9 ms·
Google’s Nest fiasco harms user trust and invades their privacy
- foolzcrow 8y agoGoogle is Skynet
- hgjwq 8y ago>“The on-device microphone was never intended to be a secret and should have been listed in the tech specs,” a Google spokesperson said. “That was an error on our part.” I don't know, it sounds believable. Maybe they put it there "just in case", but didn't want to put it in the list of specifications because it had no software support, and having it there would've mislead customers who could've thought the microphone was functional software-wise.
- FakeComments 8y ago“Unexpectedly smart” and “hidden, software enable-able features” are both anti-features of security hardware. I don’t think Google deserves the benefit of the doubt anymore: these untruths happen with every product, and they’re always in Google’s favor. There’s a consistent pattern of Google specifications, documentation, etc being knowingly untrue. The only “error” is Google got caught deceiving people, again.
- dpark 8y agoIt may be true that Google no longer deserves the benefit of the doubt. The hyperbolic “every product” doesn’t help your case, though. Claiming that they engage in misleading behavior with every product, especially with no supporting evidence or examples, makes it look like you just have an axe to grind.
- FakeComments 8y agoYou are correct, let me list the Google services I’ve experienced deception from Google on: YouTube, GMail, Google search, Google Docs, Google Drive, Google ads (both selling and buying), and GCP. To me, that seems like every core product they offer, and so a little hyperbole is appropriate when calling out the misconduct of a gigacrime[0] syndicate. It is, however, very HN to say I was too hyperbolic and mean to the gigacrime supyndicate. [0] I mean this in the technical sense — I believe YouTube has committed over 1 billion acts of copyright infringement for profit, given that Google’s editorializing removes their safe harbor coverage. I believe other parts of Alphabet have similarly engaged in “scaled petty crime”. Edit to footnote: I do want to say, I don’t think Google is unique in this category — and it should be taken partly as a criticism of corporate governance (particularly American), rather than Google in particular, that any business is allowed to operate that way.
- cube2222 8y agoYou've just listed a bunch of services, in no way have you described how they use deceptive strategies in them.
- FakeComments 8y agoBecause I don’t care to. It’s easy enough to Google literally any of them and read substantial numbers of articles on their practices: For example, AdWords misrepresents clicks by slow rolling fraud mitigation and Google is quite deceptive about what various statistical measures and advertising practices actually deliver. As another, YouTube has a quasi-DMCA process while feigning that it’s a safe harbor purveyor of information, while in fact maintaining an editorialized anthology. This quasi-DMCA process is frequently used to steal ad revenue from creators through acts of fraud which Google’s automated systems and lack of human support (intentionally) don’t mitigate. It’s just not worth my morning to document all of it, because it’s literally a story a week for years. And a dozen stories a week for the past few years.
- rum3 8y agoThe whole purpose of all these Google services is to collect private data. Very few people actually realize the scope and power of the data they are collecting and how it is used, and how they plan to use it when they will have the technical capability. If they would have it written out in clear text exactly what they do with this data, and what they can do with it in the future then nobody would use their services. Therefore all these services are deceptive.
- eli 8y agoWhat do you think was the secret nefarious purpose for this hardware?
- FakeComments 8y agoNothing, I think it was hardware that was included because they might one day add a feature which used it, under the belief that customers would want that. What I think is nefarious is not informing customers about that latent capability, because denying customers that information increased sales (eg, by not informing people who would be concerned by the mic). A lie of omission for “good intentions” often is actually just denying the other person the information that they need to make an informed decision, for your own benefit. That seems to be what Google did here.
- rum3 8y agoTo develop some opt-out feature in the future that will record audio as often as possible, activated by an update with this information hidden behind a long wall-of-text terms of service that nobody will read.
- unionpivo 8y agoIt's possible that google does it differently than other electronics devices manufacturers that I worked for, but I can't imagine someone putting something like this on device without some concrete plans on how it will be used.
- yardie 8y agoThey could have done what every console maker has been doing since the 80s. List the expansion port, say it’s for future use, and leave its use optional.
