20 ms·
Accepting Bitcoin as a Small Business – 4 Years In, No Customers
- Cypher 8y agoWell bitcoin is better for store of value, just use a CC for spending - more protection.
- godzillabrennus 8y agoHas your local currency been so awful at storing value that it lost more than 75% of its value in a little over a year? In Venezuela you’re probably better offer with Bitcoin. If you live in a developed free market economy then probably not.
- nybble41 8y agoBitcoin did not lose "more than 75% of its value in a little over a year". You're conveniently picking the peak price during a short-lived bubble as the baseline for your comparison, as if $20k were the normal price. No one with any sense purchased significant amounts of Bitcoin at that price. (Obviously quite a few people did buy at that price—but that's not the point. Buying after a sharp rise in the price is a losing strategy for almost any investment.) I could just as easily draw your attention to the fact that even now Bitcoin has nearly tripled in value (+190%) over the last two years. Right before the run up to $20k Bitcoin was around $6k; now it's at $3700. That's only a loss of 40%, not 75%, if you bought at the pre-bubble price. And it reached $3700 for the first time only about a year and a half ago, in July of 2017. It's hardly the only investment to show no net gain (or loss) over that time period.
- theandrewbailey 8y agoBitcoin is terrible for storing value.
- jondubois 8y agoIt's been a great store of value over the past 6 years. It has outperformed every major index and currency. If you had invested just $10K in Bitcoin in May 2013, by July 2013 you would have lost almost half of your money... But if you were smart and had held on to it, today you would have over $350K! As Warren Buffet would say, you just have to buy when everyone else is selling and sell when everyone else is buying. You have to keep your eye on intrinsic value... and the other eye on the Lambo. Easy peasy.
- theandrewbailey 8y agoStores of value aren't investments.
- this_user 8y ago> It's been a great store of value over the past 6 years. I don't think you understand what "store of value" means. Store of value means little to no volatility. Meanwhile, Bitcoin is one of the most volatile assets in existence. And a real store of value is a store of value permanently not just over a certain period of time.
- tim333 8y agoWhat Warren Buffett actually said "In terms of cryptocurrencies, generally, I can say with almost certainty that they will come to a bad ending."
- isostatic 8y ago> You have to keep your eye on intrinsic value $0
- onomics 8y agoWhy would you 'store value' in something that's so new and volatile? If you want something impractical that serves to store value, buy Gold.
- acdha 8y agoThe only value Bitcoin has is group consensus. If nobody has a need to use it, the values of otherwise-meaningless numbers will trend to zero.
- dnautics 8y agoLiterally true for every currency at some level. I suppose you could use a greenback as very poor toilet paper.
- acdha 8y agoThe part you're leaving out is that most currencies are backed by governments with significant economies and that backing creates a substantial market because you use those currencies to pay your taxes and government workers and contracts are paid using that currency. In contrast, a pure fiat currency like Bitcoin has no inherent value and no built-in demand. If something else becomes popular, there's zero anchor for anyone who doesn't have a substantial holding and the pitch of “you should use this so I get rich” is not generally compelling.
- dnautics 8y agoWhy I said "at some level": what are governments backed by?
- jondubois 8y ago'Need' is a relative term. If you ask me what I need, I'll say I need a house to live in, air to breathe, water to drink and food to eat. If you ask Mark Zuckerberg what he needs, he'll say "All that can be counted". Mark Zuckerberg has much more money than you or me. So when it comes to valuing things on the open market, his opinion of what 'Need' means matters a lot more.
- acdha 8y agoThat doesn't really relate to anything I wrote. My question was that if Bitcoin collapsed tomorrow, who'd notice other than the get-rich-quick crowd? Statistically nobody uses it for daily transactions and almost everyone has other options which are some combination of cheaper, faster, safer, and easier to use. There just isn't a long-term anchor pushing people to use that particular system, certainly not at the level needed to sustain the high infrastructure costs.
- jessaustin 8y agoobvious sarcasm, people.
- lenticular 8y agoThat's the latest line since transaction costs of bitcoin have become out of this world. But it's more volatile than any non tin-pot dictatorship currency. It's vulnerable to hacking, hardware failure, or fraud by exchanges. I swear every 2 weeks a hear about another $100 million vanishing. How is this not just an utterly useless technology for anything except illegal transactions?
