10 ms·
Experimental rejection of observer-independence in the quantum world
- comboy 8y agoHere's a dumbed down version: https://outline.com/7Ckkqa https://outline.com/7Ckkqa Also not directly related video if you like your mind being blown: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ORLN_KwAgs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ORLN_KwAgs Especially given how our understanding of the world changed during the last 200 years, I would say we are still very much clueless. I find that exciting. Btw, no idea why did researchers get "freedom of choice" involved.
- Svoka 8y agoFor me "freedom of choice" argument always seemed completely philosophical with no practical implications. But still, philosophical arguments are fun.
- crooked-v 8y agoI'm personally a fan of the theological-style "everything is perfectly predestinated, and also you have full free will, and both are true at the same time" arguments.
- lenticular 8y agoI've never quite understood those kind of arguments. It seems that if that were true, then either the logic that the physical or metaphysical world runs on would be inconsistent. I suppose that isn't necessarily a deal-breaker, though.
- jMyles 8y ago> It seems that if that were true, then either the logic that the physical or metaphysical world runs on would be inconsistent. This statement itself depends on the logic which are you supposing might be deprecated.
- Retra 8y agoIf everything was predetermined, you'd simply be predetermined to feel justified in the belief that free will exists. So we would all agree to it, even if it were false. Personally, I don't see any reason it isn't a figment of the mind. Nobody is debating whether love exists. Our ability to model counterfactuals in our mind doesn't have any broader philosophical implications, so I don't see why free will would, when that may as well be all that it is.
- state_less 8y agoAs we gather more information, the free will argument seems to be looking less viable, but it'll be interesting to see how things pan out as ANNs start to guess our next moves. It might be something like picking the next word using a string of past words. Perhaps such a system could predict our actions and intervene when some poor outcome is predicted and direct us toward more positive outcomes?
- neom 8y agoI like to explore the idea that there is premeditation in asking a question, but the experiments you run to get there may contain free will.
- polynomial 8y agoHow does that work exactly?
- ridgeguy 8y agoYou're in good company: "There's a divinity that shapes our ends/ Rough hew them how we will." Hamlet, to Horatio, in Hamlet Act 5 Scene 2.
- msviss 8y agoThe argument isn’t that “everything is predestined” but there is still free will. That’s illogical by definition (and theologians are not intellectual weaklings). Rather the question is wheather, despite God’s omniscience, we still have free will. The question therefore is: is God’s omniscience equivalent to predestination? Some think yes (no free will. some Protestants and Muslims). Some think not (therefore we are free. Catholics, ppl who reject omniscience.) Personally I like Tolstoy’s take on the whole thing in WnP, because it betrays how deep his understanding of physics is (he even scratches at chaos theory).
- smoyer 8y agoI definitely believe in both but not because God is omniscience. We experience time because that's how God designed our universe and we progress along or timeline exercising free will. God on the other hand is outside our universe and can see our entire timeline. So he hasn't predestined us to make one decision or the other but is rather able to see every decision we've made in or future.
- quickthrower2 8y agoLike the series Quantum Leap?
- tylerjwilk00 8y agoI like to use a record player analogy for this concept. We are the needle. The needle responds to the environment of the record but can't see outside it's little perspective. God on other hand sees the record from above all at once. We are a consciousness needle scratching a path through 4D space-time.
- goldenkey 8y agoFurthermore, our consciousness is harmonic in nature. Every moment experienced reflects a bounded bitrate state of the brain. And death is when the needle has scratched the record so much that it has become worn flat, producing just silence. The record is still being played but the effect is all the same.. Until a new record is placed on the player. Do you identify yourself with the record or the needle? ;-)
- andrepd 8y agoSuperdeterminism?
- atq2119 8y agoThe most important thing is to acknowledge that "freedom of choice" or "free will" or any concept like that isn't a binary. Addiction and marketing both prove beyond a shadow of a doubt that we don't have "perfect" free will, and this is both (1) true regardless of what you think about determinism and (2) more relevant than any consequences of whether the universe is deterministic or not. The pragmatically relevant aspect of "free will" is to what extent our actions can be predicted and/or manipulated by others today and in the future. This necessarily involves e.g. measurement and computational limitations that others have, and it's something that occurs on a scale rather than as a binary.
