26 ms·
Visible signs left after Google Fiber abandons Louisville
- endofcapital 8y ago"But Google Fiber got something out of its time here. It learned that nanotrenching—the cost-saving process of burying fiber optic cables just two inches underground—was a bust. “We currently do not have plans that call for 2 inch trenches, our primary specifications are focused on going deeper,” a Google Fiber spokesperson said in an email." It's so weird to just use cities as A/B tests and just disregard all the people and plans built around a failed case at the drop of a hat. Are they going to start A/B testing countries against eachother next?
- paxys 8y agoTrying new products in small markets as an experiment has been a thing forever, and is something literally every company does regularly. There is nothing weird about it. As for the fallout, IMO the city is to blame for it more than Google, since the company is obligated to do exactly what the contract entails.
- tzs 8y agoYeah, but when a soda company, say, tries out one new flavor in my town, and different new flavor in your town, and mine flops and yours succeeds, they don't just stop selling soda in my town. They start selling the flavor from your test in my town, too. It would have risked much less bad publicity if they had done the 2" experiments in a city they were willing to use 6" trenching in. Do part of the deployment with 2" and part with 6", and if the 2" part doesn't work redo that part with 6".
- 908087 8y agoSoda companies also don't leave deteriorating trenches behind on the roads in town when their tests fail.
- op00to 8y agoI think what's different is typically cable/phone companies have been reluctant to give up on their investment so easily. This is probably somehow due to the past and present monopolies they hold. Google, like the honey badger, don't care.
- pathseeker 8y agoGoogle does this all of the time with all of their products. The purposely degraded the performance of some users on their products (search IIRC) to see how they would react.
- kalleboo 8y agoYouTube too, can't find it now but they did a study where they degraded users to 480p to see how many would manually switch back to HD (spoiler: very few did) I believe YouTube also experimentally surfaces new recommendations slowly to see how many clicks they get and if it should be surfaced more or not
- abraae 8y agoThis already happens, Facebook sometimes tests features in specific countries e.g. New Zealand before wider rollout. https://i.stuff.co.nz/technology/social-networking/103511194/facebook-test-new-downvote-button-on-new-zealand-users https://i.stuff.co.nz/technology/social-networking/103511194...
- AaronFriel 8y agoIsn't that what cities, states, and countries are in an abstract sense? They are randomized trials of different systems of law and government, and so on. It's much messier when it's accidental, but ... wouldn't it be smart for say, new state propositions in California to be tested in a trial to verify they produce the consequence voters asked for?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- paxys 8y agoThe failure of Google Fiber paints a very bleak picture of the future of internet infrastructure, or even all communication in this country. If Google cannot compete with the status quo, who can?
- bovermyer 8y agoThat's not the lesson I'd learn here. This seems like Google has not yet learned how civil engineering works, which is a crucial component in internet infrastructure. It's unfortunate that Louisville is getting bit hard here.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- smueller1234 8y agoI would also point to the engineering required to build and operate some of the world's largest datacenter and wan infrastructure.
- halbritt 8y agoThey don't build the WAN infrastructure, nor is building data centers an exercise in civil engineering. Typically, data centers are located where the least amount of civil engineering is required.
- smueller1234 8y agoGoogle don't? Not exclusively, but well: https://techcrunch.com/2018/07/17/google-builds-its-own-subsea-cable-from-the-us-to-france/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/07/17/google-builds-its-own-subs...
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoThe lesson is never trust in the longevity of Google products, a lesson they keep teaching us over and over.
- esmi 8y agoI wish they provided some details on why the San Antonio and Nashville small trials didn’t scale to Louisville. If the issues were really so glaring and obvious it seems those efforts should have revealed them. Edit: Looks like it didn’t actually work in those cities either. One wonders why the Louisville representatives missed this. https://www.wsmv.com/news/repaving-streets-reveal-google-fiber-buried-too-close-to-surface/article_9af6a069-1466-582a-90d2-514b4eeef7ea.html https://www.wsmv.com/news/repaving-streets-reveal-google-fib...