- untog 8y agoI actually agree that it almost definitely wasn't something nefarious. But it speaks to a general lack of awareness of Nest's part about privacy and customer expectations - was there really no-one in a position of power who could have said "this is bad for customer trust"?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- HALtheWise 8y agoThe obvious reason for it existing is to serve as a glass breaking alarm, something that might have been part of the planned specs, and listed on the spec sheet, when they finalized the hardware design but they couldn't get working for launch. That's a very real feature people want their security systems to have, and forgetting to add "a disabled microphone, IMU, bluetooth and FM radios, and probably some other random chips privacy-obsessed people will care about" back onto the spec sheet is a really easy mistake to make, especially a few years ago when Nest mostly had user trust. To be clear, I don't know exactly what chips modern electronics contain that we will worry about in a couple years, but all of the above seem like plausible things.
- 013a 8y agoIt is believable. But that doesn't mean they shouldn't be reamed like crazy for it, including fines. There's a difference between "this was an act of god accident" and "we created the environment where this accident was allowed to happen". Let me throw this at you. They shipped hardware with an incomplete spec sheet. Probably by accident. What's the probability that they ship software with incorrect behavior? Like, say, the software on the device? Software which could engage the microphone and send it to a remote server? At their scale, this is possible to mess up, with all of the abstraction layers and number of customers they're dealing with. Google is the most careless company to ever reach the level of success that they have, possibly tied with Facebook. They need to be slapped, HARD, by some government, or else we'll never see the true institutional change necessary for a company of their power.
- xg15 8y ago> While collecting data on users is nearly inevitable in today’s corporate world, secret, undisclosed, or unpredictable data collection—or data collection abilities—is another problem. A smart-home speaker shouldn’t be secretly hiding a video camera. A secure messaging platform shouldn’t have a government-operated backdoor. And a home security hub that controls an alarm, keypad, and motion detector shouldn’t include a clandestine microphone feature—especially one that was never announced to customers. This sounds too much like trying to move the overton window for me. If the next generation of smart devices is advertised as "no hidden cameras and microphones! (we'll just spy on you with the visible cameras and microphones)", I don't think this would be a win.
- benj111 8y agoAgreed, but I would say the Overton Window was already way over there somewhere anyway. The fact that they need to lay out why this might be wrong is mildly depressing.
- renholder 8y ago>If the next generation of smart devices is advertised as "no hidden cameras and microphones! (we'll just spy on you with the visible cameras and microphones)", I don't think this would be a win. Agreed but we have to consider that it's entirely plausible that we're in the minority in this line of thinking.
- xg15 8y agoTrue of course, but what specifically makes you think that?
- baxtr 8y agoI have said this before: the reason why people find a hidden camera much worse than a visible camera is simple. People aren’t dumb, they make trade-off choices. Of course they could spy on you with a visible camera, too. But either you know and don’t care and still buy the damn thing or you don’t. Knowing means in this case being able to make an informed decision. Not informing customers about a camera inside a home device feels like they don’t want you to consider this fact in your decision making...
- gcb0 8y agowait, that's even in question?
- benj111 8y agoPlus if you know about it you can cover it over etc. And get to question why they even need a camera to start with, before buying the product.
- jstanley 8y agoI agree with you in principle, but I think the Nest actually only includes a hidden microphone, not a hidden camera.
- ehsankia 8y agoMany other Nest products, such as the Smoke alarm, doorbell and camera have microphones too. I agree that not disclosing that one was bad, but realistically if you have a Nest home, you probably have at least one microphone somewhere. It also comes down to much you trust them that the microphone was disabled. If you don't, then you probably also shouldn't be carrying a smartphone with you either.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- iamrobschiavone 8y agoYep, it's "only" a microphone, but it's still an inexcusable breach of trust.
- willart4food 8y agoAs long as "It's better to apologize later than to ask permission" is free or cheaper than doing the right thing, this is what we get.
- scarejunba 8y agoI am quite convinced that consumers don't care all that much. I certainly am not. I trust Google not to fuck with stuff. When they do, I'll kick up a fuss. The degree of "you should be panicking" around this is annoying to me.
- notatoad 8y agoYeah, this doesn't seem like a big deal to me, and i haven't seen any outrage from actual customers of the product. All the outrage seems to be coming from bloggers who are taking this as justification for their existing "google is a privacy threat" stance.
- iforgotpassword 8y agoI suspect this is going to be an unpopular opinion, but I still don't get the fuzz. People buy crap like Amazon echo left and right, and have been carrying little computers with microphones and an internet connection around all day for even longer. Apart from the fact that any sane person shouldn't trust any google product value their privacy in the first place, how many people are there consciously not buying a smartphone in fear of it being used to spy on them, then go buy this nest product and feel safe about it. I might be an asshole for it and rightly so get down voted, but I really feel schadenfreude from this story. And maybe now some more people will learn their lesson. You can tell a toddler a dozen times that the stove is hot. They really only learn after they touched it once.