- nybble41 8y ago> That's the latest line since transaction costs of bitcoin have become out of this world. You should update your FUD. The average cost to have your transaction accepted in the next block is currently about 31 cents. If 1-2 hours is acceptable (6 blocks) then you can reduce that to less than a quarter. There was a period when the transaction fees were much higher (because the network was undergoing DOS attacks) but that passed some time ago. Bitcoin is vulnerable to hacking, hardware failure, or fraud by exchanges in much the same way the USD or EUR or any other currency is vulnerable to theft, physical destruction, or fraud by exchanges (or banks)—except that Bitcoin offers ways to protect yourself against theft or hardware failure which are not available for physical currencies, and there is no particular reason to maintain a balance at an exchange. People have no problem accepting that it's unsafe to carry around large amounts of physical currency but won't take simple measures like using a hardware wallet with a PIN to store their private keys. Don't blame the Bitcoin protocol for people failing to take obvious and recommended security precautions. I'll grant that it's more volatile than most other currencies, but that's hardly unexpected for something new and experimental. It's less volatile now than it used to be, though, and that trend is likely to continue.
- api 8y agoIt's a terrible store of value. It requires a constant massive electricity expenditure to keep it up. Gold, property, etc. do not and are much better if you just want to park money in something other than a financial instrument.
- cwyers 8y agoThe original Bitcoin paper is all about payments: https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf If Bitcoin isn't any good for that, it's kind of a failure.
- spectramax 8y agoBitcoin has the same sort of issues that plague Linux Desktop and why Linux never took off as the defacto standard for PC OS. It’s the lack of user focus. Setting up a bitcoin account, understanding the security implications, hardware wallet, secret keys, the whole enchilada is too big for an average consumer to digest. Somewhere in Jobs’ biography by Walter Isaacson, there is a snippet about how products often fail when they’re designed by geeks, engineers and technology people - they make products to sell to customers that are like themselves. I’m an engineer myself and I also think the contrary is also true - products and services developed by “MBA” kinds often fail because the people in charge of the company roadmap have no fucking clue about the technical details and trade-offs of the product. Bitcoin transaction process is designed for the most part for the nerds, not for the average Joe. I know there exists Coinbase and other “easy” setups for Bitcoin. But I’m talking about what happens when an average joe Googles “How to setup a bitcoin account”. Instant “nope” - I don’t have time for this shit and my personal money is at stake if I mess this up.
- joshstrange 8y agoThis is a really good comparison that I had never thought of. You are 100% right, the user experience for BTC is terrible and not likely to get a whole lot better. Even coinbase can be a PITA sometimes, it's really the Ubuntu of the crypto-currency world IMHO. Also quick question: When was the last time you thought about the swipe-fees for your CC? I'll answer for you: Never. Yet with BTC and other crypto's this is a concern. And please, don't even talk about "Oh it's gotten better with the lightning network" or "The new QRS spec will speed this up", it's really just embarrassing.
- ecwilson 8y agoDepends on the industry. For very large transactions, like if you are paying a home improvement contractor for something, they will often make you eat the fees if you want to pay with a credit card. So you end up having to figure out where your checkbook is (probably collecting dust in a box somewhere). I give Bitcoin and LN a continuous pass on UX for now. We're in the infrastructure phase -- growing trust and improving reliability matters far more than UX. Before you know it, there will be 20 years of development and battle-testing behind the tech. The UX can come at any point in the future, while a breach of trust would be fatal. It's a question of ruthless prioritization. Thankfully, the open source devs behind these projects are long-term thinkers, not ponzi-scheme enablers. Lastly, the UX need not come from Bitcoin/LN. They are a protocol, not a product.
- joshstrange 8y agoIt's about time we admit the emperor has no clothes. BTC/ETH/XYY/123 can store value (I don't care to get into the fluctuations right now) and moving it around can be a lot easier than outdated systems like ACH but they are terrible for paying for things. Maybe something like the lightning network or similar will be able to solve part of that but accepting BTC has always been more of a fad/PR-move than an actual business decision. Unless you are running in the gray/dark web (Silk Road-type, Torrent/nzb trackers, seedboxes, etc) your customers are not going to jump through the hoops required to spend BTC.
- eropple 8y ago> moving it around can be a lot easier than outdated systems like ACH To be specific: a lot easier than outdated systems in the United States. If you do any work outside the United States, this is much less of a thing.
- legionof7 8y agoGray/dark web stuff is different in America/most European countries than in other parts of the world though. Just because something is perfectly legal here, doesn't mean that it's the same elsewhere.
- tim333 8y ago>Maybe something like the lightning network or similar will be able to solve part The article mentions they also take Dash which transacts pretty much instantly for less than 1c but still hasn't taken off apart from maybe a few outlets in Venezuela.
- Ruphin 8y agoUsers that already have a Bitcoin wallet don't have to jump through any hoops to spend BTC. It's just as easy as any kind of digital money transfer. Obviously using BTC to pay for anything is a huge hassle if you don't already have a wallet with some BTC in it. But that's like saying Apple Pay is inconvenient because your customers have to go to and buy an iPhone first.