- KennyFromIT 8y agoLouisville's representatives likely missed that because they were wearing rose-colored glasses. They were thinking "big picture" about would a successful project could mean for the city and were ignoring the details. They were probably (rightly?) assuming that an organization like Google would be able to learn from their mistakes and "this time would be different". Really, it's hard to fault them for thinking this way, but just like every other situation in business, if it seems too good to be true, it probably is.
- dwighttk 8y agohoping to get something for their $400K investment.
- kalleboo 8y agoMaybe it was so soon after those trials started that the problems hadn't shown up yet?
- spullara 8y agoFiber is probably a dead end and will ultimately be replaced by 5G point-to-point transmission for the last mile.
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoI really can't see this happening. I really don't want to see this happen. Wired is robust. I can spit and wireless takes a dive.
- spullara 8y agoDownvote all you want but this is why Verizon stopped rolling fiber out and why Google Fiber fails in most places. It doesn't make financial sense to hard wire every house with fiber when you can get higher speeds (20 Gps) over the air with the next generation of wireless technology. It will be cheaper to deploy and will have far broader reach.
- neom 8y agoGrace Simrall the CTO over there is no n00b. They're a customer of ours and they're probably one of the most advanced cities we work with in terms of thinking about a "city stack". Google Fiber didn't abandon them, as far as I can tell they just have better plans that don't include being strong armed by google.
- gz5 8y agoWould it be surprising to see Google pivot to 5G for the tech solution? I believe their business goal is still to control the access. Anyone see a realistic unit cost analyis for 5G in urban environments at maturity? On the fiber side, I think cities need to build the infrastructure (and are often in a position to finance via low interest rate bonds etc), and then enable any party to lease/operate/compete on that infrastructure.
- ecshafer 8y agoDoes Google own the rights necessary to radio frequencies to do 5g? That seems like the major blocker.
- LockNess0 8y agoThe latter is pretty much the Swedish model, by the way. It makes sense. Fibre optic cable is mostly a solved solution, just like copper wire for electricity and pipes for gas, water and sewage.
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 8y agoI have WebPass (webpass.net) in Denver, which is a company that Google acquired. It's mainly for residential multi-unit apartment buildings, though. I've had it for several years and it works extremely well. It uses point-to-point radios from their main node in the city to the top of your building, then you get an ethernet hookup in your unit. I almost always get in the ~700-800Mbps up and down range on ethernet connections, regardless of time of day. Never had any issues during snow, rain, fog, etc. My guess is that Google realized that fiber-to-the-home is the wrong strategy, and too costly, just as Verizon FIOS halted their rollout years before. And I believe even ATT only does fiber to a neighborhood and then coax to the home, right? It's sad to see, but the cost is astronomical and it's a lot harder to get cities/municipalities to let you dig things up. Especially for America with it having so much sprawl, a wireless solution will probably work better and the rollout will be quicker.
- jedberg 8y ago> And I believe even ATT only does fiber to a neighborhood and then coax to the home, right? No, I have a fiber going right to my dmark. I watched them string it and terminate myself.
- yingw787 8y agoWhen I interned at AT&T a few years ago, I asked a manager I respected whether they were worried about Google Fiber coming in and eating their lunch. "No", he said. "We'll sue them for every mile of fiber they lay down". I can understand why they would make that play. It's kind of the only play they have. AT&T and Verizon innovate enough to remain...okay...but they're not exactly Google. The only way they would win is to get dirty and turn fiber laying into Google's very own Stalingrad. And between starting a new, massive, low-margin (by advertising's standards), and capital-intensive business, and keeping salaries high and employees happy, Google chose the latter and bowed out because honestly, dying on this hill isn't a smart move. I doubt Google wants to do this. Pulling out at this stage, when Fiber hadn't actually provided the "nudge" to internet speeds and throughput that would make Google and Internet companies more powerful, would not place Google at a place of negotiating strength. It makes Google look bad and cements the ISP monopolies' notion that Google pulled out because they physically can't bear the pain and so they remain safe, not because Google chose to, can do this whenever they want, and have the ISPs at their mercy. It probably also burned a few bridges, if there were bridges at all, and makes weighing favors in a (hopefully not long-term) post-net-neutrality world swing towards the other major power players like Amazon or Facebook.
