8 ms·
This shouldn't be Trump announcing the ban. Either FAA or Secretary of Transportation should be announcing the grounding of flights. Its just odd to me that Tru
by dragontamer 8y ago
This shouldn't be Trump announcing the ban. Either FAA or Secretary of Transportation should be announcing the grounding of flights. Its just odd to me that Trump would be involved...
- Trisell 8y agoIt sounds like he had to go to an Executive Order to get the FAA to comply.
- dragontamer 8y agoI mean, he has a phone-line, and his Secretary of Transportation is in charge of the FAA. So its just odd that he'd personally involve himself in this issue. There's a myriad of ways for Trump to get this done with better optics. Even if Trump were to give a phone call along the lines of 'Ground the Plane or else I'll write an executive order' , the optics of the situation would be so much better if Chao (Secretary of Transportation) or Dan Elwell (FAA Acting Administrator) were to give the announcement instead.
- ceejayoz 8y ago> So its just odd that he'd personally involve himself in this issue. Personally involving himself unnecessarily is Trump's MO. "Only I can fix it." was one of the themes of his 2016 RNC speech.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- chrisseaton 8y ago> if Trump were to give a phone call along the lines of 'Ground the Plane or else I'll write an executive order' , the optics of the situation would be so much better If the President is requiring it then the proper mechanism to do that is an order. You're suggesting a side-channel phone call and a threat so that he's still deciding but it's recorded as someone else's decision for PR purposes, and you think that's better? That's a terrible idea.
- amyjess 8y ago> You're suggesting a side-channel phone call and a threat so that he's still deciding but it's recorded as someone else's decision for PR purposes, and you think that's better? That's a terrible idea. I disagree with GP, but this is basically how firings are handled at high levels. It's very rare for a POTUS or a corporate CEO to actually fire a direct report. Instead, they say "you have X days to resign before I fire you" via a side channel, and most of the time the report opts for the resignation. (funny thing is, at the first company I worked for, the CEO did this to the VP of Engineering... and the VP assumed he was bluffing, waited out the whole 30-day period he was given without resigning, and then got walked out of the building one morning in front of everyone who was there that early... and the guy who was in charge of walking him out was one of the people who was promoted to replace him)
- CydeWeys 8y agoThere's a difference between personnel changed and commanding actions to be taken, though.
- ejstronge 8y ago> his Secretary of Transportation is in charge of the FAA I actually don't believe this is true - I can look up citations in a bit, but the FAA is an independent body whose directors are appointed by the president.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> but the FAA is an independent body whose directors are appointed by the president. The Federal Aviation Agency was an independent agency, but the Federal Aviation Administration, which it became, is a subordinate agency within the Department of Transportation. It has an Administrator, but it does not have directors, commissioners, or some other multimember voting governing body.
- ejstronge 8y agoUnfortunately didn't have a chance to check this on mobile, but the parent poster is correct: https://www.faa.gov/about/history/brief_history/#agency https://www.faa.gov/about/history/brief_history/#agency
- billfruit 8y agoOptics for whom? Trump might feel it is better optics for him, if it comes out as something that he has done.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Theodores 8y agoRemember that Trump knows a lot about planes. Unlike most people here he owns a big plane made by Boeing. As well as being a narcissist this is something he can feel he can understand, it's his topic, he pays the bills to get his own plane serviced. more to the point, who told the FAA bods not to pull the plane? Was this the President too? Because of how this has been handled by the Trump I think Boeing now have a 'Samsung Note 7' on their hands, i.e. a product that isn't going to be re-released as it is poorly engineered and can't be fixed by just changing a supplier or two. It was a hack with another hack to keep the hack okay. There will be a who knew what and when scandal. This won't be like the Dreamliner teething issues due to two lost planes. People can forgive teething issues but a scandal is a different beast.
- kalleboo 8y agoHe also ran an airline for a couple years and personally managed a air safety PR incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trump_Shuttle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trump_Shuttle > In August 1989, a Trump Shuttle flight arriving in Boston incurred a nose gear failure upon landing due to maintenance errors by Eastern personnel prior to the acquisition. Trump personally flew on the next Trump Shuttle flight to Boston in order to manage the media reaction to the incident.[3]
- agildehaus 8y agoOwning a plane does not equate to understanding anything about them, easily proved by his completely stupid tweets about the complexity of modern aircraft being a bad thing.
- Someone1234 8y agoAccording to [0] this is true. I'm surprised a president would need to use an EO for this? Couldn't they just command FAA to take a course of action? [0] https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/13/boeing-shares-fall-after-report-says-us-expected-to-ground-737-max-fleet.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/13/boeing-shares-fall-after-rep...
- jdavis703 8y agoAn EO is the legal mechanism to command an agency to take an action. Agencies shouldn’t be taking instructions from random tweets, TV appearances and speeches as it’s hard to interpret the exact meaning. Further if some random bureaucrat were to act on a random Tweet and then be sued they’d be unable to say “I was just following orders.”
- justin66 8y ago> An EO is the legal mechanism to command an agency to take an action. Agencies shouldn’t be taking instructions from random tweets, TV appearances and speeches as it’s hard to interpret the exact meaning. Yes, but it'd not be unusual for the agency's director to check in with the president on a course of action or vice versa, verbally or via memorandum, without the president formally invoking his presidential authority via executive order. To put the whole thing in perspective, the number of EOs issued annually by recent presidents Bush and Obama was very modest, averaging 36.4 and 34.6 respectively.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> It sounds like he had to go to an Executive Order to get the FAA to comply. The words he used was "emergency order" and "we", not "executive order" and "I". CNBC is reporting it (not quoting any official source which says that, and citing only the President's "emergency order" public statement) as an "executive order", but other news sources are not, and Boeing is saying that they recommended the grounding to the FAA. My initial impression is that this is an FAA action based on Boeing's recommendation that the White House wanted to take the press attention for.
