7 ms·
This is great work. It's a real job gathering and analysing all that CEO performance data. My guess is that most people were suspecting this anyway. The fact i
by lordnacho 8y ago
This is great work. It's a real job gathering and analysing all that CEO performance data.
My guess is that most people were suspecting this anyway. The fact is the CEO is there for a few years making a few key decisions, a large company is like an oil tanker, and markets are quite hard to predict.
Taleb has cooked a fair bit of soup on the fooled by randomness idea, but in this case his observations are correct. It is very very hard to show that CEO performance is something other than random.
That's not to say that everyone's performance is pure chance. Sports generates a lot of reproducible data about its performers, and we can tell from the numbers which players are better.
This is why it's not such a big deal for most people that Ronaldo or Messi get paid a lot more than their teammates, and the rest of society.
What does bother people, including myself, is that people are given far more credit for outcomes than is credible. Why should there be a many-multiples reward for being slightly up the senior management ladder at each step? Is it not most plausible that the leaders just under CEO also understand the firm's situation, and can make sensible decisions? And the step under them? Is it really so hard to find a CEO that you have to pay hundreds of grunt salaries to get one?
The other issue is MBAs. I don't think anyone is surprised that it doesn't help at all. I went to a well known business school too, and it's not like they tell you how to run a company. It's really just a kind of brainstorming exercise where you have bit of a think about what a company might do to be successful. What it does seem to be is a kind of stamp of ambition. People who go to business schools are keen to work hard to reach the top of the business world.
This might seem fine, but you have to wonder whether the best managers are ambitious people who want to be managers, or people in the line of business who want to compete for the same jobs.
I know who I'd pick.
- pacala 8y agoTo play devil's advocate: The primary function of a manager is to say "No". As one goes higher and higher up the hierarchy, one has to say "No" to pushier and pushier subordinates, and the cost of every misplaced "Yes" is higher and higher. While leaders just under the CEO may understand the firm situation just fine, they may also be unable to say "No" to enough bad ideas for a myriad reasons, including lack of political clout with other leaders, with investors or with peer CEOs.
- lordnacho 8y ago> The primary function of a manager is to say "No". I'm a manager, and I can't really see this being the key job description. But if it was, why would that have gotten harder in the last few decades?
- UncleMeat 8y agoLots of people come to my team asking for work on X. If I said yes to everything my team would collapse from being spread too thinly. Being able to say that X is lower priority than what I am currently working on and leave the door open for re-evaluating priorities if needed is a key part of my job. My team also frequently comes to me with ideas for interesting work that also isn't contributing to our vision. If we just did everything that came to mind we'd also fall apart.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Gibbon1 8y agoMy experience after 35 years is nothing scares me more than when a team of out of control developers are adding more and more features to the spec. Most baffling is it's obvious they think they are accomplishing something and you're a meanie for trying to rein them in. It always ends the same way. A lot of things can go wrong in a project. But that's that one 100% guaranteed to sink it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- com2kid 8y agoOn the flip side, a team of developers who aren't even interested in adding anything of their own volition is also a bad sign. There has to be a balance.
- 8y ago
- marktangotango 8y agoWell, poor outcomes can certainly be attributed to poor direction from a CEO. Many of us have experienced that. My example is a new ceo who came in making a lot of noise about cleaning house and righting the ship. His intention was the sales org, but effectively scared off the best developers. He did also gut the sales org, and sales never recovered. So objectively it’s not out of the question the reverse could be true, that a ceo could influence a positive outcome, maybe just harder to measure?
- lordnacho 8y agoBut this doesn't test what another CEO would have done in the same situation. All we can do is make a guess about how the average CEO would have performed. There's no way to really test it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- twic 8y ago> What it does seem to be is a kind of stamp of ambition. People who go to business schools are keen to work hard to reach the top of the business world. Same as most degree credentialism. People don't hire Harvard graduates because of all the valuable stuff they learned at Harvard, they hire them because they were smart and driven enough to get in to Harvard.
- hexane360 8y agoOr they hire them because they went to Harvard as well.
- di3sd 8y agoWe don't need Presidents and Popes either. The world is a much more complicated place today, than during the time of kings, and the accumulating data is going to keep revealing the complexity is too much for one man or woman to be responsible for it all. But when a Deepwater Horizon type event happens and the whole herd starts baying for blood, are we sophisticated enough to say hey look at the data whats the point of lynching one person? Of late the US seems to have attained that level of maturity, given how they have dealt up with Wall St after 2008, or the Pentagon for the 20 year war or dear Mark Zuckerberg. So maybe it's time. I don't see older firms changing but newer firms might turn less hierarchical.
- tsunamifury 8y agoIt's an interesting thought. Object oriented responsibility is as archiac as object oriented data analysis because since the rise of ML we know that the larger objects were just mental models for human decision making. However they erred by covering through averaging of more granular inputs that had conflicting information. I.e. if I'm a CEO and 3 of my VPs are good but one is terrible is it my fault that only one has become a risk. Under current object oriented thinking, yes but with granular analysis no it's the VPs fault.
