10 ms·
What's puzzling is that the IRS seems to calculate your taxes anyway; if there's a disparity, then they send you a correction a few weeks later. Why can't they
by musicale 8y ago
What's puzzling is that the IRS seems to calculate your taxes anyway; if there's a disparity, then they send you a correction a few weeks later.
Why can't they do this beforehand so you have the option of just clicking "OK" and being done with it?
- rcfox 8y agoCanada more-or-less has this.
- craftyguy 8y agoAnd some European countries (Finland I believe, for example).
- rayiner 8y agoMany other European countries do things like require you to register with the government within a week whenever you move to a new place. They track much more information about you.
- craftyguy 8y agoEven in the US you eventually need to basically 'register with the government' (usually in the form of getting your ID/drivers license updated, and notifying USPS of mail service change).
- rayiner 8y agoYou only need to update your drivers license when you change states, not when you change residences. (And if you don’t drive you don’t need to do that either.) And you don’t neee to notify USPS of your mailing address.
- cgriswald 8y agoIn every state, you must notify the DMV of a change in residence, typically within 30 days.
- tptacek 8y agoHave you ever heard of someone getting ticketed for not doing this? I have never once notified the DMV of anything, and have driven for years with old addresses on my license. And, of course, if you don't drive, none of this applies.
- wglb 8y agoI have, but it was in Montana and many years ago. Turns out if you want to appeal your cook county tax, you need a current drivers license
- cgriswald 8y ago> Have you ever heard of someone getting ticketed for not doing this? Yes. > I have never once notified the DMV of anything, and have driven for years with old addresses on my license. You might want to fix that. In some states it's a misdemeanor rather than an infraction. > And, of course, if you don't drive, none of this applies. True, but I was only addressing the inaccurate information, because it could have consequences for people who believe it is true.
- tptacek 8y agoThat's interesting. I'm not sure I see how it could be anything worse than the penalty for driving without your drivers license (which will always get you ticketed, but rarely anything worse). I can always just not present my license at all.
- cgriswald 8y ago> I can always just not present my license at all. Sure, that might work. But a likely scenario is the officer will ask your name and DOB and look you up on his MDT and now you've got three tickets (including whatever you were pulled over for because now it is definitely not going to be a warning) instead of just one. Another scenario is the officer discovers you have your license and are just refusing to show your license. In California, and other states, you've now escalated a simple ticket to a misdemeanor with large fine and possible jail time. Another scenario is you just update your address with the DMV and don't risk compounding your problems during a traffic stop.
- atombender 8y agoMore than 32 countries do this: All of Scandinavia, Finland, Spain, Estonia, Macedonia, Australia, India, the Netherlands, Japan, the U.K. and a bunch of others.
- johnlorry 8y agoBelgium as well. Your employer reports your income to the tax administration, your bank reports your house mortgage for tax deduction and so on. For me it’s pretty much just a bunch of checkboxes check. The hardest part is getting my electronic id to work to log in to the bloody site.
- plinkplonk 8y agoIndia doesn't do this yet, but it is set to be launched in a couple of years.
- atombender 8y agoIn 2020, apparently: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/business/india-business/from-2020-pre-filled-i-t-returns-refunds-in-a-day/articleshow/67565007.cms https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/business/india-business/....
- Freak_NL 8y agoIt's a breeze in the Netherlands. I finished filing my taxes two weeks ago, a day after the pre-filled form became available online on the revenue service's website (works in all modern browsers, on all operating systems). It took five minutes (two incomes, mortgage, bank accounts, all filled in correctly by employers and banks). Most of that time was spent authenticating myself and my partner. Anyone fighting this in the US should make a bunch of videos showing average people from these countries filing their taxes in the blink of an eye.
- tnolet 8y agoFor employed people the Dutch system is indeed awesome. When you run a business, it's still quite archaic.
- pawelk 8y agoA system like this was launched this year in Poland, this year limited to employees and contract workers, but it's planned to expand to self-employed / business owners as well. If one doesn't log in / doesn't do anything, the form will be submitted Apr 30. If you log in you can update the form (e.g. add deductions or declare extra income), or just accept it as is - then it's submitted right away. There were some minor kinks, but in my opinion it was a success. Being self-employed I didn't get to use it, but saw how it works. I filed taxes on-line directly from my book keeping software and it took me ~20min, including getting my wife's pre-filled taxes from the govt service to combine with mine.
