7 ms·
It's so shady that their advertised price includes some hypothetical "potential gas savings", and the actual price is behind a tiny "learn more" link.
by paxys 8y ago
It's so shady that their advertised price includes some hypothetical "potential gas savings", and the actual price is behind a tiny "learn more" link.
- LeoPanthera 8y agoThe real price is at the bottom of the page without having to click through, but yes, it's still really shady. No other car OEM does this.
- goshx 8y agoMy experiences with other cars are the opposite. I've seen a lot of advertised prices that are not really what they want to charge you when you make it to the store to purchase.
- fengb 8y agoFunnily enough, the listed MSRP usually much higher than actual dealership price.
- mjevans 8y agoThat's just so they can give you the illusion of some kind of savings. It'd be like if I got to go in to a hiring offer and was able to demand a million dollars a year so that any lower salary seemed like a value.
- bduerst 8y agoAnchoring. It's a negotiation tactic since most purchases are through negotiation. Also the same with the advertised monthly leasing prices that you see on commercials - all subject to credit and other circumstances.
- saalweachter 8y agoMy experience has been that when you actually go in to buy a car, you get a swath of arbitrary discounts to the MSRP, then you get a few other fees and especially taxes that bring it back up to the MSRP. So I'd guess that there's also a component of the high MSRP + large standard discounts which is also making sure that you don't come in expecting to pay an advertised price, get aaaallllmost all the way through the process, get the final price with tax that is ~10%/several k$ higher, and then crap out there both because it is a real kick in the pants and you may not have the extra money.
- driverdan 8y agoInvoice minus promotions is what you should pay which is typically a few thousand USD less than MSRP.
- berberous 8y agoHow many car OEMs push misleading lease prices by increasing upfront cash to make the monthly payment seem lower? Only $LOW/Month* * After large amount upfront.
- schintan 8y agoothers doing it doesn't justify their doing it.
- dmode 8y agoTry buying a BMW with the $328/mo lease that they advertise every day. Tesla is waaaay less shady than any car maker. Their base model comes in with a LOT of features that other car makers will nickel and dime you to death. Example, LED lights.
- saberience 8y agoErrr what? The base Tesla comes with almost no features at all.
- dmode 8y agoTry test driving a BMW 320i
- Spooky23 8y agoIsn’t that the BMW for people who cannot afford a BMW?
- saberience 8y agoThat car isn’t sold anymore. Check bmwusa.com
- npunt 8y agoHow many of those sell electric cars which have entirely different economics? I wonder if Nissan Leaf or Chevy Bolt use this.
- iooi 8y agoI don't have a Twitter account, but I recommend submitting this to: https://darkpatterns.org/ https://darkpatterns.org/ This is shameful and should be called out. Price is not the same thing as cost of ownership.
- whatislovecraft 8y agoYou can only use Dark Patterns with a Twitter account? Is this some kind of intentional irony or something? Social Login force-tied to a specific company is Dark Pattern #1 in my books. Edit: They define "dark pattern" at the top of their site: > Dark Patterns are tricks used in websites and apps that make you buy or sign up for things that you didn't mean to. That's exactly with Login With Twitter is. The user is presented with a simple option for logging in, but then is tricked by giving their metadata and account info that will 'sign them up' to be analyzed and targeted by Twitter for whatever purposes. Yes the TOS is probably there on social login, but aren't Long TOSs that are prompted in the middle of a user flow also Dark Patterns, as no user is likely to read them? Can't possibly take that site seriously. Edit 2: The darkest pattern from their site: > We aren't great at responding to email — Twitter is best. Yikes.
- genericone 8y agonot good at email, "Twitter is best" -> if we aren't publicly able to show how responsive we are, and what our answer is, its a much lower priority for us...?