- 8y ago
- jelling 8y agoOf possible interest, Moon, a company in our our accelerator cohort, lets people pay with crypto on any website that accepts credit cards: https://paywithmoon.com/ https://paywithmoon.com/
- jstanley 8y agoWhy does it require a Coinbase account?
- oarsinsync 8y agoMost likely because intra-coinbase payments are instant, as they don't occur on the blockchain, but in the coinbase local database only
- pjc50 8y agoAre you saying that the most convenient and cheap way to handle a trustless distributed blockchain currency is .. within a single database? /s
- Drdrdrq 8y agoIiuc the requirement holds only for the merchant and is similar to requirements of many credit card payment processors about holding a bank account with their chosen bank. The reason is probably the same (transaction costs).
- jstanley 8y agoOh! So it doesn't let people pay with Bitcoin on any website that accepts credit cards. It lets any website that accepts credit cards also accept payment in Bitcoin. There is a big difference.
- this_user 8y agoAnd why would you choose a slower, more expensive, more cumbersome and less secure method of payment when you can just use a credit card?
- mateuszf 8y agoThere is still a pretty good chance that with Lightning it will change, because of minimal transaction costs, speed and scalability.
- futureastronaut 8y agoI've been hearing about Lightning for a couple years now, is this the new Duke Nukem 3d/Perl 6 or what?
- hrdwdmrbl 8y agoNo, Lightning has been released. It works. There are multiple implementations. It isn't perfect. Version 1.1 should fix a lot of the shortcomings.
- Nursie 8y agoIt has routing problems that are unsolvable.
- kbody 8y agoUnsolvable like internet/BGP routing? I guess internet doesn't work either. Tech evolves, most teams working on LN are working on getting the basic cases to a rock-solid state before doing more R&D on different routing strategies although there are already proposed alternatives on the mailing list. Layered-strategies are the way to go.
- thefounder 8y agoBitcoin is the most expensive method of payment when you factor the difference between exchangers and merchant gateways(i.e try using bitpay). It is more expensive than gift cards. Not to mention that the volatitlity puts the clients in a pretty bad situation.
- stevenjohns 8y agoThe only time I ever paid with bitcoin was for likely-illegal pharmaceuticals. And that’s only because that’s all the online pharmacy accepted. I can’t imagine it’s much useful as a payment system for much other than that.
- DiseasedBadger 8y agoI personally never got into, because it's not private. No regular person can verify their transactions without joining a public vehicle that requires a credit card. Even bitcoin atms require a photograph of your face. Mining is a huge loss of value. Bitcoin itself was simply never a good idea for most people.
- hrdwdmrbl 8y agoYou can verify your transactions on many websites like https://blockchain.info/ https://blockchain.info/ ... You can buy semi-anonymously in-person using something like localbitcoins.com
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- throwaway77384 8y agoBisq sort of solves that problem.
- hanniabu 8y agoBisq uses centralized intermediaries
- hrdwdmrbl 8y agoI also run a small clothing business. We have received about bitcoin 6 sales over 5 years. Only 1 was offline though. Bitcoin is too valuable to spent. Hopefully something like Grin or Dai will make more sense for spending day-to-day.
- andirk 8y agoHow many sales were purchased through gold bars? Probably only like 1 or 2 per year.
- mattferderer 8y agoI find accepting it & having to pay US taxes to be a pain unless I convert it into USD immediately. Otherwise I have to use special software to figure out the USD price at the time of receipt & then the USD price at the time of conversion into anything else. I would imagine for large businesses this probably isn't to big of a concern. I also wonder if they could get away with making significant amounts of money by picking the price highs & lows of the day of receipt and day of conversion to USD when reporting taxes. On the consumer side, I can't imagine keeping track of BTC prices to pay for stuff if I used it as an every day form of currency. I would need special software to help me file taxes. It would need to keep track of every purchase of BTC and then the price of BTC/USD whenever I purchased something. To me this is a huge issue & would create a giant spreadsheet to turn in with my taxes. On the bright side, if more people did this maybe we would have different tax laws regarding cryptocurrencies in the US.
- oarsinsync 8y ago> I would imagine for large businesses this probably isn't to big of a concern. I also wonder if they could get away with making significant amounts of money by picking the price highs & lows of the day of receipt and day of conversion to USD when reporting taxes. Nope. The daily spot price is determined and that's the value you need to use in your accounting with currency conversion for tax purposes. It's set by taking the value at a particular time of the day, and that's the value set for the day. That also happens to be the busiest time of day in the Fx markets, unsurprisingly, as minor fluctuations in the price can have massive positive (or negative) impacts on banks businesses.