- akvadrako 8y agoFreedom is choice is important because you might decide to base your choice on a property of a photon that originated in a galaxy far away. If you have no choice, than that property must have been predetermined to have a specific conspiratorial outcome, essentially since the beginning of the universe. Just to make sure you and your friend make compatible measurements. Without that assumption, every outcome can be explained as due to a highly unlikely conspiratorial setup.
- naasking 8y ago> For me "freedom of choice" argument always seemed completely philosophical with no practical implications. The "free will" debated in philosophy is not the same as the "free will" physicists talk about. The former is about moral responsibility, the latter is about being able to set experimental parameters independently of the system you're measuring.
- devoply 8y agoWhat's really interesting to me is the philosophical interpretation of this... as if something wants the experience of things within the universe to be somehow consistent. That implies intelligence and not just randomness.
- crooked-v 8y agoAlternately, maybe you're looking at progressive 3D slices of a 4D spacetime blob, and consistency is tautological in the same way as fitting together 2D slides of a 3D object. From what I understand, this basic idea of 4D geometry also provides some of the more elegant explanations for the effects of relativity when approaching the speed of light, because time dilation effects reduce down to (relatively) simple 3D trigonometry in a 4D graph. Of course, that raises predestination questions, because you're treating all of time and space as a single "object".
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- keyle 8y ago> It begins with a single polarized photon that, when measured, can have either a horizontal polarization or a vertical polarization. But before the measurement, according to the laws of quantum mechanics, the photon exists in both polarization states at the same time—a so-called superposition. Pardon my basic understanding, but doesn't it meant that it's both simply because it hasn't been measured - and therefor we don't know? Meaning it's either one or the other; at a very fast rate, it's both.
- shredprez 8y agoPiggybacking on my similarly basic understanding of wave-particle duality: it is literally both, and the mode of measurement is what causes the superposition to collapse into one state or another. In other words, you can “force” a superpositioned particle into the desired state simply by measuring it appropriately. We infer from this odd arrangement that the particle contains both states at once. Pardon any incorrectly used terminology above, but I believe my explanation is conceptually sound.
- colanderman 8y ago"Exists in both states" is a very misleading description of how quantum states work. I wish introductory texts didn't use that phrasing (or "superposition", for that matter). A photon can have one of an infinity of polarizations. These states are describable as a mixture of any two orthogonal polarizations (a "basis"), such as "horizontal" and "vertical". "Left circular" and "right circular" are another choice. The funny thing happens when you measure "how much" a photon is polarized into any given orientation. It appears as being polarized either in that orientation, or in the polarization complementary to what you measured. E.g., horizontal or vertical. The outcome is determined with a probability based on the actual polarization of the photon prior to your measurement. Then – the funny thing – the photon takes on that polarization. Repeated measurement using the same basis gives the same results. Measure again with a different basis, and the game starts over again. You can see this in the macro world with a laptop screen and two pairs of polarizing sunglasses. Using one pair of sunglasses, you should be able to block the light from the screen entirely – you are holding them perpendicular to the polarization of the screen. Place the second pair in between the first and the screen, and rotate it. At certain orientations, you will be able to see the screen! The second pair (nearest the screen) is diagonally polarized, and will "convert" the light from the screen into that polarization, before it reaches the first pair (furthest from the screen), which is orthogonal to the screen only. (Note: Things change completely once a second photon enters the picture. It can be entangled with the first, and their states are no longer independently describable. Measurement of one affects the pair.)
- IgorPartola 8y agoHere is what I don’t get, and never did as a physics undergrad: why is the information transfer important here? Let’s modify the thought experiment: Wigner’s friend measures the photon’s polarization and determines that it is horizontal. He then calls Wigner on the phone and tells him the result. Does this affect the result that Wigner sees when he verifies superposition? What if the friend lies? The post you linked seems to specifically call out that the friend cannot reveal the result of his measurement, lest the experiment get spoiled. This all seems to point to some philosophical/theological Mumbai jumbo with regard to consciousness being a necessary ingredient here, which doesn’t hold water. Yet with every thought experiment like this that I have seen, this kind of clause is included. Can anyone explain it like I am 25?