- kazinator 8y agoMore or less has what? Here it is copy paste from the CRA website: There are several ways to send your tax return to the CRA. Ultimately, this may be dependent on how you decided to complete your return. - By software (electronically) If you selected a NETFILE certified software, it will communicate directly with the NETFILE application servers and transmit all required information on your behalf directly to the CRA via the web service. - By paper: Mail your completed income tax package to your tax centre. - By phone: Follow the instructions in the invitation letter for File my Return that you received from the CRA. "By software" means using certified software, like Intuit's TurboTax. This is the very racket they seek to protect.
- rcfox 8y agoSo I use simpletax.ca. (It's free, but will ask for a donation after you file.) (Also, I don't work for them.) In it, there's an option to login to the CRA via your bank account (oauth?) and it will populate a bunch of data for you.
- craftyguy 8y agoUsually people on HN don't read the article, but in this case the title literally answers your question.
- black_puppydog 8y agoActually, the title answers the question "Why don't they just do that?" The question to "Why can't they do that" is simply "they could and it would save tons of money and headaches, but it goes the American Dream (21st century edition) that once you have a profitable business, nobody is to take it away from you.
- echevil 8y agoThe title doesn't say why would the government care about the opinion of TurboTax maker at all
- rayiner 8y agoThat wouldn’t work for most people. If you are married, have kids, or own a house, the IRS cannot calculate your taxes correctly. (Single young people downvoting me. The IRS doesn’t know how many kids live with you, what you pay in mortgage interest, and whether you’re still married to your spouse, all of which are necessary to calculate even simple tax situations.)
- llukas 8y agoNeither of those changes often. IRS can send you pre-filled taxes using status from last year or provide webpage with a checkbox.
- freehunter 8y agoSo the IRS mails you a questionnaire that asks these questions, you send it back, and they calculate your taxes automatically. No need for the $40 TurboTax fee, no need to type your W-2 information. But if what you say is true and the IRS can't calculate what you owe, that would mean they have absolutely no idea what you should be paying and you could get away with paying basically anything you want as long as you're not randomly selected for audit.
- cma 8y agoIsn't that why there is an audit process? Audits are a tool to ensure compliance with a stochastic threat due to high cost of research and enforcement. For things they can check automatically they already do, but audits can find more detailed things, at a higher cost to carry out.
- rayiner 8y agoTurboTax and Quicken are free for everyone making under $60,000, which would be most people whose taxes are simple enough that it could be done with a questionnaire. The IRS has some information about what you make obviously, because employers withhold your income. But they have very little information about deductions. Of course the IRS could calculate a maximum tax amount and put the burden on you to apply for deductions, but Republicans would flip their shit because it’d be a huge effective tax increase. They want tax season to be painful every year. Which gets to the point that is whizzing by everyone’s head. Intuit and Quickin aren’t single handedly lobbying to keep tax filing complicated. You could probably crowd fund an opposition if that was true. Intuit and Quicken are leveraging a political situation that exists for other reasons.
- hudibras 8y agoThat's the entire point of the article.
- oligopoly 8y agoThink about it this way. They make money from people who don't optimise their taxes
- kazinator 8y agoThey calculate the taxes on the information you have to supply, right? (I'm not in the USA, but Canada.) You could lie on the tax return by not reporting income, or claiming some false deductions and credits; the difference could be thousands of dollars. They will only be checking the false version for arithmetic or logic errors. The result might be, say, having to pay $50 more due to some mistake, even when actually it should be $5000 more due to lying. What this story is about is that the government could provide some service, like a website, where you can just put in your info and have it do the detailed calculations and form filling for you: essentially a government-run version of the software that Intuit and other vendors sell. The government can't just do this without any input from you, though. They can't just send you a bill for you to agree with or dispute.
- grawprog 8y agoAlso in Canada. Yeah i know people that work under the table that do this. They'll report traceable sources of income while leaving untraceable income out. It's fairly illegal. It's actually one of the ways they get small time drug dealers, they'll go after them for tax fraud. Personally, my taxes are simple enough that I could do them with the book if I wanted. I've found suitable tax software that doesn't cost me and is fairly easy to use. I'm not sure what it's like in America, but if you don't have a family, own property, run a business, or make a bunch of income from investments, doing taxes with a calculator really isn't that difficult.
- mrmanner 8y agoThey could use the information that others (banks and employers) report to them about your finances to pre-fill all the forms. That way you only need to add things that are missing and double check what’s there.
- kazinator 8y agoSure! And they could know about all your doctor's visits, so they could do your medical expense credits for you and similarly track every move you make in society. Oh, you paid for $257.35 on your VISA credit card ending in 1295 for prescription drugs this year: that's deductible! Is that what we want?