- mattferderer 8y agoGood to know. I was under the assumption you were to use the price at the time of the transaction. The daily spot price seems like a huge risk for businesses.
- tim333 8y agoI'm more up on the UK system than the US but how it kind of works here is technically the liability is the price at the time of the transaction but they don't mind you estimating or using approximate prices if it doesn't have a large effect on the tax liability.
- EvagohP5 8y agoof course who use those memecoins anyway
- ausbah 8y agountil cryptocurrencies are able to be as accessible, easy to use, and fast as everyday debit or credit cards, i fail to see any significant future for their usage beyond people well versed in tech
- ecwilson 8y agoThey never will be. I think people misunderstand cryptocurrencies because of the mania that surrounds them. Bitcoin, for example, is a protocol, and should be judged as such. The most important thing for the protocol is trust, reliability, and scalability. Not UX and convenience. That could/should come from the layers/products that get built on top of the protocol.
- criddell 8y agoSatoshi Nakamoto did say this: > The existing Visa credit card network processes about 15 million Internet purchases per day worldwide. Bitcoin can already scale much larger than that with existing hardware for a fraction of the cost. He clearly expected Bitcoin to cheaper and faster than credit cards and I've often wondered how he could have been so wrong about that.
- magnamerc 8y agoThat's likely because he expected the block size to increase in addition to second layer scaling solutions.
- Nursie 8y agoAnd Bruce Schneier says the trust thing is a bust - it moves trust, rather than eliminating it. Usually to parties that I have far fewer reasons to trust.
- larry_mulgrave 8y agoBecause Bitcoin is optimized for speculative investment, not as an actual currency.
- jrumbut 8y agoRegardless of what it was, it is really cool to see someone do a follow up on their experience being an early adopter of a technology in their business. You see so many "why we're choosing this" and not so many "how it went a few years down the line" posts.
- ykevinator 8y agoAgreed. I love retros too. Amazing that some people in this thread don't want to hear it.
- tamaharbor 8y agoSolar panels and electric cars are not as prevalent as the media would have us believe either.
- endless1234 8y agoDid you comment to the right article?
- krzkaczor 8y agoITT: Bitcoin as a store of value not a medium of exchange. They should look into decentralized stablecoins like DAI (1 DAI = 1$). Particularly xDAI and BurnerWallet https://medium.com/gitcoin/burner-wallet-at-ethdenver-was-faa3851ea833 https://medium.com/gitcoin/burner-wallet-at-ethdenver-was-fa... are interesting.
- miguelrochefort 8y agoI've been given some xDAI at an event, and spent hours trying to get them out of the burner wallet, to no avail. This left a very bad impression to many people there. They're still stuck there.
- magnamerc 8y agoxDAI is no more than a few months old, and DAI itself is a little over a year old. Give it some time... Come back in a decade or two if you're looking for super smooth user experiences.
- Kaotique 8y agoBitcoin is more like gold or diamonds. Expensive to mine. Interesting as an investment and to store wealth outside normal currencies. But nobody pays in the store with diamonds or gold. It's not practical.
- vortico 8y agoGreat analogy, I'll remember that one. BTC is only really useful to me when other payment methods surpass ~$100 of effort. For example, when paying contractors tens of thousands of $ internationally, it's impossible to avoid $50-300 fees from bank wires, TransferWise, or Xoom. So if both parties are fine with sitting down and figuring out how to send/receive BTC on their computer, only then it is worth my time.
- pjc50 8y agoI'm reminded of the guy who lost $400k by trying to do an international transfer of his own money through Quadriga at the point they collapsed.
- sparkie 8y agoIf only he was using a trustless cryptocurrency rather than a "trusted" custodial entity, he would never have had that problem.
- tim333 8y agoMy friend lost trustless cryptocurrency that would be worth well over $400k today by forgetting about it and formatting his hard drive.
- sparkie 8y agoHe clearly didn't value it highly enough at the time. You're implying that if he didn't accidentally lose his private keys, he would've had the nerve to hodl it till now and wouldn't have cashed out when it was valued less on the USD markets. Some banks will shut your account after a long enough period of activity. There are statutes of limitations which may prevent you from claiming any assets you had lodged in the bank if you suddenly remembered you had the bank account N years later. There are pros and cons to both Bitcoin and the traditional banking system. With Bitcoin, you can at least chose for yourself, whereas the decisions are made for you when you use custodians.