- anonymous5133 8y agoIt did have a positive impact though because AT&T and Verizon started actually building out their fiber networks more aggressively when they saw google entering the space. I live in Orange County, CA and AT&T out here started building out fiber when they saw Google building in Irvine, CA. AT&T knows that if they could just "rope off" google to a small area then their initial investment wouldn't really be worth it.
- yingw787 8y agoMy concern is whether the ISPs will find expanding and maintaining their fiber infrastructure necessary if Google continues to pull out of the market, or whether it'll end up crushed like the EV-1 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_EV1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_EV1). Is there enough demand already generated in industries requiring significant network throughput (e.g. e-sports, industrial IoT, or elsewhere) that ISPs will shoot themselves in the foot if they collapse the market? I personally don't use enough data to justify a Gigabit connection. My friends who stream video and game online might. Hopefully the latter will pull us into the future, but I don't know for sure.
- dgacmu 8y agoThis was announced a month ago: https://fiber.googleblog.com/2019/02/louisville_7.html?m=1 https://fiber.googleblog.com/2019/02/louisville_7.html?m=1 And discussed here at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19106998 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19106998 (207 comments)
- dang 8y agoGood catch. But the current article has new information. I've attempted to give it a more specific title. If anyone suggests a better one (i.e. more accurate and neutral), preferably using language from the article itself, we can change it again.
- shmerl 8y agoVery irresponsible behavior. If they have commitments, they should have stuck to them. The way they behaved with Google Fiber is atrocious. Networks can't be built without long term investments and Google knew well about that when they started.
- 908087 8y agoThe "Google never actually meant to be an ISP, they just wanted to kickstart competition" spin I hear pushed on this reminds me of the "they were just trying to start the conversation" spin when people get caught faking racist/sexist/homophobic attacks on themselves.
- aksss 8y agoAs the article says, the problem set is multifaceted. Nanotrenching doesn't work, and laying infrastructure in any case is super expensive. In a green field implementation in your privately owned parking lot, it would be an expensive undertaking in terms of material and time & motion, tooling. Now add in permitting requirements from the city to do the exact same mechanical exercise, plus coordination to shut city streets temporarily, enviro-impact studies, etc, etc, etc. Then add project managers, regulatory experts & lawyers to deal with the city and navigate it all. The costs are huge. It's annoying to me that some people gloss over the role of civil administration as a market barrier, but by its nature Telecom as an industry has high capital and expense requirements from installation to O&M. A lot of folks don't fully appreciate this until they work in the industry or like Google, try to revolutionize it.
- jly 8y agoI'm a happy Google Fiber customer (Austin), and my neighborhood was deep-trenched. The results have been excellent, with near-zero reliability issues and a clean look on the street. Unfortunately, not everyone is having the same experience. The perception here is that they are operating a shell of what the previous ambitions were. Service has been active in my area for close to 3 years now, but I have neighbors who have been on waitlists for months or years to get their house on the network, still being told to call back every few months. It seems like any houses that missed the initial sign-up (now many years ago) are a crapshoot to ever receive service in a timely manner. Some streets that didn't receive enough sign-ups were never trenched, while adjacent streets were. Sometimes fiber is installed all the way to the house with months-long delays connecting to the network (splicing issues, conduit clog, etc). I've loved my service and it's been rock-solid, but there are certainly a lot of obstacles compared with traditional telecom providers.
- EpicEng 8y agoSame here in the burbs. Would love me some fiber, but it's never going to happen.
- lizknope 8y agoI live in the Raleigh-Durham, NC area and we heard Google Fiber was coming to the area around 2015. A couple of months later Time Warner upgraded my cable modem speed from 15Mb to 50Mb download for the same monthly price. Then 2 years ago AT&T came through my neighborhood installing fiber and turned it on 3 months later. Google Fiber is concentrated in a few small areas. AT&T Fiber is expanding all over the area. I know 1 person with Google Fiber and about 15 with AT&T Fiber. I would prefer Google over AT&T but the AT&T Fiber works and is reliable and Google is so slow at expanding that nobody cares anymore.