- eclipxe 8y agoThat's not what they're doing - they aren't saying login with twitter - there is no login for darkpatterns - they just want you to spread the word using their alias and hashtags. >Use Twitter to spread the word about Dark Patterns. It's the most effective way to put pressure onto companies to stop using Dark Patterns. >Retweet, quote and favorite other people's tweets about Dark Patterns. >@mention the offending brands and tell them what you think about their practices. >When you see a Dark Pattern, take screenshots and tweet it. Mention @darkpatterns or use the hashtag #darkpattern. >If you've got an example that doesn't fit into a tweet, you can use a platform like medium or imgur, then tweet it.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoYeah, that's really bad. I also think they shouldn't make you click to check each model to see what the range is. I should, at a glance, know that it's the $43,000 "long range" model that has as much range as my Toyota.
- cma 8y agoToyota probably makes you click through to find 0-60 time.
- CydeWeys 8y agoAnd range, for that matter. The # of miles you get off a tank of gas is not a highly-surfaced metric for vehicles. It's certainly not in the trim level name. You always have to dig into the detailed stats to find it.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoPerhaps, but range is not a huge concern for most vehicles: Range rarely differs significantly between trim levels and all are generally 300+ miles. Tesla's specifically dividing their trims by range, but chose to use "standard range", "standard range plus", "long range", etc. instead of just telling us the range. And their "standard" range is well below the standard range of an average car.
- cma 8y agoIt is good for an electric car though. Do people really buy based on summary description, or do they use that to pick a starting place to learn more? It is a big purchase.
- scarmig 8y agoI am going to start advertising all my products as free, with a hidden qualifier that it's only free in the sense that you won't be purchasing something of equal or higher cost and so you're effectively saving money.
- traviswingo 8y agoThe actual price is literally right there on the screen. Potential gas savings is still a huge selling point to the market they're addressing (maybe not for you or I). I'm not sure this qualifies as "shady" when everything is displayed within the same viewport.
- protomyth 8y agoThe actual price is one place on the screen at the bottom in white text on grey with the fake prices on the prominently on the side in bold. Its shady.
- Aeolun 8y agoThis qualifies as shady. It’s pretty much the definition of shady. Probably just barely legal.
- reitzensteinm 8y agoThey subtract gas savings, but don't add the destination fee or any state taxes. I kind of get the gas savings bit, but to selectively include savings and hide other fees is shady as hell in my opinion. At least that's what it was like before; in Australia, the Model 3 configuration screen is apparently now stuck in an infinite redirect loop. It looks like it's unchanged, but I can't look at the page for more than a second.
- ABCLAW 8y ago>I'm not sure this qualifies as "shady" when everything is displayed within the same viewport. It seems concerning that outright dishonesty in consumer-facing material for large purchases might reasonably be considered par for the course. What an abject failure of industry leadership. Good thing they weren't kind enough to include the amortized battery replacement costs or other differentials in operating costs, like a comparison between their repair and maintenance schedule to an industry average.
- martin_bech 8y agoIts shady, but its not hypothetical, having owned a Model S for 4 years, I’ve saved a ton on fuel.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ekianjo 8y agoIf its your first car it makes absolutely no sense.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoIt makes no sense either way. CapEx and OpEx are different animals.
- greglindahl 8y agoYeah, no one in the computer industry ever does anything to trade one for the other! Oh, wait, cloud. Server leases. I guess we do it all of the time.
- martin_bech 8y agoCapEx and OpEx are different labels for money, thats all. Its still going out of your pocket, if its one or the other.
- dmode 8y agoIt is still a savings as you would have bought an ICE otherwise
- Rebelgecko 8y agono I wouldn't
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mmcconnell1618 8y agoYes, very shady. If you view the details, you can adjust your annual miles to "1" which zeros out that discount.
- matz1 8y agoIt might be shady and of course some people will despise it but if the net effect is sales increased, then they should do it.