- kbody 8y ago> Otherwise please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait; don't editorialize. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Actual title is "Accepting Bitcoin as a Small Business – 4 Years In"
- gvb 8y agoSince that day over four years ago and the time of writing, we have not had one customer ask to pay in Bitcoin, Dash or any other cryptocurrency. I viewed it as a useful summary of the article, quoting from the article, not editorializing.
- amenod 8y ago> Should my small business accept Bitcoin? > We think accepting Bitcoin is a positive move for your small business. While you may not get anyone paying in it now, it does come with other added benefits The change of title clearly misrepresents author's message by picking a single fact without context. It doesn't matter if you agree with the author, the message conveyed in modified title is very different from what the article talks about. Don't like the message? Write your own blog post. But don't misrepresent others' intentions.
- appsonify 8y agoThe actual title is link bait. On HN, people don't want to have to read through the whole article to reach a conclusion. In this case, it's perfectly valid to include the main point of the article - Bitcoin failed. Do I sense another ulterior motive for you to force the title to change? I've definitely seen this behavior on Reddit.
- kbody 8y agoIt misrepresents the point of the actual author, the author focuses on everything other than the lack of transactions with crypto. The focus on the number was given by the submitter. If the case is valid for the rule, motives or biases like mine, yours or anyone's are irrelevant.
- moonbug 8y agoBitcoin needs to die in a fire.
- dr_win 8y agoIMO, UX is a minor issue. Why would anyone spend hard money before fiat money? (Gresham's law) Also each spending could trigger a separate taxable event (depending on your jurisdiction) and that would be a serious accounting nightmare if done willy-nilly for casual payments. Bitcoin is a store of value and a payment rail for significant sums. Currently it is not suitable for casual/small retail payments. In near/mid-term future I expect new banking services to allow people to stay in bitcoin for "savings accounts" and offering traditional fiat credit in "current account" for daily spending (backed by bitcoin in savings account as a collateral). Settlement and transfers between savings and current account to be less frequent and easily trackable for tax purposes. This would allow a person to completely stay out of fiat while still having access to fiat payment infrastructure - this would cost some interest on borrowed fiat which I expect to go pretty low thanks to collateral (bitcoin) liquidity. See companies like BlockFi which are getting close to this model.
- zcopley 8y agoI think Gresham's Law explains it. I could pay a locksmith in bitcoin, but I would rather keep my bitcoin and pay with USD. Bitcoin is harder to get and can be used for purposes that USD cannot (e.g.: donating to financially censored people and organizations).
- turkeytotal 8y agoThis should come as no surprise, but not for the reasons the author thinks. >I could list 50 different reasons why but for us it boils down to two main facts. A very small percentage of our customers posses Bitcoin in a hot wallet ready to transfer and secondly, Bitcoin can be slow and expensive for small payments. The main reason is that no one needs to use Bitcoin to pay for their locksmithing. Bitcoin is not your neighborhood Visa competitor. Bitcoin is your last resort payment method/store of value--for when you don't have access to traditional financial infrastructure (for whatever reason). This article is a signal only that people are not ideologically using Bitcoin as a payment (which is a good thing, I don't care to store payments on my node that would be better served by Visa).
- amanaplanacanal 8y ago> Bitcoin is your last resort payment method/store of value This is what people have traditionally held gold for. It feels to me like there are very few use cases that aren't already served by physical gold.
- turkeytotal 8y agoYou can't use gold online in an trust-minimized way. One counterexample are industries with high chargeback/fraud rates. Bitcoin is perfect for merchants exposed to friendly fraud, it completely removes the leverage customers have over them.
- leereeves 8y agoBut accepting only Bitcoin is hardly an option even for those merchants.
- argo_ 8y agoBitcoin on-chain transactions are almost on its historical peak again: https://www.blockchain.com/charts/n-transactions?timespan=all https://www.blockchain.com/charts/n-transactions?timespan=al... This forum has been denying bitcoin since the first time someone posted about it: first time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=463793 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=463793 second time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=599852 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=599852
- wcoenen 8y agoI'm not sure on-chain transaction rate approaching new highs is cause for celebration. Last time the rate of new transactions exceeded bitcoin's capacity, confirmation times became erratic and fees unpredictable. Why do you think this won't happen again?
- argo_ 8y agoThe bitcoin software is not the same as before, updates have happened in the meantime. Now, 40% of all transactions happening are SegWit transactions, a lighter format which enables the network to handle a higher volume of transactions simultaneously. SegWit transactions are also cheaper in terms of fees. So, the number of transactions can exceed the previous high without colapsing the confirmation time or fees.
- dmitriid 8y agoLess than 10 transactions per second while spending more electricity than several medium-sized countries. Yup. Technology of the future that we are fools to dismiss.