- asark 8y agoThe field's (quantum physics') moving back and freely between: Serious Math; ill-advised specialist terminology that borrows then twists common words in just the worst ways; and seemingly metaphysical stories or explanations that are... literal? Metaphorical? Full of borrowed BS words from point two that fall out of the math but don't "mean" anything in everyday terms? Definitely one of those until you ask a question then you're an idiot and it's another, until it's not again? Has put me off any childlike interest I once had in it. It seems fun. But I can't tell when they're serious or screwing with me. Sometimes one person claims something's serious, and they do so with authority, and another says they're screwing with me with just as much authority. I gave up. Somewhat relatedly[0], I can't find an explanation of the Oberth Effect that makes any damn sense. Every so often I try again and leave disappointed. People are happy to provide them. There are lots of them. They attribute it to all sorts of things. Not one of them I've read makes sense. [0] i.e. is physics, but is not quantum physics. So far as I know, anyway.
- Baeocystin 8y ago>I can't find an explanation of the Oberth Effect that makes any damn sense. It's simpler than people make it. When a spacecraft is moving at a high velocity, the amount of kinetic energy embodied by its fuel mass is a significant fraction of the chemical energy already present. And kinetic + chemical is greater than chemical alone. That's all there is to it.
- PavlikPaja 8y agoIt's essentially the schrödinger's cat - the first observer is the observer, while his friend is the cat. But the time won't stop going for the cat, it does experience its death and not, but it's vawefunction only collapses for the observer once the box is opened.
- wozer 8y agoMaybe we can just say "true randomness" instead of "freedom of choice"?
- pishpash 8y agoThat's not just a dumbed down version, that's a version with no useful information about this particular experiment.
- Razengan 8y ago> Especially given how our understanding of the world changed during the last 200 years, I would say we are still very much clueless. I find that exciting. Exactly. The universe would be rather boring if we learned everything about it during my lifetime.
- p1mrx 8y agoIf you're reading this, congratulations for observing a universe that contains this experiment.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoJust don’t expect to measure the paper’s impact factor.
- charlesism 8y agoAnd condolences to our selves in parallel timelines where this experiment was never conducted.
- everdev 8y ago> Wigner can even perform an experiment to determine whether this superposition exists or not. This is a kind of interference experiment showing that the photon and the measurement are indeed in a superposition. From Wigner’s point of view, this is a “fact”—the superposition exists. And this fact suggests that a measurement cannot have taken place. > But this is in stark contrast to the point of view of the friend, who has indeed measured the photon’s polarization and recorded it. The friend can even call Wigner and say the measurement has been done (provided the outcome is not revealed). A bit of a stretch saying that protons lose their superposition based on the content of a conversation.
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoFrom a Many Worlds point of view at least, they absolutely could, because the superposition represents ignorance in the mind of infinitely many Wigners, but once you remove the ambiguity you are just dealing with one specific Wigner, who would then know which Everett branch he is actually on (at least ip to the ambiguity of this particular experiment).
- gus_massa 8y agoIn this experiment, in both branches he receives the same information "A measure has been done.", so it doesn't remove the ambiguity, and it doesn't destroy the superposition.
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoI was talking about the case when the friend is told the outcome of the measurement, that’s the only part relevant to what the parent comment said.
- ivanbakel 8y agoWhy?
- everdev 8y ago
- powera 8y agoThis is an ARXIV pre-release. Has anyone peer-reviewed this?
- lisper 8y agoIf this turned out to be wrong it would be bigger news than if it turns out to be right. This result is 100% expected.
- cromwellian 8y agoRon Garrett gave a presentation at Google years ago on Quantum Information Theory that kind of demystified a lot of spooky stuff (like quantum eraser), and I'm wondering how much of this is merely an artifact of the way we're interpreting the math. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEaecUuEqfc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEaecUuEqfc
- pishpash 8y agoAs they say, the only mystery in QM is the Born rule.
- 8bitsrule 8y agoMeanwhile, the world could sure use more kinds of biodegradable containers. If these philosophers could spare a minute.
- anonytrary 8y agoMeanwhile, people complain about quantum theory research on a device that exists thanks to years of quantum theory research.
- quickthrower2 8y agoPlease tell me you work for a FAANG because that would make my day!
- mLuby 8y agoYou wouldn't even care about biodegradability had it not been for previous "philosophers" so there's no need to be glib. And who's to say the downstream effects of this research don't lead to advances in areas you care about? Theoretical research leads to applied science which ends up in products. Remember that GPS is only possible thanks to relativity, and e-commerce only works thanks for number theory.