- robocat 8y agoAt many traffic light intersections, you can see where the trenches are used for inductive loop car sensors, with wire in them. https://www.traffic-signal-design.com/vehicles_detected.htm https://www.traffic-signal-design.com/vehicles_detected.htm The trench is narrow, cut with a diamond saw, and the filler (tar?) doesn't come out. The example photo of a failure in the article, showed a relatively wide trench, presumably width required for the microduct for blown/jetted fiber. So maybe they used a trench that was too wide, and a filler that was unsuitable. I have also seen microtrenchs used in New Zealand across private driveways (low traffic use). I wonder how good the trials were of the filler? I sometimes see paint tests on the road (multiple lines of different product and different thicknesses, being tested by heavy, real traffic use).
- rcchyssser 8y agoIt's Kentucky, it always looks like that.
- ilovecaching 8y agoLet’s not forget that the real issue here is that American ISPs are a complete monopoly by Comcast and AT&T, companies made of pure greed. Small end sub ISPs have to claw for every strand of dark fiber. Google really shouldn’t be the answer though. We need to demand that politicians address the issue in the upcoming election before they start looking at the Silicon Valley giants.
- ianai 8y agoProbably the mayors in the lineup would be most aware of this need.
- vonmoltke 8y ago> Let’s not forget that the real issue here is that American ISPs are a complete monopoly by Comcast and AT&T It doesn't change much, but you left out Verizon and Spectrum.
- usefulcat 8y agoTrue, but in any given market you'll be lucky to have even two of the above as competitors, let alone 3 or more.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- onetimemanytime 8y agoOn the other hand, they laid the cables first, a very expensive undertaking.
- ilovecaching 8y agoThanks to huge government subsidies that they squandered. They have promised time and time again to build better infra for hundreds of millions in tax payer dollars and we still have total crap. People who work for them are morally bankrupt.
- greedo 8y agoMy city negotiated a fiber contract with Allo that was very favorable to the city. Allo basically provides free internet to municipal buildings for the right to sell fiber to residential areas. The entire city is almost covered (300K people), and rates are very affordable ($90/month for 1gig symmetrical). Allo also sells tv and phone service as well. I've been extremely happy. Allo provided the CPE at no cost, doesn't require a contract, and has support people who seem to be close to the metal.
- sodosopa 8y agoHow bad were their roads prior to Google? If it's like a lot of other states, roads get little funding for improvements Louisville should have looked at the model set by Chattanooga's EPB. Fastest internet in the country and a highly rated customer service team. Their roads suck too but it's not the ISP's fault.
- paul7986 8y agoGoogle is a terrible company!
- xparco 8y agoGoogle owes them nothing. These people are so entitled. They need to be sent off for war.
- ggm 8y agoLong time ago, the campus I worked at was offered "the deal of the century" from Dec to buy FDDI cards for all campus. A really sweet deal, only $5000 per host.. The moral of the story: beware geeks bearing gifts. Google should have been put into a contract to only field-test shallow trenches, if they committed to remediation into deep trenches at their own buck. "they would have gone somewhere else" is the voice of Amazon city bidding nonsense: this is public utility infrastructure. They ballsed it up, they should have been contractually obligated to get it right. If it was a testbed freebie, different story. You let somebody in to test something for free? Sure. Public Liability? sure. Disappointed customers? Sure. Hang on.. who are they disappointed in? the elected Lousville Officials?
- rdiddly 8y agoAnybody else notice the symmetry of how Google's competition is described as "entrenched" and how Google's fiber lines were literally, insufficiently entrenched?
- WhuzzupDomal 8y ago“The company also wanted to cover the trenches with epoxy, rather than the typical asphalt mix.” Along with the rest, this outlines a basic problem that modern Google and other Silicon Valley companies have with technologies. The Google people have massive talent, capabilities, and funding. Yet the use this almost as a handicap nowadays. Because they have talent doesn’t mean they have a monopoly of it. We have extensive testing of every conceivable paving and repair mathod done over 100+ years. Engineering colleges around the U.S. (and the world of course) have a massive legacy of tests. To go in and just guess your new idea is going to work for a new project just isn’t necessary in such basic technologies.
- Criper1Tookus 8y agoI really don’t think Google knows what they really want to achieve with Fiber - otherwise they’d have figured out the right way to roll it out years ago. They also bought a separate company, Webpass, that does “fixed wireless” (wireless to the building using a pretty big antenna, about the size of a stadium light, building is wired from there), and that has also been rolling out very slowly.