- scarmig 8y agoBefore, my impression of Tesla was that it's a company that has had some struggles but is genuinely trying to do a cool, useful, good thing. After, my impression of Tesla is that it's incredibly shady and manipulative, and I have a great deal of anger at it because this page is disgustingly deceptive. You've got to get a reasonable estimate of how much less likely I'm going to purchase a Tesla in the future, but before there was a nonzero chance I would, while in this moment I feel like I'll never purchase one. That's negative value, there.
- goshx 8y agoSolely on the fact that they show the cost of ownership first?
- scarmig 8y agoSolely on the fact that they present an imagined "cost of ownership" as the price, yes. It's deceptive enough--and 90% of people who saw that page would say that the costs of the cars are what's listed on the right column, which makes it deceptive--that it leaves a wildly unpleasant taste in my mouth. And, in my case, it's not even close to accurate: I don't own a car right now, and any purchase would be because I actively like a particular car. The "savings on gas" is a total lie, because I'll be spending nothing on gas anyway.
- goshx 8y agoI find it annoying too, but it takes seconds to realize that’s not the actual price and the price is right there on the bottom. And you can’t really not understand what the real price is before placing the order. It’s not an imagined cost of ownership for me, an actual owner, who just got $7,500 back and pay $7 for 300mi.
- _s 8y agoAbsolutely - I made a comment a few years ago around the Model S pricing when they compared it to a E or S class Mercedes. The base price of a given vehicle is $35k, and then I'd spend either $1500/yr on fuel and maintenance o, or $500/yr on fuel and maintenance if it's - for example - electric, on top the of the base price. Spending $1000 less per year does not magically mean the car is now $34k. If anything, the price has gone from $36.5k to $35.5k for that first year. I don't even understand the mental gymnastics you have to do, or how ignorant you have to be to not understand that. Unless I'm taking crazy pills? Someone please correct my logic otherwise.
- TheSmiddy 8y agobuying a $35,000 Tesla has the equivalent cost of ownership of buying a $26,950 ICE car. It's not a massive amount of mental gymnastics. I definitely don't agree with Teslas practices of framing it that way, I'd rather they just show cost of ownership comparisons across a variety of cars. Especially since they can't even meet the demand they currently have, why resort to shady practices?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tfehring 8y ago> buying a $35,000 Tesla has the equivalent cost of ownership of buying a $26,950 ICE car. It's not a massive amount of mental gymnastics. But only if you arbitrarily include the difference in fuel costs, which makes Tesla look cheaper, and exclude the differences in insurance and maintenance costs, which make Tesla look more expensive.
- thebluehawk 8y agoMy experience is that insurance is the same and maintenance is cheaper with an electric vehicle.
- tfehring 8y ago
- bbeekley 8y agoJust did some napkin math and the potential gas savings number seems reasonable. (I expected it to be inflated and still think it's a dark pattern to include it.) Model 3: (50 kwh battery) * (0.166 $/kwh for Los Angeles residential power) / (220 mi range) = 3.8 $/100 mi of fuel Average ICE sedan: (3.00 $/gal average regular gas in LA) /(30 mi/gal) = 10 $/100 mi of fuel If you drive 12000 mi in a year, it comes to about $4.5k in savings over 6 years. That drops a ton if you would have purchased a Prius or other hybrid though, and to zero w/ cheap Texas gas. So it's a reasonable number if you're a Californian who would have bought a BMW instead of a Model 3. For everyone else, it's likely too high.
- natch 8y ago>That drops a ton if you would have purchased a Prius or other hybrid though. Nicely done math. Based on Toyota etc.’s marketing claims I guess. In which case it might be around $6/100 miles (guesstimate) versus Tesla $3.8/100 miles.
- dice 8y agoThat savings also drops to zero if you're coming from another electric vehicle such as a Leaf.
- taurath 8y agoOn mobile at least it’s right at the bottom of the screen in a footer. But yeah, $10k in gas? Cute but the Prius doesn’t take $5k off the show price because it’s not an F150
- atarian 8y agoIIRC, they've been doing this since the Model S, not that it makes it any less shady.