- crystaln 8y agoWhataboutism?
- nomoel 8y agoI think you're expecting Plato to be Archimedes.
- pdonis 8y agoIt is quite an exaggeration to talk about this experiment as actually realizing a "Wigner's Friend" type scenario. In the Wigner's Friend thought experiment, the friend--an actual conscious macroscopic human being--is put into a superposition of different, mutually exclusive conscious experiences that Wigner, from the outside, is able to measure as such a superposition. Nothing like that is being done in this actual experiment: the only things being placed into superpositions are microscopic systems that have no experiences. This experiment is certainly interesting, and it realizes the basic structure of the multiple Wigner's Friend scenario that a number of theoretical papers have been written about recently, but I don't think it comes anywhere close to probing the actual issues raised by those theoretical papers. The kinds of real measurements that would have to be realized in order to probe those theoretical issues are many orders of magnitude more complex than those in this experiment.
- ikeboy 8y agoJust going to repeat from the HN thread a few days ago[0] https://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=3975 https://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=3975 Here's Scott Aaronson arguing that the theoretical work underpinning this experiment is flawed. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19369655 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19369655
- ricksharp 8y agoI think this needs many up-votes. It reminds me how sometimes converse is confused with contrapostive.
- hyperion2010 8y agoAh, I knew this rang a bell. Reflecting on this a second time, I wonder whether it is possible to interpret this as the universe not caring until the information interacting actually matters. For example, if someone tells me that they have measured a value, they could very well be lying, and until I say "prove it, what value did you measure?" the underlying implementation of the universe is in a superposition where they both did and didn't measure the value (where the friend is telling the truth vs lying).
- ikeboy 8y agoThe theoretical possibility of someone lying to you isn't quantum-based and doesn't work as a superposition. If they generated a random bit and lied depending on that value, then it would be.
- erydo 8y agoI am even more of a layman than most here, but — why is it different? Isn't that basically Schrödinger's cat?
- PavlikPaja 8y agoIt just doesn't bring anything new. It was obvious it has to work this way, since non-elementar particles can be in superpostion. If we assume that the time is still going for systems that appear to be in superposition for the outside observer, there doesn't seem to be any other explanation other than superposition being relative - the observers in the system still experience time as usual, and the superpostion only exists for the outside observer.
- dooglius 8y agoDid the results of this experiment differ from what quantum mechanics predicts? No? Then what is the point of publishing it? It's not as if different interpretations make different testable claims, or else they would be theories rather than mere interpretations.
- wilg 8y agoYou don't want people to publish experimental results that confirm predictions?
- dooglius 8y agoQuantum mechanics has already been experimentally confirmed ad infinitum. If I experimentally verify predictions of Newtonian mechanics with some new configuration of billiard balls, would you consider that worthy of publication?
- ceejayoz 8y ago> Did the results of this experiment differ from what quantum mechanics predicts? No? Then what is the point of publishing it? Experimental confirmations of theoretical predictions are very valuable.
- anonytrary 8y ago> Did the results of this experiment differ from what quantum mechanics predicts? No? Then what is the point of publishing it? Quick counterexample: By that logic, do you think results showing agreement with Einstein's GR should have never been released? I'm taking a wild guess that your answer is "no". This case is not any different.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- paraschopra 8y agoThere’s an interpretation that keeps observer as the central element. It is not as popular as many worlds or Copenhagen but I find it very intriguing. Check out QBism: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_Bayesianism?wprov=sfti1 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_Bayesianism?wprov=sf... In QBism, the Born rule is normative in that it tells the observer which observations to bet on, and observations are data points to update the observer’s subjective assessment of outcomes. Taking this perspective, a lot of paradoxes in QM seem to get resolved trivially. It’s controversial for sure but mathematically it’s rigorous.
- jliptzin 8y agoNot a physicist but I was under the impression we already knew this. For example if someone is falling into a black hole, to an outside observer they never cross the event horizon, just fall asymptotically slower towards it. But to the person falling in, he gets ripped to shreds. But I guess we haven’t tested that out.
- akvadrako 8y agoThat's the general relativity world, not the quantum world. They are different models, which is where these things are being proven.