- andirk 8y agoIs there hard evidence that shows the energy consumption of bitcoin? How is that calculated? I do believe it's "a lot" when I see those giant farms churning. And how do we compare it to fiat where the security is via vaults and sharks with lasers and other types of security?
- IAmEveryone 8y agoWe got a regular trickle of three to ten orders per month for about three years, until the rally to 5-digits broke the system because transaction costs started to surpass our order values. ...which was excellent, because we had forgotten the entire system even existed. We had accrued a few hundred orders in the $80 range, many paid at exchange rates < $100.
- boznz 8y agoThe only advantage and attraction of bitcoin to date to the lay person has been capital gains, not so much lately but at least its semi-stabilised to most holders relief. I suspect that was the secret attraction of most businesses who set up to accept it. However in real life it is too awkward for the average joe or joan and if you want to "go dark" cash or gold much easier to use and understand. Cryptocurrencies day will come but not until it is as easy to use as a credit card or cash
- mnort9 8y agoA shift in consumer habits require orders of magnitude in improvement over previous solutions to achieve mass adoption and become the new true "normal". The reality is bitcoin and crypto are not much of an improvement (if any) for the avg consumer compared to cash/debit/credit card.
- Ruphin 8y agoMany posts here about how Bitcoin is not user friendly, and how it can't compete with existing (digital) payment solutions in terms of UX. My experience with it is quite the opposite, and I prefer paying with Bitcoin/cryptocurrencies in most (but not all) situations. My phone has a wallet app with some small amount of Bitcoin on it. If I have to pay for something, all it takes is opening the app, scanning a QR code, and clicking ok. For paying beers at a bar (which I have done) the setup is slightly less convenient than NFC touch-to-pay solutions but not significantly worse. But for things like purchasing digital goods or other items online, the process is sometimes significantly better than alternatives. If I purchase something from an online vendor it's the same process; QR code shows up, I scan it with my app, and press ok. For this scenario it is almost always more convenient than having to enter some payment information, or logging in to some payment processor like PayPal or whatever solution my bank has implemented. The downsides are that my phone effectively has a bundle of cash strapped to it, and when I lose the phone my cash is gone too. Getting the money onto my phone is also not the most convenient process as I need some external service like an exchange to acquire the coins first. Not all the problems have been solved, but things are slowly getting better. Just like Linux on the Desktop, people will keep repeating the same story that it's never going to happen, but the reality is that modern Linux distributions have nearly the same install-and-go ergonomics as Windows, with many happy users.
- exit 8y ago> The downsides are that my phone effectively has a bundle of cash strapped to it, and when I lose the phone my cash is gone too. you should have the root mnemonic of the wallet stored separately, in which case you would be able to regenerate the private keys and access your funds again. i can recommend the eclair wallet, by acinq, for android. as well as traditional on-chain transactions, it also supports spend-only lightning channels. receive functionality is being tested on testnet and should arrive on mainnet soon.
- Ruphin 8y agoIt's exactly narratives like that, "you have to store this passphrase somewhere secure or you risk losing all your money", that makes anything in this space so much less accessible to normal people. You can choose to ignore those complexities and just treat a wallet like a simple app that just sends and recieves money without understanding anything about how it works, and the UX is way better. You just have to live with the consequence that your money is gone if you lose the phone (which is the same as losing the cash in your physical wallet when you lose that). In my experience that narrative works much better for onboarding people, because it doesn't place any burden on them to do anything. They just have to choose their level of acceptable risk, which is something they are familiar with (carrying cash in their physical wallet).
- stakhanov 8y agoThe biggest argument against bitcoin, in my mind is this: Regulators really only get involved in allowing/prohibiting innovations very late in the game. I'm thinking of how Air BNB and Uber were allowed to grow really huge despite being blatantly in violation of a lot of laws in a lot of places (for example restrictions around subletting in contracts between tenants and landlords, regulations around running businesses that are hotels or taxis, etc). Only after they had gotten really big did regulators start to think about whether or not they like what's going on, and then they shut down large parts of the sharing economy. For bitcoin there are only two scenarios in my mind: Either it dies right now for the problems it is facing right now (network externalities around lack of merchants/customers outside darknet/illegal stuff, volatility etc), or it overcomes those problems, gets really big, and is then killed by regulators. For the most part the trend in regulation of financial services and financial reporting has been: erosion of banking secrecy (even Switzerland and tax havens in the Carribean are now sharing data with law enforcement), anti-money laundering regulation tightened (FATCA/CRS), increased requirements around creating transparency about ownership of legal entities in cross-border corporate structures (e.g. "persons of significant control" register introduced in the U.K. and many European countries), increased reporting obligations around cash transactions even for small businesses (parts of Europe are now mandating the introduction of electronic cash-registers capable of reporting on a transaction-by-transaction basis even for small businesses like a self-employed taxi driver), etc. etc. Allowing bitcoin to happen would not fit into that regulatory trend AT ALL. It's just that bitcoin isn't big enough yet for regulators to even be thinking about it. But it'll happen.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Ruphin 8y agoBitcoin and cryptocurrencies are an active issue for regulators right now. Statements have come out from several parties that confirm networks like Bitcoin and Ethereum are not securities. The SEC is actively shutting down ICO schemes that are deemed securities. Things are moving slowly because it's a complicated topic, but we are seeing more and more guidance from regulators like the SEC and others. AirBnB and Uber are doing pretty fine for companies that got killed by regulators.
