4 ms·
>I find it worrying that it took them so long to come to the obvious conclusion Aviation regulators and internet forums are literally at the opposite end of th
by whatshisface 8y ago
>I find it worrying that it took them so long to come to the obvious conclusion
Aviation regulators and internet forums are literally at the opposite end of the spectrum with regards to jumping to conclusions.
- jsharf 8y agoFrankly, it hasn't even been a week. Thousands of flights happen every day, and these two accidents were 5 months apart. If it takes 2 weeks to make the decision, that actually sounds quite rushed. In the meantime every pilot on the planet is probably paying attention so they know what to do if they find themselves in the same situation, so likely the risk has already gone down slightly. I think that waiting 2 weeks until we have better facts represents a very reasonable tradeoff between safety and paranoia. It sounds to me like grounding the plane is a good idea, but I don't know exactly how the anti-stall system works, and I have no context for making the decision.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dmix 8y agoYep a lot of papers have mentioned how these groundings by airlines was a very rare occurrence. Especially without any FAA confirmation and the day after an accident.
- sesutton 8y agoI don't think it would be so bad if aviation regulators did jump to conclusions by erring on the side of safety.
- Someone1234 8y agoThat's a truism. You're kind of ignoring their point though, which was that the data existed and was readily available. Internet forums may be "jumping to conclusion" but regulators have had this data for days, and didn't act on it. They only acted after regulators in Europe and elsewhere acted first.
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoMaybe the operative word is validated, then.
- rfugger 8y agoIf you're a regulator, and you have unvalidated data that suggests a plane may be unsafe, how long do you wait for validated data before deciding to ground that plane "out of an abundance of caution"?
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoThree days? It's their job to keep people safe. They do that by looking at data they trust. I don't envy the position they're in this week one bit.
- joezydeco 8y agoThe "data" being ADS-B information gathered by amateurs over homemade receivers? If I was a regulator I'd want a verified and traceable data source as well.
- marcosdumay 8y agoTiming does not carry much information here. Those decisions are taken by bureaucracies, and we are talking about days. The Brazilian flight authority, for example, makes this kind of decision once a week, and there's a backlog. Even if all the technical analysis was ready minutes after the accident, it wouldn't have decided on it yet. Most western ones have a similar organizational model. Data gathering takes days, data verification takes days, every time one has to contact somebody in a timezone with 4+ hours of difference, it takes a couple of days, informing superiors takes days, scheduling a decision takes days, even publishing it takes days.
- rfugger 8y agoThe conclusion in this case is, "two of the same type of plane crashed under similar circumstances so until we know more, no one should fly this plane." I have no problem with a regulator jumping to that "conclusion" until they are absolutely certain the plane is safe. What bothers me is that yesterday, Garneau was basically saying, "until we're sure the plane is unsafe, we're going to keep flying it." That's backwards.