- colordrops 8y agoAlways something negative when it comes to Tesla. They finally delivered on their promise of a $35k model 3, which is a monumental achievement, and yet the top comment is about the website. Haven't seen the desktop site, but on mobile the full price of $35k is clearly visible.
- gowld 8y agoMonumental achievement like the $36.6K Chevy Volt https://www.chevrolet.com/electric/bolt-ev-electric-car https://www.chevrolet.com/electric/bolt-ev-electric-car (with longer range than Model 3)
- colordrops 8y agoYes, they are both great achievements.
- mercutio2 8y agoGM's insane decision to give two very different cars names which sound the same when spoken aloud strikes again. You linked to the Bolt-with-a-b, but said Chevy Volt-with-a-v. Certainly the Bolt is comparable to the Model 3; the Volt not so much.
- turtlebits 8y agoMSRP with traditional dealers is never correct. I picked up my Bolt for 30,900 in December of last year. (w/ fast charging option)
- outworlder 8y agoI agree that it is unnecessary and borderline misleading. They will display the amount you actually have to pay, though. On the flip side: you don't have to deal with dealerships, which are _much worse_ You just configure the car, give your credit card information, and done. This is unlike most other manufacturers which, even if they do give you a quote, will then hand you off to shady salespeople.
- dwighttk 8y agoI feel like I’m taking crazy pills now, who is paying for their car using a credit card? I must just be out of touch.
- natch 8y agoThey can take online payment from a bank account (such as after you’ve deposited a check from an auto loan) or they can take a physical bank draft (such as you would get from an auto loan) upon delivery. They drive the car to you either on a truck or on its own wheels, you do some paperwork, and 15 minutes later the delivery driver either hops in a Lyft or gets back in the semi truck. I’m sure credit card would work too if you had a high enough limit but those are the other options.
- dwighttk 8y agoOh ok. Makes more sense.
- greglindahl 8y agoYou give a deposit at order time, it’s reasonable to do that with a credit card.
- threeseed 8y agoIn many countries e.g. Australia this would be illegal. It's completely unethical. I guess computers should be considered free given that they enable so much productivity.
- themagician 8y agoEh, no more shady than what standard dealerships do when they advertise that it's just $199/mo* and then there's some unusually high acquisition fee or an APR credit offset that applies to MSRP. Or when they offer you a 4yr/50k mile service agreement, but in the fine print it's actually a special dealership version of the service agreement that's essentially a coupon book tied to that dealership offered by some third party and good nowhere else. It's hard to buy a car without getting at least slightly cheated. The price w/gas savings included at least makes it easier to compare against standard petrol vehicles. It's kind of hard to rip on Tesla when the standard dealership model is nothing but shady advertising and sleazy sales tactics. They could get rid of the asterisk mark / learn more link and it would still somehow be more honest than going to any car dealership in the United States. Sometimes I feel like Tesla gets judged in a vacuum. Kinda weird.
- dmode 8y agoIt actually understates the savings, since it only captures the Federal credit. CA gives out $2500 extra AND carpool stickers (admittedly more valuable than the tax credit)
- Rebelgecko 8y agoI think at this point only a subset of Teslas are still eligible for the carpool sticker
- heyyyouu 8y agoAND there's a limited number given out every year -- you're not guaranteed one.
- drfuchs 8y agoTo get both the HOV ("carpool") sticker and the $2500 California credit, your income has to be under "$150,000 for a single person, $204,000 for a head-of-household, and $300,000 for a joint tax return" as per https://cleanvehiclerebate.org/eng/income-eligibility https://cleanvehiclerebate.org/eng/income-eligibility
- natch 8y agoAnd the PG&E rebate of $800.
- radium3d 8y agoI feel software limited range* is also shady. Tesla does some shady things. * Not sure if the low range model 3 is software limited.