4 ms·

Looks like YT wrote back to that post to say that's not true? "...Channels will not get deleted if you re-enable comments--can you send us the post where you s

by flokie 8y ago

Looks like YT wrote back to that post to say that's not true? "...Channels will not get deleted if you re-enable comments--can you send us the post where you saw that?"

jawns 8y ago
Ah, thanks for pointing that out! It appears that he saw demonetization and mistook that as deletion. That said, for some channels, demonetization means effectively shutting down the channel.
- dosshell 8y ago
  Limited Monitization Video that include minors and are at risk of predatory comments may receive limited or no ads (yellow icon). If you think we made a mistake please appeal [link]. We will continue to refine our approach in the coming weeks and months. Is misstaken as deletion? English is not my first language, but I have a hard time reading this as "we may delete your channel".
  - tw04 8y ago
    Removing monitization is as good as deletion for the content creators. Furthermore, their "appeals" process tends to be a black hole, as is basically everything at google that would require human intervention.
    - nradov 8y ago
      That's only true for "professional" content creators. The silent majority of creators don't care about monetization and won't be impacted.
      - Mirioron 8y ago
        The majority of content that is watched on Youtube is monetized and people do depend on it to some degree. If they didn't, then they wouldn't be on Youtube, because there are plenty of other services that offer you the ability to upload videos for free.
        macintux 8y ago
        > because there are plenty of other services that offer you the ability to upload videos for free. Even without monetization, the community/discoverability benefits of YT have to be appealing. As much distaste as I have for Google, the ability to find a plurality (at least) of the content related to my area of interest in one place is quite appealing.
      - dosshell 8y ago
        I guess I'm reading the words to strictly - We will stop giving you money - We will force you to stop by delete the channel I guess it can feel the same for many creators and be the same thing when communicating on twitter. (No sarcasm intended)
        mulmen 8y ago
        Where does it strictly say they will delete the channel?
        jachee 8y ago
        His point is that it doesn't.
    - tanilama 8y ago
      Not if you are a hobbyist.
dosshell 8y ago
YT also ask for referns so they can correct the faulty information. If i understand the twitter thread correctly, he referens that ads can decrease, and this somehow in his mind means that YT will delete his channel... Edit: In my world, that is called a lie. And well, who wants to advertize if the comments is full of pedophils?

by flokie 8y ago

Looks like YT wrote back to that post to say that's not true? "...Channels will not get deleted if you re-enable comments--can you send us the post where you saw that?"

jawns 8y ago

Ah, thanks for pointing that out! It appears that he saw demonetization and mistook that as deletion. That said, for some channels, demonetization means effectively shutting down the channel.

dosshell 8y ago
Limited Monitization Video that include minors and are at risk of predatory comments may receive limited or no ads (yellow icon). If you think we made a mistake please appeal [link]. We will continue to refine our approach in the coming weeks and months. Is misstaken as deletion? English is not my first language, but I have a hard time reading this as "we may delete your channel".
- tw04 8y ago
  Removing monitization is as good as deletion for the content creators. Furthermore, their "appeals" process tends to be a black hole, as is basically everything at google that would require human intervention.
  - nradov 8y ago
    That's only true for "professional" content creators. The silent majority of creators don't care about monetization and won't be impacted.
    - Mirioron 8y ago
      The majority of content that is watched on Youtube is monetized and people do depend on it to some degree. If they didn't, then they wouldn't be on Youtube, because there are plenty of other services that offer you the ability to upload videos for free.
      - macintux 8y ago
        > because there are plenty of other services that offer you the ability to upload videos for free. Even without monetization, the community/discoverability benefits of YT have to be appealing. As much distaste as I have for Google, the ability to find a plurality (at least) of the content related to my area of interest in one place is quite appealing.
    - dosshell 8y ago
      I guess I'm reading the words to strictly - We will stop giving you money - We will force you to stop by delete the channel I guess it can feel the same for many creators and be the same thing when communicating on twitter. (No sarcasm intended)
      - mulmen 8y ago
        Where does it strictly say they will delete the channel?
        jachee 8y ago
        His point is that it doesn't.
  - tanilama 8y ago
    Not if you are a hobbyist.

dosshell 8y ago

YT also ask for referns so they can correct the faulty information. If i understand the twitter thread correctly, he referens that ads can decrease, and this somehow in his mind means that YT will delete his channel... Edit: In my world, that is called a lie. And well, who wants to advertize if the comments is full of pedophils?