- acabal 8y agoAt Scribophile, I set up an option to pay for a membership upgrade directly with Bitcoin, i.e., without an intermediary to USD like Coinbase. Customers would be given a Bitcoin address to send a certain amount of Bitcoin to for a 1-year upgrade purchase, and once the transaction was verified, their account would be upgraded. In the ~5 years we had the option, I think we had about 3 purchases with Bitcoin. I kept it as an option for a long time because I was mildly interested in the philosophy of Bitcoin. That is, its use as an alternate currency for everyday transactions, not its use as an intermediary for USD transactions or its use as a Ponzi scheme to separate the stupid from their savings. But with such a poor sales rate I finally removed it some time last year. It was interesting while it lasted but Bitcoin is clearly nowhere near being useful for e.g. buying a bag of flour. After some thought I decided that the entire cryptocurrency space, in its current pump-and-dump/outright scam incarnation, is mostly stupid, and unethical at best and criminal at worst. I could have kept Bitcoin payment as an option indefinitely--it's not hard to keep a static page up--but I felt that doing so would be in some small way promoting an unethical industry. (Unethical not because of what people are buying with crypto, but because today crypto is being used as a thinly-veiled scam to trick gullible people out of their investment money.)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Proven 8y agoBitcoin has failed and succeeded. It's main success is that it started both blockchain and cryptocurrency evolution. Other than that, it's failed. It's fairly useless as either a currency or store of value. I've seen comments that state how Bitcoin or Lighting Network works. It does, but for the tiny fraction of people who can't use fiat, other top cryptocurrencies work even better (cheaper, faster, no Layer 2 complexity). I always find it curious how some assume Layer 2 is inevitable on any currency that scales and therefore Bitcoin, having early lead in LN, can only increase its dominance. But no one can force us to do that and we don't have to use just one made up currency. We can use an unlimited number of coins, each without Layer 2. Bitcoiners have been saying other coins will die off; not only that hasn't happened, but even tiny coins haven't died off.
- minikites 8y agoAre the drawbacks of Bitcoin (massive global electricity usage, makes email/malware extortion scamming much easier) worth the advantages (the ability to anonymously buy things online at a small number of places) overall? I'm of the opinion that Bitcoin is a net negative (Bitcoin mining has wiped out all of the gains we've made from the recent renewable energy boom), but perhaps there a useful purpose that I'm unaware of.
- sparkie 8y agoBitcoin is going to drive research into renewable (cheaper) energies faster than all of the G20 combined. The reason is simple: Mining profitability is measured in Hashes per Joule. Increasing hashes means bringing down the price of mining equipment, which is happening already, and it is reaching the limit of Moore's Law, meaning that the mining equipment will have a much longer lifetime, and the amount of energy it will burn in that lifetime will dwarf the cost of the chip. In effect, the "Hashes" in the above equation will become negligible - mining profit will be measured solely in Joules. If miners want to remain competitive, their profit will be the difference between the bitcoin reward and the cost of their electricity. The mining reward is unpredictable, but the subsidy is going to decline over time. The clear path to increasing profitability then, is to reduce expenditure on energy! Miners have an absolute requirement to invest in cheaper energies, because if they don't their competition will, and they will go out of business. Industrial mining is a race to see who can develop the cheapest, most abundant, lowest maintenance energy solutions.
- xd 8y agoIt shows your customers that you are a forward thinking company. Bit of a loaded assumption that; accepting bitcoin has nothing to do with being forward thinking. Bitcoin appeals to human greed, that's it. The comments comparing this to Linux and TCP/IP is apples and oranges. Why would I as a hard working member of my society with a house and kids invest money into a system completely unregulated. I'm all ears.
- exit 8y agoat a base level its regulation is completely transparent and algorithmic, unlike the closed-door regime of central banking.
