44 ms·
So this isn't just banning from airports, this is banning from their airspace? That's then more or less a total grounding of them in Europe. As an example, Nor
by alkonaut 8y ago
So this isn't just banning from airports, this is banning from their airspace? That's then more or less a total grounding of them in Europe.
As an example, Norwegian (who has 15 of them) said they weren't grounding them as late as this morning, but now they'll have no choice. They use them mainly for their medium flights between scandinavia and southern europe (Nice, Budapest, Tenerife etc). No way they can do that without flying over Germany and France. It wouldn't be very good optics if they swapped their MAX'es to domestic use to free up regular 737's for flying over the continent either.
- the_mitsuhiko 8y agoAustria also closed the airspace for 737 max planes, while not the largest country in Europe together with France and Germany that adds quite a bit of extra detour coming from Norway.
- erokar 8y agoIndeed. Norwegian is doing this because the optics now force them to do so, not self-assessment of the risk. They, and the Norwegian Civil Aviation Authority, failed in that regard.
- dclowd9901 8y agoAt least it’s not the country bound and determined to prop up the brand at all costs. If it was 2 A320s that went down, you can bet we’d be banning them instantly in the states.
- jka 8y agoDo you have a reference to confirm that this was a knee-jerk/optics reaction, out of interest? (definitely curious to see how airlines/authorities are reaching these decisions) The MCAS system and the way it was introduced sound a little like a patch, and slightly haphazard. While training & runbooks and procedures are important, take-off is a busy time, and the Max-8 is (afaik) intended to operate very-nearly-like a standard 737, so it's not inconceivable that pilots wouldn't have time or intuitively know how to handle this situation. Ultimately any vehicle/software/tool is going to be safest when the responsible designer makes it intuitive and reduces the possibility of failure cases rather than adding workarounds or runbooks to patch over them and/or disclaim the liability. Anyway, it seems like it could be early to strongly assign blame or critique until we know how serious the issue is.
- Svip 8y agoOver 300 people dead sounds pretty serious to me. It's probably safest to ground the plane model until we know more.
- jka 8y agoI should have been clearer here; I was responding to the parent post's assignation of blame towards the airline/air authority. Generally do agree with grounding the Max 8 fleet as a precaution, and also given the poor engineering smell around the MCAS. But not keen to assign blame/failure and damage reputations until there are credible investigation results, or without providing references.
- bryondowd 8y agoI've seen a number of people pointing at this likely being more an issue with untrained pilots than the plane itself. EI, the flight crew on the crashed planes may have had considerably less experience than the minimum requirements most major airlines and all US airlines set for flying these planes.
- AsyncAwait 8y agoThis seems like corporate PR blaming "3rd world pilots" and am not sure it's such a smart move. If your plane requires substantially different handling & the interface does not accommodate it, it seems to me the problem is not the pilot. It seems more likely that the plane suffers from some elemental design problems that were insufficiently patched over to pass inspection in order to protect the already invested capital.
- dis-sys 8y agoHuge number of third world pilots are flying other models of Boeing 737, they obviously didn't crash that often. They are just blaming the victims, trying to let those already killed pilots to take responibility for their faulty designs.
- 8y ago
- qw 8y agoNorway also closed the airspace 40min ago
- paganel 8y agoIt looks like Norwegian is already asking its 737 Max flights to return to their departing airports, at least according to this recent screenshot I found on reddit [1] [1] https://i.redd.it/6gtecemacpl21.png https://i.redd.it/6gtecemacpl21.png
- gizmo385 8y agoYikes. How would ya like to be a passenger on one of those planes: "We're returning to our departure airport because this airplane has been grounded."
- jsty 8y agoAlthough if you'd realised it was a 737 MAX, you might already be clutching a medicinal gin & tonic ...
- tivert 8y ago> Although if you'd realised it was a 737 MAX, you might already be clutching a medicinal gin & tonic ... I wouldn't, haven't all the problems so far have been during takeoff? So once you're cruising you're safe from them?
- tapland 8y ago12 and 6 minutes after take-off.
- dreamcompiler 8y agoThe MCAS problem cannot occur when flaps are deployed, and it happens when flaps are initially retracted. So if it hasn't happened by now, it's not going to.
- JshWright 8y agoIt could also happen while resetting after a late missed approach.
- ElBarto 8y agoA potentially interesting tidbit from Norwegian's Wikipedia page: > Diversion to Shiraz, Iran December 2018 > A Norwegian Boeing 737 MAX suffered an unspecified technical failure over Iran in December 2018. The pilot made a precautionary landing at Shiraz Shahid Dastgheib International Airport without incident. Spare parts required to make the aircraft airworthy were not available in the world outside the United States, which has prohibited exports of technology to Iran. Two months later, the almost-brand-new aircraft remained stranded in Shiraz and subject to seizure by the Iranian government.[86] > On 22 February 2019 the plane was ferrried from Shiraz to Stockholm as DY8921
- bfirsh 8y agoA good podcast episode about that: https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2019/02/06/692155923/episode-892-the-lost-plane https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2019/02/06/692155923/epis...
- benj111 8y agoThat seems like a disincentive to buy American aircraft. If you're a reasonably sized international airline, it seems like a reasonable possibility that you'd have to (or want to) land in a territory that the US in unfavourable toward. Why take the risk?
- bengotow 8y agoThis is somewhat true, but to be fair there are only a few countries the US and it’s allies don’t do business with - as long as you don’t land in Iran or North Korea you’d be in pretty good shape.
- lostlogin 8y agoNot so sure about that. The US Government lists 13 places as “Do not travel” and 15 as “reconsider travel”. Looking at the list, it doesn’t seem unreasonable advice. https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/traveladvisories/traveladvisories.html/ https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/traveladvisories/...
- m2ndpixel 8y agoBanned in the entire EU now: https://www.easa.europa.eu/newsroom-and-events/news/easa-suspends-all-boeing-737-max-operations-europe https://www.easa.europa.eu/newsroom-and-events/news/easa-sus...
- snazz 8y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19370835 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19370835