- specialist 8y agoSome people want to receive what they pay for, nothing more, nothing less. If you had a peanut allergy, wouldn't you want to know if the candy bar has peanuts?
- ncallaway 8y ago> People buy crap like Amazon echo left and right People know the Amazon echo contains a microphone. > have been carrying little computers with microphones and an internet connection around all day for even longer People know that their phones contains a microphone. Surely the difference of being able to make an informed choice is still significant? > I might be an asshole for it and rightly so get down voted, but I really feel schadenfreude from this story I don't understand the schadenfreude here. Because some people make privacy choices that you disagree with, then we should take pleasure when companies stop presenting a choice at all? I guess I just fundamentally don't understand how you can equate the two categories of products together. In one category people make a knowing choice. In the other category they do not, and the company has outright lied to them to prevent them from making a knowing choice.
- ehsankia 8y agoI don't understand the shadenfreude either, but for the opposite reason. I think most people who have Nest products also are in the Google ecosystem, and are probably happy that they now have a Google Home for free. Considering half of the other Nest products contain microphones already, I don't think anyone who truly is worried about this stuff would've gotten a Nest ecosystem to start with. I agree, it's important to have all the facts so you can make informed decision, but this specific case has been way overblown, mostly by people who don't use Nest nor ever will. Almost anyone who's outraged probably would've never bought the product anyway.
- cascom 8y agoThese companies want it both ways - they hide behind their terms of service etc. saying consumers should actually read this stuff and be inforned, and then when they get busted for failing to disclose something it’s “oops, our bad, we didn’t think anyone cared”
- baybal2 8y agoI think that experience with abandonware will for long scare away regular people from all that IOT stuff. My own position has for long been that all that IoTness needs to be "invisible," or otherwise it turns the thing into an annoying toy: I've seen people throwing away their smart assistants already. A lot of people get quite surprised that the famed speaker is far more than just a speaker and tries to insert itself into your breakfast conversation. And those annoying, repeated "Internet connection failure," I think a few people threw them out just because of that.
- ReptileMan 8y agoLet's start with the obvious question - why all of those sensors require internet connection AND accounts. Seems absurd.
- calimac 8y agoNEST was RIP THE DAY GOOGLE BOUGHT IT. Was anyone surprised to find evidence of google, the surveillance arm of the C!@, having undocumented surveillance equipment built into the device? F-Google
- wowNoice 8y agoAs if this shit wasn't COMPLETELY predictable.
- chopin 8y agoGoogle should put its actions where its mouth is: can I return the device and get a full refund?
- starky 8y agoAre these Nest products sold worldwide? I recently worked on a product that included a microphone as an integral feature and we were told that in order to sell it worldwide we had to include a physical disable switch for the microphone in order to be able to sell it in multiple countries. Even though nobody who ordered the product would ever disable the microphone. How does Google get around selling their devices without even announcing there is a microphone in it?
- IshKebab 8y agoThere was a perfectly good reason for the microphone to be there, and there was a good reason why it wasn't mentioned (though it probably should have been). I'd hardly call the event "trust shattering".
- nabakin 8y agoI agree they were being dramatic, but Google still violated the trust of many people. Accidentally or not.
- skookumchuck 8y agoCameras and microphones must come with physical switches to turn them off, not software switches.
- upofadown 8y agoThe OpenBSD people implemented an interesting insight recently. Now a microphone attached to a OpenBSD system does not work by default. You need to actively turn on a sysctl as root to activate the microphone. So to get eavesdropping access on a default OpenBSD system you need to root the system, which makes that access somewhat harder to obtain. The moral here is that microphone access should be treated differently than access to the rest of the audio system. You can get more protection through software than we normally get.
- skookumchuck 8y agoAny software switches can be subverted by malware. But not physical ones. Physical switches and a light (like video cameras used to have when recording) are simple, cheap, and effective. I don't understand why companies don't add them to allay their customers' fears.
- bg24 8y agoA product release in an established organization goes through legal checklist. It could have been one of those “our checklist for search, chrome, nest etc. can be same”. I am not defending nest. Just saying that sometimes these get bypassed, people move to other jobs, new folks come in, someone finds out and damage control begins.
- tehlike 8y agoWe are at the last decades where privacy is somewhat possible. It is downhill from here.