- dragontamer 8y ago> My initial impression is that this is an FAA action based on Boeing's recommendation that the White House wanted to take the press attention for. That would make me feel better if this were true. It seems to match my expectations for who is in charge of various decisions, as well as the politics that Trump likes to play. So it makes sense at least.
- jrochkind1 8y agoTo me another plausible explanation is that the reason the FAA _wasn't_ grounding them was because Trump said not to. > Early Tuesday, Dennis A. Muilenburg, the chief executive of Boeing, spoke to President Trump on the phone and made the case that the 737 Max planes should not be grounded in the United States, according to two people briefed on the conversation. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/12/business/boeing-737-grounding-faa.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/12/business/boeing-737-groun... Maybe Boeing changed it's mind in between yesterday and today?Or that reporting was inaccurate? Or, that's exactly what happened, but then today either Trump or Boeing or both of them realized this wasn't gonna fly (no pun intended), and that they had to be grounded, they talked to each other again, Trump decided he wanted to make an announcement about it because he likes being on TV about whatever he's thinking about at the moment. (I'm not sure an "emergency order", which Trump said it was, is even a thing?) I mean, really, who the fuck knows. This administration doesn't tend to make a lot of sense, and it's kind of kremlinology trying to guess why they do what they do.
- foobarbazetc 8y agoThis stopped being a functional democracy a while ago.
- caprese 8y agoThe President is analogous to the Chairman/CEO of [most of] the executive branch. That role can tell them what to do and what do focus on, but mostly doesn't. He told them what to do, now the FAA has to do it. The Secretary of Transportation could likely have unilaterally issued an order without needing it to tell the FAA what to do, or waiting for the President. But either way, this is symbolic and shows the stance of the government to the world and internally. The highest office in the US is grounding the planes like the rest of the world is, the administrative nuances are irrelevant. Boeing and the airlines would be the ones to challenge it, way to go for PR.
- dragontamer 8y agoOf course the President can just tell the FAA what to do. I understand that. The question is how the public should have been informed by the event. Dan Elwell, the acting director of the FAA, is both a military and commercial pilot. If he made the announcement, it would have carried far more weight than Trump (who likely doesn't know much about airplanes).
- numbsafari 8y agos/likely/clearly/
- caprese 8y agoThe President of the United States made the announcement. Thats what is being written in the history books. It carries weight regardless of who is in office. In a tiny little footnote on wikipedia it will mention how disturbed citizens of California got the Secretary of Transportation or the FAA to reissue the same order because "orange man bad". You might be led to think I'm being "unsubstantive" but this is how the EO for gold confiscation is recorded (but the Secretary of the Treasury merely reissued it after a court challenge), as well as the EO for Japanese interment camps are recorded.
- bluesroo 8y agoThat would have only carried weight for those who know who Dan Elwell is. He carries no weight with me other than apparently being "acting director of the FAA". The president, even if he's disliked by many, carries much more weight for the average person.
- ww520 8y agoMaybe he was letting FAA to do their job to avoid the appearance of interfering, but the external pressure was getting too high and FAA was dragging their feet so he stepped in to overrule. Interesting to see who's the original appointter of the FAA commissioners.
- dragontamer 8y agoNobody. Trump has failed to appoint an FAA administrator for his entire tenure as President. FAA has an acting administrator: Dan Elwell. He was appointed by Trump to be Deputy Administrator.
- ww520 8y agoDid Congress block his appointment or he simply didn't nominate one?
- ceejayoz 8y agoThere's simply no nominee. http://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow-show/why-hasnt-trump-nominated-someone-lead-the-faa http://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow-show/why-hasnt-trump-nomi...
- dragontamer 8y agoNo nominee at all.
- burfog 8y agoNominating one isn't so simple. First of all, there is a backlog of higher priority nominees. It wouldn't be good to distract congress from those. Second of all, the constant harassment of this administration must be having a huge impact. A person has to be slightly crazy to accept a nomination. They and their family will be facing physical danger, legal danger, and more. Lots of competent people are thus unavailable as choices. The constant harassment has had a real negative effect on the quality of our government.
- 8y ago
- post_break 8y agoMaybe he wanted to be seen as the savior vs letting the FAA do it?
- InclinedPlane 8y agoBingo.
- mzs 8y agoFAA 3PM eastern https://twitter.com/FAANews/status/1105908677612056578 https://twitter.com/FAANews/status/1105908677612056578
- mikeash 8y agoThis is by far the most interesting aspect of this story. I expected that the US would ground these planes soon. There was too much pressure to follow the rest of the world. But having the order come from the President rather than the FAA is highly unusual. Seems like something very strange must be going on behind the scenes. Maybe the FAA is reluctant and he’s forcing their hand, or maybe he’s trying to take credit for their decision.
- ikiris 8y agoOr more likely, he pushed initially for it not to be grounded and now changed his mind and is getting in front of the story to cover his ass.
- lucb1e 8y agoGives the impression that he called the shots, which would be a worrying scenario for all people flying in the USA indeed.
- nabla9 8y agoTrump has not nominated administrator for the FAA. FAA has currently only acting administrator. He initially tried to nominate his own pilot for the job (the same who screwed so much that FAA had Trump's plane grounded).