- analog31 8y agoThey could make it work like how most of us use "enterprise" software: 1. Fill in the obvious things like your name. 2. Click "submit" and let it highlight what's missing. Fill in those things. 3. Repeat until it stops throwing exceptions.
- blevin 8y agoDue to the designed complexity of our tax code the IRS cannot compute it both correctly and efficiently across the taxpayer base. Instead, they put the burden on the taxpayers, with stochastic validation and penalties (aka audits). For my part, I hope someone out there is managing to claim those Ottoman Turkish Empire Settlement payments. All I know is that the Empire hasn't existed in 100 years but is something my tax code asks me about every year.
- philwelch 8y agoThat's a California thing. (Did you know the Ottoman Empire contained substances known to cause cancer?) It is, apparently, a mechanism for survivors of the Armenian genocide to deduct any reparations they may potentially receive from their California state income taxes.
- kokokokoko 8y agoFor almost 70% of US taxpayers this is the case. Free of charge tax payment. You literally type in your address and other info along with your w2(these days many w2s have codes where you only have to type in a number and it fills the whole thing in). https://www.irs.gov/filing/free-file-do-your-federal-taxes-for-free https://www.irs.gov/filing/free-file-do-your-federal-taxes-f... Otherwise we're just talking about state taxes which the federal government has no control over. I expect to see this on some Facebook/reddit post, but on HN it is depressing to see how many people don't realize that what this comment describes has existed for decades.
- nulbyte 8y agoOn the contrary. Free-file does not let you "literally type in your address and other into along with your w2." You have to first choose a third-party tax preparer based on your qualifications (it's not the same across the board). Then you have to remember your password, or create an account. Then you have to hope the preparer's service puts you in the free package, while navigating through a site designed to get you to pay more for things you don't need. Often, you'll have to decline to upgrade multiple times, and it is downright annoying, if not confusing, as to how to do that. And if you do choose the free option, the preparer will not pull in your wages automatically, despite Intuit and others building systems that could (but don't) do this. No, the proposed system has not existed for decades. It has never existed. And as long as we keep listening to Intuit and the like, it will never exist.
- bvinc 8y agoI once simply forgot to put some income on my taxes. I only leaned about it a year or two later. I not only owed about a thousand dollars, but also I owed back interest. I wish they informed me after 2 weeks.
- hjk05 8y agoThat’s the way it works in Denmark. You get an email saying basically: “here’s a draft of you filling where we have filled out everything for you” you can then go and make any needed corrections and hit submit. Super simple straight forward system.
- flexie 8y agoThe Danish system is only super simple if you are a salaried employee. Once you run your own business it’s generally as difficult as the American system.
- jeromegv 8y agoConsidering majority of people are employed it’s already a huge step forward. Can’t we at least get there first before we criticize them?
- GuB-42 8y agoSame thing in France. Filling taxes for employees is essentially just clicking a button. But if you are self employed, you have to hire an accountant. It is not a legal obligation but there are so many things that can go wrong that you are putting your business at risk if you don't.
- mrmanner 8y agoThe Swedish system works the same way, but as long as your own business isn’t too complicated it’s still quite simple to file. You have to have your books in order anyway, and tax filing is usually as simple as copying over some numbers from the bookkeeping software and then Skatteverket (Swedish IRS) will suggest what is probably the best deductions and periodizations available for you. For my one man consulting business it takes less than an hour, and requires nothing more than having my accounting in order.
- xtracto 8y agoIn Mexico it works more or less the same: All payments are invoiced and signed with a Private/Public keypair unique for the person/company and provided by the government. At the end of the year, you go into SAT (Mex IRS) page to file your taxes and they provide you with a list of your money Input and Output, and they tell you how much you owe in Taxes or how much you are owed by them. You still can add other things that were missed by the system.
- anonymous5133 8y agobecause the IRS benefits from people basically overpaying their taxes out of fear of being prosecuted for underpaying their taxes.
- WrtCdEvrydy 8y agoThe IRS has changed over the years. I knew a guy who didn't pay taxes for nearly 10 years, this is a kid that was doing minimum wage work so he didn't think he needed to. IRS sends a letter going 'we think we owe you about 3,000. call us'
- burfog 8y agoIt's a way to check errors. Mismatches trigger audits. If you owe lots of taxes, and the IRS sends you their calculations, you might discover that they are unaware of some of your income. Well... guess they don't need to know!