- maxxxxx 8y ago:Of late the US seems to have attained that level of maturity, given how they have dealt up with Wall St after 2008, or the Pentagon for the 20 year war or dear Mark Zuckerberg. So maybe it's time." I don't think 2008 was a sign of maturity when the people who caused and benefitted from the meltdown got bailed out and could keep their money. Maturity would have been that the people who ran the banks before the crash would have lost all their money since it turned out that their contribution was overall negative. We have reached a point where the people who make the most money can hide behind big faceless corporations. They reap most of the profits while the losses go to the rest.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoNeither the President nor the Pope have a considerable amount of power. The office of the pres. was specifically designed to 'not be a king' and he's highly constrained by the other wings of government. The US was supposed to mostly about the states. The Catholic Church generally gives a very wide berth as to the operational artifacts of Parishes. He's also to some extent a figurehead. CEO means such different things at different scale, at different organizations, it's really hard to compare. I suggest the issues may have a lot to do with short-term vs. long-term incentives. Also - 'average' pay isn't so helpful when there are a few with massive, massive pay packages that skew all of the data.
- mbesto 8y ago> I don't think anyone is surprised that it doesn't help at all. I know you're purposely being sensationalist, but there is pretty incredible value in the networking by doing an MBA...which IMHO is actually what makes good CEOs - having strong networks of people around you.
- alexpetralia 8y agoRight, clearly this makes strongly networked CEO, but not a "good" CEO in terms of subsequent period share returns, as the research demonstrates.
- 75dvtwin 8y agoWhat most long-term investors would prefer is a cult of a 'process', rather than a cult of 'personality'. A process' is a combination of know-how + culture + rules + compliance. Every business goes through cycles (eg startup, growth, pivot, then repeat) At every cycle, different personal qualities of a CEO would be more beneficial. However, a property of a company with a cult of 'process', is that the process will organically select and retain a right CEO at a right cycle. So two outcomes of the above position: a) recognizing a company with a good process, is a very important and powerful skill to have (likely Warren Buffet has it). b) averaging CEO performance without recognizing what cycle the company is at, compared to CEOs skills, is not by itself a measure of CEO performance. It is more of a proxy measure to whether the company has a sustainable and investment-ready process or not. -- By the way, with regards to > This is why it's not such a big deal for most people that Ronaldo or Messi get paid a lot more than their teammates, and the rest of society. I would challenge that, and say that it is quite abnormal, historically, for entertainers to get paid this much. The development of multiplicative technologies (radio, TV, internet), and lack of wars between the 'super-nations' -- is really what made entertainers into exceptionally wealthy profession. So, yes it reasonable to assume better performing sportman will get paid more than their team mates. But it is not reasonable that they get paid this much... that bothers me.
- gotocake 8y agoAthletes and entertainers being paid insane amounts isn’t as new as you might think, although fashions do wax and wane. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaius_Appuleius_Diocles https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaius_Appuleius_Diocles Gaius Appuleius Diocles was born in approximately 104 A.D in Lamecum... Diocles is believed to have started racing at the age of 18 in Ilerda... Records show that he won 1,462 out of the 4,257 four-horse races he competed in and was placed in an additional 1,438 races (mostly finishing in second place). The ‘champion of charioteers’ is one of the best-documented ancient athletes, most likely because he was such a star at the famous Roman Circus Maximus. [1] Being the best in the field also seems to have allowed Diocles to perfect his showmanship. Many of his victories took the form of a ‘come from behind’ crossing of the finish line at the last possible moment. The crowds loved it. Any race with Diocles quickly became the ‘featured event’ of the day. This naturally helped Diocles make even more money. His winnings reportedly totaled 35,863,120 sesterces, equivalent to 358,631.20 gold aureus or 2,600 kg of gold, allegedly, over $15 billion in today’s dollars, an amount which could provide a year's supply of grain to the entire city of Rome, or pay the Roman army at its height for a fifth of a year. Classics professor Peter Struck describes him as "the best paid athlete of all time".
- skookumchuck 8y agoThe CEO's decisions matter. For the most obvious example, see Apple. A series of CEOs drove Apple to near bankruptcy, then Jobs became CEO. With the same employees, plant, equipment, culture, etc., he turned it into the largest company in the world. He did something similar to Pixar. Microsoft is another example. Same company, same staff, same products, 3 CEOs, stark difference in results.
- kochikame 8y agoYour examples show that CEOs "can" matter, but not that they "do" matter. I think anyone would agree that there are plenty of CEOs who happened to get their jobs just as pipelines come through, the economy rebalances in their favor, long-term HRD plans come to fruition etc. but they get all the credit anyway
- skookumchuck 8y agoThe man in charge always gets the credit. I have some AMZN stock. I wouldn't trade Bezos for someone cheaper. Would you?
- ALittleLight 8y agoTo my knowledge Bezos gets paid only 80 grand a year - so no.
- skookumchuck 8y agoThat's salary, not compensation.
- Pharmakon 8y agoIt’s pretty much both. https://www.marketwatch.com/story/the-typical-amazon-worker-made-less-than-30000-in-2017-2018-04-18 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/the-typical-amazon-worker-... Companies this year are reporting their CEO pay in relation to the compensation of a median worker for the first time as a result of a 2015 rule mandated by the Dodd-Frank act. Amazon Chief Executive Jeff Bezos recorded total compensation of $1,681,840 in 2017, almost all of which is money paid for personal security — Bezos drew a salary of $81,840 and received no additional stock. Bezos’s compensation is 59 times the median Amazon worker’s. He doesn’t need to draw a fat salary or get more stock, he already owns more than $110,000,000,000 in stock.
- megablast 8y ago> This is why it's not such a big deal for most people that Ronaldo or Messi get paid a lot more than their teammates, and the rest of society. This is not why, and has nothing to do with it. Players get huge wages, because they are the best on their teams, and the sports generate a lot of money. If it wasn't going to the players, it would go to the owners.
- salty_biscuits 8y ago"Why should there be a many-multiples reward for being slightly up the senior management ladder at each step?" Really suggests some sort of a ponzi scheme...