which, as a standard, we are bound to be conformed, what formerly delighted us by its false show of righteousness will become polluted with the greatest iniquity; what strangely imposed upon us under the name of wisdom will disgust by its extreme folly; and what presented the appearance of virtuous energy will be condemned as the most miserable impotence. In particular the concept of the Image of God has profound consequences for the way you think about dignity and human personhood. I recently watched Won't You Be My Neighbor, the documentary about Fred Rogers, and was struck by the way he treats an interacts with people, not as means to some end, but as ends in themselves, with real dignity and respect. It was counter-cultural at the time, but boy is it strange now. It feels like everything is outrage and disingenuousness. We treat people like tokens of their tribe, with pure contempt and toss them aside like their worthless and inhuman. Maybe Calvin was on to something.
- lisper 8y agoThe problem with this approach is that when different people acquire knowledge of God they often end up with very different results and no way to reconcile them, c.f. the Islamic State.
- opvasger 8y agoWhen people write "persons", my head starts spinning.
- grzm 8y agoWhen making such a distinction, people refers to a group en masse, while persons refers to a collection of individuals, emphasizing their actions as individuals as opposed to as a whole.
- wwarner 8y agoDefinitely some heat equation or field/particle transformations possible here.
- booleandilemma 8y agoIf I was the last man alive in a post-apocalyptic world I’d still be a person though. Not to mention I’d have time enough at last to get to all those books I’ve been meaning to read.
- jacobush 8y agoBetter keep those glasses safe.
- zwkrt 8y agoI don't disagree, but I find it interesting that if you were the last person alive you would spend your time reading the literary artifacts of other people, thereby continuing to grow and define yourself through social action.
- dwaltrip 8y agoIn such a situation, your personhood would be sadly diminished.
- OnlineCourage 8y ago> Ubuntu philosophy First off, there's no such thing as, "X philosophy." Philosophy (the noun) is a field of study, there's no such thing as, "My personal philosophy," - you don't get your own philosophy, there's just "philosophy." It wouldn't make sense to say, "well according to my own personal mathematics..." Likewise it doesn't make sense to do this kind of comparative cultural philosophy nonsense. It's extremely plausible that ancient African philosophers could have been absolutely wrong with certain propositions they put forward, and it is absolutely plausible that French philosophers in the early modern age were completely wrong. There's no, "happy smile and hold hands, let's all agree that there are different philosophies." That would be called politics, not philosophy. > a person is a person through other persons Secondly, that was not what Descartes was talking about, he was not talking about how to define a person, he was talking about how do you create a platform on which to define absolute truth of the existence of something. He was saying, "well, suppose you have a mind, doesn't matter where that mind comes from, just a mind...if that mind doubts that even itself exists, that doubting proves that it exists, therefore it exists." He wasn't talking about defining personhood, he was talking about securing the foundation of how knowledge works.