- xd 8y agoYou invest in bitcoin and lose your key or it's stolen.. how does that work out in the end? Edit: don't get me wrong, I have crypto currency I've blown many a kw/h on. But you can not as a society rely on a currency with such flaws. Hell maybe insurance startups will popup to handle the issue but I'm not holding my breath.
- blancheneige 8y agobecause it's not your society. it's that of your elites.
- Barrin92 8y agoThe distribution and concentration of bitcoin and its mining resources makes even decidedly unequal societies look like socialist utopias.
- tim333 8y ago>Bitcoin appeals to human greed, that's it Much of the motivation of the founders and enthusiasts was that governments and existing financial systems are flawed so it may be valuable to have a peer to peer financial system outside of that.
- pjkundert 8y ago"Why does no one want to pay their local locksmith with Bitcoin?" The reasons given (few customers have it in a hot wallet ready to use, slow and expensive for small payments) are not the reasons! Even if many people had it, and the expense was lower -- few people would use it. The real reason? Gresham's law: a monetary principle stating that "bad money drives out good". Given 2 forms of commodity money in circulation, the more valuable commodity will eventually disappear from circulation. A fixed-issuance token is designed to Deflate (go up in value), if its uptake and utilization increases. Hence, Bitcoin will "disappear from circulation" as money, vs. almost any alternative form of money! Who's going to spend something that the believe is likely (barring catastrophic failure) to go up in value? It is astonishing to me that this topic is even a question that people actually have...
- paulgb 8y agoYou're mixing up two things. Gresham's law applies when the conversation rate is fixed, not when it is set by the market. It's not the same as a currency being deflationary. Hayek wrote about the confusion: https://fee.org/resources/denationalization-of-money/#VI.%20THE%20CONFUSION%20ABOUT%20GRESHAM%E2%80%99S%20LAW https://fee.org/resources/denationalization-of-money/#VI.%20...
- pjkundert 8y agoIts original application was to coinage with a fixed face value and a fluctuating inherent (market) value, of course. The "spirit" of Gresham's law applies to any money that is (or is likely) to become more valuable in the future than it currently it. The same mental process applies in the holder of the money: "why would I spend this potentially more valuable money, when I have this other less valuable money to spend?" edit: the article mentions the German Weimar inflation as a counterexample; in fact, it is a prime example of this concept: if a vendor accepts either the Weimar Papiermark or the US Dollar as payment, who in their right mind would pay that vendor with US Dollars? That vendor would probably never see a single US Dollar in payment! Bad money would have totally chased out good, from their perspective. The real issue is not fixed exchange; in a free market, where vendors accept multiple forms of payment: unless forced, payors will always pay with "bad" money, and will keep the "good" money for themselves.
- classicsnoot 8y agoBack in early 2016 I told myself that if BTC dropped below $200 I would buy one. The lowest I saw was $203. When it went meteor a few years later, I felt Fold remorse. Perhaps it is sour grapes, but every time I walk by the BTC machine at my corner store, I relish in seeing how low it has gone, though still well higher than $200. :/ More on topic, the only action the corner store BTC machine gets, apart from drug addicts, is scams. That I can attest to, twice some tech ignorant soul has walked in, dumped their savings, then asked the cashier for a receipt. Unless crypto currency can be inoculated from speculation (impossible IMO) it will be some time, if ever, before it becomes a viable mechanism for general economic exchange.
- skinnymuch 8y agoWhat’s a BTC machine? What happened to the money the poor souls dumped into it?
- classicsnoot 8y agoYour guess is as good as mine. It looks like a MTO kiosk. It feels like an ATM. According to [redacted] their money went straight ether.
- skinnymuch 8y agoHaha I See. “Straight ether” meaning it went straight to them just losing it? Interesting. Also feel bad for the people, of course.
- nybble41 8y agoIt's a vending machine for exchanging BTC and local currency. Depending on the type it may be linked to an account at an exchange or else rely on scanning QR codes for the receiving address (either the users or the machine's). Some only sell BTC, while others support both buying and selling. I imagine that this was one of the models that was linked to an exchange account, since the QR-based versions make it fairly obvious where the funds are going and won't work unless you first set up a receiving account and present the QR code for the machine to scan.
- jakobegger 8y agoA handful of people have requested that I add Bitcoin as a payment option to my store. But when I offered these people to purchase my app with Bitcoin, none of them actually bought a license. As much as I like the idea of Bitcoin, it just doesn't seem like people really use it for buying legal things.
- Smokinator 8y agoI've bought a lot of legal things with Bitcoin, and I've never bought an illegal thing with it. Check out BTCPay Server if you're serious about accepting it as a merchant.
- arisAlexis 8y agoand I was going to ask why isn't there an "I hate blockchain and Bitcoin sucks" article on the first page today