- datenwolf 8y agoIf I were to review this paper, my critique would focus on this little paragraph: > We note that, although Bell’s mathematical machinery [9] is used to show the result, the set of assumptions considered here — and therefore the conclusions that can be drawn from a violation of inequality (2) — are different from those in standard Bell tests. That statement contains a lot of handwavium and in fact the interpretation of the results depends a lot on, if this experiment may be interpreted as another test on locality. Which I strongly presume, it does.
- SubiculumCode 8y agoAn interesting thing about deterministic systems. If the deterministic system ever enters into a state exactly like a prior state, then from then on, that system will be in an inescapble loop destined to repeat forever. If there ever was a repeatable state, I'd bet it would be at thr big bang, though i am no physicist.
- westurner 8y agoObjective truth!? A question for epistemologists to decide. How could they record their high entropy (?) solipsistic observations in an immutable datastore in such as way as to have probably zero knowledge of the other party's observations? Anyways, that's why I only read the title and the abstract. Wigner's friend experiment: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wigner%27s_friend https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wigner%27s_friend
- naasking 8y agoIt actually doesn't reject observer-independence unless you agree to certain axioms that an observer-independent interpretation of QM wouldn't feature. Bohmian mechanics is still perfectly viable, for instance.
- amai 8y ago"they seem to assume that all the photons' degrees of freedom are described by pure states according to both observers. This seems wrong to me. The observation of the photons by Wigner's friend creates an entanglement with the degrees of freedom in the friend's body, so the state of the photons themselves become mixed according to Wigner (I mean the external observer), not pure. So I think that when these things are done correctly, it's not possible to find this kind of a "contradiction" in practice." https://motls.blogspot.com/2019/03/six-photons-claimed-to-prove-that.html https://motls.blogspot.com/2019/03/six-photons-claimed-to-pr...
- bookofjoe 8y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19366854 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19366854
- badrabbit 8y agoI am very far from even understanding quantum physics theories but for all this experiment to be valid to begin with,the idea that superpositions exist must be true, correct? What if what they're proving is really the abscence of a superposition state? I never understood how superposition can be verified independent of assumptions. In this case,how can Wigner measure the photon has veritcal and horizontal polarity at the same time? Lastly,could superposition be explained by human's limit of sampling reality? For example audio recorded at 10Hz means 10/samples of audio a second,a sort of audio-resolution. If our reality-resolution is low,some things might require ability to measure their state at a better time-space resolution than what humans can currently sample (or build equipment that can measure this)? But with limited time-space resolution it can appear as if the object is in two states at the same time. Sort of like watching a movie at a very slow frame rate and you capture a moment where half the screen is of one frame but the rest is of a different frame since the display is only half finished rendering the raster/rows. Apologies if I am being absolutley clueless.
- maxander 8y agoThe classic demonstration of superposition is the double-slit experiment [0], where an experimenter shines a (coherent) light through a pair of slits at a screen (or fires a stream of electrons through a pair of slits, or small particles- it works with anything.) Because light is waves [1], light coming through one slit will interfere with light coming through the other slit, producing an interference pattern. But weirdly, this still happens if you turn the light source down so low that it emits only one photon at a time. In that case, the photon is in a superposition that travels through both slits, and the interference is between "the part of the superposition going through the right slit" and "the part of the superposition going through the left slit." So it's not a matter of our being unable to make detailed enough measurements; we can actually observe phenomena that directly indicate superposition happens. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double-slit_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double-slit_experiment [1] And so are electrons, particles, humans, etc.
- phayes 8y ago> for all this experiment to be valid to begin with,the idea that superpositions exist must be true, correct? Depends what you mean by "exist". All that needs to be true - and is true - is that QM provides an accurate model of the experiment. For many of us, QM is just probabilistic mechanics; i.e. probability theory applied to mechanics[1], and so long as you maintain the distinction between (epistemic) probability space states and (ontic) configuration space states (something the article under discussion here unfortunately fails to do), no ontic existence of [superposition] states is ever assumed in the first place. [1] More precisely, a natural and necessary generalisation of the classical, Kolmogorovian probability theory you might be familiar with (necessary because of the noncommuting random variables): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19315457 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19315457 See also: http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/cosmicvariance/files/2011/11/banks-qmblog.pdf http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/cosmicvariance/files/2011/...
- internet_user 8y agoDoes this imply Leggett's inequalities have been proven?